GeekCast Radio
GCR – Episode 52 – Top 100 Animated Films 100-81

Part of a Collection
About this Episode
Geekcastradio .com presents The Geekcast Radio
Top 100 Animated Films Countdown Joker's back
in town! Hello and welcome to the Geekcast Radio
Network's Top 100 Animated Films Countdown. I
am one of your hosts, TFD1Mike, and joining me
is Optimus Solo. Hello. Movie Revolt Dan, hello.
Hello. And of course, Steve Megatron, hello.
Hello. Today we're going to be counting down
the films from number 100 through 81. We, as
we said in the intro, we are not telling you
people anything about honorable mentions until
the whole countdown is over. Because it's just
going to spoil it and it's going to create way
more speculation that's needed. That isn't needed,
I should say. So we are going to get to the countdown
right now. 100. Alright, starting the countdown
off. And our number 100 spot is... Waltz with
Bashir from 2008 had 296 points, and it was only
listed on four out of the 20 lists that were
submitted. The highest person to rank this film
would have been Movie Revolt Dan himself, who
had it at his number two spot. So, Dan, we should
start with you. I know you're probably upset
that it's already being listed, but maybe you're
happy that it's listed at all. I don't know.
What is your reaction to number 100? Well, geez,
way to start it off, I guess. It's tough. In
some ways, I'm really happy it made the list
because it is not the most popular movie out
there. I mean, a lot of people haven't seen it.
It is a foreign film, but there is an American
cut of it that is in complete English. It's an
interesting film because it is like a documentary
and animated movie kind of combined. But I really
hope, like I talked about in the intro before
this even started, that, yeah, the number of
things are important. What's really fun about
Lists for me is discovering movies. And of all
the movies we get to, I obviously hopefully I'll
get to discover some. I hope some people will
go out and try to discover Waltz with Brashear.
It is one of the most emotional, draining films
I've ever seen in a good way. It's very powerful.
The animation is crisp. It's unique. It's a hard
movie to watch, no doubt. It deals with some
severe issues. It's about these... These are
really veterans as they try to relive what they
did in Lebanon. This guy kind of goes around
and trying to get all their stories because you
all tend to forget what happened in some way.
But it's really well done. It was the first animated
film ever to be nominated for Best Foreign Film.
So it has a lot of acclaim. So I really wish
it was a lot higher, as you can tell just by
my ranking of it. So I'm a little disappointed,
but I'm happy it's on the list. And hopefully...
You go ahead. just so do you honestly just saying
because a lot of times what happens is we'll
make our list and we'll submit them and then
when time comes closer we'll be looking over
our list and some of us make question or or say
well maybe i didn't quite put that one high enough
or maybe i put that one too low do you honestly
feel that that one's the second best animated
film of all time i do i do believe it's one it's
if i was the way i kind of looked at my list
if i was when i was ranking them i'm like if
i was going to give someone an animated movie
and say hey this is showing the power of animation
and showing what you can do as a storyteller
and how animation can be used to tell interesting
and powerful tales waltz of bear sheer is one
of obviously number two on that list for me um
so without a doubt and animation on top of that
which i found i think the animation enhances
it and even if this movie wasn't animated it
would still be powerful so And some people might
have heard that I said that it was only listed
on four lists. And you might be questioning,
well, if it's only on four lists, how could it
have made our top 100? And that would be because
of how high it was ranked on those four lists.
It had an average ranking of 17th amongst those
four lists. So that's definitely how it garnered
the points necessary to break and crack into
our top 100 list. Rotten Tomatoes gives this
one a score of 96. With the critical acclaim
that it got, I have no problem with it appearing
on our list. I don't feel as strongly as Dan
does about it, but I definitely think it deserves
a spot somewhere. Mike, any reactions to Waltz
with Bashir at number 100? No. Steve? I've never
heard of it, so no. And I think that's the case
with a lot of people, especially more mainstream
or casual moviegoers. And it's fairly recent
within the last five or six years. I think maybe
as time goes by, it'll garner a little more popularity.
But, hey, number 100, starting off with a foreign
film, nothing wrong with that, and we'll see
where we go from here. 99. All right, moving
on to number 99. Now we're going to stay in the
2000 decade here, and we are going to go to 2005
from DreamWorks for our 99th film, which will
be Madagascar. Oh, God. 307 points, which meant
that it was about 11 points higher than Wallace
with Bashir. It appeared on eight lists, so twice
as many lists. The highest it got ranked was
11. My dad's sister. I'll go last on this one,
because maybe you guys will say some good things
about Madagascar before I go. Okay, the only
thing that I like about the Madagascar franchise
is the Penguins. They were the best thing about
that entire franchise. DreamWorks is a studio
that constantly, and there's nothing wrong with
this, but they constantly go with big -name stars
for voice actors. I have absolutely no problem
with this, but the voices that they got for this
franchise overall, not just even this one film,
I just don't like the stories. The animation
looks great, but the story is just too far -fetched
for me. See, it looks like all the other DreamWorks
films. As far as it looks good, animation's good,
voice acting I have no problem with. The voices
are fine. For me... Madagascar, from a dialogue
standpoint, from a plot standpoint, from a story
standpoint, just fell flat all the way across
the board. I watched this with my nephew and
niece, and I was like, this is one of the worst
animated films I've ever seen. What did you think
of The Penguins? I liked The Penguins of Madagascar
as a series. They weren't enough in the movie
to save it for me. I just really, I've never
had... this much of an adverse reaction to any
of the dreamworks films as i did with this and
i just really do not like this film um dan what
do you think about madagascar i think it's a
harmless movie uh i think it just it is one of
those uh computer enemy movies that i think what
i did like about it was how a lot of the motions
of the characters were kind of throwbacks and
like they would act like cartoon characters of
just through their their actual motions but like
you said it just kind of you know it's there
some of the music is pretty fun and some of the
voice acting is funny but it's just you know
it dreamworks tend to be people have paper thin
movies occasionally they break out with a good
film but madagascar was on my list it was near
the very bottom for number 99 i have no objections
i do think it's not nowhere near as good as waltz
of bashir but uh yeah it is like i said it's
a harmless movie okay now you gotta preface that
with you could say that now about every single
movie that we list until we get to whatever you
have number one yeah it's just it's just still
stinging a little bit i got i'll get over it
i'm just gonna pat in a corner and i'll come
back you know i said this back when we did the
the top 10 film genre countdowns and i'll say
it again here i hope to god none of the sequels
for this franchise outrank the original It will
be something to keep track of as we go through
if we have sequels listed, how they compare to
their originals, etc. Steve, any knowledge on
Madagascar? Yes, I actually put that in my top
20 just because it's one of those few animated
films, at least by DreamWorks, that I can sit
and kind of enjoy only for the fact that it's
more of one of those fun, kind of goofy... um
cartoony kind of cg films whereas i mean yeah
there's not a lot there in dialogue or plot i
mean it's it's pretty flat and all that but uh
i do like a lot of the characters the portrayals
the voice acting uh the music and then of course
everybody loves the penguins because they're
freaking hilarious um they could have made a
whole film on that that would have done way better
but uh But no, I mean, it's one of those few
of the DreamWorks films because I'm not fond
of most of them anyway. It is one of the few
that I can stand to watch more than once. So
I'm fine with it being where it's at. I mean,
I had it in my top 20, but that's only because
I was trying to give some love to DreamWorks.
Found it where you could. Yes. All right. So
we have Waltz with Bashir at number 100 and Madagascar
at 99. 98. All right. Next up on our countdown,
we're going to stay with the more modern films
here at number 98. And that is with 2013. And
I should mention that it is the first time we
will see a sequel so far on our top 100 list.
And that is Despicable Me 2. We will definitely
be keeping track of how sequels fare, but we
already have our first one in Despicable Me 2.
I will say, out of the world of sequels, it's
not a bad choice. It only appeared on five lists,
but it was ranked pretty high amongst those that
had 310 points, and the highest it was ranked
was by TFG1Mike himself at number six. What the
hell is wrong with the other four people? Are
you serious? What's wrong with you? No. What's
wrong with the other four people? This is it.
easily at least top 75 or top 50 yeah but you
ranked it number six well that's because yeah
because i enjoy it so much and it's a damn good
movie this reminds me of when we did the comic
book movies and iron man 3 was number one oh
stop it you have a memory of like five seconds
it's like you know that's what i just saw so
it's number six No, actually, it's no, it's not
because of that at all. It's because it was a
damn good movie and it was because it was hilarious.
I was continuing the story from the original.
I will say we've taken a step in the right direction
because, you know, we started with Waltz with
Bashir, which had a Rotten Tomatoes score of
96. Then we went to Madagascar, which we didn't
mention, but it had a Rotten Tomatoes score of
55. Now we're back up to 76, so at least we're
headed back towards the right direction, possibly.
I have no problem with Despicable Me 2 as a film.
I love the franchise. I absolutely loved the
first movie. I think this one did not compare
to the first one. I'm not saying it was bad in
any way, but it did not live up to the level
that I enjoyed the first one. Being in our top
100 list as a sequel, I don't have a problem
with Despicable Me 2 being there. know how you
would rank it in your top 10 of all time but
we'll leave mike to that uh steve did you have
a chance to see that yet i know it just came
out uh yeah i actually did see despicable me
too while i did like it uh i would have to say
that i still like the first one much more than
the second one i just i i think that there was
uh more to it in in the first one uh and there
was just, I don't know, not that the second one
wasn't fun, but it was very predictable from
the get -go what was going to happen for the
entire film. And I just, I kind of was in and
out mentally in that one. Whereas the first one,
I didn't really know what the heck was going
on, even though I kind of knew what was going
on, but it was still different. One of the reasons
why I ranked it sixth of all time is because
of the fact of the story with him and the kids.
Because it was a damn good story. Yes, I agree
with Steve. The villain thing, oh, mysterious
plane crashes. Villain fakes his own death. Yes,
that is very predictable. But going from the
first one to this one to the second one, I was
like, oh, how are they going to further the family
story? And I really enjoyed how they did that.
Plus more minions. Dan, I don't believe you're
a fan of this franchise. You have not seen this
one? I'm not saying I'm not a fan. I ranked the
first one. I haven't seen the second one yet.
I'm not as big as I think all you guys are. I
think they're fine, but I doubt if I saw Despicable
Me 2 before I made my list that it would make
it. It would have to majorly impress me. But
yeah, I did rank the first one, but I don't know.
I can't really comment because I haven't seen
it. Yeah, like I said, I think the second one
is a far step away from the first one, but I
still enjoyed it. I think the minions make that.
What separated the first and the second one for
me is this first one had much more moments that
just stuck with you, much more dialogue moments,
quotable moments, just things that just kind
of stuck with you, whereas the second one still
had the minions and still had some of the characters,
but it didn't have those moments that stuck with
me as much. It was a lot of throwaway gags. Yeah,
it wasn't like that thing where you're like thinking
about it later on or if someone said that, you'd
be like, oh, I remember that. You know, it was
like I honestly can't really recite a single
line from the second one, whereas I could give
you about 10 or 12 from the first one. So that's
kind of what separated it for me. So, yeah, that's
our first sequel to appear on our list. We'll
have to wait and see if we get any more during
this section of the countdown. Let's see what's
next. 97. All right, that's right. It's time
for our 97th film on our list, and we cannot
escape films from the last 10 years. Specifically
going back exactly 10 years for number 97, and
that is Disney's Lilo and Stitch from 2003. It
was on six lists, had 310 points. The highest
it got ranked was number eight by Mr. Michael
Wilson. And like I said, we keep going in the
right direction. Rotten Tomatoes gave this one
an 86, 10 points higher than Despicable Me 2
got. So number 97, Lilo and Stitch. Mike, what
is your reaction to that? I think it's great.
I don't know if it should be at 97, maybe somewhere
in the 80s. But again, it's one of those films
that has a very wholesome family story. It has
great comedy bits with friggin' Ving Rhames.
As Coco bubbles and everybody remembers Stitch's
blue punch buggy line. It's just an amazing movie.
It really, really is. Steve, have you seen Lilo
and Stitch? Yes, I've seen just I've seen every
Disney movie animated wise. We actually have
a Disney chest with all of them, but periodically
go through them. But yeah, I mean, I've seen
this one a couple of times. It's not a bad film.
I didn't. I think I overlooked it with some other
films that I probably could have left off my
list in place of it. But I still would have probably
ranked it close to this end of the spectrum,
probably not quite this low. But, no, I mean,
I agree with what's been said already, though.
I mean, it's pretty fun. There's a lot of moments
with trying to civilize this. scientific beast
and and you know having the crazy scientists
and everything else going on so i mean it's it's
it's fun i think definitely for its time period
when it came out in 2003 it was everywhere um
i think a lot of that generation really gravitated
towards this film and it was kind of like a pretty
good success i think as a franchise You know,
it was obviously a little bit later in my movie
-watching time for animated films. I think the
franchise deserves representation somewhere here
in our top 100, so I'm not having a problem with
it. I didn't rank it super high, so I have no
problem with it falling here in the 90s. Dan,
what about your opinion of Lilo and Stitch? I
think it's a fine film. Of all that Disney's
research in the 90s and really early 2000s, this
is probably their swan song. Thinking back to
all their classically animated films, this is
probably the last really solid one that Disney
did before they went the more CGI route. But
it's your classic kind of a kitten -dog situation
with your crazy pet and whatnot. But it was a
sweet story. It hit the right beats, and it wasn't
exceptional in any ways. But compared to a lot
of the other stuff that was coming out through
Disney around that time period, like Brother
Bear and other things like that, it was a step
above all of those. Yeah, I definitely agree
with that. Yeah, I think you hit it right on
the nail there. Out of that group of Disney movies
that was coming out, it was probably the best
that they had to offer. All right, well, we have
had our first Disney film. Let's see what we
have next. 96. All right, for number 96, we are
going to stay with Disney. But we are going to
finally break past the year 2000. We're going
to go all the way back to 1995 for a movie that
I didn't think would make this list. But coming
in at number 96 is a goofy movie from 1995. When
you think of Disney animated films, this might
not come to your mind right away. It was on eight
lists. The highest it got ranked was actually
46th, so nobody ranked it really too high in
a top 50 type film, but it did get ranked on
eight lists. Mike, your opinion on a goofy movie
coming in at number 96? I think it's a fun spot
for it. I really enjoy a goofy movie. This is
one of those Disney movies that I enjoy the sequel
more because when the sequel came out, Extremely
Goofy Movie, it was still in that time of extreme
sports where all the rage and everything else.
With a goofy movie, it's got a good story. It
builds on Goof Troop's animated series stuff
and everything else. It's just, again, it's one
of those. It's taking a character like Goofy
and actually giving him a story. Having a son
and having to deal with neighbors and all this
and all that, I really like it. I almost think
it should be maybe in the 70s on the countdown.
Steve, what's your opinion? I really like Goofy
in the sense of when he's actually in something
where they give him a plot, kind of like what
Mike said. I like the whole dynamic between him
and his son and having his neighbor peed. everything
else and uh it's i don't know it takes the the
antics of goofy but actually gives him some some
meaning uh so plus it adds that kind of family
dynamic to it as well because he's having to
cope with the fact he's a goofball uh and his
son isn't kind of trying not to do that but does
anyway so i mean it's it's kind of it's One of
those kind of feel -good family type Disney films
of that era. Before we let Dan go, I do have
to say, I think it was the first time we interviewed
Jason Marsden when Tara and I talked with him.
We asked him about doing Max Goof, and he said
it was just an absolute blast. Very few people
can mimic Goofy's a yuck. And he did his own
version of it, and it was just really, really
cool. And he said that working with Bill Farmer,
who was the voice of Goofy, was just absolutely
hilarious. So it just goes to show you that you
can take a comedy character and actually give
them a really good story to wrap around. Dan,
when you think of Disney films, do you think
of a Goofy movie? uh honestly not really uh it's
i put this at number 98 on my list mostly because
uh i remember liking it as a kid and i was a
fan of a goof troop television series and you
know a goofy movie was a decent extension of
that around you know what are we at you know
here it's a fine number for it i probably would
have but pretty much every other movie we've
gone ahead of it maybe not madagascar but like
you all said given Providing some layers to the
character of Goofy, who usually is just that,
you know, goofy sidekick who is prone to his
physical comedy. But providing some depth to
him, providing him, like, with a son and giving
him the opportunity to be more than just that
gimmicky sidekick. It was well done. Considering
that it was based upon, you know, a television
series and usually those movies are horrible,
it did pretty well. It's been a while since I've
seen it. Like you mentioned, I do remember, like
Mike mentioned, I do remember watching the sequel,
and I personally was not a big fan of that one.
But yeah, I mean, if anything, it's going to
prod me to go back and revisit it because it's
been a while. I think for me, it's not, you know,
Dan, you said it was, oh, it was a movie based
on a television series. I didn't see a Goofy
movie that way, even though that's kind of what
it is. I saw it more as, hey, Goofy's getting
a shot in the spotlight. Goofy's been around
for so many years, and he's had his physical
comedy all that time, and now they're actually
writing him into a real story and a real adventure,
and I thought that was one of the greatest things
about that film. Yeah, I could see that, but
I never saw Goofy as the main character for that
movie. I always thought his son was really the
main protagonist, and he was just... He was there.
He was the name, as they say, but I really didn't
think it was his movie. I felt it was more so.
If anything, he shared it with the son character,
Max, I guess. Yeah. All right. Well, that is
our first five films of the countdown. Let's
see where we go from here. 95. All right. Not
that this couldn't have been predicted, but at
times during the countdown, it seems like we
may get heavy doses of Disney. Our number 95th
film of the countdown is Sticking with Disney,
but going a little bit further back, all the
way back to 1988, and that would be Oliver and
Company. This movie appeared on seven people's
lists. The highest it got ranked was 18th. Beat
out a goofy movie by one point for the spot of
95. I guess I consider this somewhat of, I know
it's not like, it's weird because I guess I consider
classic Disney like anything before, this and
anything before it, for me, all falls under classic
Disney, even though that spans a whole heck of
a long time. Because I really don't feel like
it changed until, you know, Beauty and the Beast
and Little Mermaid is when I kind of have my
resurgence in my head, even though that. Doesn't
seem logical. Oliver and Company coming in at
number 95. Dan, how do you feel about this one?
And especially compared to the last two movies
on the countdown, which have also been Disney
and a goofy movie and Lilo and Stitch. Oliver
and Company has ever been one of those Disney
movies I've really had been all that involved
with. It's just it's funny that it comes out
in 1988 because for some reason I always think
it came out a lot earlier than that. It it's
one of the most forgotten in some ways. So. It's
fine. I think it is that movie that hit right
before Little Mermaid. So it was on the right
path as Disney was rediscovering itself. Considering
a lot of the other cartoons Disney put out in
that decade. One of the better ones from what
I can remember. I thought, like, I could be wrong,
but I remember, like, All Dogs Going to Heaven
came out around the same time, and I always gravitated
towards that movie more than Oliver and Company.
But I could have the years mixed up, because
I'm not really sure. All Dogs Go to Heaven was
depressing as all hell. All right. What is your
opinion of Oliver and Company, then? So much
better than that other movie. No, I mean, you
know, this is... I believe Katzenberg was still
at Disney at this time. I could be wrong, but
I think he was. And this is one of those movies
that I don't mind it being star -studded because
you have star -studded singers in this movie.
Billy Joel, Ruth Pointer of the Pointer Sisters,
Bette Midler. And it's basically a Disney version
with animals and humans about the Oliver Twist
story. I really love this movie. This is one
of my favorite Disney movies. So are you upset
that it comes in at number 95? Eh, a little bit,
but I don't, because a lot of people like Dan
might not pay a lot of attention. I think Dan's
pretty accurate, though, that it's kind of one
of the forgotten Disney films. You know, it's
not like... Like you said, most people probably
think of it and think that it's just as old as,
you know, like Lady and the Tramp and Jungle
Book and those types of films, when in reality
it's only a year removed from when they get to
Little Mermaid. I think most people would be
surprised to learn that. I think you just kind
of assume that it's older. But I think it definitely
does get lost in the shuffle. I'm not saying
it's a bad movie, but when you think of Disney
movies, I mean, I think of Oliver and Company
before I think of a goofy movie. But I would
list a lot of other ones before I... eventually
remembered Oliver and Company. Steve, what is
your opinion about this one coming in at 95?
It actually completely slipped my mind. I haven't
seen that one in a long time, but no, I mean,
it's not a bad film at all. And I will agree
that it kind of looks a lot more dated than,
say, Little Mermaid or some of those other ones.
I don't know if it was a change in animation.
It was definitely a change in style. I don't
know if it was a change in the animation department,
but between Oliver and Company in 88 and Little
Mermaid in 89, it was a definite change in style.
But it's not a bad story or a bad film by any
means. It's just I think that that's kind of
why it may have gotten... either a forgotten
or be this low on the list is because people
kind of equate it to like a early to middle eighties
kind of film. Yeah, I definitely agree with that.
So that is three Disney movies in a row. Let's
see if that street can be broken. 94. All right.
Like you said, we're up to number 94 and we were
going to see if we could. break the disney streak
we have jumped forward eight years from 1988
to 1996 but we are going to stay in the world
of disney and this time for a little bit different
disney film here james and the giant peach um
was on eight lists which is one more list than
oliver and company appeared on um and the highest
it got ranked was 22nd Rotten Tomatoes score
actually on this one was 93, so it's ranked pretty
high amongst that crowd. And kind of in giving
our reactions to this, looking back here, because
this is the fourth Disney film in a row, get
each one of your reactions if we have this in
the right order as far as going from Lilo and
Stitch to a goofy movie to Oliver and Company
to now James and the Giant Peach, Mike. I never
cared for this film. I had seen it a couple of
times. after it was on vhs and i just i don't
know i just it's just one of those stories that
i just didn't care about the animation is nice
but i would rather watch a lion king sequel than
this whoa if you just went on based on rotten
tomatoes uh it would have gone Oliver and Company
with a 43, Goofy Movie, 53, Lilo and Stitch,
86, and then James and the Giant Peach, 93. Dan,
what's your reaction to the order of these four
Disney films and then James and the Giant Peach
just in general? Of all of them, I do think James
and the Giant Peach is probably the best. And
I would probably say Lilo and Stitch is probably
after that. And a Goofy Movie and Oliver and
Company to me are kind of, you know. They're
about even. At a given day, it could change back
and forth. But regarding James and the Giant
Peach, that book was one of my favorite children's
books growing up as a kid. And I actually came
to it around the same time the movie came out.
And I did love the movie as a kid. I haven't
revisited it much as an adult, but animation's
great. I disagree, and I think the story is really
fantastic. And it's really well -told within
this movie. And it keeps very strictly to the
book, well, as much as you can. And overall,
it's really well done. And I'm a big fan of stop
-motion animation, and it's done really well
here. And I actually didn't even realize James
and the Giant's Peach was a Disney movie. Yeah,
I didn't either until I was doing this, and I
was like, oh. It's kind of like a Goofy movie.
It's not one that you would list off when you're
listing the best Disney movies. It doesn't come
to your mind as one of them. As a Disney film
in general, I'm not saying as a good film, but
it's definitely one that you don't realize is
a Disney film. Steve, have you seen James and
the Giant Peach? Yes, I have. It's not a bad
story by any means. I do think that it does have
a it kind of does what films are supposed to
do. And that's take you kind of out of your problems
of life and puts you in an immersive, different
location. which is kind of what this story does.
I didn't personally put it on my list, but that's
more so because I had seen it one too many times
as a kid between school and everything else,
so it kind of grades on me. That, and I'm not
a fan of the animation at all. It reminds me
of Nightmare Before Christmas. I hate that film
in general, like The Nightmare Before Christmas,
not this. So it's kind of a double -edged sword
for me on this one, but I don't have a problem
with it being on the list whatsoever, though.
Mike, out of the four Disney films that we just
listed, which one's the best? Out of the four
that we just listed? Yeah, Lilo and Stitch, Goofy
Movie, Oliver and Company, and James and the
Giant Peach. James and the Giant Peach is last.
The animation is okay, but I'm not a fan of stop
motion animation in a lot of things. I mean,
I like it when, like if it's specifically done
for like toys and stuff and tour reviews, but
stop motion animation with Disney and any of
the animation companies, I cannot stand it. I'd
rather watch Lilo and Stitch than the other three.
You guys are crazy. All right. Will somebody
be able to beat? Disney and take over here and
we will see heading into our next movie 93 I
think it's fitting that we have a film like this
that will stop the Disney streak here. We're
going into our 93rd film on the list, and we're
only going two years after James and the Giant
Peach. We're going to 1998, and this will be
our first entry from a Marvel or DC film. I'm
lumping those together. I know they're different,
but for category purposes, I'm putting them together.
So coming in at number 93 is 1998's World's Finest,
and I am going to just turn it over to Steve
and Mike and Dan. I'm going to let Mike go first
on this, and then I'll go after. Okay, so first
of all, some background information on World's
Finest. It was originally a three -part episode
arc in Superman the Animated Series, which they
then turned into a made -for -VHS DVD film, and
they basically took out the intros and the outros
of Superman the Animated Series and made their
own credits around it. Watching the film as a
film, I find it so much better than watching
the individual three -part episode arc. This
is in the DC animated universe. This is the first
time Batman and Superman meet. The film structure
for the story of this is so well done because
you don't explain. When I first saw this as the
individual episodes, I was like, ooh, Superman
animated series. But wait, why are we in Gotham?
Oh crap, there's the Joker. What the hell is
going on here? Bruce Timm and his team structured
this story so well where you have the villains
meet first and the heroes have to team up to
take them down afterwards. The animation is spot
on, the voice acting is spot on, the story is
beat by beat, beginning, middle, end, and it's
just so amazing. It really, really is. Steve?
Uh... I really love this film. You have the great
voice acting of Mark Hamill, Kevin Conroy, Clancy
Brown, Tim Daly. Those are the most iconic voices
of those four characters anyway. That's the number
one thing. The number two is you have the main
two of... you know, the, the DC villains and
DC heroes going head to head in this episode,
uh, even to some degree, the, the heroes going
head to head and the villains going to head to
head with each other. So, I mean, it's, it's
kind of a, a real big kind of one, two punch
between everybody. And I, I would definitely
rank this pretty high, not as high as two other
DC universe films, but, uh, I ranked this as
my number 20 on my list just because of that
fact and then how great the story is. Well, this
is something like I don't want to I'm not trying
to compare it to Waltz with Bashir, but in comparison,
it was only on five lists. So what helped? Both
World's Finest and Waltz with Bashir was how
it was ranked on those limited number of lists.
So even though it was only on five lists, it
was average rank of 31st. It falls all the way
down to 93rd on ours. And once again, we can
turn to Mike because you had this ranked higher
than anybody else at number eight. So before
we get to Dan's thoughts, are you just happy
that it's on the countdown since it was only
on five lists? Or are you upset that even though
you ranked it at eight, it comes in at number
93? I think it's a movie for superhero fans,
specifically Batman fans and villain fans and
superhero fans. It's a movie that could have
easily been at least in the lower of the top
60, like somewhere between 60 and 59 if more
people voted on it. Somewhere between 60 and
59? 60 to 51. Thank you very much, jerk. It's
one of those things where it's got so many unexpected
moments. There's a moment where Joker and Lex
are discussing it. And in the background, they're
henchwomen. Harley and Mercy are having a fist
fight. And you just hear all the background noises,
the oops, the uggs, and all that stuff from them
fighting. And you hear Harley scream, Bonsai!
And all this and all that. And it's just a very,
very interesting movie. And it also... It's just
one of those things where you don't expect half
the things that happen in it. There's a scene
where, you know, the movie's been out for a number
of years, so I'm going to spoil it because I
know Kevin doesn't care because he doesn't watch
superhero stuff a lot of the times. But there's
a scene in it where Clark, where Superman scans
Batman's mask and Bruce Wayne at the end of it,
at the end of that section of scene. Batman has
put a tracer on Superman. Superman finds it,
crushes it, and says touche. I mean, it's just
amazing. And the chemistry between Lex and the
Joker is just amazing. It's just an overall amazing
movie. I am kind of disappointed it's in the
90s, but I'm still glad it made the countdown.
I think it should be somewhere around, like I
said, just under the top. 59 and a half, right?
Shut up. I think it should be 59. Dan, we haven't
got your thoughts on this. World's Finest, number
93. I don't know. I don't nearly think it's as
high as Steven might do. To me, it's just three
episodes of a cartoon put together. The story
is just... It's the same type of story you always
get when two superheroes meet in comic books.
If you look at any Marvel team -up or any DC
team -up, it's the same. type of plot line you
know you have the villains of each character
you know combined and they have to fight to fight
the common enemy they don't like each other at
first it's it if you look at this and and then
compare it to something like i don't know the
dark knight returns you just realize that there's
no comparison uh it's fine like i do like the
you know the batman obviously the batman animated
series in the superman animated series but i
don't i don't think it's anything special to
me it's just all right here you go if anything
it just putting this into a movie just to me
was just a ploy to you know package a dvd and
sell it like they're like i don't see it as nearly
as amazing as you guys do i don't know it's a
three -part episode though so i mean it's it
still fits together nicely as a as a film yeah
i mean and i and were you trying to compare it
to the dark knight returns No, what I'm saying
is if you look at... You're talking about the
interplay between Batman and Superman. It's far
more interesting if you look at something like
The Dark Knight Returns. Yeah, but that's a totally
different dynamic. Yeah, that's a completely
different dynamic. Yeah, it's also better done
and more interesting. And what I'm saying is
this is just kind of... It's a cartoon for kids,
so it's basic and straightforward. And yeah,
there's three episodes, but the X -Men cartoon
had... The Phoenix Saga, which was like five
episodes, if I put that into a movie, would I
say it's better than a lot of things? I don't
think so. To me, it's just, yeah, you want to
put it on the list, fine. I think in the 90s
it was serviceable, but I don't see it as this
amazing feat that you guys do. It's just, it's
been done, this type of story, the world's finest
story, has been done a lot, and it's been done
a lot better in a lot of different areas, comics
or even other, you know. straight -to -DVD movies.
Ladies and gentlemen, the Roger Ebert of the
GCRN. The point here is, though, at the time
when it happened... I would take that down and
wear it with pride. When it happened, no one
expected it to happen. Yes, BTIS and STIS were
still ongoing at the same time, but nobody ever...
I remember seeing advertisements for this on
TV for the three episodes, and I was like, wait
a second. What are they doing? For fans of those
characters, for fans of that cartoon universe,
no, it is not just that. The Batman cartoon,
Superman, all that DC animated stuff is not just
a kid's cartoon. A kid's cartoon is friggin'
Teen Titans for Christ's sake. I will play devil's
advocate here in kind of the middleman of this.
I will agree with Dan. It probably doesn't deserve
to be that high on the list. It's good that it's
on the list. Yes, it was a three -part episode
and probably a ploy to sell it as a DVD anyway,
but it's still a three -part episode. But I will
also argue that it is comparatively better than
the X -Men cartoon or the Spider -Man cartoon
of the era because the Bruce -Timverse is actually
a lot better written than a lot of the 90s animation
was at the time. Which is fine if you want to
compare it to other animated... When you're looking
at the acclaim -wise, where you think, oh, this
is an amazing feat for animated... No, I wouldn't
say it's any better than comparing it to Mask
of the Phantasm. Then, no, Mask of the Phantasm
kills it because there's a lot more depth to
the film than what's in this. To me, if you look
at an animated movie, the idea of doing an animated
movie, to me, it's like, what are you doing within
that medium that is different? Or how are you
using that in an interesting way? I don't think,
yes, they maybe edited it better for the overall
DVD release, but I don't think anything enhances.
It becomes enhanced by being on a DVD, like getting
it on a DVD or watching it on television. It's
the same thing either way. Then if you were to
compare it to something like the direct -to -DVD
releases of DC, they do something with that format
for most of them, and there's something... more
enhanced compared to your television series.
So what I'm saying is, yes, as a TV series, great.
But as a movie, I think it fails in comparison
when you look at movies that do similar storylines
and have similar characters. I think what we've
done here is discovered two things. Number one,
that eventually we need to have a discussion
just strictly based on Marvel DC movies. And
number two, that this is the first GCRM. debate
ever that i completely had no impact or input
on um all right that's because you're an anti
-hero i guess so we've had our first marvel or
dc appearance we're about to have a first of
something else with our next film 92 all right
so we are moving into our number 92 slot on our
top 100 film like i said we are about to have
another first because this time uh we're actually
just gonna flip the numbers on that last one
last one was 1998 we're gonna be in 1989 now
um for our first anime entry on our top 100 list
and that is kiki's delivery service like i said
from 1989 it was on seven people's lists and
the highest it got ranked was actually all the
way up to number four And I should mention...
I don't want to animate. It deserves to mention
that Rotten Tomatoes score of 100 currently for
Kiki's delivery service, which is not something
that's easily garnered. Dan, I'm sure you're
going to have the most to talk about with this
one, so let's start with you. Of all of Matsuki's
films, this is probably the one lower on my list.
because it's bad just because it's probably the
most, one of his most straightforward film, straightforward
films. And I do, I do enjoy it. I do feel though,
like it doesn't immerse you into the world quite
like a movie like spirit of white does, which
is a hard comparison because it's, I mean, that's
the comparison, like a movie to like citizen
Kane, but I do like it. I think the character
is, the characters are strong. It is like with
any Matsuki film, he creates a fun world of all
these different quirks, a lot of detail. if like
someone like who he is a good comparison to someone
like del toro and the way he creates his world
because it's all in the details same thing with
this just the you know the delivery service aspect
of it using witches and taking different things
like witches and switching them and doing his
own thing with them but the what's interesting
about like the delivery service is there's very
like limited conflict there's like no really
pro you know antagonist per se compared to some
of his other movies. So that's kind of why it's
lower on my list. I'm glad it made it. I'm curious
to see what other Matsuki films make it. There
should be a whole bunch more, but for me, this
is good, but it's not nearly as great as other
stuff. Mike has obviously blatantly pointed out
that there is at times an anti -anime bias here.
So Dan, looking at this one as our first anime
film, is it, Is it showing our bias that it's
in the 90s? Should it be higher than that? Or
what are you feeling as far as a first anime
film on our list and where it's ranking? Is it
completely skewed? I ranked it 71, so I'm not
completely that far off. Like I said, of all
the anime that I have had on my list, it's probably
all the Matsuki films. I don't think, for me,
I know a lot of people have a high opinion of
it, but it just didn't have the same impact as
a lot of his other stuff. I don't think it's
a huge bias. I don't think it's one that is adored
as a lot of his other films. In the 90s, it's
fine. I think you can make an argument for the
80s or the 70s, but anything beyond that I think
would be pushing it a little bit. Any comments
from Mike or Steve on Kiki's Delivery Service?
Nope. I will admit it's not on my list. There's
certain anime I'll watch and certain I won't.
this is where I kind of take a page out of Mike's
book with, I see a trailer and I either, Hey,
don't care. Or I don't say that it's going to
be crap necessarily. Not that he says that every
time, but, um, I, if it doesn't, if it doesn't,
yeah, I know I'm just dagging, you know, hitting
that dagger just right. But, um, No, I mean,
if it doesn't entice me to see it with the trailers
that I've seen of this stuff, I just won't watch
it. It's not that I have a dislike or a hate
for it because I do like certain animes, primarily
in the TV series realm. But technically, this
is also a Disney film because the second English
track that it got in 97 was by Disney. But, yeah,
I mean, I don't really have a... kind of complete
opinion of it i remember when it came out and
i saw commercials for it back in the day but
uh i i can't argue one way or the other all right
well that's our first anime film on our list
we'll see where we go from here uh running out
the first uh 10 of our group here 91 All right,
well, let's go somewhere where we haven't gone
since number 97. You know, we started our countdown
off with a bunch of modern movies, and then we
got away from it for a while and got attacked
by Disney. We're finally making it back into
more modern movies and back to DreamWorks. Rounding
off our first group of 10 at number 91 is 2012's
Rise of the Guardians. It was on six people's
lists. The highest it got ranked was 24th by
Mr. Wilson again, 335 points. I have not had
a chance to see this yet. I haven't either. So
I'm not going to be able to talk a lot about
it. There was a lot of hype to it. I remember
it kind of sounded like an attempt to do what
they did with what happened with Shrek in a different
way, kind of taking the traditional. Holiday
and different types of characters like that and
then try to do what they did with Shrek. But
I wanted to see it, I just never got a chance
to it. Dan, have you seen this one? I have. I
caught it on HBO. HBO has been blasting it for
the last month or so on repeat, so I finally
sat down and watched it. I was not a fan, I must
say. I think this is going to be a movie that
is forgotten within the next few years. Yeah,
the concept's interesting, but it just, it is
so... poorly done and it's really a huge mess
in my opinion and yeah there it too feels like
we talked about like star -studded cast it does
feel like just big names that they got in and
threw it in like hugh jackman plays the role
of like a you know the easter bunny and it's
just he it doesn't work it's not a lot of the
act the the um voice acting just doesn't work
and i don't know wait so hugh jackman went from
roddy the rat to the easter bunny oh boy talk
about being flushed away Wow. It's another DreamWorks
movie that he was in. I know. I got the pun.
I just am trying to forget it. Like I'm trying
to forget Rise of the Guardians. I don't know.
To me, I think if you did this list within the
next five years from now, it wouldn't even be
on it because it's going to be forgotten. So
this is one of those that's just because, like
you said, something that people have seen recently,
so it's on their mind? I think so. For me personally,
I don't really know many people that... I guess
obviously we have six people that liked it, but
I don't know many people that did, and I don't
know many people that it has a lasting opinion
on. Steve, have you seen this one? Yeah, I mean,
it's... Yeah, the story is not very, I don't
know, complex in any means. But... And yeah,
it's got a star -studded cast, but... that doesn't
necessarily mean that it's going to be a good
movie as we've seen with actual light live action
films. You can have all the star studded people
that you want in a film, but that, you know,
it can still be crap. I enjoyed as far as like
some of the voicing is concerned, like just the,
the actors themselves. And then I enjoyed the,
the animation style. Because it's slightly something
different, but this is another example of DreamWorks
kind of continuing failures. Screwing the pooch,
I think, is the term you're looking for. I was
trying to be a little bit more clean, but yeah,
that about rounds my thoughts on it. Alright,
well, Rise of the Guardians. Kind of a subjective
one. I think a couple of us wouldn't have this
in our top 100. So it comes in at number 91,
so I guess at least it wasn't any higher. And
we'll see where we go next as we start our next
group of 10. 90. All right, so after our quick
visit in 2012, we're going back to the past.
You know, I wasn't sure how many of these we
would see, but we have our second sequel. to
make our top 100 countdown. We'll see how many
we get in all, but coming in at number 90 is
an American Tale 2, Fievel Goes West. It was
on six people's lists. I guess I had it ranked
higher than everybody else. You did. Maybe a
bit too high. I'll admit that. A guy that hates
sequels? Yeah, a bit too high. I love this sequel.
I had it ranked in my top 10. I just loved the
whole... franchise in American tale. I mean,
I know it kind of goes crazy bad after this,
but, uh, five goes West. I was just, maybe it's
a soft spot. Maybe it's nostalgia talking, but
I had it right to my top 10. Maybe you should
adjust that for future reference, but, um, As
far as sequels go, I have no problem so far as
Despicable Me 2 and American Tail 2 being two
of the sequels that have appeared in our top
100. Because I will have a major problem if certain
sequels show up. These are not two of them that
really ruffle my feathers too much. So I'm glad
it made the list. Number 90 is fine. It's probably
much better at 90 than 9. Maybe I forgot a zero
when I was doing my rankings. I'm assuming most
of us have seen this. So let's start with Mike.
How do you like American Tail 2? It's been a
long time, but going back and thinking about
this franchise, I remember I had a bunch of the
plush toys that were out at the time and everything
else. I find it strange that, and maybe it's
because it's two different situations with these
two movies, but Five Old Ghosts West or the American
Tail franchise overall. I don't mind it as much
as I mind rat cooking in France. So there is
that. You're alone in that, just so you know.
Well, ratafouille is what it's really called.
But Fievel, he's a good character. He's an interesting
character. Whenever I would go back and watch
it, I always somehow picture Sneezer from Tiny
Toons being in there somewhere, even though I
know he's not. I know technically this wasn't
Don Bluth, even though he was responsible for
the most part for the first one. But being kind
of the first film to appear in that kind of subsection
of animated films, I find it kind of interesting.
We'll see if any of his other films will appear.
I think obviously we would all hope that the
original one would appear if the sequel appeared,
but we'll have to wait to see and find that out.
Steve, how do you feel about our second sequel
list here coming in at number 90? I vaguely remember
this one. Not enough to really make an informed
opinion, but just based on some of the animation
stuff. I mean, I can definitely tell where it
was in time when it came out, but yeah, I think
that's about all I'm going to say on it because
I can't really make an informed decision. Dan,
what about you? I loved this movie as a kid.
It was huge. I think as a kid, I enjoyed Bible
Goes West so much more than the original. It's
a lot more, as a kid, it was a lot more fun.
It's a lot more bright. of course, and brighter,
I should say. And just the Western aspect of
it was interesting. As an adult, I do, you know,
I can see that the original is superior, I would
say, to this one, at least I think so. But I
do enjoy it. It's funny because I feel like Fievel
is one of those characters that I don't know
if kids today or the youth today have any idea
of him. I don't know if that's one that's really
carried through generations. Or if he would resonate
with today's audience at all or not. Yeah, I
don't know. Maybe. You never know how things
work. Like I said, I liked it as a kid. It was
a good of animated sequels out there. You could
do far, far worse. I remember this being really
big at the time. I just could have been in my
own head. I remember it being... But yeah, yeah,
Fievel Goes West. There's been a long time since
I thought about Fievel, but like I said with
Goofy Movie and Alvore and Company, this is kind
of making me want to go back and revisit it because
it's been a while. Like Steve, I have not seen
it in maybe a decade or more. I want to see,
it makes me want to watch both of them back to
back again because I kind of have similar memories
to you where I almost remember as a kid liking
the second one better. And now I'm interested
to go back and see them back to back to see what
my reaction would be. But I think you hit it
right on the head there. As far as sequels go,
you could do much worse. So that's how we start
our second grouping of 10. We'll see where we
go from there. All right, into the 80s we go.
Number -wise, not year -wise. Year -wise, I'm
somewhat almost surprised that we're going to
have our, I think if I'm remembering right, our
fourth film so far from the last five years.
I'm surprised that we're having so many. I guess
what I would call current or modern films that
are making the list, but maybe it's not surprising
that they're all at this end of the list. So
going into number 89 is 2012's Paranorman. It
appeared on seven different lists. The highest
it got ranked was 34th. So nobody ranked it,
you know, extremely high. 89 for Paranorman.
Dan, did you have a chance to see this one? I
know it just recently came out. Yes, actually,
I called it the best animated film that came
out last year when I did like my end of the year
reviews. And I stand by that completely. I love
Paranorman. I think it's again, I mentioned I
love stop motion animation and clamation. It's
beautifully done. It uses that really well because
it during that last year you had this and like
Frankenweenie. And to me, this was so much better.
The story went in a really unexpected way and
got. A lot darker, but a lot deeper than I was
expecting. The characters are all strong. There's
a really good sense of humor to it. A lot of
great visual gags. I do think this is one that
will probably even grow in appreciation as the
years go on. But I do. I love Paranorman. It
was a huge surprise to me because I really didn't
have that much interest in it. But watching it,
I was really impressed. It drew me in right from
the get -go. And actually, it's one I revisited
a few times since then. So very happy to see
it. make it the list. And I do think it's deserving.
I honestly think you could make the argument
that it could be even lower or higher on the
list like in the 70s or so. But I think right
here is a fine place for it. I agree that I think
I haven't seen the movie in its entirety, but
I've seen little bits and pieces as I was capturing
sound clips and whatnot. I think the voice acting
is very, very good, especially for some of the
young people that got involved with it. I think,
like you said, it's better than Frankenweenie.
Interested to get your take, Dan, because like
I said, we've had like four or five films here
from the last five years. Despicable Me 2, we
had Rise of the Guardians and Paranorman. Is
this the best of that group so far? Well, I haven't
seen Despicable Me 2, so in fairness, I can't
say it's better than that. But yes, I think it's
superior than the other films in every way possible,
all across the board. Like I said with Rise of
the Guardians, I think it's going to be forgotten
rather quickly. I think Paranorman is a strong
story that's really deep, and it's, to me, one
of the biggest surprises I've had in the last
few years. When a movie can kind of... turn me
and take turn me from like a hater to a believer
it doesn't happen very often but it happened
with paranormal so steve have you seen this one
i know it just recently came out so uh no i haven't
had a chance to see it but um other than what
i saw the trailer and everything else um uh it
looks like it's a lot of fun i mean just from
what i've looked at um i don't mind this animation
style or anything and then uh the voice cast
looks again kind of Star studded. But I again,
I haven't seen the film, but I would I think
didn't this come out around the time of like
the Frankenweenie came out in August last year.
So, I mean, it came out the same year anyway.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Because I would much rather
watch this than that. But I digress. All right.
So. Paranorman in at number 89, and we'll see.
Are we going to stay with more modern films for
the rest of this segment, or are we going to
go back in the past at some point? 88. All right,
we're going to keep the modern flavor going here
with number 88. I'm just going to go back up
three years before Paranorman to go with 2009's
film from Sony. Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs.
Also on seven lists, just like Paranorman was
the highest it got ranked. Remember, the highest
ranking for Paranorman was 34. The highest ranking
for Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs was actually
12 by TV's Mr. Neal. Interesting that on Rotten
Tomatoes, both Paranorman and Cloudy with a Chance
of Meatballs scored identical at 87. So they
both scored fairly well. I just want to say I
have seen Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs.
I think it's one of those films. Because basically
what we had, in my opinion, we had our Disney
era with the resurgence with Little Mermaid,
Lion King, Aladdin, etc. And then it kind of
started to fizzle out through the Mulan years,
Pocahontas, Hunchback of Notre Dame, etc. And
then we had this insurgence of CGI, film, DreamWorks,
Pixar, etc. And after a little while, it just
seemed like we were getting the same thing over
and over and over again. In my opinion, it was
basically the same film, different cast of characters,
different area, whatever. But it was the same
film. I felt like it was within these last five
years, five, six years that we got some uniqueness
with films like Up and WALL -E. And for me, Cloudy
with a Chance of Meatballs, Despicable Me. Some
of those films kind of, in my opinion, broke
the mold a little bit. And I really enjoyed Cloudy
with a Chance of Meatballs. I'm very glad it's
on our list. I think it could be ranked even
a little bit better than it is than at 88. But
I'm very happy that it's on our list. Dan, have
you seen this one? I have. And I talked about
Paranorman surprising me. Cloudy with a Chance
of Meatballs really did too. I love the book
as a kid. The book is very different. It's mostly
a picture book. There's not much words to it.
So they changed a whole lot. There's very little.
resemblance to it as much. And my wife, who's
a teacher, really can't stand this movie because
of how much they change. But personally, I thought,
like you said, it was unique. The visual gags
in this were amazing. Visual gags can be kind
of corny sometimes, but what they did and how
they took a really simple story and really developed
it even further was really well done. I still
think I probably enjoy Paranorman a little bit
more just because of my love for Claymation.
But yeah, like you said, Compared to a lot of
the more mediocre CGI films, especially from
Sony, this is probably their best one, from what
I can remember. Steve, have you seen Cloudy?
Yeah, I actually, this is one of the films my
kid actually likes, which is funny. Just because
it's kind of goofy, I like the funny monkey and
then a lot of the little gags that they have
throughout the film. I find it to be one of the
more enjoyable. And I do agree that a lot of
the films within the last five years have actually
been different. And I did notice, too, that a
lot of the films previously to that were pretty
much the same film over and over and over. Although
now we're starting to get sequels of all these
films that came out. So it's kind of treading
down that same road again. But again, I think
this film. It could have been maybe a little
bit higher on the list, but I'm not sad that
it's at least on the list. Yeah, and I think
out of the more modern ones that we've had, I
definitely think it's deserving, along with probably
what Dan said with Paranorman. Definitely have
no problem with them showing up. Mike, have you
seen Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs? Bits
and pieces of it. I haven't seen it all the way
through. Every time it comes on Cartoon Network,
I always fall asleep or change the channel. You
imbecile. I'm just kidding. No, I think it's
deserving. I think it's interesting that we are
getting this influx of more current films going.
And we'll see how many more we get with our last
few films as we round out this first episode.
Alright, for number 87, we're going to 2007.
And for our second anime film to appear on our
list, and that is 2007's Persepolis. If I'm saying
that right. And interesting to point out on this
one, it was on five people's list, so it's again...
an example of something that didn't appear on
a lot of lists, but on the list that did appear
on it, it ranked really high. If we were just
to look at the list that it appeared on and rank
all of our top 100 that way, it would have ranked
number 20th instead of number 87th. And the highest
ranking it got was 10 from Double D and a Rotten
Tomatoes score of 96. So it seems like the people
that have seen this film and... or commenting
or critiquing it all seem to be in agreement
that it's high quality work. Dan, have you seen
this one? I have. I think it was 13th on my list.
It was in the top 20, I know that much. I love
Persepolis. This and Lost for Sure kind of make
me a little bit sad that they're ending at this
end of the list, but it's really great. The animation
is unique. It talks about a story that a lot
of probably Americans are not aware of. It is...
you know it's this really truthful story this
really honest story about this girl that grew
up within like you know the seven years war just
her you know how much she lived in terror and
how animation is used there's there's a lot of
negative space there's a lot of darkness used
in in this movie but uh there's also a lot of
great comedy to it too so i i was persepolis
to me is one of those movies like with walsh
for sure that i hope more and more people Go
out and try to watch it's a like it's I Don't
know I could see a lot of people not liking it
because it is unique It's not necessarily something
they're used to the animation isn't cut and dry
you know there But I think if you really try
to view it with an open mind I think you'll see
that there is a universality into what they're
saying even though it's coming from a different
culture especially considering where we are like
As a society, I think it's a really important
movie. But I really wish this was a lot higher
than it is. It is good to see that those that
did list it have a lot of love for it, and I
can see why, because I share that love. Fair
enough. All right, we'll see what we have next.
86. All right, moving into our number 86 film,
and I do apologize for saying that Persepolis
was anime. I was getting it confused with...
Number 86 because they're right next to each
other. Persepolis as a foreign film and number
86 as an anime film. And we are going to break
out of the 2000s and go all the way back to 1986
for the movie Ninja Scroll. It was on six people's
lists. The highest it got ranked was number five.
And it is our second film to appear in our countdown
that has had a 100 score from Rotten Tomatoes.
We had Kiki's Delivery Service that had 100 and
now Ninja Scroll that has 100. Dan, have you
seen Ninja Scroll? Honestly, this is the first
one we've done that I have not seen. And this
is the only one that we've done that I have seen
to this point. Wow. It's been a very long time
since I've seen this. Are we in the Twilight
Zone? My mind is blown right now. Yes, we are.
We're in the Twilight Zone and we've gone way
beyond the outer limits. So am I. It's been a
very long time. I think I saw this. When did
you say it came out? 86. I saw this like 10 years
after it came out, like somewhere around 95,
9, 10 years later, 95, 96. Outside of the action
and the style of the anime, I don't remember
a lot about the story. This is one of those things
where I was living with friends and her husband
put it on and we watched it and I was like, oh,
okay, well that was... But I haven't seen it
since. But I do remember at least having seen
it at one point in my life. And now we have another
film for Dan to mark down as films he's going
to watch. Yeah. My Netflix queue is going to
get angry at me. After this whole countdown is
over. Steve, have you seen Ninja Scroll? No.
And I have not either. So I guess we will not
do this film justice. Except for Mike's bag leaf.
Foggy memory of it, but assuming from the Rotten
Tomatoes score of 100 that someone had this is
highly ranked as number 5 and that with only
being on 6 list, it got all the way up to number
86 on our list should all make it seem like it's
definitely belongs. He beat Persepolis out by
one point. So it's definitely interesting to
see where we're going here in the mixture that
we're getting. Let's see what we have here with
our final five films of today's episode. All
right. So it's been a while since we've been
there. I think the last Disney film we had was
at number 94. And so with number 85, we will
go back to Disney and see what they have to offer
us in the form of 1996 is. Pocahontas. It was
on nine people's lists, which I believe is the
most list a movie has appeared on so far. Goofy
Movie was on eight. James and the Giant Peach
was on eight. So nine is the most list that we've
had so far from Pocahontas. The highest it was
ranked was number 32, so nobody ranked it in
the top 30 at all. Rotten Tomatoes score of 56.
Yikes. 366 points. Mike, how do you feel about
Pocahontas coming in at number 85? Eh, it's alright.
I remember the movie and I know the story, but
the main thing I remember from this is the song,
Colors of the Wind. Sadly, even though I don't
generally say I'm ashamed that I'm a film score
buff and a film soundtrack buff, this was one
of the Disney soundtracks I did have when it
came out. I don't know why. But overall, the
animation is good. It's not the best animation
Disney has ever done. The story was interesting
to a certain point, especially at the time. If
you watched it in the time it was released, I
don't know if it holds up to today's standards,
specifically to storytelling. Animation, it might.
But, I mean, I liked it. I liked the voice cast.
I thought it was pretty cool. I think my major
problem with Pocahontas is most of Disney films
have been based on, you know, basically based
on fiction, based on fairy tales, based on fantasy
worlds, etc. And Pocahontas, I guess, tries to
cloud that, it seems like, because it's based
on actual, I mean, not based on, but... It shares
a character that really did exist in history.
And where I run into problems with that is it
gives kids aren't smart enough to know that when
they hear about Pocahontas later in life, that
it is so far removed from this film. this is
in no way an accurate portrayal of any of the
historical events i'm not saying it was intending
to be but it leads for some confusion there so
i kind of have issues with it from a teacher
standpoint um and from a historical standpoint
but uh i guess that's more just my own personal
gripe about it not something that it really not
a mistake or not something wrong i guess it did
um but i i don't really care for it that much
in that respect i do you know agree that the
music's decent it was one of the last for me
of of that disney era that kind of for me it
really ended after the major four there but kind
of a little bit existed with this and even i
guess mulan and maybe hunchback a little bit
but by that point it was all just kind of fading
off into not as goodness um it's trying to resurge
nowadays But I expected Pocahontas to be somewhere
on the list, I guess. So I'm not surprised. I
think 85 is a fine spot for it. Dan, what do
you think? I think Pocahontas is, you know, pretty
much an average movie. I do agree that it does
have some well -made songs. You know, just about
beyond the river bend. Some of the characters,
it is, you know, Disney -fying. A very strange
tale that, you know, like you mentioned, it's
kind of taking something and making a hero out
of who in all sense was probably in real life
a pedophile, you know, six year old man going
out with a 14 year old girl. But, you know, in
Disney's eyes, it's a lot different. But I don't
know. To me, it's like you can have that issue
with a lot of things because we tend to do that
a lot with historical, you know, stories when
we look back and change them. And, you know,
if you just look at Columbus or. Paul Revere,
like a lot of those stories are twisted on their
head because of works of fiction. So that doesn't
really bother me as much, but to me, it's just
a lot of the characters, like it was that standard
Disney formula and it just kind of tried to copy
it. And it just, at this time, it was like a,
you know, the diminishing returns at this point.
It just, it wasn't nearly as good as something
like Lion King or, you know, the other films
that are far superior to it. It did its job,
but it didn't go that extra level or have characters
that really stood out. A lot of the side characters
were just rather generic and there was just nothing
really special about it. Even the villain was
kind of dumb. But it wasn't a horrible movie
in the 80s. I probably would put this behind
a lot of the other films we just went over, but
I'm glad it's not any higher. The funny thing
is, I actually enjoy Mulan more than this. I
kind of have to agree with you. Wow, did we all
just agree with Mike? Yeah. And the world is
about to break. No, I mean, I've seen this film.
It's not bad, it's not great, but it's also among
that last remaining of actually animated Disney
films before they went the entire Pixar route.
Funny note is Batman is in the film. Wait, what?
Christian Bale. Oh, geez. That's right. I just,
I had to throw that in there. I thought it was
funny, but yeah. So it's not that bad. There's
funny moments with the animals mostly, but other
than that, it's kind of ultimately one of those
forgettable. Frank Welker's in this too. Anyway.
He's in everything though. All right. We all
remember what happened last time we dipped into
the Disney pool. Let's see if it has that same
effect moving forward. So if we were to come
up with a theme for this first episode, this
first group of 20 movies, it seems like it's
Disney and it's modern. And I guess that is all
encapsulated here with our number 84 film, which
is 2009's Princess and the Frog. It was on seven
lists. The highest it got ranked was 23. Rotten
Tomatoes score of 84. So it's pretty highly ranked,
actually, for Rotten Tomatoes. 2009's Princess
and the Frog. Dan, have you seen this one? I
have. I did appreciate Disney trying to go back
and go back to classic animation after kind of
going away for such a long time. It is, I don't
know. I could see why then they quickly went
back to their CGI animation. They didn't really
stay with that path all that much, but it was
kind of an interesting nostalgia trip seeing
them go with a lot of those characters. It did
feel like your classic Disney movie, and I did
appreciate that they went to New Orleans and
trying to go to a setting and to a story that
they've never really touched on before. Overall,
though, I don't know. It's okay. I didn't...
I don't hate the film. I don't really love it.
It's just, you know, it's more notable because
of when it came out than its own quality, I guess.
It beat Pocahontas by five points. Is it better
than Pocahontas? I don't think so. I think the
songs of Pocahontas give it a little bit of an
edge over The Princess and the Frog. Steve, have
you seen this one? I know it's somewhat... Yeah,
I've seen this one. I mean, it's not bad. And
I did like the fact that Disney tried to go back
to their classic animation to some degree. But
I didn't find myself liking the songs as much
in this as I would. I'm kind of in the same boat.
I'd rather listen to Pocahontas songs in this.
The story is not all that bad. I mean, it's but
again, it's kind of that typical formula. of
Disney films. So, um, you know, the, the, the
whole princess aspect and, you know, it, I don't
know, it gets old. I mean, it disapproves with
our opinions. No, no, not at all. Oh, okay. This
is the worst Disney movie in the last 30 years
because of two things, because of one thing.
First of all, she's not even a princess. She's
a regular frigging girl. She doesn't become a
princess until she marries the god prince whatsoever.
And it's just so ass backwards. The animation
is okay. I prefer the Disney CGI. But at the
end of the movie, I was like... Okay, so they're
taking the whole princess kisses the frog thing
and turns him back into a prince and reversing
that whole thing. That's just lame and stupid
and dumb. Lame and stupid and dumb. Lame and
stupid and dumb. You got that right. And at the
end of it, it's like, she can marry the guy and
the curse will be broken. Yay! The only two good
things about this movie is that Jim Cummings
is in it and Keith David is in it as two of the
voices. That's the only two good, decent things
about this damn movie. If I never see this movie
again, it will be too soon. I guess I don't need
to see it anymore. So did you just say that you
prefer the Disney CGI over Disney classic animation?
When it comes to this movie, yes. I don't know.
I don't know why you have such a hatred for it.
I cannot stand this movie. This movie was so...
Pocahontas is ten times better than this. Your
issue with it saying, like, hey... He doesn't
become a princess until whatever. Does that mean
Aladdin's not good because he's not technically
a prince until he marries Jasmine? No, no, no.
The reason why in Princess and the Frog why it
sucks is because they say that the spell won't
be broken until she marries the prince. Okay.
My confusion is... It becomes a princess. Okay,
I'm fine if you have a problem with part of the
plot or part of the story. No, no, hold on. I'm
fine if you have a problem with that, but why
does that problem then translate into the animation
is not as good? Because I just didn't care for
it. Okay. Just wanted to clarify. All right,
so some strong opinions about Princess and the
Frog. We'll see how much strong opinions we have
on our final three films for today. All right,
time for number 83. Still staying with some modern
films here. 2004, and the film for number 83
is Polar Express. Castle Rock Entertainment.
It was on eight lists, so it appeared on quite
a few lists there. Steve, you had this ranked
all the way up at number seven, so you were the
highest one for this one, which is the first
time we've seen you have a film as the highest
ranked one. Rotten Tomatoes gave it a 56. I ranked
this as well, but we'll let you go first, Steve,
since you had it ranked a little higher than
the rest of us. How do you feel about Polar Express
coming in at number 83? Well, I like the film.
For multiple reasons. One, it's showing this
kid's journey of disbelief and the whole Santa
Claus thing and everything related to Christmas.
And then his journey and transformation into
finally believing by the end of the film. Two,
you have the CG style on this not only is borderline
realistic to some degree because even the conductor
looks like Tom Hanks. uh and the and the bum
on top of the train uh so i mean there's a lot
of like almost realistic kind of looks to it
um i i found this story to be i mean granted
it's nothing like exceptionally spectacular or
anything uh but it's it's it's a fun kind of
christmas film and uh again i just i i like performances
between Tom Hanks and all the various characters
in the film and then some of the songs that are
in it and again just the CG in it just kind of
at that time was stellar for what came out and
it was pretty cool for like IMAX kind of perspectives
with it. I definitely thought it was unique and
visually something that seemed like we hadn't
seen before. Do you think 83 is not a good enough
ranking for it? I mean, I'm fine with it being
at 83. I don't have a problem with it because
I'm sure there are better films that are ahead
of it. I'm sure I'll come into a point where
some CG films I'd rather were below this one.
But no, I mean, I'm happy that it's not in the
90s at least. I'm glad that it's on here. Dan,
what do you think about Polar Express? I'm not
a big fan, honestly. Honestly, regarding animation,
I really don't like it at all. This is, I think,
before stop motion animation really was there,
quite there yet. It was on its way, but I just
think the characters look lifeless. I think,
you know, you have the common complaint is like
the dead eyes. And I think that is a case here.
And the... I just thought like, unlike something
with Claudia's chance to be balls that took like
a children's story that was very basic and added
some life to it. To me, the story for the polar
express really didn't add that much. And it was,
it just felt like a series of events and not
actually a story being told, which is kind of
the, which is kind of what the book is, but I
don't hate the film, but I don't know. To me,
it's, this is when like Robert Zemeckis got stuck
in his soft motion animation phase. And out of
all of them, it's probably The Bastards much
better than Beowulf, much better than A Christmas
Carol. But I just, I don't, I think, put it as
highly, I don't, it seems like I don't put it
as highly as you guys. Mike, have you seen Polar
Express? Let me ask Steve, was this, wasn't Hanks
motion captured for this? I believe he was. Yeah.
Yeah, it was performance capture. And again,
it's another one of the Sony animation. Right,
yeah. So, same studio that did... I've seen bits
and pieces of it, but I haven't seen the whole
thing all the way through. It's one of those
films that, and I have to be honest here, when
I first saw it, it's one of those films that
kind of has to grow on you. Yeah. After a couple
of watchings, I enjoy the film. The first run
through, I was kind of like, meh. And then after,
I've come to like it. I mean, granted, it's nothing
spectacular, but it's one of those movies I like
watching every Christmas season. All right. Well,
Polar Express, I think, too, it had good timing
because it did come out around Christmas season.
I think it looked like something that was unique.
It looked like something that was... The marketing
was huge behind it, especially with Tom Hanks.
So I actually haven't seen it, so I can't give
you my opinion on it. But I did expect it to
fall somewhere in our top 100, so I'm not upset
about that. Anybody else? Did it come out in
November or December of 2004? Does anybody know
off the top of your head? It came out in November,
United States -wide. But Chicago, it came out
in October. Yeah, see, that's the thing. When
they do the Christmas movies, not just animation,
and they put them close to it, then depending
on which ones it is, some take off, some don't.
And I think this is one of those ones that did
take off for a long time, and it still does now.
Like Steve said, it's one that you can watch
if you liked it when you first saw it. It's one
you can watch every Christmas. All right. Well,
only two films left to talk about for today.
We'll see what those two films are. 82 all right
coming in at number 82 i believe this is the
first time we have gone back before the 80s i
don't think we've i don't think we've had a film
that wasn't in either the 2000s we've had a few
90s a few 80s this is going back before that
which i believe is the first it's also going
to be the first film that is on that has appeared
on half of the submitted list we're going back
to 1970s uh aristocats which is on 10 lists so
that's half of the list going back to disney
going all the way back to 1970. nobody had it
ranked higher than myself i had it ranked at
number 21. And it comes in at number 82. I have
a soft spot. I know this is easily one of the
Disney films that sometimes gets forgotten. We
talked about Oliver and Company in that respect.
I think Aristocats, Robin Hood in some respects
get lost because they're not the big names like
the classic Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Snow
White or Jungle Book or stuff like that. But
I think Aristocats is really good. I love the
diversity in the music. I love this film in general.
I wouldn't rank it as like the best Disney film
of all time or anything like that. So I'm not
completely upset that it's in at 82. I'm glad
it made the list. I'm glad it's ahead of Oliver
and Company and some of the other Disney stuff
we've talked about. But I'm not upset. I mean,
I know I had it ranked number 21, but I didn't
expect it to be that high. Mike, what do you
think about Aristocats? It's got some cool songs
in it, but I'm more of the dog lover Disney film
persuasion than the cat lover Disney film persuasion.
I think that's the only one. Yeah, well. No,
there was those evil Siamese twins in the dog
movie, but anyway. Dan, what do you think about
Aristocats? I do enjoy it. Like you said, it's
probably, of all the Disney movies, it's probably
in the middle for me for the most part. I do
love the jazzy songs and the jazzy score to it.
mrs mrs well with the overall story i mean i
love the character of o'malley and you know the
voice acting of phil harris i think overall there
was a lot of you know a lot of cool characters
you know it but uh yeah i do enjoy it um usually
when i hear aristocats or the first thing i think
of is that classic stand -up uh comedy joke the
aristocrats which is notably the most dirty joke
ever said. But regarding this movie, I'm glad
to see it. I do place this much higher than something
like Oliver and Company or Pocahontas or really
any of the other Disney movies. To me, it has
a lot of those classic Disney voices that you
know, like you hear them and you just know, you
just automatically associate them with. disney
movies so you may not know their names you just
they have those voices that are like in you know
movies like dumbo or aristocats and it just makes
you feel like a kid again when you hear their
voices it's really nostalgic in that end so but
yeah a good spot for it i guess steve your thoughts
on aristocats um it's one of those it's one of
those earlier films that i just i i don't care
for as much i mean i i don't mind the the the
film itself but i don't particularly care for
a lot of the animal films that are pre -90 1990
um i don't know they just don't don't pull for
me i don't know if it's because i didn't watch
them growing up as a kid and i watched them as
an adult that they just don't kind of linger
with me so i i don't really have a opinion i
i don't hate the fact that it's on the list because
i mean a lot of the disney films it's kind of
hard not to have on the list uh being that they've
all kind of had some kind of an impact uh on
animation but um i personally don't care for
it fair enough well there's only one spot left
in today's episode lots of films out there that
people are probably waiting to hear we'll see
if one of them is our number 81 film 81 All right,
rounding off our episode today, we've gone from
100 all the way down to number 81. And guess
what? We're going to end with a modern film from
2013. And our second Marvel slash DC entry on
our countdown, and that is Batman Dark Knight
Returns Part Dos. I don't know if we would consider
this a sequel or not, since it's really just
a second part of the other one. But it appeared
on six lists. The highest it ranked was actually
number six. 21 Network ranked it all the way
up at number six. 394 points for Batman Dark
Knight Returns Part 2. I will hand it over to
the rest of the panel. I have yet to see this
part because I was waiting for the deluxe edition
release where both parts are in the same release
so I could watch the movie in its entirety instead
of, well, I've seen part one. Part one's damn
awesome. Oh, part two. Okay. Okay. Okay. I'll
let you go in a second. Put your tongue away,
Joker. I'm sure part two is simply amazing as
well as part one was, but I have yet to see it.
I got to get the combined release. Go ahead,
Steve. Okay. I have seen part one and part two.
I've watched them back to back. Now that I have
them. Part two. Is the ultimate battle. Between.
Batman and the Joker. And Batman and Superman.
It's also. That's. The Dark Knight Returns. For
those not familiar with it. It's based off the
comic. By Frank Miller. Forever changed Batman.
Well, this was done beautifully on the animation
scope because not only do you have the grittiness
of the Frank Miller dialogue and type of animation
and everything, but it shows all the random extremes
that go on between the Joker and Batman on a
personal level. as well as some ramifications
of something that someone tells Superman to do
and Batman having to kind of put Superman in
his place before making some kind of a change
in his regime, I should say, without trying to
spoil it for any that haven't seen it. But it's...
uh i i think that it it holds up really well
um and it stays true to the uh um frank miller
adaptation yeah i go no i was just gonna say
real quick before you go dan uh kind of to preface
this um because you disagreed with their take
on world's finest um so how do you feel they
are they on par are they still overrating this
one no actually i i agree that this when i talked
about world's finest The one thing I was bringing
up was The Dark Knight Returns, and this is actually
the movie I was referencing. When you look at
it, because The World's Finest has that dynamic
between Batman and Superman, it is so much better
handled than this. They're not even... I mean,
some people could say it's unfair to compare
them because one is a Saturday morning cartoon
and another one's like a Dragon TV release that's
rated PG -13. Fair enough. But still, it is...
This, like I said, takes that format of... film,
even direct -to -DVD film, and does some things
very interesting with it. I think this stands
far and above all the DC animated movies that
went straight to DVD. This stands far and above
all of them. Some people could argue, well, yes,
it's because of the source material. All it's
doing is taking one of the greatest, one of the
most notable comics of all time and putting it
on the screen, which is true, but even great
source material doesn't always... mean you're
going to get a great return or a great movie.
There have been countless occasions where great
comic books, great books have not translated
well or they were not made well. In this case,
it stayed true, like Steve said. The animation
was flawless. There was enough little bits to
remind you of Frank Miller's art or the art of
the comic. There's so much that happens in that
part, too. It never feels overbloated. It never
feels like they're brushing through things too
much. Everything gets its proper time and proper
place. And to me, too, this is the first DC animated
movie to use that PG -13 rating and use it wisely
and use it well. So I'm really glad it made the
list. Is it better than something like we've
gone over? Maybe not. I had it in the 90s for
my list just because it's... But I do think,
as of right now, of all the animated films I've
watched this year currently, it's superior to
everything I've seen. I haven't seen an animated
movie that is nearly as good as this one. So
I do think the second half is better than the
first half, but I don't think it is kind of unfair
because the first half does a lot of legwork.
In the second half, you get all the payoff. But
yeah, Mike, I definitely advise picking it up
because it's pretty amazing. I ranked that actually
number 12 on my top 100 just because of how great
the film is. Mike, any other thoughts on it?
As I said, I've been waiting for the deluxe to
watch them both back to back. The first film,
as Dan said, does a lot of setup. but the first
film is still a damn good story. As far as Dan's
comments about using the PG -13 rating most effectively,
it does because Dark Knight Returns is a very,
very dark comic. I mean, it's something that
they probably had to cut back on a lot of the
animation stuff to just get it to a PG -13 rating.
But, I mean, I'm glad to see that it's here.
Fair enough. Well looking back at our first group
of 20 here a couple observations Some diversity
here. We've had a couple of anime films, Kiki's
Delivery Service, Ninja Scroll. We've had some
foreign films with Waltz with Bashir and Persepolis.
We've had definitely an influx of Disney films.
We've had some modern day films. So we're going
to get everybody's thoughts about this first
group of 20 real quick after this break. All
right, as I said, we've had a little bit of mixture
of everything. We're going to just do a quick
roundtable here and go around the table and see
what people's reactions are now that we've had
a little bit of a chance to let some of these
films settle in. Like I said, we've had two anime
films, two foreign films. We've had two comic
book films. We've had two sequels. We've had
only one film that... Predated the 80s with our
1970 film Aristocats. A whole lot of modern films.
Despicable Me 2, Rise of the Guardians, Paranorman,
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs, Princess and
the Frog. So a lot of ones from the last five
to eight years. A good deal of Disney. One, two,
three, four, five, six. seven disney films if
i'm counting right so starting with dan just
looking at our first 20 here 100 through 81 what
are your reactions so far based on the positive
side i'm glad to see that we do regarding just
format wise regarding medium regarding genre
we do have a variety there like you mentioned
anime we do have foreign films we have a claymation
we have stop motion animation so there is a variety
there and i think variety is good um there are
with 100 to 81 i think you do kind of have a
crap shoot you're gonna have those movies that
are really really good that probably deserve
to be higher uh cough cough loss of rashear and
persepolis but just haven't been seen by a lot
of people And you're going to have, I think,
those movies that are fresh in people's minds
that may make the list, like Rise of the Guardians
or other films like that that maybe don't deserve
it, but because they're recent, they didn't make
the cut. I don't know. Overall, I'm happy. I
am a little disappointed about a couple movies
that I've saw them already, but I'm probably
going to say this a lot. I do, in the long run,
I think it's good because hopefully it will get
people to... go out and try to experience those
movies and try to see what they're like and see
if they think they're better or if they deserve
higher. Like for example, I've never seen Ninja
Scroll. So I, while we're at break, I added it
to my Netflix queue and I will be checking it
out to see, you know, if I think it should be
higher as well. So to me, the numbers, you know,
the numbers can be what they are. I just, I like
more so diving deep in and discovering new movies
and seeing, you know, what other people think
of different mediums, as you can see. We all
have different opinions here, which is good.
So to me, that's the best. So numbers are one,
but you're going to have that. I think the other
thing that you get a little more at this end
of any of these countdowns is you'll have a few
more usually towards this end where not everyone's
seen it or one person's seen it or two or three
of the people have seen it, not everybody. And
I think as we move forward, it's more than likely
going to be the case where we get to the point
where. They're just films that everybody's seen
maybe. That's just a guess, but that's sometimes
what happens when you go start at 100 and work
your way up. I am interested to see that we've
already had two sequels and to see how many more
we see or is there any more sequels that are
deserving to be on there outside of a couple.
So how will that come out? To see kind of the
rankings amongst the genres, like as far as,
you know, if you're going to take all the Marvel
slash DC films in the order we put them in, are
we getting it right? If we take in the Disney
films, are we getting the order right? Some stuff
like that. So Steve, looking back at this first
group of 20, what are your initial reactions?
Kind of surprised in some of them. Along the
way. Are there any that we just, in your opinion,
any that just shouldn't be on our countdown or
any that should be very much higher? I wouldn't
say that some of them shouldn't be on the countdown.
But at the same time, I think some of them should
have been a little higher. Like, I like the...
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs. I like the
Dark Knight Returns Part 2. I definitely think
that one should be a lot higher than where it's
at. For that one, at least the top 50 just for
what it is and because it stayed true to the
adaptation or the source material. So I think
that those should have been a little bit higher.
Again, some of them I'm not familiar with, so
I can't really comment, but then the other ones
I can't really disagree where they're at. You
know, Mike, I think you said something, I don't
remember if it was on air or off air, but with
the influx of movies from the last five or six
years, there's two ways to look at that. Either
one, it's saying that in a bad light that we're...
just more conscious of those because they're
more recent and our memories more fresh and so
we're we're giving them more credence than they
deserve or in the positive light um a lot of
them are appearing now in the countdown versus
higher up um so what's your thoughts about about
all these films from the from the more recent
years more recent years i mean like With me and
Despicable Me, with that franchise, those characters
are so lovable, each one for different reasons.
Yes, the stories might not be the best animated
film story ever, but specifically with those
characters, it's just so heartwarming in a lot
of places, and it's an evolution between DM1
and DM2. As far as the rest of it, personally,
I think princess and the frog should be at 100
and everything else is better than that movie.
I just, I don't care for that movie whatsoever.
I just don't. That's probably the only one that
I would really switch around. Um, the rest I'm,
I'm fine with so far. And yeah, I mean, having
says the thing is like, that's, I mean, we've
gone over four decades pretty much. 70s, 80s,
90s, and 2000s. I mean, there's more than one
decade so far in 2000s. But what I'm saying is
we've gone through those four decades in this
section of the countdown, right? So, I mean,
it's a nice variety. Sure, there are a lot more
modern films than I would probably like. I wish
it was more even doubt over the 100 list, but
the problem is if we have... the more modern
films closer to, say, like top 40, top 30, you
know, people are going to say, oh, well, that
just came out. How is that the best? Or how is
that this? How is that that? And, you know, I
know we ran into problems with that on the top
100 animated series countdown. But I mean, yeah,
I guess it is good that we're getting a lot of
the modern stuff out, as you said earlier, Kev,
you know, as we go along. You know, we get to
top 50, 40, 30. It's going to be a lot more of
stuff that people have seen. I'll say right now
for me, I was even surprised when Ninja Scroll
came up because that's like one of the only animes
I've ever seen. So and I know for a fact that
as soon as Kevin says, you know, hey, this is
the next anime film on the list. I'll immediately
hit my mute button because I don't watch that
genre. Not saying I dislike the genre. It's just
it's not my thing. And. Other than that, I think
we're off to a good start. I think we have a
nice variation of different animated films in
the first section here. So just going back to
Dan real quick before we close out the discussion
this time, anything as far as looking forward
into the rest of the countdown, stuff you're
scared about, stuff you're excited about, what
are you curious the most about as we move forward?
Well, my number two started this list, so I'm
really hoping my number one doesn't start the
next list because that would make me feel like
that. I'm curious to see if this continuation
of a variety of genre continues. I'm also curious
to see if this is the end of the modern stuff.
If we start to get more into the more classic
and more acclaimed movies from the past. I expected
it with the top. you know 20 does that now dissipate
more as we move on and we get closer and closer
so and to me i'm really curious like to see where
some of the uh how the studios stack up to each
other like the pixar versus disney versus dreamworks
versus uh you know sony and all those different
areas like you know who's really going to reign
supreme that'll be interesting to see so Alright,
well, there you have it, folks. Numbers 100 through
81 are in the books. Join us next week when we'll
be counting down numbers 80 to 61. For now, I
am TF2 and Mike with... Steve Megatron Phillips.
And Optimus Solo. And MovieRevolt Dan. Thank
you for listening. Until next time, unleash the
geek in you. You've just listened to GeekCast
Radio. On the Geekcast Radio Network, there are
several ways to get in contact with us or leave
feedback for the show. First, visit the website
geekcastradio .com where you can comment on all
of our different podcasts. Second, you can rate
our show and leave us feedback in iTunes. Third,
follow us on Twitter at Geekcast Radio. Fourth,
become a fan on Facebook. Go to facebook .com
slash geekcastradio. Call the voicemail line
502 -526 -5821. Please remember to tell us the
show you are leaving the message for and your
name. So until next time, unleash the geek in
you.
No chapter markers for this episode.
Hosts
More from GeekCast Radio
All Episodes →
The Top 100 Animated Series: The 15th Anniversary Ultimate Wrap Up!

The Top 100 Animated Series: 25-01 | Part 5 - The 15th Anniversary Countdown

The Top 100 Animated Series: 50-26 | Part 4 - The 15th Anniversary Countdown

Only thing I’m REALLY bummed about is Lilo and Stitch is way too low IMO. Other than that it’s a fine list so far, glad to see Persepolis and Waltz with Bashir make it!
FINALLY The Countdown has come back to Geekcast Radio. Of course I said that in the Rock’s voice lol. It’s great so far. The Waltz movie and Persepolis I never heard about, but they sound interesting. Looking forward to see what is to come!
Persepolis was waaay too low. That should easily be in the Top 20 maybe even top 10
A lot of fun so far guys. I’m a little surprised to see the World’s Finest on here. Was that really an animated movie? I guess it was, and I did love it.
as stated in the ep originally it was a three part ep arc in Superman TAS. Which they then later combined all three parts by taking out the previously on and end creds of STAS. The film version plays a lot smoother then watching three eps lol
I could see what you are saying, and I do like that it. I don’t know if it is a movie per say though
Cool, but take it from an obsessed DCAU nut…. when they “cobble multi part eps into film style… it’s not done half assed at all.
The did the same treatment to Justice League Star-Crossed which was the Season 2 three part finale. The film version added NEW music and end credits, and it was very smoothly spliced as if the end credits pr prevuously on was never there.
Crap I feel like I just repeated myself. MAYBE people can listen to LOTDK Ep 25 when it releases….. Steve and I will be doing commentary on WF then! That way I can get my point across better in general lol
It doesn’t make it a film though. They take out the ‘previously on’ stuff when they put it on Netflix. It doens’t make it a movie now. Nearly every TV show or cartoon series has had multipart episodes. Would you include the Spider-Man episodes where The X-Men showed up as a movie to? You open the flood gates if you are going to say The World’s Finest episodes is a movie that belongs on this list.
Really? Waltz of Bashir and Persepolis in the bottom twenty? Not going to lie, not starting off on the greatest foot there lol. Though points for having Dark Knight Returns Part II and James and the Giant Peach.
never even heard of Waltz or Persepolis… The only Polis I know is Metropolis lol So there’s no way I personally could vote for stuff that I never even heard of.
I understand what you are saying here but you have to realize that any time a list is being created using upwards of 20 people that more niche films, unknown films, or ‘non-mainstream’ films usually don’t get ranked very high. Not saying I agree with all of the selections so far but the mere fact that they made the list shows their value and is a positive in my book.
Persepolis is far too low. Still happy it made the list.
I never heard of those movies before I listened to this list
Obviously Waltz being at 100 does hurt me quite a bit, but honestly I was surprised it even made it. Like I have said, and will say again, the number part is fun, but to me I am in it more for the discussion and discovery.
Great fun so far! BIg ups for a Goofy Movie Forgot that even was MADE lol
Loving it so far. Glad to see the love for Dark Knight Returns! Part II was so EPIC! A Goofy Movie making it was the biggest surprise to me so far.
It’s been pretty good so far. I think Ninja Scroll and Lilo and Stitch should be higher. Always thought Oliver and Company was crappy, but besides that its been fun.
I can’t believe the HATE for Oliver & Company….. I didn’t go into FULL detail as to why I enjoy it so much during this ep of the countdown. But it has several things that are great about it:
-Good characters
-a bit of mystery when it comes to the villain
-Billy Joel rocks as a voice actor
Sure the plot is standard, but I love the action of it, and the songs were awesome too!!! The animation looked crisp to me, and loved all the different dogs!!!
Here’s ToonCast Classic Ep 34 where I ramble on more about Oliver and Company.
http://www.geekcastradio.com/archives/tooncast-classic/tooncast-episode-34-oliver-and-company
I think I watched that cartoon once as a kid or so. Saw it with my kids recently and they hated it. It has not aged well I’ll say date. All the songs play like bad MTV video knock offs.
Great list so far. No big complaints some interesting surprises.
You are one of the few lol. Thanks for the support.
Actually haven’t heard hardly any complaints compared to what lists like this usually get…
Glad I heard about this. I enjoyed listening a great amount. I don’t think I have even watch 100 animated movies so no big complaints yet. The extreme hatred for Princess and the Frog is odd to me. I still don’t get why. Besides that all good.
I hate it because they made a poor resolution to the story. It was a freakin’ catch 22 that she even “became a damn princess”
Man has this been a trip down memory land so far. It bringing me back to the glory days of my childhood. James and the Giants Peach. Are you kidding me! I forgot that movie even happened. Man now I need to go watch some movies again! Great podcast so far. Looking forward to hearing more
Thanks for the kind comments, hope you enjoy the rest of the episodes!
Sheeeeeeeeet! The first three episodes of “Visionaries” was released as a feature length episode on video back in the 80’s. Could I have included that?
I agree, don’t get why that one was even included. It’s a TV show not a movie. Ok they released it DVD. They did that with The Spider-Man animated series among many others. I understand direct to dvd movies being included, but cartoon series or TV movies should be in a separate category.
You’ve made your opinion known, no need to repeat yourself numerous times 😉 It was deemed eligible end of story
geez man. Settle down. Just making conversation. Touchy, touchy,
I believe you missed my smiley face 😉
While I don’t feel as strongly about World’s Finest as Steve and Mike I do think it does qualify for the list. We did make the regulation that movies that went to straight to DVD do qualify, and to be fair World’s Finest isn’t just three episodes of one cartoon. It is combing multiple cartoons into one story. So while other cartoons have had multi part episodes with it being a ‘special event’ does make it different then something like Spider-Man having a guest star.
The podcast has been good so far, but there are many movies I have an issue with. Watz, Persepolis, Lilo and Stich, Aristocrats, among others should be much higher. Oliver and Company was the low point of Disney animation, and the reason they changed course for the better. Rise of the Guardians was crap and should be tossed out. How anyone can say Despicable Me 2 is the 6TH GREATEST animated movie of all time is crazy to me. Its an okay sequel at best. Nothing about the story is ‘damn good’.
Fox and the Hound was probably the low point of Disney animation, Oliver and Company was on the upswing and was the test case for a Disney musical before The Little Mermaid. Without Oliver and Company there’s no Disney Renaissance.
I don’t agree with that Disney was doing musicals since it began. Maybe not directly taking a musical and putting on screen, but they have always been heavy on the musical base. Not to mention it was critically panned. So how can you say its a test case?
Plus I like Fox and the Hound. Besides Little Mermaid its the best Disney had to offer in the 80s
He’s saying it because it’s a fact. This has been mentioned by people actually working at Disney.
I stand corrected, still does not make it a great movie.
agreed don’t think anyone was claiming it was great though haha
if you look at DM1-2 they are awesome stories, and the sequel takes the story further. Hence why I rated it so high. I found more enjoyment in that film than most of the animated garbage that has come out this year.
The stories are ok. The idea of the vilian being won over by children has been done to death IMO. The first movie is good, but the 2nd one is an average movie at best. The animation and story in Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 is much better.
Plus 6th movie of all time? Lion King, Spirited Away, Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin–you think that movie belongs in the same league as those? There is no explanation that can make that true.
I saw the first cloudy and it was meh lol
Loving it so far guys! No complaints yet! Keep it up! lol. Honestly though nothing all the big annoyed me number wise. Have enjoyed the discussion as well.
Well where do I start. For one too many newer movies, Rise of the Guardians, Despicable Me 2, and Polar express have no place on this list. Cloudy, an actual good recent movie, should be much higher. Ninja Scroll too low but I expected that after listening to the 1st episode and lack of anime knowledge. I’ll give you credit that I have no idea what to expect next.
I would argue that even though Polar Express isn’t ‘great’ that it is unique and from a technical standpoint important enough to make it into a top 100.
I agree sir!
You mean the awful performance capture, which nearly ended Robert Zemeckis career? I hate that animation The only time it was used well at all was in Avatar and in video games. The characters in Polar Express look soulless lol
I was never a fan of that look either. I still really love Polar Express though. Watch it every Christmas.
I have no issues with the numbers by any means. You can argue until you are blue in the face the what movie goes where. My question is more so how much research went into this list for some of you. I think its impressive you went to so many sources, but some people on the record appeared, I apologize if this sounds rude, limited in the area. Certain movies I think are essential viewing when making a list like this appear to be foreign to some of you. You can’t watch everything I get that, but if I were to put out a list there are certain movies that I make sure I watch. Something like Persepolis would be on that list considering how huge it was in critical circles. It’s only the first full episode so I may be saying that too early. I do look forward to hearing the next episode.
My issue with this is, one if it wasn’t originally released here I personally don’t care to see it. Two that also means I would never have heard of it to begin with. So doing “research” I have seen almost every North American released animated film. Granted my knowledge maybe lackluster or dated on whether I remember them all at this point but I have seen them. Not discounting films such as Persepolis or others similar to it in quality but to me I have my own issues with that will come out in the next episode. The fact some of these even made it on here speaks volumes as to those that have seen the films.
Persepolis was released here, by the way, and was nominated
for an Oscar. Not that it means anything, it does show it was rather acclaimed and not a niche’ film. Look at any major listing of the greatest animated movies and I’m sure you will see it there. I assume when constructing a list like this that was done correct? I would assume if you all are going to this trouble, promoting this thing, you are at least looking at what are the top films in the genre, and not just going off of the films you watched as a kid? And if you haven’t seen them trying to? Did you see any movies in preparation to try to fill those holes?
The statement about only be interested in films that were released here troubles me some for the rest of this list. How can you construct a list and purposely ignore a huge part of the animation world. I understand if you don’t like them, but not doing the decent thing of WATCHING them makes we wonder why you even did a project
like this. I’ve seen many similar lists to this one online, and I enjoy
listening and reading them. I enjoy the ones a lot more when I see people are doing a decent amount of research. I get that you can’t see everything, but not even giving an effort to see some of the more notable that aren’t made by Disney or Dreamworks makes this project kind of pointless. I hope you bothered to watch movies like
Fritz the Cat, Heavy Metal, Fire and Ice, Animal Farm, A Soldier’s Tale, Plague Dogs, and The Story of the Fox?
I love lists like this, and for my money this is the only Top 100 Animated Movie list I have ever seen so I got excited for it. But when some of the major people involved put little thought into their lists my enjoyment does dissipate. To be fair I can’t say that is the case for everyone. Just some of the people on the record. I hope the other episodes prove me wrong.
To be fair I wasn’t claiming to be all knowing. I have seen films and not just by Disney or DreamWorks. As for looking at other top lists, no we didn’t because it wouldn’t be our opinion. Some of us may have but by looking at a list like that to me, I will disagree blindly and not voted more fairly. It would be a game to beat the system. This I voted on my opinion of the top 100 best. Also of note, not everyone has the same tastes. I rank based on what I watched. For you to tell me those are great films is fine, I will try to obtain them. That being said, I’ve never heard of them to even rank. So I would have bothered had I heard of them. I voted sed on what I’ve watched out of 200 films. Others have voted for those so who knows what will show. That’s the benefit of doing such a grandiose list with other contributors. It eliminates the issue of something not getting brought into where it should be. We aren’t claiming this as an all time list either but again the first episode or episode 51 tells exactly what I mean here. I also haven’t tried to vote by what I saw as a kid as much. 95% of my list I’ve watched within the last year or so. Again not discounting your opinion but mine also is taken into account where I am but one piece of 20-25 voting parties. Also as far as the Oscars, to me that whole awards and many others like them are a joke.
Love the feedback and appreciate what you are saying however there are some major problems with your argument here.
First, you assume that just because people are on the ‘record’ that they are ‘major players’ in this project. Outside of Dan and myself no one on any of the records so far or throughout this project is any more ‘major’ or a player than any of the other 20 people/groups/websites/podcasts/blogs who submitted lists for this project.
Second, you can’t make any educated judgements about any particular person within that above mentioned group without seeing the INDIVIDUAL Top 100 List that they submitted. For example, let’s say we get through all 100 and you criticize me because based on what was said on the record you have assumed that I don’t like ‘this or that’ etc etc. However, you would have no idea that perhaps on my own individual list I had those particular movies ranked in the Top 50 or even Top 20… So without seeing the particular lists its hard to think you know how people compiled their lists.
If you listened to the introduction episode you would have heard that OVER 350 movies received votes. Remember though, this is not supposed to be the Top 100 Critically Acclaimed Animated Movies, nor the Top 100 Animated Films of All-Time…this is the Geekcast Radio Network’s Top 100 Animated Films – may seem like semantics but there is a difference.
A lot of people involved did do some research of varying levels and I myself did re-watch or watch for the first time some films that I felt necessary to watch in order to accurately rank my films. Granted most of the movies that most people haven’t heard of I have actually seen already in gathering character images for behindthevoiceactors.com so I had that advantage. (This is proven by the fact that I had a dozen or so on my list that NONE of the other 20 lists had haha). I also did peruse other Top lists but I don’t see that as important as you do. Other lists should not really have any factor in if a movie deserves to be ranked or not…I hate the idea of ‘I should rank this high because such and such did’ that’s just cancer to any list like this.
Again, great to hear such detailed feedback. Keep it coming. Usually the first half of Top 100 countdowns can be all over the place and its the second half where you really see the cream rise to the top.
I see what you are saying, but there are certain things you need to keep in mind. For one we probably had about 30 or so people combined making this list. We knew ahead of time there re certain areas some of us are less versed in than others, which is why we reached out to so many sources.’
Also the only person who knows what is on the list is Kevin, so we are finding out just like you are. So we may not have in depth reviews of a movie right on the spot. On the bright side you get to listen to our honest reaction. So far it seems we disagree with the list more than anyone lol. As we are seeing some of our favorites fall quite quickly–which also shows how well versed of opinions we have when our favorites aren’t near the top.
There maybe a movie or few that I have not seen on the list, or someone else. But the good thing about the record right now in my opinion is we all seem to have differing opinions. What I enjoy is much different that Steve, and Steve’s opinion is much different than Kevin’s etc.. I prefer that as it makes for more interesting discussion, and based on the reaction we are getting people agree.
Also I have said from the beginning the best thing about lists like this is discovery. In the first episode I was not aware of Ninja Scroll, but now I have the chance to watch it. Some may have never heard of Waltz or Persepolis who listened, and I hope they do the same.
Took me a long time but I caught up with this. It’s been fun so far. The mass amount of current movies on the list so far is strange. I hope that means the classic are where they should be.
This is such an epic project. Went back and checked out your old Top 100, and that was awesome too. I mean, I do disagree violently with the list lmao. I still loved listening.
I went back and listened to the first episode and I’ll admit I did rush to judgment a little but. Still, when I hear people so dismissive of movies that aren’t mainstream it irks me a little bit.
No I completely understand your position though. Maybe in a yer or two when we do it again we will know better. I just don’t follow films unless I know the franchise or its been to theaters.
what steve says below about not following films unless he knows the franchise is exactly where I’m coming from too. Plus as I’ve stated many times before, I’ll watch something that has Russian being spoken, but with subtitles. However I refuse to watch anything in a total other language, forcing me to read subtitles through the entire thing. That to me feels like work.
Glad you are enjoying the ride
I’m not unsympathetic to your disinterest in anime. I don’t really think that there’s much anime that’s truly worth watching. Even during the golden era (way back in the early-to-mid-90s), the main reason we were watching the stuff was because other than Animaniacs and Batman, there was no animation on TV worth watching. So my friends an I would hit up Blockbuster and rent one or two selections from the “Japanimation” section.
If any of you have ever stayed up late watching terrible B-movies on UHF channels with your buddies, this is really no different. Just something that is fun and weird to watch at 11PM at night. And eventually, this sort of ritual is what evolved into MST3K.
There are certainly some gems, but I think most anime is pretentious. In particular, Ghost In the Shell is so far up its own ass, it’s practically lost. And I’m sure it’s ranked high on this list. …unfortunately.
Can’t speak on Ghost In the Shell but agree with everything else you said here!
So you are dismissing an entire genre of animation that is adored by millions with a whim, yet you are saying it is Anime that is up its own ass. Hmmm…okay.
Replace “adored by millions” with “adored by an extremely vocal minority”.
And I’m hardly dismissing it. Ask Blanchard about my affinity for anime. Or you can listen to my podcast where I talk about it all the time. If you think I don’t like it, you’re sorely mistaken.
What I’m saying is that anime has become pretentious in how it is marketed to the west. I recommend anime all the time, but I also have many, many critiques as to how it’s produced in Japan and how it’s marketed to the west. It’s repetitive and it turns off a mainstream audience.
I think there is a lot of anime that Blanchard and company SHOULD watch, but I also understand their disinterest in it, because a lot of it is utter crap. For every good anime, there are at least ten bad ones. And thanks to people who think that anime is a genre (that’s like calling all of American animation a genre), we had companies like ADV who just bought up the rights to everything they could get their hands on, whether or not it was actually worth watching. That’s how garbage like Godannar go localized.
Frankly, I blame the anime fanbase for the downfall of Japanese animation in the west, because they’re the ones who put Japanese animation on a pedestal. And companies like ADV listened. And now ADV is out of business, because they sold way more garbage than what was actually worth watching.
You know what ADV’s highest DVD sales were? The remastered version of Robotech. It sold way more than even Evangelion. That should be a wake-up call to anyone who thinks that anime has been relevant in the last 20 years.
Western audiences just aren’t interested. Get over it.
I totally agree with Neil here.
“Get it over.” Smart choice of words there, as the
entire time I am reading your off tangent remarks that barely form any sort of logical point the phrase that echoed through my head violently was this statement is written by a person who really needs to get over themselves.
Your incredulous masturbatory remarks are interesting. I’ll give you that. So maybe when I’m in a masochistic mood I’ll spend some time and listen to your podcast.
Making a big deal about calling something a genre like anime
is a pointless argument of semantics that I honestly don’t even want to bother to get into, but I’ll amuse you. The term genre has greatly morphed over the years, and now is even used to describe the likes of superhero movies. Is it a genre in the same vein as action or comedy? No, but anime does tend to share certain characteristics and style—which is commonly associated with genre. I’m sure I could have used a better turn of phrase to categorize anime, but genre did the job and unknowingly had the side effect of striking some sort of random nerve with you. So if it’s that big of a deal to you I’ll admit a mistake there.
Also you do realize how many people are in this world right,
and when I indicated millions nowhere did I indicate specifically the west. So no I was right. Millions across the globe have a strict fondness for anime.
Interesting you accuse me of ignorantly lumping anime in as
a genre, and then seemed shocked that the scope of anime would not have a flawless record. You seem to assume that I place anime on this pedestal of infallibility. I agree there is a great deal of it that is not very good. As is the same with any form of film. The bad can outweigh the good.
My statement was simply meant to call out the hypocrisy of diminishing most of anime as pretentious when you statements so far are obviously soaked in pretentiousness. You state you are against things being up their own ass, but so far it appears you enjoy the pleasure of your hand firmly up your own.
Dude, seriously? WTF?!
I try to explain my point, and all you can do is throw a temper tantrum.
All I was saying was that I understand why the hosts of the show aren’t interested in anime. And I’m someone who WATCHES anime.
I try to explain that the vast majority of anime lacks the sort of appeal that would draw a more casual audience. For some reason, you took this personally.
This is exactly the sort of elitist crap that drives people away. Good job.
You didn’t even read half of what I said.
@InsurgentCinema:disqus This is coming from someone who disagrees with @Neilsama:disqus on a LOT of topics….but he is right on just about everything he has said in this post. I’m not trying to flame a war or turn this into a negative conversation or discourse but you seem to have gone in defense mode here because someone ‘seemingly’ said something harsh about something you love and now it seems that you are just grasping at straws and trying to find ways to serve up low blows instead of actually engaging in intelligent well thought out dialogue….unfortunate since I was hoping you two could actually begin an interesting and engaging discussion on the subject… 🙁
Wow! Lots of comments and feedback. I’m enjoying the countdown so far and believe it is off to a pretty solid start. What is the title of the movie at 100? Wallz something? I heard you mention it a few times and I still can’t make it out. Plus, searching for “Waltz” or “Waltz movie via Google and Netflix isn’t helping. If you can tell me what it is I would be interested in checking it out.
Ninja Scroll got 100% on Rotten Tomatoes?! I think it’s a very enjoyable movie, I’m just surprised so many critics liked it. The fights are pretty darn amazing. I like the animation style and it’s just fun. Glad to see it on the list and I’m not upset it falls where it does on the list.
Likewise, I’m not a fan of the Madagascar movie, and I haven’t seen the sequels. I’ll agree with Mike that the penguins are the best thing to come from the franchise, as the Penguins cartoon is excellent.
I’ve never seen The Polar Express. It didn’t look appealing to me, but it’s on Netflix so I’ll try to catch it sometime.
I agree that Pocahontas is more enjoyable than Princess and the Frog. Princess isn’t bad, it just lacks anything that makes it very memorable. And the songs in Pocahontas are more fun.
I just thought Aristrocats was okay too. Like Steve, I didn’t see some of the 70’s and 80’s Disney toons until I was older, so they didn’t have the same appeal for me. Yet, I feel better movies have that all-ages appeal, and that makes them worthy of being higher on the list, so again, I think they’re fine being on the list, and I’m glad they’re no higher.
The Dark Knight Returns movies (parts 1 and 2) are excellent. It’s one of the strongest of the DCU animated films, and my favorite animated movie of the year as well, Dan. I would like to have seen it higher, but it is recent, so that could be why it ranks lower. The battles between Bats and Superman and Joker are EPIC! I waited to buy them and got the Target Steelbook of the Deluxe Edition and I’m very happy with it.
World’s Finest is an excellent story, but I’m leaning towards Dan’s view that it’s basically three episodes of the cartoon slapped onto a DVD. Don’t get me wrong, I love it, and I’m okay with it being on the list though.
I’m sure there are other comments I wanted to make, but that’s all I can recall for now.
The movie is Waltz with Bashir. It is an Israeli animated documentary where a former soldier interviews his past friends about the invasion of Lebanon
OK. It actually was the first hit on Netflix when I had searched, but the cover art didn’t strike me as being an animated feature. It also suggest that I will “Like” this movie, giving it 3 out of 5 stars. It is not on streaming, so it’ll take a while before I get around to it. Thanks for clarifying.