GeekCast Radio
GCR – Episode 56 – Top 100 Animated Films 20-01

Part of a Collection
About this Episode
Hi, this is Pat Fraley, purveyor of duck, doog,
and felon vultures, and you're listening to the
Geekcast Radio Network. Hey, it's David Kaye,
voice of Beast Wars Megatron and TFA Optimus.
You're listening to the Geekcast Radio Network.
Geekcastradio .com presents... Top 100 Animated
Films Countdown. Welcome to GeekCast Radio. This
is episode 56. I am one of your hosts, TF2, and
Mike. Joining me is Optimus Solo. Hello. Yes,
sir. Steve Megatron. Hello. Hello. TV's Mr. Neal.
Howdy. And, of course, Mirabelle Dan. Hello.
How's it going? It's going. Today we are revealing
the top 20 of the GCRN Top 100 Animated Films
Countdown. It has been a long process getting
here, and after what we had two weeks ago with
Episode 54's backlash, oh my god. Kev, you got
any info you want to dump on us before we get
started? I haven't felt too much of a backlash
from anything. I just think, I can't believe
how fast we've gone through this list. um relatively
it seems like it seems like we just can't believe
we get it done before christmas just a couple
things i guess to look for in this one that way
i mean we're finally to the the end of the line
here we're finally to the top 20. um As we've
been going through this, there's been different
shifts as far as how many of these will we see
or how many more will this be? I mean, obviously,
there's no more room for anything else. So we're
getting to the time where the discussion shifts
a little bit. And I think one thing that I find
interesting looking at once you get to this end
of the list or any list like you're doing like
this, I think one of the main questions is before
people question, you know, should something be
on the top 100, should it not? Really, I would
think those arguments can kind of go by the wayside
for this episode. I would hope that anything
in our top 20, the argument's not whether it
should be in the top 100 or not. It's just whether
it's placed where it should be placed. But I
would hope that everyone would be kind of universal,
that all of these films deserve somewhere in
the top 100. And I will apologize in advance
for anyone I call out or... um reverse the train
on um as far as throwing them under it but something
that boggles my mind for some of these is is
how certain films can be left off of somebody's
top 100 list entirely um so i'll go about it
in the nicest way possible as far as uh talking
about uh certain films that were left off people's
list entirely um but it's uh it's gonna answer
all the questions here today we're gonna answer
you know not as far as stuff that we'll do in
the wrap up, but all the things will be revealed.
So people could figure out, you know, how many,
which decades are best represented, which companies
are best represented. And then we will obviously
comment on all of that in the wrap up. But it
should be interesting. I know nobody really knows
the results. So people might be nervous on, especially
since we did not give the honorable mentions.
So now it comes time to figure out. Was that
film that you've been waiting for just completely
left off of our list or did it find a spot in
our top 20? And if we didn't have them before,
I mean, I think last episode we saw three people's
number ones fall with Akira, Nightmare Before
Christmas and Grave of the Fireflies. And obviously
we had to had one fall previous to that with
Batman Beyond Return of the Joker. So that was
really only four people's number one. As we go
through, we will see an onslaught of people's
number ones, obviously, and people's number twos
and threes and everything. So it'll be interesting
to see how we boil this down. Dan, kind of go
around the panel here real quick before we get
into it and before we pass it back to Mike before
we start. But thoughts, fears, hopes on the journey
so far and on what we have left for today, Dan.
Well, after the threat last week, I am you talk
about fears. I am doing tonight's podcast with
a paintball mask on just in case Neil's number
one does not make the top top 20. But I guess
my fear, I think the best podcast this far, at
least talking wise, have been the ones that have
been a mixture or at least somewhat of a mixture
of different types of animation, whether it be
like anime versus traditional or, you know, classic
versus, you know, claymation or CGI. So. Part
of me wonders, when we get into this top 20,
will we see more of that? Will we just get a
lot of CGI animation? Will we just get current
stuff? Because that's been dominating the list,
at least in my mind, and that may not be number
-wise. So that's not necessarily a fear, just
a question I have. And two, I guess, seriously,
though, thinking about if anyone's number one
doesn't make the list, doesn't make the top 100.
because we don't know that at this point. So
that'd be kind of cool to see if there's actually
a number one out there that doesn't miss the
list completely. And two, I think I have an idea
of what number one is. I have some money running
on it in Vegas, so hopefully it turns out to
be correct. Is there any film specifically, Dan,
without naming the film, that you're worried
is not going to show up on the list at all that
you were hoping to see? There's one I'm worried
that will show up and one that I'm worrying that
will not show up specifically but So, yeah, I
guess the question the answer that question would
be yes All right, Mike thoughts before we get
into today on the countdown so far and what we
have looking forward to today well It's going
to be very interesting. I think It's gonna be
call into question the list will be if 20 to
11 are all Disney sequels. I will say this again
in the wrap -up. It's more so to address what
you said earlier about how people can leave stuff
off their lists. For me personally, Number one,
I was not going to go back and watch every animated
film there ever was in preparation to do this
countdown. No, no, and I agree. I know, I know.
I'm not saying this against you. I'm just telling
the people in general. I've seen on the website
comments of, oh, how can you not have seen this?
How can you not have seen that? And this, that,
and the other thing and everything else. And
for me, if I haven't seen a film, it doesn't
get ranked in my personal, you know. In my personal
list that I submitted for this collaboration.
So that may sound like I'm being closed minded.
No, I'm not. I don't watch every single animated
film ever. I kind of brought that up more as
a, not saying that someone was wrong for not
including it, but more so bringing it up on,
I'd love to have the conversation with people
on why certain things aren't included. Is it
because you haven't seen it? Is it because you're
just biased against it for some reason and you
ignore it? acclaim or its impact. It's false
acclaim is what you're getting at here. No, I'm
just saying in general what the reasoning is.
But no, as far as what's in the top 20, as we've
stated, only Optimus Solo knows that as we reveal
these. And I don't know. I mean, I'm hoping...
Honestly, really, I'm outside of maybe three
Disney films. I'm hoping the rest are not Disney.
Yeah, we'll have to see which companies are represented
in the top 20. And before we get to Neil and
Steve, throw out a few minor stats for you. We've
been going over points the whole time because
obviously the max number of points you would
possibly get was 2 ,000. And with Ratatouille,
which came in at 21 last week, we... reached
the 1 ,000 point mark. So everything in the top
20 obviously has over half the possible points.
And only two films that we will talk about today
appeared on less than 16 lists. So there's only
two films that did not appear on at least 16
out of the 20 collaborative lists that were put
out there. And something else we might talk a
tiny bit about is some rankings if you just took...
based off people that did rank them um but yeah
we'll see uh steve any thoughts on the countdown
so far or what's your without naming you know
specific movies what you're looking forward to
or in fear of for today's episode any films that
you are worried might not make it uh no i mean
i'm not really that worried i'm kind of curious
to see what is exactly is going to be in the
top 20 uh whether it be something everybody's
voted very highly on or just many people or everybody
voted on something um i'm just kind of curious
to see what comes in uh i'm a little disappointed
at the previous episode uh falling of my number
two but uh not to dig back down that rat hole
but i uh no i mean i'm i'm pretty pleased with
it so far i mean yeah the next time Things will
come out differently, but this time it's interesting,
to say the least, to see what's coming up. And
Neil, coming through, kind of joining the crew
as far as the actual records go for these last
40 out of the 100 and being able to listen and
look at what has come previously, what are your
thoughts just overall in general on the countdown
so far? Well, coming in late, I... I don't have
a strong opinion about a lot of the entries that
have come so far. Going into the top 20, there's
a couple Disney films that I'm pretty sure are
going to be there, and then there's at least
two that I'm kind of worried won't show up that
I'm really rooting for. That's about all I have
at the moment. Okay. And one last question for,
let's throw this one to Dan here. We have talked
previously about the companies and which ones
have shown up, which ones hadn't. And then there
was kind of a long, long wait for the first film
from Pixar. And we kind of decided that it was
much longer than any of us expected for our first
Pixar film to show up. We've had four Pixar films
so far in the countdown. Shot in the dark, how
many Pixar films do you expect to see in the
top 20? You know what, I'll cut it in half and
I'll say, I don't even know the total off the
top of my head, but I'll say 10. So half of the
remaining countdown could possibly be from Pixar?
Yeah, I'll go with the over and say 10. All right.
Mike, take it away. All right, so we are here
to reveal the top 20 numbers 20 through 1. And
here we go. All right, let's start off with number
20. You know, it's kind of interesting. Every
time we reveal one, it's like one less spot for
someone to see their movie show up. Let's start
somewhere where we knew we would go somewhere
in this top 20. We knew we would travel to the
wonderful world of Disney at some point. We're
going to start off. there and we're going to
start with a film from 1967 it was on everybody
except for two lists uh 1021 points the highest
it ranked though was uh the highest i got ranked
was number seven nobody ranked it higher than
seven it comes in at number 20 and that is disney's
the jungle book um like i said only two people
left this off of their list 86 rotten tomato
score um Mike, your opinions on Jungle Book starting
off our countdown at number 20. It's a memorable
movie, but top 20? No. Very enthused reaction
from Mike. Just no. Well, it's an interesting
film. It does, if you think about it, it probably
appeals to a lot of people who were adopted.
Because it is about an adopted boy who was adopted.
I don't know. It's one of those weird movies.
It really is. The Disney version is probably
the best version you could actually watch. It
doesn't just take the whole context of the story
to weigh out weird places. But all the Disney
movies that we talked about in episode 55 are
so much better than Jungle Book. I disagree with
that somewhat. I don't know. For me, if I was
to rank my top 10 Disney films, and I'm not doing
that, so I'm not saying 100 % I know what they
would be, but I'm pretty sure Jungle Book would
be in my top 10 list of all -time Disney films.
And being in my top 10 Disney films, does it
deserve to be in top 20 overall? I guess it would
come down to the math and figure out where it
ranks. I had it in my top 20 on my 100 list,
so I have no problem with it. I love the music.
This one is similar to me in how I feel and how
I react to Robin Hood. I don't know. I really
like these two. This is, I think, my brother's
favorite Disney film, so maybe that has something
to do with me being exposed to it more so over
my childhood. But I have no problem with this
one being in our top 20. Neil, what do you think
about Jungle Book? I like the Jungle Book. I
don't know if I'd put it up this high, but it's
a good film. I find the animation more appealing
than the actual story. Like I said last time,
I kind of like that era of Disney where it kind
of looks like it came off of a Xerox machine.
It kind of has that kind of sort of dirty look
to it, and that's what this has. I'd say it's
maybe five, ten spaces too high, but I still
like it. It's a good film, and I'm okay with
it being here. Steve, how do you like The Jungle
Book? You've had interesting opinions on, you
know, you've seen a ton of Disney films, if not
all of them, it seems like. And you said you
had quite a library of them. And you have some
interesting opinions on some of them. How do
you feel about The Jungle Book? I find this one
a little bit more enjoyable than some of the
other ones. Example being like Cinderella or...
Dumbo or stuff like that. I find I can watch
this one more than those films. So I definitely
can see where it belongs in the top 100. I don't
know if I would put it in the top 20 per se.
I could have seen that more or less than the
previous episode that we recorded. But I mean,
I don't have a problem with it. Overall, I mean,
the voice acting's fun and the songs, the animation
actually isn't bad for the time compared to some
other ones that were around that time. But funny
enough that it's this particular number, it's
the 19th animated feature film by Walt Disney
animated series. Definitely. It's funny that
it ranks this close to that number. But yeah,
overall, it's a good film. Like I said, that's
where I would rank it is in maybe the 40 to 21
section. And interesting, as I said, also remember
that I said it landed on 18 lists, but nobody
ranked it higher than 7. So this was one of those
cases where it got up to the 20 mark more so
based on... universal appeal and that it was
on almost everybody's list and not so much that
it was so high on anybody in particular's list.
I mean, if you average it out, it would have
probably fallen into our 40 range somewhere based
on how it was voted on. But so many people had
it that it, that it falls into our number 20
spot. Dan, what's your reaction on jungle book?
I think it's 100 % belongs in the top 20. I mean,
Maybe a few spots too high. I probably would
put Dumbo and Pinocchio higher than it, but something
like Robin Hood and some of the other Disney
movies we talked about, I think it's superior
then. And yes, like Neil mentioned, the story
isn't all that dynamic or there's not much to
it, but I think what works with it is that it's
just loaded with interesting characters. We mentioned
with Bambi that the main character in Bambi is
not that interesting. It's the characters around.
And the same thing with Jungle Book, you know,
you have Baloo, Shere Khan, just this assortment
of interesting characters that you really just
traveled, you know, in between back and forth.
And I think that's what makes Jungle Book work.
And, you know, Bare Necessities, one of the best
Disney songs of all time, I would say top 10,
top five. And two, I mean, this also let us get
Tailspin. So points for it there. I think, too,
if you had to take a Disney film and ask people,
like if you were asking like a general consensus
or just like a general survey on, you know, name
your favorite character from a film, I think
you bring up a good point. I think Jungle Book
would have the most different amount of characters
named somewhere in there, whether it be King
Louie or like you said, Baloo, Bagheera, Shere
Khan, Mowgli, etc. Like there is so many different
people for people to either relate to or gravitate
towards compared to, you know, your standard
film where you have, you know. one two maybe
three characters that people really are drawn
to so i think that's part of its appeal i think
the variety of characters and the music has a
lot to do with it um all right so we start off
with the jungle book in the wonderful world of
disney and should be interesting like we said
we had predictions on how many pixar films we
we might see i guess i should have asked how
many disney films will we see so let's see where
we go from here 19 all right at number 19 we
stay with disney For a unique Disney film, I
guess, going back to 1940, at number 19, we have
Fantasia. It is only on 14 lists. That is the
lowest we will see in this entire episode, a
film only appearing on 14 lists. So those people
that did rank it, ranked it pretty high. And
it is another number one to fall. One of our
contributors had this at number one, so they
will be somewhat disappointed. Rotten Tomatoes
score of 96. If anything, it deserves to be mentioned
on our countdown for its uniqueness, for its
impact, for a lot of kind of intangibles, I guess
we'd say. We ended with Dan on this last one.
Let's start with him on this one. Dan, what's
your opinion on Fantasia and how it fits in?
to all these other movies we're talking about
well it's certainly beautifully animated there's
no doubt there and i remember as a kid we watched
this in like music class like every year and
uh just you know just the use of classic uh you
know the music in it is is well handled and all
the different little stories and honestly most
of them i don't remember uh you know the the
one i think everyone remembers is that with like
mickey and the i can't think of the name of it
but the with all the rooms and whatnot but uh
Certainly, I'm surprised to see it this high.
I don't think I ranked it in my top 20. But,
I mean, on an animation standpoint, on a music
standpoint, it's certainly an achievement. Steve,
have you seen Fantasia, and what's your opinion
on the film? That's one of the few I've skipped.
Gotcha. And it's definitely not a film for everybody.
Yeah, I mean, one, it's... the the that time
period uh but i mean i i don't necessarily have
a problem with it showing up i just don't i i
don't have the information to back up one way
or the other fair enough um neil what's your
opinion on on fantasia a fan or not i like it
it's it's basically a music video done to uh
classical music What I like about this movie
is that it's basically a compilation. I think
every single composition is done with a different
director. And so you're getting different animation
styles throughout the entire picture. And I wouldn't
say that I'm a classical music aficionado, but
it did kind of give me some appreciation for
classical music. an album as a kid that was the
nutcracker suite on one side and right of spring
on the other and it was uh no it was dance of
the hours never mind but it was uh it was done
specifically for this picture it was a disney
release um i think i think my favorite one is
actually uh night on bald mountain that's where
all the cool animation is the big demon thing
on the top of the mountain and he's summoning
demons they're all doing a dance you know And
then it ends with Ave Maria. Excellent film.
I was really hoping it would show up in the top
20 just because it does deserve to be here. Ironically
enough, I didn't rank it because I didn't know
if it really counted because there are some live
action portions. I think there's a bridge to
the whole thing that just has the performers
and live action playing. But I'm glad it's here.
Yeah, it's kind of one of those where the animation
kind of was present enough to be an overwhelming
majority of the movie seems to be. I mean, it's
been a while since I've seen it, but from what
my memory holds, it's like in comparison on the
flip side, like Mary Poppins is, you know, 85
% live action and has some animation thrown in
there. This is like the flip version of that,
I guess. Not that it has anything closely related
to Mary Poppins. But I agree. I mean, I think
some people might be surprised about it, but
I definitely think it deserves to be on the list
and in the top half of the list. Whether top
20 or not, I think it comes down to math as far
as which ones are in it, which ones aren't. But
it's definitely deserving to be here somewhere.
Like I said, some people might not enjoy the
film. And I think kids at some point, you know,
maybe the first time they see it might be a little
bit confused if they're used to regular Disney
films. Regular, I say, because lack of a better
term. But I'm happy to see it and happy that
it comes in here. Interesting to be back to back
with Jungle Book, which is definitely on the
other end of the spectrum for Disney. So, all
right, let's see. Let's see who other number
one ranking films we can have drop by the wayside
as we make our way through our top 20. Well,
it takes skill for another company to wedge a
film into the Disney and what we were thinking
might possibly be Pixar dominated top 20. But
number 18 has done that. Number 18 is a film
from 2001 from DreamWorks. And that would be
the original Shrek. 1 ,038 points on 15 list.
Fantasia was only on 14 and Shrek was only on
15. Those are the two lowest as far as the top
20 goes. Everything else is everybody. Every
other film that comes in will be on more list
than that. It was ranked number one by one of
our contributors. So we've had consecutive number
ones fall. 89 Rotten Tomatoes score and a DreamWorks
appearance in our top 20. Dan, how do you feel
about it? And is it the last? I would say so
unless there's I would I definitely think this
is probably I don't think it's the best DreamWorks.
I think that's how to train your dragon, but
certainly the most notable one and probably the
one that really launched DreamWorks animation
to, you know, to compete, actually show it can
compete with Disney. So on that end, I could
see why it's deserving of top 20. I don't have
an issue with it being a top 20, similar to like
the Ice Age movies and other films. Like I think
it gets hurt a lot by just. unnecessary amount
of sequels. I think if it stood by itself, it
wouldn't be, you know, I think it's kind of people
have turned the table and started disliking it
a great deal. But the original, I think it's,
you know, stands on its own. Good voice cast,
Mike Myers, I think is, is effective as Shrek.
And Eddie Murphy as Donkey, I think when this
movie began, that's when that character, you
know, obviously stole the movie and he wasn't
overused too much as he was in the later films.
So I think it's deserving of top 20 just based
upon. what it did for that company. Mike, agree,
disagree? I agree. I don't agree with the whole
sequel thing, though, because out of all the
sequels we've talked about, Shrek, by far, out
of the ones that have shown up on the countdown,
Shrek has had the best ones, minus Shrek the
third. That was just a travesty. And outside
of Despicable Me 2, which you had right in your
top. Right, but I'm saying, like, that have had
more than one sequel at this point. Shrek, the
first one I saw, I remember seeing this in theaters.
It was cool. It was basically a PG version of
Axel Foley as a donkey, which is kind of awesome.
Oh, he is an ass. Yeah, he can be. You know,
there are a lot of memorable lines from this
one. It does something with fairytale storytelling
that hadn't been done before, where the ugly
guy wins. And it's more so a commentary on it
doesn't matter what you look like. You know,
it more so matters about what your personality
is. And I think in the top 20, it deserves to
be where it is. Alright, fair enough. Neil Shrek
in our top 20. Possibly our last DreamWorks film.
Is that how it should be? Probably. I have to
make a confession. I was probably one of those
people who dinged it for the sequels. Because
looking back on it, yeah, it is a lot better
than maybe I gave it credit for and a lot of
other people did. So it does deserve to be here.
I like that it... It takes the fairy tale thing.
It actually takes it away from Disney. Because
Disney has had a virtual monopoly over fairy
tales for so long. And this movie finally came
along and said, you know what? Pinocchio is going
to be in our movie too. And so are the three
little pigs. And so are like all these other
characters that you're used to seeing only the
Disney versions of. So that was cool. I agree.
Steve, are you a Shrek fan or not? I was in the
first film. This is the first film. I understand
that. I'm just saying that it's got the Ice Age
syndrome to me. The more they go on, the more
I hate them. So, yeah, the first film, and I
really like the touches that were thrown in there.
I like the voice cast, the animation, the fact
that they kind of played somewhat dirty jokes
as far as the kind of fairytale characters are
concerned. uh little kind of pokes at everybody
in there so it was it's it's definitely deserving
of being in the top 20. Yeah I definitely think
I had a unique take on on uh something we hadn't
really seen done before and I did it successfully
um so much so that it apparently felt like it
could continue to do that over and over and over
again um so yeah I agree with most of what you
guys have said I think it it's deserving for
its impact and it definitely was one of the most
popular. films there and franchises for a while
so that definitely says something about it. The
other thing I want to bring up about not necessarily
arguing with Steve but the whole Ice Age thing
they pretty much when they got to Forever After
they saw how the plot was progressing and they
said okay we're going to cancel no matter how
much money the film makes or doesn't make we're
going to cancel the fifth one and this is where
Shrek's journey should end. So as far as I know,
as far as I can tell doing research online, there
are no plans for, you know, an Ice Age type of
thing with the Shrek franchise. And that's why
I give it a lot more credit than most people
do because, yes, it had two sequels in the middle
that are kind of iffy at best with Shrek 2 and
Shrek the 3rd, but... Overall, the franchise
itself really introduced, as Neil said, you know,
interesting, different take on different characters
and really lovable characters, characters that
you, you know, find funny in different times.
And I mean, the whole gingerbread man thing,
I mean, come on, who didn't laugh at that? Every
different time, something different happened
with that. But yeah. All right. Well, we've been
to Disney. We've been to DreamWorks. Let's see
which company we will go to next. You know, I
haven't brought it up so far in the countdown,
but I was interested before we started this whole
process and this whole project, how this, I guess
what I could call sub genre of Disney would fare.
And I was curious to see how they would rank.
And I really haven't brought it up up to this
point, but. Outside of, I guess, what you could
call the modern ones, Dan, are you surprised
we have not seen any of the classic Disney princesses
yet? I honestly didn't even think about that,
but that is a good point. I mean, we saw like
Pocahontas and Mulan, I guess, if you want to.
I guess they're thrown into that group as well.
And I guess the princess and the frog, too, but
no, not really. That's too modern. That's not
classic at all. I didn't say classic. I just
said Disney princesses has become a thing that
people... I mean, there's toys about Disney princesses.
There's everything about Disney princesses. But
yeah, we haven't really seen any of the classic
ones until now, obviously, alluding to this.
And that's at number 17 in the first Disney...
princess classic version, I guess you can say,
that we're seeing is from 1950. And that is Disney's
Cinderella coming in at number 17. It was on
17 people's lists. Nobody ranked it higher than
five. Rotten Tomatoes score of 97. Cinderella,
our first classic Disney princess, falling into
our top 20 at number 17. Let's see what this
group of guys has to say about Cinderella. Let's
start with Mike. I like the film. It's interesting.
It kind of gives you in its plot the whole happily
forever after, and you don't really need a sequel
to it, even though there were two sequels. The
first film... Again, just as I said with Shrek,
there are so many memorable characters with this,
between Bruno the dog, Lucifer the cat, the mice.
And again, it seems as if Cinderella, who is
the main character, she is not the main focus.
Everyone else around her is the main focus. She
is the cause and they are the effect. And by
them being the effect, they then... just cause
her to just go crazy and it's just one of those
things where it's a whole back and forth between
her and the wicked stepmother and the stepsisters
and and the and then all the all the animals
it's actually this movie is probably the best
disney has ever done with uh combining humans
and animal interactions as far as that goes like
okay sure you could argue 101 dalmatians but
that's more from the dog's point of view I mean,
you know, we even said, I don't know if I said
this or not, but the whole opening monologue
of 101 is from the dog's point of view, whereas
here it's more of a melding of the two and having
it in the top 20, I think it's good. I just hope
one of the other ones isn't on here at all. And
interesting that there must be a couple of people
that are anti -Disney because... Two people in
particular left both Jungle Book and Cinderella
off of their top 100 list. I won't call them
out because they're kind enough to contribute
to us. Dan, your thoughts on Cinderella being
in our top 20? It's not one I personally gravitated
towards a huge amount. I did rank it. I'm not
sure where. I don't know. For some reason, it
just never appealed all that much to me. I remember
just being a kid. rather watching other disney
movies at the time i had three sisters so i did
have to end up watching this a great deal i mean
there are certain sports that i did like obviously
just the fairy godmother and the transformation
scenes those are a lot of fun that song pippity
boppity boop again like like uh bear necessity
is one of the let's say one of the best disney
songs and i do like mike mentioned with the animals
the the mice What I love the most is what I cared
about the most. I could care less about Cinderella
and her plate. I care more about those mice.
If we were going to have a classic Disney princess
in our top 20, is this the right one? Just the
princess or so? I don't know. I would go with...
There are some other ones I think I'd go with.
I don't have an issue with it being in top 20,
but I wouldn't call it my favorite Disney princess
movie, which is weird to say out loud. And I
forced you to. No, I'm just kidding. Steve, what's
your thoughts on Cinderella and does it deserve
to be in our top 20? I am personally not that
much of a fan of the film. I've seen it in all
of its sequels that are increasingly bad. But
I would never have ranked it in the top 20, but
I can see why some people could have. Or the
fact that all of us have ranked it somewhere.
higher up and it somehow got enough points to
get here but yeah it's kind of similar to not
i mean to interrupt you but kind of similar to
jungle book where it's on so many lists but nobody
ranked it higher than five um so it it was more
so that it was just on so many lists i think
if you were taking the average it'd be in our
30s somewhere but being on so many lists bumps
it into our top 20 continue though but yeah i
mean i i can i can kind of see that uh I don't
have a problem with it, but I don't know if I'd
put it in the top 20. I know Mike wants to take
a moment probably to defend Disney sequels in
Cinderella's case. I don't know. The only one
I defend is Twist in Time because it did, again,
talking about something that it did with the
story that we hadn't seen before. And basically,
in that film, The stepmother got a hold of the
wand and trapped the fairy godmother and then
went hog wild with it and took everything away
from Cinderella. I mean, it's your classic takeaway
story, but it was something I was never expecting
because I figured the crappy Dream Come True
sequel was going to be it for this franchise.
And then they released Twist in Time and I was
like, oh, this is actually kind of cool. Right.
I won't comment on Disney sequels at all. Neil,
your thoughts? I haven't got you yet on Cinderella,
and do you think it should be in our top 20?
No, I had it much lower than this. I don't think
it belongs in the top 20. Of all of the Disney
princesses, I think this is one of the least
interesting. She's kind of in Mary Sue territory
almost because it's basically a story about someone
who lives under terrible circumstances. And then
comes out of it when a wonderful man rescues
her. You know, I don't think it's a very interesting
story. I mean, the animation is nice and the
songs are okay. It's a film, yeah, without the
animals and the songs, nobody would... I mean,
the only interesting thing about this movie is
June Foray is the cat. Fair enough. Yeah, I can
see where you're coming from. Yeah, if you strip
some of the stuff away from it, kind of the fluff,
you're left with something that maybe a lot of
people wouldn't be interested in. But hey, what
does a bunch of guys know talking about Cinderella,
I guess? I know we've already had the film on
our countdown quite a ways back, but I feel like
we're going down the rabbit hole here. I had
to bring up something about Disney princesses,
didn't I? Let's knock out another one at number
16. Another classic Disney princess. Funny that
Mike commented something on the last one. Oh,
no. This film would be number 16 on our countdown
from 1937, what a lot of people claim as the
best animated film of all time if you look at
certain rankings and lists, and that is Snow
White and the Seven Dwarves. Over 1 ,100 points
on our list. Only two people left it off of their
list. That would be Tim. And none other than
Mike himself, so he'll get to defend that a little
bit here. The only two people that left it off
their list. Nobody ranked it number one, number
two, or number three. It got ranked number four
as its best ranking. I will have some opinions
on Snow White in a second, but let's just let
Mike get on his soapbox and take it from here.
I remember watching Snow White as a kid, but
I don't remember how... I didn't remember until
we did the episode in ToonCast Classic of how...
convoluted that plot is. You want to talk about
a plot, you know, Neil was talking about the
plot for Cinderella is just bad. This is even
worse. It really is. First of all, where are
any of the adults in this movie? Because the
seven old midgets that want to do stuff to Snow
White don't count. Secondly, who's there to stop
the Queen? from doing whatever. Why does she
want to capture Snow White other than, oh, oh,
I must have her beauty. Oh, I mean, so many,
you know, I mentioned earlier about the Jungle
Book, the different versions of the Jungle Book,
so many different versions of Snow White, the
more crazy, more wacky, more, oh my God, how
did they get away with that, are better than
this movie. And, you know, and I'll transition
to Kev here for a second because when we did
ToonCast Classic Episode 29, you had brought
up... How is this, you know, the standard of
being beautiful with this chick? Oh, yeah, I
did go on a tirade about how it must be a sign
of times how people found Snow White to be the
object of the most beautiful person in the world
when, in my opinion, she's the ugliest Disney
princess we've ever had. Anyway, that's neither
here nor there. I guess kind of going back and
forth with you a little bit here because we definitely
shared our bashing of this film on. the tooncast
episode but what i will say is is my point is
not okay my point is that i have a problem with
people just blindly ranking snow white as a film
as as the best of all time or the best animated
film of all time just simply because it was one
of the first uh if not the first successful animated
film or the thing that's you know kind of started
all off for disney etc etc as a historian i have
a problem with things being ranked highly just
because they were first um but unlike you I still
feel it deserves to be ranked in the top 100.
Not this high, I don't think. Well, you didn't
have it on your list at all. Right, because I
don't like the movie. Okay, so I guess there's
some separation of bias, and if something still
deserves to be in a top 100 list, I would still
rank it in the top 50, if not top, I don't know,
40, 30 maybe. I could have no problem with it
being in our top 20 as long as it's not number
one. That's my issue. Let some other people get
in on this argument though that maybe be able
to defend Snow White a little. Dan or Neil? Well,
I think I'll defend it. For one, regarding people
ranking it number one blindly, I feel uncomfortable
saying someone's ranking something blindly when
I don't know the reasoning for it. So I think
that's kind of, are the people that do that?
Maybe, but I don't think there's... no basis
whatsoever to rank this that high. I personally
didn't, obviously, because no one ranked it that
high. I'm not sure where I had it. I think I
had it in my top 10. And I agree with you, Kevin,
that just because you're first doesn't mean you're
best. Just because you do some sort of innovation
doesn't necessarily mean the overall quality
of the film is great. But I think you do have
to consider, I did consider some of those factors
when I ranked it. One, the risk that you're taking
like there is if no if you were to live in a
parallel universe where Snow White was not a
success where Snow White critically financially
we don't know what the ramifications could be
more so than any other movie in some ways we
would we probably get animation still of course
I don't think that any movie is that powerful
but would we get the powerhouse that disney is
who knows it may have came may have came later
um regarding the story being convoluted i don't
agree with that at all i think the story is rather
simple it's i and you know to say it's like well
what's what's the witch's mission or why does
she care about her beauty i mean that's pretty
i think it's pretty basic you know you look at
where the fairytale is coming from i mean there
are proverbs they are teaching different lessons
about um, the negative qualities of being a human
and whether it's feignness, whether it's greed
or, or those different areas. So I think that
is why that's simple. There is that simple story.
I mean, most fairy tales, you know, are obviously
meant for children. I, I, or in some, you know,
in some extent, so you're not going to have this,
you know, gigantic story full of a lot of different
components. It's basically, you know, going to
be simple and straightforward. And I think that
like we talked about, it's kind of a, you know,
we're going in circles here, but with the characters,
the seven dwarves, you know, how those kind of
set the standard for what Disney was going to
do with, it said that Disney formula, you can
argue the Disney formula, you know, this is good
or bad, but what came after definitely was impacted
by Snow White. Like I said, it doesn't necessarily
mean that makes it a better movie, but I do think
you have to get credit for that. And regarding
her beauty, I don't know. I think that's really
a matter of taste. So it's hard to really argue
against that. Plus, you know, this is 19, you
know, this came out in 1937. The ideal beauty
in 1937 is a lot different than, you know, the
ideal beauty now. You know, you look at a couple
of magazines or whatever. You know, Snow White
was very much a representation of that time period.
So I think it's unfair to criticize it for that
as well. Oh, no, that was that was more so tongue
in cheek. That's just I understand that that's
just a personal. Yeah, I get what I get what
you're saying. I mean, I mean, what I did here,
probably not partially because she's a cartoon.
So I don't I personally don't find cartoons attractive.
Well, you know, Jessica Rabbit aside. Because
everyone said that at the same time. So I do
believe it does belong in the top 20. Not just
because it is one of those instances where it
had a huge impact on a medium, but it's also
a good movie. I mean, I think that says something.
Is there any legit reason outside of not seeing
this film for someone not to rank it in the top
100? legit reason i not in a top 100 i don't
think so okay um neil thoughts on snow white
and everything that's been said so far hmm well
i don't i don't think it's the best disney film
by a long shot so i wouldn't put it in the top
20 i had it ranked somewhere around 50 and i
think most of that was because uh historical
significance and uh you know just for being the
first animated film ever But when I look at the
film, just the structure of it, I agree it is
a simple film. I don't see it as convoluted at
all. The problem I have with it is that the characters
aren't very interesting. The motivation of the
queen, Snow White, is another Mary Sue. And even
the prince, he just kind of shows up at the end.
He's like, yes, I am here. And the dwarves are
probably the only sort of real characters in
the movie that you can identify with. I think
the version of this movie I would want to see
is a commentary track with the gremlins watching
it. Just because I've seen this so many times,
and I don't think it's a terribly interesting
movie, but I think it's a movie that everyone
should watch. And it's not a bad movie, but I
don't think it belongs in the top 20. So we definitely
have some different opinions all the way across
the board. We have extreme hate on one hand,
a couple people think it deserves to be in the
top 20, some of them have it around 50. Steve,
where do you fall on the spectrum? I definitely
see that it deserves to be in the top 100. I
don't know if I would say that it, I would say
in the latter end of it, it's more of those hi
-ho, hi -ho, off to hell it go. type movies for
me. But yeah, that's pretty much my opinion of
it. I've seen it. I don't really care for it
all that much. So one Disney princess followed
by another as we've gone from Cinderella to Snow
White. And just like that, there's only 15 spots
left in the countdown. So let's see what starts
off those 15 spots. I mean, if you've seen one
Disney princess, you've seen them all, right?
Maybe not so much. Coming in at number 15, a
fairly more modern Disney princess. And one of
the... I'll get into my opinions on the film
in a second. But coming in at number 15 is 1989's
Little... mermaid. On 16 lists, four people left
this off of their top 100 entirely. Rotten Tomatoes
score of 91. Myself and one other of the contributors
had it the highest ranked. I had it ranked number
three. 1 ,147 points, 1989's The Little Mermaid.
I guess we can start with Mike, and I don't mean
to back the bus and then go forward and then
back again. I honestly don't remember not ranking
this. You ranked Little Mermaid both of the sequels.
No. But not the original. No, no, no, no, no.
You must have misread that. I'll give you your
list. The only sequel that I ranked was the second
one. I've never even seen Ariel's Beginning,
so you must have misread that. I'll show you
the email you sent to me. Anyways, so you meant
to rank Little Mermaid somewhere in your 100?
It should have been wherever you said that second
sequel was, because that wasn't what... I would
have never put Ariel's Beginning on a top 100
list. All right, well, we'll have to just blame
Mike for not being able to type things out properly.
Or Kevin for reading stuff properly, like usual.
And move on to Steve. Your thoughts on Little
Mermaid and does it deserve to be in our top
20? That's the question on all our movies, I
guess. That one's kind of difficult to answer
just because I'd say that it's one of the better
ones out of all those different Disney princess
movies. The villain was actually... halfway decent
um the the story somewhat halfway decent uh i
don't know i i would much rather watch this than
the disney films that have been listed in this
episode so far or some of the other ones that
have managed to make the list i mean i would
for me i i love this film i don't care if i don't
care that Mostly when I was growing up, it was
all females that loved this film. And there were
some more male -pointed Disney films to come
after it. But to me, I loved this film. I loved
the music. This was something we had never seen
before, as far as my eyes. This is so far removed
from what you expect Disney to be when you're
growing up in the 80s and 90s, I guess, when
you've seen all of the classic stuff and when
you've seen the stuff from the 60s and 70s, and
then you kind of went through this period you
know, late 70s, early 80s, where it's like, I
don't know what is going on at Disney, I guess.
And then all of a sudden 1989 comes and Little
Mermaid just shatters all idea of what you picture
Disney to be. And it goes on into this, whatever
you want to call it. Some people have called
it a Disney Renaissance or a rebirth or whatever
you want to call what happened with Disney. in
the late 80s early 90s but but this is the film
that started that all and it's kind of like in
a different way in a lesser aspect than what
dan was saying you know what if snow white had
failed obviously that would have had different
and more intense ramifications but if little
mermaid fails uh you know not having some of
the films that come right after without naming
them uh you know that definitely would be some
type of an impact because this started a run
for a good almost 10 years of of Disney success.
And I just, I don't know. I really love the film.
I love the music. I love the characters, you
know, just all of the different, especially the
underwater characters that you get to see the
different types of, what do you want to call
it? Sea life, I guess. And the music overall,
the music is phenomenal. So I love this film.
I definitely think it deserves to be in our top
20. What about you, Dan? I think so. Like you
mentioned, it is the movie that brought Disney
out of the brink, so you have to give it credit
for there. And, too, like with Snow White, I
do stand behind Snow White. Yes, maybe it's not
the most complex or full of interesting characters,
but I think Little Mermaid, certainly Ariel,
is a lot more of an interesting character than
that of Cinderella. Her bizarre acceptance is
something that's, I think, a lot more complex
than that of just... Prince save me type of behavior.
Um, the, we do kind of get that near the end,
but I don't know. I, like you said to you, I
definitely think it belongs there. Great music,
uh, under the sea, a great song, of course. Uh,
and two, I mean, just based on the amount of
internet memes it made with some of its questionable
animation, you know, and it's possible sexual
orientation with its, uh, VHS cover art back
in the day. Uh, certainly, uh, It certainly started
a trend there. But yeah, deserving of top 20.
I think too, like Kevin, you mentioned you loved
it as a kid. I think I was part of that group
that was probably too scared to say they liked
it because it was a girly movie of that period.
But as a mature or quote unquote mature adult,
I can recognize it as the great film that it
is. And I think, too, another thing that it does
well that I think separates it a little bit from
some of the other Disney films, I think, okay,
yes, we're talking about mermaids. We're talking
about people living underwater. We're talking
about magical spells that take voices away, et
cetera. So don't get what I'm about to say twisted.
But it almost seems to me that from a character
standpoint that you can almost relate more. as
a kid to Ariel than you can some of the other
past Disney movies that are so enwrapped in kind
of main plot lines based around this fantasy
magical element. Like for me, you know, when
you think about like a Snow White or Cinderella
or some of those other ones, like it's harder
to relate. Like Snow White is like, okay, she's
a quote unquote beautiful person who a witch
is jealous of. So we're going to have a spell,
et cetera. Here we have a character in Ariel
who wants to know what else is out there, who's
going against her father's wishes, who's dealing
with falling in love and being with someone that
she's not supposed to fall in love with. I mean,
it just seems to me like when you boil it down,
there's more relatable concepts about this character
that... if you hit it at the right time in your
life, you can relate to and you can connect to,
even though, yes, we are under the sea. We're
mermaids and et cetera. And we got Ursula and
all this stuff. And Ursula is a pretty good Disney
villain, by the way. But I don't know. I just
think one of the reasons Little Mermaid was a
little more successful was because of that ability
for kids at that time to relate to different
issues that she was going on. I'm not saying
those issues are completely invisible in other
Disney films, but sometimes there's a lot more
magic and fantasy hiding some of that. Maybe
I'm the only one that feels that way. Neil, how
do you feel about Little Mermaid? I agree. I
mean, the analogy I was going to make is that
this movie is like, what if Cinderella was motivated?
I mean, Cinderella, if you watch Cinderella,
she doesn't really do anything. She just kind
of sits around and does chores and waits for
somebody to save her. Whereas Ariel actually
goes out and tries to accomplish things. She
wants to get out and she wants to be free and
walk on land. and stuff and she's she takes things
into her own hands that was kind of cool and
also comparing her to snow white i mean if the
if the uh if the queen was willing to sacrifice
her own beauty to get to get after uh snow white
she might also just put a gun in her mouth if
she saw ariel um this yeah this movie is much
much better as far as disney princesses go and
uh yeah was the it was like a huge Renaissance
back in the day. Cause this was one year after
Oliver and company, not knocking that movie at
all, but it was, you know, quite a leap. And
the only other thing I have to say is that just
a couple of weeks ago, the podcast, good job.
Rain did a, did an episode about this. So people
listening to this, go, go listen to that. I think
if, if you were to show, if you were just to
take kids, I have never seen. you know, these
films, and you were to show them Oliver and Company,
and then you were to show them Little Mermaid,
and then you were to have them write down what
year they thought each one was made, you would
never have them put in those two films in the
same decade. Yeah. The thing about The Little
Mermaid is I agree with everything Kevin and
Neil have said. I mean, it's a movie about exploration,
about, you know, Basically, it's one of the first
animated films I know of as far as the child
trying to break away. I mean, it's kind of like
when people said, oh, well, 90210 broke all these
barriers with exploring situations on television
that no one ever had done before. And this is
one of those films that does that. So the film
has come a long way. You have completely blown
my mind. You are the only person on the planet
that could get a 90210 reference into a top 100
animated film podcast. Hey, it's the truth. Just
said it yourself. She's dealing with something
that is completely, you know. I'm not saying
it's bad or anything. I'm just saying. And they
did that the exact same thing in 90210. All right.
I mean, really, if you want to make another analogy,
the one that you actually prefer, technically
she's doing the same stuff, some of the stuff
that was done in Saved by the Bell. I mean, I
just like the fact that in the same discussion
we had, Dan talking about his fear of mentioning
that he liked Little Mermaid when he was a kid
to your outright professions and your knowledge
of 90210. It's an interesting dynamic there.
What can you say? All right. Well, Disney princesses
have taken the countdown hostage. Let's see if
their grass around it can be broken with our
next selection. Dan, it's just fun to put you
on the spot. Is there a Disney princess we haven't
talked about yet? I'm sure there is. This is
all your fault. Okay, well, coming in number
14 here on our list, it's four in a row here
for the Disney Princesses. They're teaming up
on the countdown. This one's from 1959, and it
is none other than Sleeping Beauty. On 16 lists,
so a few less, same as Little Mermaid, they were
both on 16, but a few less than some of the other
ones we've talked about previously. Got as highly
ranked as number two on the list, so out of the
four... Disney princess movies that we've just
talked about, Cinderella, Snow White, Little
Mermaid, and Sleeping Beauty. Sleeping Beauty
had the highest rank out of all of them at two.
And Rotten Tomatoes scored 91. Of course, four
people did not rank this. I guess as we're doing
this one, let's look back at what we've just
had here with the four Disney princesses. And
do we have them in the right order? Do they all
deserve to be in the top 20? We started with
Cinderella, went to Snow White, Little Mermaid,
and now Sleeping Beauty. Let's start with Mike.
I'm really surprised that Sleeping Beauty made
it in. I mean, we all know that Maleficent is
one of the best villains ever, but I'm really
surprised because I don't know if this is a film
that a lot of people think about when they think
about Top 100. Sure, 16 of our members did, but
I don't know. This movie always felt like to
me that it was something that people knew about
in the back of their minds, but... isn't something
that you would think of when you think of a Disney
princess. Yes, she is a Disney princess, but
her storyline, out of all the Disney princesses,
is probably the most dark. Yeah, I can see that
in a way, possibly. And interestingly, you bring
up Maleficent, too. Talking about Disney villains,
I agree. She is definitely one of the most imposing
Disney villains and mysterious and evil -looking.
Especially when it's starring Angelina Jolie.
Not talking about that film yet. Neil, what are
your thoughts on Sleeping Beauty coming in here
at number 14, higher than Cinderella, Snow White,
and Little Mermaid? I don't know if I'd put it
higher than Little Mermaid, but definitely I'd
put this one higher than the other two. I like
this princess a lot better, except that I'm blanking
on her name. Was it Ariel? no it's a little aurora
that's it yeah um well i haven't seen this in
a while but yeah i love this movie even though
it kind of falls into the same trap of not very
interesting princess but she has a little more
uh screen time where she gets to develop and
i i think what really drew me to this movie was
was maleficent because she is the first disney
villain that i actually thought was scary I will
agree with that. And I was trying to say earlier
when we were talking about Little Mermaid, Ursula
is, like Kevin said, Ursula is another one. I
would say she's kind of like the late 80s, early
90s, most scary villain as far as Disney goes.
But yeah, Maleficent just, she was, by far, like
her villainy is just, it makes people speechless.
It really does. Well, if you think about it in
a way, it's, we've talked about some of disney
films and having like this vast array of characters
that you can relate to and watch and enjoy and
jungle book you know we rattle off a bunch of
names and you can do that with with a couple
different disney films when you look at this
one i mean it is maleficent and then you have
sleeping beauty who obviously is sleeping for
A good deal. You have a somewhat nondescript
prince, and then you have your three fairies.
So, I mean, really there's not a lot to choose
from. It's really carried by the fairies and
Maleficent. But at least this prince did something
in this film versus the other prince who basically
did nothing other than just show up. Yeah, that's
true. Very true. They don't work for it. Dan,
you know, Neil was saying that he would rank
this higher than Cinderella and Snow White, but
not Little Mermaid. Where do you feel Sleeping
Beauty falls amongst those? I would probably
agree with that. Like I said, just as a historical
importance perspective, I think I would maybe
Sleeping Snow White a little higher, but I don't
argue that Sleeping Beauty, just based upon the
movie itself, is better. I would like the mix
of fantasy with the animation. think more complex
and it has a dragon in it which is always a plus
so um i think that is an interesting point though
because when you're thinking about it you have
molessa molessa wow you have you know the villain
in this and uh the thinking of character wise
there isn't it's not full of a lot of different
characters or anything like that but i don't
think that makes it a bad movie just and how
it's designed so um i agree though i probably
would have The Little Mermaid above it, just
because I enjoy it. I think that has more personality
and it's just a brighter movie. A quick question
for you, Dan. Number one, are you surprised?
A two -party question, I guess. Number one, are
you surprised to see all four of these Disney
princess films at the same time, all of them
in the top 20? Or are you more surprised that
we don't see one of them in our top 10? I'm a
little surprised we don't see one of them in
the top 10. I'm not surprised they're all back
-to -back -to -back like this. I think we've
seen that a lot with the different, you know,
that happened a few times throughout the list.
I think that just tells you how closely they're
ranked. Sometimes when I was making my list,
it was hard to differentiate between them and
choose an ordering. So I think what you ended
up having a lot is people probably ranked them
within the same amount. So that's probably why
they're like this. I am surprised at least one
of them doesn't make the top 10. I thought Snow
White would have a chance at the top 10, just
because, like you mentioned, Kevin, it's often
ranked number one on a lot of lists. And do you
think there's people listening here, fans of
one particular studio, that may be getting nervous
that some of their favorite films are not on
our countdown? Either getting nervous or others
getting nervous that it's only going to be those
in the top 10. You would guess there possibly
could be 10. I'd still hold that. And we've gone
through seven spots on our countdown without
seeing one. We'll see what lucky number 13 brings
next. 13. All right. I guess with number 13,
the curse is broken. We will have our first Pixar
film of the day. Coming in at number 13 is 2001's
Monsters, Inc. They first filmed to break the
1 ,200 -point mark. It was on all lists except
for two. Only two people left Monsters, Inc.
completely off of their top 100. Nobody ranked
it higher than six, though. Rotten Tomatoes score
of 96. If you were taking its average score,
it probably would have gone somewhere in the
upper 20s, lower 30s for us. But Monsters, Inc.
is our first Pixar film of the day, and it comes
in at number 13. Mike, your thoughts on Monsters,
Inc.? I love Monsters, Inc. for how different
it is. It's basically taking something we've
all probably had as a fear as a child and showing
you that monsters are actually scared as well.
Overall, the story is good. The animation is
amazing. The friendship that you see in Mike
and Sully is awesome. And the voice cast, I mean...
John Goodman and Billy Crystal, who would have
ever thought that those two would be an interesting
team -up? Not to say that they're not interesting
actors at all. I'm just saying that those two
voices for those two specific characters and
how different they actually are. Absolutely loved
it. And the casting of Steve Buscemi as the chameleon.
Steve Buscemi plays some really slimy, slimy
characters in his career, and Randall is by no
means any exception. I absolutely love this movie,
and I really did enjoy the prequel as well. Question
for you, if the date's right here. Monsters,
Inc. came out in 2001, which is the same year
that Shrek came out. Shrek came in at number
18, Monsters, Inc. came in at number 13. Is that
an accurate saying of those two films? Yeah,
most definitely. Monsters, Inc. was a way better
interesting story overall. Fair enough. Neil,
your thoughts on Monsters, Inc., our first Pixar
film today? I left it off my ranking probably
more due to a brain fart. My list was winding
down. I guess I just forgot about it. It's not
exactly my favorite Pixar film just because it's...
I don't know. It just never appealed to me. Maybe
it's because of the casting. I mean, Billy Crystal.
I'm one of those people where I could... I could
watch an hour of Billy Crystal and not laugh
once. I don't know what it is. I just don't find
him very funny. I do think it's a good film.
The story is nice. The character of Boo is particularly
appealing. A very cute character. This one's
up there with a bug's life where I just didn't
really like it. As much as the other ones. That's
fair enough. You're allowed to not like something.
Steve, fan of Monsters, Inc. or not? Yeah, I'm
definitely a fan of the film. I like Billy Crystal
as far as the animation part of it is concerned,
like with the vocals and John Goodman in there
and Steve Buscemi and everybody else. I think
that it was a pretty well done film. I believe
at the time that it was pretty revolutionary
with the hair aspect of Sully. Of how they animated
it and everything. I believe at the time it was
kind of revolutionary with the CG animation.
uh so i mean it has that going for it uh and
also i just love the story all together of them
kind of being these scares and then having to
you know deal with the fact that oops we let
a human into scare world so it's i i find it
really enjoyable i i ranked it in my my uh 20s
on my list so i i don't have a problem with it
being here All right, your first of your 10 films,
Dan. Monsters, Inc. coming in at number 13. Your
thoughts? I do like it. I would not put it nearly
this high. I think I would think more so in the
30s, maybe 40s or so. I don't think it's as,
I don't know. It's not the highest of Pixar by
any means. Like Steve mentioned, some of the
animation is incredible. I think even with lesser.
Pixar films for the most part the animation is
usually always on point but to my to Neil I'm
not a big Billy Crystal fan and after watching
him in the Oscars two years ago not laughing
at him for an hour is kind of an understatement
but I do I do like John Goodman though and like
Bashemi as well I do like the construction of
the world and the concept about it I think that's
well handled and Just the idea behind it. And
like Mike, I actually did too, like the prequel,
not nearly, not a huge amount. I probably wouldn't
rank it in the top 100, but I thought it was
fine and added a little bit more to this world
of monsters. And I love this, like the construction
of all the different types of monsters and how
they look and all their different characteristics
and how they all have like their own unique set
of skills. And if it's a chameleon or whatnot.
And I also love Sasquatch. I thought he was a
pretty... funny character too all right so there
you have it our first pixar film of today's section
of the countdown and there's only a dozen spots
left and i think we're going to start off that
dozen with i'm not passing judgment one way or
the other but i will think if there's going to
be a surprise somewhere in our top 20 it may
be coming up next 12 all right coming in at number
12 is a film from 2012 We had our Disney princesses.
Let's go somewhere completely different with
Disney. Number 12 in our top 100 is none other
than Wreck -It Ralph. 1259 is the points on everybody's
list except for three people. It was ranked number
one by one of the panel members here. Yep. So
another number one has fallen, so let's let him
start. Are you disappointed that Wreck -It Ralph
comes in at number 12, or are you just happy
it's in the top 20? I wish it would have been
at least the other side of the top ten, maybe
number nine. But for me, overall, and I know
that we've said this before, oh, it's people
ranking what's new and what's now. It has nothing
to do with that, honestly. Wreck -It Ralph could
have come out ten years ago, and I would have
still put it at number one for this list, for
my personal list to go into the... the overall
making of The Master List, because of the simple
fact of the story. That's really why I put it
at number one. The animation is great. The fact
that it's one of, if not probably the best video
game film ever made, as far as, you know, we
all know that video game movies in general are
not very well made. But the story with this was
really interesting. It really makes you think
about certain aspects of changing your life or
accepting who you are. Again, going back to The
Little Mermaid, wanting to explore new things
and get out and do something different. Sure,
Wreck -It Ralph has a lot of cool video game
homages and references and nods and everything
else, but... It's just an amazing, amazing story.
And that's why I put it at number one. Steve,
how did you like Wreck -It Ralph? I ranked that
number four on my list. But I'm pretty much in
agreement with everything Mike just said. All
right. So some love on this end of the panel
for Wreck -It Ralph. Let's see how it goes on
the other end. Neil, Wreck -It Ralph deserves
to be in our top 20. Possibly. I had to be very
careful about how I ranked this just because
I have such a video game bias anyway. I mean,
I love it because of the references. There was
a scene in the Root Beer Tapper bar where I think
there was a joke about how the bartender can
only serve root beer now. If you're a big video
game aficionado, then you get that joke. But
it's a good movie, and I... Like I said, I was
very careful about where I put it because I didn't
want to put it too high, but I think it's in
a good spot. Okay, three people not having a
problem with it being in our top 20. Dan, Wreck
-It Ralph, deserving or not? Everybody get the
pitchforks ready. I don't believe so by any means.
I'll preface this by saying I did enjoy the film.
When I wrote a review of it last year when it
came out, I gave it four out of five stars, which
is definitely a stamp of approval. But four out
of five stars is certainly not top 20 worthy.
I think I ranked it in the 90s. And I find it
interesting that with Mike that Snow White, you
indicate it's convoluted, but you like the story
with Wreck -It Ralph because I would say the
story with Wreck -It Ralph is supremely convoluted.
I think that's where it lacks the most is in
the script standpoint. So much of it is devoted
to establishing all these different rules of
this world. unorganically telling them to you.
It shows its hand way too early. I didn't see
that coming. I did not see, and spoilers for
anyone who hasn't seen the film yet, I did not
see that ending coming with her actually using
her glitch to her. I didn't even see that coming
at all in the story. It tells you, it sets up
all these different rules, like you can't die
in your own game, or you can't leave, all these
different... moments that it just blatantly tells
you that you, I don't know, maybe that one specific
moment it doesn't tell you, but it just, it spends
so much time, I think, establishing a world unnecessarily.
I think you end up, like, wasting time with some
of the characters, losing time with some of the
characters. I think the basic story between,
you know, the Ralph character and, I forget the
girl's name. Penelope. Yeah, it is Penelope.
I think that story within itself is good. Sarah
Silverman, I never thought she would be able
to actually remove some of her rawness as a comedian
and actually give a sweet voiceover performance.
And I love John C. Reilly, and I think he's effective
as well. But I do think people have a tendency
to overrate this movie. I hate using the word
overrated, but I think if you do remove... many
of the aspects of the fact that it's a video
game and there's video game references and i
you know i know it's making a joke here and that
like and you remove those moments of it i don't
think people if you took that story place it
in a different world people would be as highly
like would think of it as highly and now people
just talk about often when you hear people say
it's just like oh i love all the cameos i mean
if a cameo makes your movie good you don't have
a good movie now i think record ralph is better
than that like i think a fair comparison is that
like roger rabbit where you have combining both
you know all these different elements of animation
and disney and warner brothers and whatnot i
think uh roger rabbit creates its world so much
better it It tells its story and it doesn't get
caught up with the exposition the same way that
Wreck -It Ralph does. So I don't disagree that
it deserves in the top 100. I don't think it's
a bad movie. But when you're talking about the
best of the best, which we're talking about now,
the animation of all time or whatever you want,
however you want to put it, I'm going to look
at it more critically than I would if I'm just
ranking it normally or just looking at it on
its own. So I may be coming off a little harsher,
but... That's more so because if you're going
to be placing it so high, I think you have to
try to look at is it as good as we're thinking
it is, or simply does it appeal to us just simply
based off premise? I mean, I think it's unique.
I enjoy the references and the cameos, and I
think it's unique, and I think it's something
different than what I had seen before. But I'm
almost forced to agree with parts of what Dan
is saying there that I think if you remove...
A lot of that, when you're left with just a stripped
-down story, does that hold up on its own? I'm
not sure. I know there was moments that I...
I don't want to say this because I thoroughly
enjoyed the film, and I had it ranked number
37. But there were times during the film where
it got a little long, or I almost even got bored.
But I still like the film. I still think it deserves
to be in our top 100. I'm just saying, I think
if there was one film in our top 20 that people
may point to or may be surprised, it might be
this one. But I do enjoy the film, so I don't
want people to think I'm hating on it. But I
don't know top 20. Mike, defense, you had it
number one, so I'll give you another chance.
I mean... And I will say, I did enjoy the video
game references as well, but this is a movie
that doesn't just throw them in your face. This
is a movie where, as Neil said, some of them
are hidden, and you have to really kind of look
for them. I mean, in that beginning scene with
Grand Central, or Gaming Central Station, a Sonic
thing just kind of whizzes by the screen, or
a Sonic, you know, but it's not like... Boom,
here, you know, product placement. As far as
the story overall, I think it does hold up. I'm
sure there may be one or two spots where it's
slow, but I never found myself being bored watching
this movie. I just didn't because I didn't know
what was going to happen because these are two
very different people from very different worlds,
and you... Sure, I will agree with Dan as far
as more so not necessarily the plot with Penelope,
but the plot with the villain. That was kind
of beat over your head. I will agree to that
point of, oh, hey, there's this guy back in the
old days, and then there's this new villain now.
Well, that's obvious. But as far as setting up
the world, I disagree with Dan on that because
you have to set up the world and set up the twists
because... You have to set up the world that
much for the twist to come into play at the end.
For them to say, no, screw the world, we're going
to break the rules and see what happens. But
I think there's a way to build a world and not
explicitly tell you the rules out loud as much
as it did. It's one thing if it's like one or
two things, but it's consistently throughout
the movie. And I'm not saying the entire world
building was not done well. I think there was
a lot of great things, like the Grand Central
Station, like you mentioned. I think that was
a wonderful scene. That idea, just how it's all
connected with the extension cords and stuff
like that. I think that was done creatively.
the group of all the different characters getting
together, the villains, like, you know, anonymous
month or whatever thing they had. So yeah, there
are elements of world building that done well.
It's when they get into the specific roles and
how things work and it just, things get kind
of lost and it's within that for me. I, like
I said, if I'm going to be ranking this or ranking
this at a certain point, I do think you got,
you know, is it, is this something we are ranking
because it deserves it or is it something that
it just appealing to a certain. certain audience
like in that audience is us all right well we'll
have to let the listeners cast their votes i
guess as far as uh the debate on record ralph's
uh deservingness on being in our top 20 or not
but soon the discussion will change who doesn't
deserve to be in our top 10 because there's only
one more spot on this side of our top 10 so let's
see what that last spot is Well, there's one
place we haven't been yet today on our countdown,
and that is the decade of the 90s. We have not
been there today, so let's go there now. And
that will be for our number 11 spot. And that
goes to 1999's Pixar film, sequel time, Toy Story
2. It was on 18 lists. Only two people left it
off of their list, which... I think it's a little
more fair to leave something off the list when
you have a series of multiple movies from the
same franchise. I'm not going to give people
a hard time for that. The highest it got ranked
was number two. A Rotten Tomatoes score of 100.
We haven't seen a lot of those, but it did have
a 100 score on Rotten Tomatoes. 1 ,262 points
for another Pixar film here. Toy Story 2 coming
in at number 11. Let's start with Neil on this
one. Toy Story 2 being in our top 20. I think
this is the least favorite of the three movies
for me, just because, I don't know, this one,
like most Pixar movies, it's a good movie, but
it... It didn't really resonate with me as much
as the first and the third one did. I've only
seen it a couple times. Like Lashley said earlier,
I didn't exactly go and watch every single movie
that I've ever seen for this list. So I'm a little
fuzzy on the movie itself. So I can't really
say much more about it than that. Steve, you
didn't have this one ranked, is it more so just
because there are three in this franchise, so
one of them you decided to leave off, or do you
not care for this one? What's your opinion on
Toy Story 2? Well, I enjoy all three of them.
Some of them to more degrees than others. I just
didn't find the second film to be as emotionally
charged as the other two. I didn't find myself
as connected or as caring towards the story or
the characters. Was it good? Yeah, it was good,
but to me, the first and the third are actually
stronger films overall than this one. Mike, agree,
disagree? This film was an attempt to... Sure,
it brings in the continuity of the first film,
and you see that time has passed, and you see
that... Buzz and Woody are getting along now
and everything else, and now they basically had
to pick, hey, which character are we going to
have go on a solo adventure? The best thing about
the Toy Story films, outside of the plots of
the first and the third film, is when they do
the animation with the toys. Where you think
it's, oh, hey, what's this adventure? And then
at the end of it, you flash out and it's actually
Andy playing with the toys. With this one, it's
like, hey, let's have Woody have an origin story.
Toy story origins Woody. Great. I liked it. I
found it enjoyable. But I do tend to agree that
it... It's not the best out of the three. It's
not a bad film. As Steve said, I find it interesting
that Newman is the villain in this. Wayne Knight
is the voice of Al. I enjoy it. Does it belong
right before we get to the top ten? Probably
not. I would probably put this like... I don't
know, maybe... I don't even remember where I
ranked it, but... Somewhere around maybe 15 or
16. Well, if we were trying to get 10 Pixar films
in today, we had to get to some more very soon,
or we were going to run out of spots for Dan.
I appreciate it. Dan, number 11, Toy Story 2.
Does it deserve to be in our top 20? I kind of
echo pretty much what everyone said already.
I don't think so, top 20, no. Just because, I
don't know. I'd rather see other films. that
like a spirited away or something like that um
it's it's kind of like the similar if you can
kind of compare to the lord of the rings it's
like the two towers of the franchise where the
first and the third one are so much better that
it's hard to lose sight of what's good about
the second one and the fact that it's within
its own it's yeah it's it works it's effective
and i think what hurts it a little bit is the
fact that a lot of the themes it goes after in
the second one are done better in the third one
so and i think that's where it gets a little
bit lost and like neil i'm a little fuzzy on
the details but i mean i do think i think and
i think mike uh brought up a good point that
the toy story world is best when those characters
are like interaction their interaction towards
one another so i think not having one of the
major characters within that interaction hurts
it a little bit but i i It was not really for
the idea of doing a Toy Story sequel when it
came out. The result proved that Pixar could
do sequels right. And when it added additional
characters, I think those additional characters
were actually interesting. And that's often not
the case when you get sequels that bring in new
characters. A lot of times the new characters
are bringing the movie down. At least that didn't
happen. So I would say definitely not in the
top 20. Top 30, 40, top 50, yes. At least it's
getting me closer to being right, so point for
it there. That's true, and that means it's time
that we only have 10 spots remaining on our countdown.
And I will mention that there are 12 of our contributors
or people that submitted lists that have not
seen their number one film yet. So 12 people
have not seen their number one film yet. There
are 10 spots remaining. And we need how many
more Pixar films? We need eight more Pixar films
to reach Dan's prediction. So let's see what
the top ten brings us. I don't know. I can feel
people listening, getting nervous. Will their
favorite films show up in our countdown? Well,
we're not concerned with that. We're only concerned
with making Dan right. So with number 10, let's
go to another Pixar film. Starting off our top
10, we're going to go to the year 2003. We will
see one person's number one ranked film fall,
as we will, with every film in the top 10 except
for one. Every film in our top 10 was ranked
number one by somebody except for one. This is
not it. It was Rotten Tomatoes score number 99
on there. 2003's Finding Nemo is number 10 on
our list. We've also passed the 1300 point mark.
Maximum point total 2000. This is at 1308. Finding
Nemo at number 10 in our top 10. So the discussion
shifts now. Does it deserve to be in our top
20? No. Does it deserve to be in our top 10?
Dan, start us off here. That's so hard. It's
hard without even thinking of what else is on
the top 10 to see if it... deserves or not uh
just thinking off the top of my head i don't
believe i ranked in the top 10 uh so i would
say no uh but top 20 i don't have an i agree
i think it belongs there i think this is a good
area where like pixar i think was even turning
the table and becoming more and more acclaimed
like i don't think this is a fast pixar movie
but i think this is when they entered a new territory
the animation got even better uh the story would
think the scope of the story might be one of
their Biggest ones just in what they do. And
again, a lot of great characters. And I thought
like Ellen DeGeneres in this was hilarious. I'm
not always her biggest fan, but I did find her
funny in this. And Sharkbait, that character
I thought was interesting. And Willem Dafoe with
his voice acting. So I think overall the voice
acting cast is strong as well. And I don't know,
I thought it was a lot of fun. There was a lot
of heart to it. this fish trying to go and find
it's, uh, you know, it's his, his son. There's
something to that. And, uh, just, it's a cute
movie too. I mean, you gotta give it points for
that. And I'm just remember people buying fish,
Nemo fish forever. And I think most kids, when
they see that fish, if you go to any aquarium,
you're going to see people calling it the Nemo
fish. I think it's basically changed its name
because of this movie. Uh, Steve love for finding
Nemo is a top 10 worthy film. Yeah, I can see
that. It's one of Pixar's stronger films. And
something I've kind of noticed is if Pixar has
a strong film, it either A, never gets a sequel,
or B, it takes them a while to get the sequel.
Let's all go find Dory next year. That's my point.
That's over 10 years later. Yeah, that's what
my point is. I mean, look at that. uh toy story
2 isn't nearly as good as toy story 3 which had
a big gap between them or you know like incredibles
where that's never had a sequel or you know stuff
like that and then you look at things like cars
and you have cars too and then planes it gets
progressively worse so no i i see that this this
film uh is deserving of it i like the voice cast
i like a lot of the the jokes i like the Part
where Ellen is Dory and forgetting everything
that's going on in the story. You get all the
fish in the dentist's office. Yeah, it definitely
has a lot of moments. The film is very funny,
but it's entertaining for all ages. Neil? Finding
Nemo? Should it be in our top ten? This is going
to get progressively hard because I want to steer
clear of hyperbole, but it's hard to say no.
Well, personally, I did not put it in the top
10 or even the top 20, but that's because there's
so many great films and it's just hard to put
them in an order when you get this far up the
countdown. But this is a very good film. And
I think what Pixar and sequels is that... I don't
think Pixar really likes doing sequels, or at
the very least, they don't want to do a sequel
unless there's a story to be told. And I think
in a couple spots they were contractually obligated,
and that's how we got Toy Story 2 and Cars 2.
Whereas I think with Finding Dory, I think we're
going to find that they actually have a story
that's worth seeing. So I'm looking forward to
that. About this movie, though. Yeah, I love
the... the fish tank and the dentist's office.
Every character in this movie is great, especially
Ellen DeGeneres as Dory. And just, I would never
have thought of her as being primed to be a voice
actress, but she did a great job. Even Albert
Brooks, I'm not the biggest Albert Brooks fan,
but he was fantastic in this. So, yeah, it definitely,
I would not begrudge it for being on a top 10.
Maybe wouldn't have put it in there myself, but
I would not object at all. And interesting to
see. I'll save that thought for another second
here. But Mike, did you say anything about Finding
Nemo yet? Finding who? Finding Nemo. I've seen
this in bits and pieces. I've never actually
seen it all the way through. And I know a lot
of people do love the film. And I was one of
those people that when the craze hit. Like a
lot of things. And I'll admit to this to a lot
of things. When the Animaniacs craze hit back
in the 90s, I steer clear. I didn't enjoy Animaniacs
until I got older. Same thing with Finding Nemo.
When all this merchandise and all this, I guess
you could say, infamy about it kind of hit, I
was like, okay, I'll wait. I'll wait until all
that's died down. So I'll have to check this
one out eventually. All right. Well, we start
off our top ten with Finding Nemo from Pixar,
and Dan hopes to see seven more Pixar films.
Let's see if we can make that happen. Some interesting
things that we'll bring up as far as these two
coming back to back. I'm not seeing they're directly
related outside of the company that produced
them, so Dan scores another one. Number nine
is Pixar's film from 2008, and that would be
WALL -E. It was on the exact same number of lists
as Finding Nemo. They were both on 17 lists.
It was just a tiny bit higher ranking. We haven't
talked about limited rank at all, and I'm not
going to get into it because I don't want to
confuse people. But it's basically if you were
just to rank amongst the lists that they're listed
on. I find it interesting. Finding Nemo and Wally
would come in 14th and 13th right next to each
other, just like they do. With this version of
ranking, I'm 10th and 9th. Another number one
falls. Michael Wilson and as well as one of our
contributors both had it number one. So it was
the first film we've seen that two people ranked
as their number one film. Rotten Tomatoes score
of 96. But three people did off of their list
completely. WALL -E in comparison to Finding
Nemo, Mike. Again, this is another one I resisted
for the longest time. I finally did watch it.
And the first five or ten minutes, I was like,
why do people see this as one of the best Pixar
movies? After a while and after multiple viewings,
I do like it. I do enjoy the story of it. Thankfully,
at this point in time in our lives, not the entire
planet hasn't become overweight slobs. I don't
know. I thought that was kind of funny, just
kind of basically poking fun at how lazy humans
can be. I enjoy WALL -E. Is it a movie I go back
to often? Not really, but I enjoyed it. Steve,
are you a WALL -E fan? Have you seen it, and
does it deserve to be in our top ten? Yeah, I
actually have it on Blu -ray. This one I had
as my number five, so I definitely see it as
being in the top ten. It's kind of odd for me
to like a film like this, considering a lot of
the dialogue is not human. It's all inferred
over beeps and sounds. So I, too, kind of resisted
it when it came out initially. And then my wife
and I rented it and ended up buying it because
we really liked it. The story's really strong
between showing the civilization thing, and it's
kind of funny because you get the live -action
scene in there at a point of the president evacuating
the planet. I think it was Fred Willard or something.
But no, the voice cast is pretty strong in it.
The animation's cool. I like the futuristic concept.
So, I mean, I would say that it's definitely
a strong film. All right. Neil, top ten worthy?
Awful. No, I love this movie. Yes, it is top
ten worthy, and that's where I put it. I had
it at number eight. So, yeah, this is an excellent
movie. And I actually do like that for the first,
I don't know how many minutes of the movie, there
was basically no dialogue. I mean, obviously
there were. but you had to infer what was going
on more than anything. But yeah, I love the –
there's just such a – I think Pixar is really
– they like to challenge themselves. And I think
with this movie and another movie that starts
out with a lot of no dialogue, they were trying
to really stretch their legs, stretch their animation.
trying to get you to care about characters without
leaning on the actors so much. I think this was
an experiment that really paid off for them.
I'm kind of stumbling, but I don't know what
else to say. It's such a good movie. I think,
yeah, it definitely deserves to be in the top
ten. I guess what surprises me the most is I've
never heard anyone say anything bad about WALL
-E. I've never heard anything that anybody just
hates it, that dislikes it. uh despises it and
not not even that but i not even hear people
that say like nitpick little things about it
now we did have three people that left it off
the list completely should i assume that they
just haven't seen it dan uh well i i do think
there are some people that have major issues
with the second half of the movie when the social
commentary on it gets a little bit on the nose
for some people. I necessarily don't agree with
that, but I know usually the criticism I hear
the most is that once you bring in the dialogue
and you actually have human characters, it might
be a little bit too much, like Mike mentioned,
just like with talking about just how overweight
and lazy humans become. So I think that might
be reason left off, or it could be because they
haven't seen it. For me, again, like Neil, like
everyone's mentioned, it's 100 % deserving of
the top 10. One of the best Pixar movies ever,
bar none. Pixar has a unique ability to tell
you so much without dialogue and just through
facial expressions and body language. And that's
so much true in WALL -E. we've mentioned this
the first i think it's 45 minutes honestly i
don't know how long for sure but i believe it's
it's near that where you have no actual dialogue
and you just learn about you know this character
wally just through his action just through his
uh you know how he goes through his everyday
task and just he's like weird looking eyebrows
and whatnot And plus, like Steve mentioned, putting
Fred Willard as president should qualify you
for the top 10 immediately. Yes. Yeah. But yeah,
and I think one of the better love stories, if
you want to call it a love story or a friendship
between Wally and Eve, I mean, that's wonderfully
told, and there's so much heart there. When I
talked about Wreck -It Ralph, not to keep harping
on it, I talked about how that gets... unnecessarily
complicated to me. If you look at Wally, it shows
you how you can tell you, you can say so much
without even speaking the words. And it's, it's
a hard skill. It's really hard to do. So it's
100 % deserving a top 10, I think arguably top
five. So I will say that I think like the third
or the fourth or the upteenth time it's been
on like Disney channel or ABC family or whatever
else after I had seen it on DVD. Well, the first
time I remember seeing it, I was like, hey, they
made Johnny Five a midget. What the hell? And
then as I watched it more over the last couple
of years since its release, I'm thinking, hey,
Wally and Eva, or Eve or whatever, because he
says her name is Eva, they're basically Johnny
Five and Ally Sheedy is what they are. Shut up.
You know you like Short Circuit. Alrighty then.
So a Pixar trio so far to help Dan out here when
we had Toy Story 2 backed up against Finding
Nemo and now WALL -E. So apparently we need some
more. Let's see. We're running out of spots here,
guys. Let's see what's next. All right. So at
number eight, another number one falls. As we
said, all of them except for one are number ones.
But I don't think the person that had this ranked
number one will be as upset to see it at least
making our countdown. Number eight on our list
from 1999 is the Iron Giants from Warner Brothers.
1 ,348 points. It was on everybody's list except
for two people's. Mr. Wilson, what are you thinking?
TV's Mr. Neal had it ranked number one. Limited
rank of 15. So coming in at number eight is Iron
Giant. We'll let you start, Neil. Okay, you've
all been spared eye pokes. Yes. This movie is
phenomenal. I mean, I do understand that it has
some weaknesses, but I think it makes up for
just pure charm. Because they basically took
this concept that was like, what if Optimus Prime
was Winnie the Pooh? and basically this this
boy finds a giant this big iron giant and uh
befriends him and it's basically just a friendship
story and you never find out where the giant
comes from but he has some sort of there's some
sort of ominous hint about where about you know
that he may have been an invader or something
but he he hits his head at the beginning of the
movie and so he loses his memory so he's like
so he's basically like a big puppy now so and
it's it's a movie that's all about about being
who you want to be, which is a theme that I like.
And we see it in a couple other films, particularly
a Pixar film that I also hope is in the top 10.
It's a Brad Bird movie. It's really, really cute.
I love this movie. And like I said, it's got
a couple hokey spots, but I think the characterization
saves it. And that's about all I have to say.
Dan, since you were spared the eye poke that
you were so worried about before, your thoughts
on Iron Giant being in our top 10? I 100 % agree
with what Neil was saying. It's deserving top
10, 100%. It's such a wonderful story. I just
love the animation to it, too, of the giant.
He looks so classical in a way, and just his
design. I don't want to say steampunk because
that's not right at all, but I don't know. Just
in how he's all put together is just interesting
to me. And to me, this is like Brad Bird doing
Spielberg better than Spielberg can do at times
because there is such a heart to it and such
an earnestness with that relationship between
the boy and the giant, which is wonderful and
maybe probably the best Vin Diesel performance
ever. So there is that. as the voice of the giant
um but yeah great great movie great animation
and uh you know probably one of if not the best
Brad Bird movie all right uh Mike your thoughts
on the Iron Giant you know Neil said you know
mash Optimus Prime and Eeyore together and You
get Xander Cage! I could not believe... When
this movie first came out, I'm like, Vin Diesel
does voiceover? Really? Wow. But no, I love this
movie. I think this is a really, really great
movie. I think the aspirations of being something
greater than what you are, like in the movie,
Hogarth uses the example of Superman, which is
kind of funny because the... The giant is from
some unknown world. So technically this is a
Superman movie. The animation is great. I was
kind of surprised with the voice cast of Aniston
and Harry Connick Jr. Jennifer Aniston and Harry
Connick Jr. as the mother and the... The Junkyard
Artist, I like it. I think it's really cool.
The animation is top -notch. It's just an all
-around great movie, and everyone needs to at
least see this once. Steve, we haven't got your
thoughts. Iron Giant, deserving or not of being
in our top ten? Yeah, I can definitely see that.
The animation in it was really good. I liked
the story. The fact that it's giant robots and
it's got almost that E .T. kind of vibe to it
is kind of cool. No, I mean, it's definitely
a strong film. I don't have any problems with
it. All right, so we got something that wasn't
Disney and wasn't Pixar into our top ten, so
the crowd should rejoice for that, although it
hurts Dan's odds a tiny bit. I'm okay with that.
Okay, well. We'll see if we can get right back
to Pixar or if we have somewhere else to go for
our next slot. All right, coming in at number
seven. I'm sorry, Dan, but it's not from Pixar.
Number seven is a film also from the 90s, just
like Iron Giant. This time it's from 1991. We're
going back to the wonderful world of Disney for
Beauty and the Beast. The first film to... break
the 1400 point mark, but it was only on 16 people's
list. So those 16 people ranked at darn high.
In fact, if you were just to do our rankings
based on the films that it was, the list that
it was appearing on, it would have been our number
two film on our countdown. So only one film was
ranked higher if you just took the list that
it appeared on. Two people ranked at number one,
92 Rotten Tomatoes score. Number seven, Beauty.
and the Beast. Mike, your thoughts on it coming
in our top 10 and maybe in comparison to the
other Disney princess films we talked about earlier
in today's episode. I like Beauty and the Beast.
It's a movie that I think is a little overhyped.
It is a good movie. It is a good story. It's
good animation. Again, it's one of those Disney
movies that The side characters are more so the
interesting part of the film, because if you
took those side characters away, it's basically
just, you know. Rooting Batman and Vicki Vale.
It's really what it is. But you're no longer
allowed to make references for the rest of the
episode. Shut up. It's it's true, though. Overall,
I enjoyed it. Is it something I watch on a regular
basis? No, not really. I do like the arguments
between, I think it's Mr. Clocksworth, and I
forget what the candle's name is off the top
of my head. Yeah, I do like their back and forth.
I thought that was really cool. As far as regards
to the other films, I enjoy the other films more
than this, but I still do enjoy this for what
it is. But not top 100 worthy? I don't know.
I just think it's not for me because if I was
to go back and redo my list, maybe somewhere
in the 60s, but... I don't know, it just wasn't
something that, sure, the animation's great,
the music is great, the story's good, but it
just wasn't something that I thought of to put
on here. Do you think this is, I'm not trying
to rake you over the coals here. Yes, you are.
Do you think this is inferior to the multiple
Disney sequels that you did rank in your top
100? No, but at the same time, I've seen all
of those more than I've seen this. I've seen
this maybe a total of five times since it came
out. I'm speechless. Anyway, Neil, Beauty and
the Beast, not in our top 100 or not in our top
10. It comes in at number 7. Your thoughts? I
wouldn't have put it in the top 10. This falls
under the brain fart category because somehow
I didn't list it. I don't know how that happened.
It's an okay Disney movie. I have kind of mixed
feelings about it because it is kind of like
a Stockholm Syndrome type movie just because...
The Beast is holding Belle captive, but she's
also falling in love with him, which is kind
of weird. But, you know, it is what it is. And,
of course, it also kind of hurts that she's like
the smartest of all the Disney princesses. She's
a bookworm. Or is that what it is? Is she just
that smart that she found a way to not get killed
by the Beast? I'll take it. By tangling this
whole love story up in it. I'll take that. yeah
yeah it's a good movie i don't know i know i
wouldn't put it in the top 10 maybe like 30s
fair enough um and i i kind of do it maybe i'll
give you guys a chance to to comment again and
dan and steve can comment while they while they
make their first comments but uh interesting
too to see that we had a A slew of Disney princess
films come back to back to back when we talked
about Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, Snow White
and even Little Mermaid all in a row. And now
Beauty and the Beast was somewhat separated from
that pact. So think about that for a minute.
Steve, your general thoughts on Beauty and the
Beast coming in on our top 10. I kind of have
to agree with Neil. I mean, one, I forgot it,
too. Somehow a brain fart. But. I don't see it
as top 10, but I definitely see it beating everything
else that was in the beginning of the episode.
I mean, I find it enjoyable, and the songs in
it are pretty good, and then the animation's
good. So, I mean, it's a fairly memorable film
and very likable. I've seen it more times than
I care to count, but that's more so because my
wife really likes it. I definitely see it being
in the top 20. I think it has some things going
for it and it has some things going against it.
It is coming out in an era of just phenomenal
Disney films, and I think sometimes it can get
lost in the shuffle there with the other three
that come around it, even though It outranked
Little Mermaid on our list. I think it has, like
you said, the side characters are very interesting.
All the people and objects that she comes into
contact, especially when she's in the Beast,
whatever you want to call it, Castle, Palace,
whatever. It has that going for it. It has some
good music, as do all the Disney films from this
era. It has a Disney princess who... Well, I
guess... it's about any way you put it would
probably be she'd have to rank as one of the
best as far as if you were trying to find like
the ideal princess to marry um i mean she's gorgeous
she's intelligent she's definitely got a lot
going for her um she can sing um i don't know
so she you gotta yeah yeah you know she'll let
you kidnap her and uh not press charges um so
i mean You got that going for you. I think what,
for me, it falls a little short on is in the
main villain, perhaps. I don't know who else
or what other kind of awesome villain you could
have had and it wouldn't have worked with this
story. But Gaston, in comparison to other Disney
villains, doesn't rank very high. So I guess
if you were trying to nitpick, I could point
that out. I am surprised that it's somewhat separated
from... The rest of the Disney princesses, especially
Little Mermaid. Dan, what do you think? I guess
I may be alone here, but I had it in my top ten,
and I think it is deserving. Regarding the villain
aspect, I guess, to me, the villain in this or
the conflict in this is not necessarily one of
an outside character, but it's that personal
journey of the Beast. The Beast is his own worst
enemy in this. I do give it points for if you
look at a lot of the Disney princess movies,
it's often the princess being saved, the princess
changing who she is in the case of Little Mermaid
in order to fit into another world. But this
is a case where it's the princess or the beauty.
Like you said, only the beauty can save the beast.
It's the beauty is the one who is actually. in
some ways, the hero in it because she is bringing
the beast around. So on that standpoint, I think
it stands a little bit above the other Disney
princess movies. I also think the animation is
fantastic. A lot of the musical set pieces, you
know, are grandiose, huge, and wonderful. a lot
of the side characters, like you mentioned, also
just a lot of the design to the character. I
remember loving, I still do. I love the design
of the beast. There have been a lot of different
interpretations of that story of beauty and the
beast. And I think the Disney's version of it
or Disney's design of it is one of the best.
And not that this means anything or not that
this is a huge deal, but you have to give it
somewhat credit for being the first animated
movie ever nominated for Best Picture. And that's
back when there's only five of them. Again, like
Academy Awards aren't everything, but I think
that does say something about what it was at
the time it came out. So I don't know. To me,
it is deserving of the top 10. And I think it's
the, you mentioned versions of Beauty and the
Beast. It's the best version of this story I've
ever seen. I actually did have it ranked, and
I don't want to say that I was just surprised
that it was so far, not so far, but somewhat
removed from those other ones. I figured they
would all be lumped together somewhat. But I
had it ranked in my top ten as well. I think
I had it like eight or nine. So I'm fine with
it being in our top ten. Mike or Neil or Steve,
anybody have another thought on Beauty and the
Beast that they wanted to share? It's one of
the few that have had spinoffs, but not sequels.
There was Enchanted Christmas, which I guess
could really be considered a sequel, but it didn't.
Again, it... For me, in sequels, sometimes, specifically
to Disney, if it doesn't have the number two
or Roman numeral two in it or any kind of numbering
in it, it doesn't really consider it to be a
sequel, even though it is. They did have Enchanted
Christmas. They did have a couple of other things.
What interests me most about the Disney stuff
is more so how they can, or how they did, put
everything together in House of Mouse. As far
as all of the classic villains and characters
being in the audience, as far as Beauty and the
Beast, it is worthy of top 10. I probably would
put it lower, though, personally. Fair enough.
So, Dan, just if we're keeping track of our ongoing
nonsense, you need Pixar to run the table now.
Hey, if I'm wrong, I'll be happy to be wrong.
I'll be happy to be wrong. I'm going to be upset
with the next one. I'm just going to show my
hand early. Oh, geez. Oh, well. We'll see what
that is. Six. I say I'm going to be upset. I'm
not really upset. I mean, it's number six at
least. But, yeah, my number one is going down
now, too. And that will be our number six film
on the list. We're staying with Disney. We're
going one year into the future. 1992's Aladdin.
One person decided that this was not top 100
worthy. One individual. Left it off of their
list entirely. But we'll get more into that individual's
rankings maybe in the wrap -up. 1 ,500, over
1 ,500 points. So out of the possible 2 ,000,
1 ,522 on 19 list, 92 Rotten Tomatoes score.
If we were doing a limited rank, it would have
came in number 10, but it comes in at number
6. I was the only one that ranked at number 1.
I love it. just about everything about this film.
It contains my favorite Disney princess, probably,
and Jasmine. She's amazing. And no, I'm not attracted
to animated people. Robin Williams as the genie
is quite possibly one of the greatest characters
in animation history as far as animated films.
In my opinion, he was... ridiculously on top
of his game as this role um there's not a kid
that saw this film that was not laughing and
in love with the with the genie um so you have
that going for it you not my favorite disney
villain by far i i'm not a huge jafar fan but
he is a pretty pretty i don't know badass bit
of disney villain i mean he's got a lot of power
he becomes some crazy powerful stuff on genie
power and etc um so you got that you got like
the magic carpet you got a boo um i loved aladdin
as a character and i think one thing that really
got aladdin for me was when you're a kid growing
up and you've seen all the disney classic movies
and you've seen cinderella and snow white and
sleeping beauty and all these uh characters we've
talked about previously um and then you have
a bunch of movies where the you know the main
characters are you know it seems like they're
animals or they're um something like that you
know like dumbo and bambi and you know even with
like aristocats and robin hood's animals and
jungle books basically animals and then aladdin
finally comes around especially right after beauty
and the beast and and little mermaid and you
have one of the main characters is a human male
And I don't know, for me, that resonated growing
up. And I loved the voicing of him. I loved the
music in this. I think his moment when he's singing
the riff -raff part, riff -raff street rat, and
just being able to somehow see him as this person
who is on both, gets to try to experience both
sides of it, being the lowly, you know, person
being chased as a criminal to, you know, being
married to a princess, et cetera. I don't know.
There's a lot to love about this movie. I had
it ranked number one, but I will get off my soapbox
and let someone else talk. Dan, what do you think
about Aladdin? If I were going to talk about
my favorite Disney movie of all time, it is actually
my favorite just personally, but it's not the
one I ranked the highest just because I don't
think it's necessarily quality wise, the best
one. Like you mentioned as a kid, I don't. We
watched this, or it was on TV the other day,
into one of those movies. I just know word for
word. I've watched it so many times. Just every
single line just comes to me. Again, so many
great songs. You talked about the characters.
I mean, the animation too. I love the, like the,
it got me right away when you see that, the head
of the, I guess you would say tiger or whatever
it is. Tale of Wonders, yeah. Yeah, I thought
that was amazing. hooked me in and i've been
hooked ever since um you know magic carpet so
much great humor and it also was one of the best
uh disney uh psychogenesis games i've ever played
in my life so major points for it there so yeah
i 100 deserving of top 10 uh so i like you kevin
share your love of this movie excellent neil
aladdin good or bad good movie i didn't rank
it that high but it's Of the 90s Disney films,
or at least the early 90s Disney films, this
might be my least favorite. But it's good. Yeah,
Robin Williams is not exactly my favorite comedian,
but he was funny in this movie. So I'll give
him credit for that. I liked the voice of the
parrot, which was Gilbert Gottfried. Yes. I think
he stole the movie. I love that character. Just
because it's... I shouldn't even call it a character
because it just is Gilbert Gottfried. Just totally
bleeding over the character and being himself.
The aristocrats. So, yeah. And a healthy dose
of Frank Welker in here as well. Oh, yeah. Two
healthy doses, actually. Who disrupts my slumber?
That was eerily good. Lots of practice. You should
practice that more than Megatron now. Yeah, Aladdin,
okay. Let me see here. I'm trying to remember.
I did not actually get to see this in theaters,
which is a damn shame. We were, and I don't know
if it's still like this nowadays because I go
to only matinee showings now. But back in 92
when this came out. We were going, my dad, my
aunt, my cousin and I were going to go see this
in the theater. The theater was like, I don't
know, five blocks away from where we were living.
And the line stretched for four of the five blocks.
Literally, the line was around the corner of
the building and down the street. to get in to
see this film. It had that much... It was that
anticipated. And like Dan said, everything about
this movie, and like you said, Kev, everything
about it is really, really, really cool. Yeah,
Jafar isn't the... Technically, magically, he's
probably... the best out of all the Disney villains
outside. I would say he's, like, if we were doing
awards, he's the best male Disney magician on
the evil side. And, of course, his, sadly, not
former wife, Maleficent, would be the female
version. But I don't know. This movie, yes, it's
Robin Williams. Yes, it has great songs. It has
a great plot. I see the Sultan now in so many
different King roles. How stupid the Sultan was
in this movie. And Neil is right. You know, Gilbert
Gottfried, the parrot really kind of stole the
show in this. He really, really did. For me,
the genie stole the show, but, but I can see
that. Oh, okay. But on the villain side. Who
are you going to be more enjoyable to see, Jafar
or Iago? I mean, Jafar, really, if you... Well,
the thing that Jafar did good, though, he was
just... He was a villain that was honestly creepy
and you didn't want to see and you believe he's
a villain 100%. I'm not saying he's my favorite
villain, but he is a villain. Oh, yeah. I don't
know. That sounded stupid, but he is what you
want from a villain, someone that you don't want
to be seen at all and that creeps you out. And
yeah, you're right, the genie. I mean, you know,
Robin Williams, his comedy, if you like it, you
like it. If you don't, you don't. What I love
about that guy is almost everything I've seen
him in, he's using a million different voices.
And the genie is no exception. It was a perfect
showcase for him. And how many quotable lines
is there from this that the kids would just repeat
and repeat and repeat? Wasn't he also... I'm
trying to remember. I'm going to have to look
it up. Didn't he also do a second role? Wasn't
he the guy in the beginning? Yes. The narrator.
That character was supposed to be the genie,
but they changed the ending. Oh, did they? Steve,
you haven't got to talk. I don't think about
Aladdin, have you? No. What do you think about
it? I love this film. It's one of the few classic,
or if you can consider it classic, well, technically
it is because it's all CG now, Disney films that
I find myself going back and watching over and
over and never getting bored of. I really love
the, especially now I go and I sit and I can
pick out different voices like Jim Cummings,
Frank Walker. You know, all these different voice
actors I'm starting to pick up on because I know
who they are. But I love the story, the animation,
the music. Of course, Gilbert Gottfried in his
Iago role and then Robert Williams is the genie.
I just I love every aspect of this film. It's.
I ranked it at 12 on my list, but I definitely
like it where it's at. So I have no problem with
where it's at. Who would have thought that wasn't
the kid from Full House doing the voice of Aladdin?
Is that right? Is that the right show that he
was on? Growing Pains, I think. Oh, okay. Yeah,
I do. We used to talk about the songs a lot.
Whole New World and One Jump Ahead. I don't know.
There was a lot of good music in here. But again,
that was prototypical for that time period of
Disney. And then we are left with five spots
remaining on our countdown. So although we can't
get to the number Dan predicted, we can get close.
Let's start with number five from Pixar from
2004. And that movie is The Incredibles. Again,
one person left this off of their list, and that
was it. It was ranked number one, as are most
of the films we've been talking about. 1 ,533
points, just edging out Aladdin by about 10 points
or so, 11 points. Number five on our list, The
Incredibles, Dan. Amazing. I don't know if I
put it up number five, but top 10, top 15, I
don't have an issue with it. A lot of great characters.
Again, I love how it takes a lot of the tropes
of the superhero genre and flips them on their
head. And, too, it's kind of like the best Fantastic
Four movie you're probably ever going to get,
though it's not necessarily Fantastic Four. Just
that dynamic is similar in some ways. But, yeah.
I love to just edit like some of the action sequences
in this are so well done and so well handled
and different use of powers and whatnot. It's
also really funny. I mean, I think because of
Incredibles, people look at capes a lot differently
in superheroes. And yeah, exactly. So, yeah,
I I love the Incredibles. I don't know if I would.
Number five is tough just because it's that's
it's hard for almost any movie when you get up
this high. But. I don't have an issue with it
being in top ten. Mike, are you a fan of the
film? Have you seen it? Incredibles? I've seen
it over and over and over again. All right. I
love this movie. It's interesting to me the path
that Jason Lee has taken as an actor because
he voices the villain syndrome in this. Overall,
you know... I pretty much, which is probably
shocking to a lot of people, the world might
be about to break because I pretty much agree
with Dan. I mean, it's an overall amazing film.
Neil should be snickering at that world about
to break. Yes. The voice cast is amazing. The
plot is cool. You have two children, one who
is skeptical about her powers and the other one
in Dash who wants to just embrace them. That's
an interesting dynamic. You have the, I guess
you could say, overweight insurance salesman,
kind of down on his luck kind of guy, trying
to get back in the game because he's a superhero
that isn't a hero anymore. I really, really enjoy
this film, and if they ever do make a sequel,
I don't know where they could take it from here.
Steve, do you want a sequel for The Incredibles?
Yes. This was one of the films I was wondering
why the hell they never went back to it. I really
enjoy it. One, for the superhero aspect, too,
because they're in a superhero protection program.
which I find very funny. And I just love watching
the progression of this down -and -out hero having
to come back into his own, and only this time
it's with his family, and then you have Syndrome,
and then they leave it off as if they were going
on another adventure -type thing at the end,
another battle, but they also left it to where
they could pick it up right where it left off.
I found it to be a very enjoyable film. I really
like it. I think I've read that they are working
on a sequel to it, but I could be mistaken. I
just, in the process of us recording the episode,
I looked at Pixar's upcoming list and it says
there's a bunch of unannounced stuff, but like
out of the rest of. next year there's actually
i don't even think that pixar is doing a film
next year unless they haven't announced it because
the way their list reads is the next film they've
got coming up is in 2015 i will say about the
incredibles one of the coolest things quite literally
is samuel jackson is frozen that's amazing and
the commentary on being a hero and having a home
life specifically to him and his wife i love
that scene this is for the greater good greater
good i am your wife steve uh do you have anything
else that you read uh no i mean i i just i really
love that film it's uh i i feel it's very deserving
of its placement you'll agree or disagree i agree
that well the placement i think i would switch
this around with the iron giant because that's
my bias but this completes the brad bird trifecta
which is this the iron giant and uh rat chef
um i i gotta say i love this movie i love that
it's it's a love letter to to the superhero genre
but it also pokes fun at it like the whole monologuing
thing you caught me monologuing you know I loved
that because that's what superheroes do. They
stand there and talk with their bombastic speeches.
It's like, why doesn't someone just throw a punch?
Oh my god, this movie. Craig T. Nelson. I love
these casting choices. You would never imagine
these people in these roles, but yeah, Craig
T. Nelson was perfect. Who was the wife? Helen
Hunt, was it? No, it was... Not Helen Hunt. It's
– oh, what's her name? She was in – Everyone
listening is screaming out the name. Yes, I know.
It's Holly Hunter. That's what it is. Yeah, there
are some actresses that I just get confused.
But this is such a great movie. Yeah, the introverted
daughter and the extrovert son and how that resolves
toward the end of the movie. I like that it's
one of these films that says like – Yes, if you
have a special talent, you should be able to
express it, and you should be what you want to
be, just like the Iron Giant. God, this is such
a good movie. I love Brad Bird. He should do
more cartoons, but sadly, I think he's moved
on. All right. Well, unanimous love for Incredibles
amongst the panel, and then there were four.
Four. Well, some people may be upset, but remember,
it's still at number four, so that is darn good,
but I know some people were championing it on
the message boards or the website pages as far
as thinking it could possibly be number one.
Number four is 1994 film from Disney, and that
would be The Lion King. On 17 lists, so three
people felt it necessary to... Leave Lion King
off entirely. 1 ,534 points just edging out Incredibles
for the number four spot. Two people had it ranked
number one. And like I had mentioned before,
if we were taking that limited rank as far as
just ranking based on lists that it appeared
on, Lion King would have been number one. I'm
really surprised it's not. I was really... I'm
speechless. Three films ranked higher than Lion
King. So let's get our first opinion on Lion
King. Outranking Aladdin by two spots, outranking
Beauty and the Beast by three spots, outranking
Little Mermaid by more than that. Coming in at
number four, Mike, you started and so will continue.
I'm just speechless. Other three films could
be better than this, unless you're... And this
is one, I honestly, as much as I said Aladdin
was my number one pick, I went back and forth
for days on if it was going to be Aladdin Lion
King or Lion King Aladdin. So I feel that they're
equally amazing. First of all, let's get the
pop culture stuff out of the way. Darth Vader
is a lion, really? No, you don't say. That was
TFG on mic, everybody. round of applause yeah
well what's funny is when i watch it with my
wife or whenever we hear his voice on something
i'm like dearth vader she's like mufasa my only
complaint with this film and it's not really
a complaint is i i very much enjoyed um simba
as a cub and Simba as kind of an adolescent growing
up, I wish they would have spent a little bit
more time there instead of just doing the montage
to when he was older. I know there was probably
not an easy way to, you're not going to show
his entire life, but I enjoyed his younger years
almost even more. So I wanted more of that. And
I liked the singing voice and the speaking voice
of Simba as a young kid, but I mean, come on,
you got Hakuna Matata, you got a circle of life.
Yeah. So much good stuff about Lion King. Cool
Disney villain in Scar, I guess. Whoopi Goldberg
in this movie. Hyenas, yep. There's a lot of
good things to say. Whoopi Goldberg and Sheech
Marin. Two of the three hyenas. I think the other
one might have been Frank Welker. Oh, I'm sure.
It was. Steve, your thoughts on The Lion King?
It's definitely a very memorable film. Really
good. I think it's one of the greatest of the
90s of Disney by far, and it definitely kind
of blows away everything in the past. Not only
for the animal -based ones, but for just visually
and musically and every other aspect of the film.
It's really well done. just all, all the care
they took into making things sound authentic
and, and to some degree and, uh, kind of, uh,
it gives you that showing of, of death and animation,
but it's not like, I don't know. It's, it has
a deeper meaning in this film. Whereas most of
the other ones, it's kind of like, yeah, they're
dead. Boom. Next scene. You know? So, I mean,
it's, it's, it's, There's a lot of different
moments that it touches on in a person's life
kind of thing in this film. Just to clarify,
the third Hyena was Jim Cummings, not Frank Welker.
Oh, okay. Either way, continue what you're going
to say. Either way, I mean, it's not... Yeah,
they're both legends in their own right. The
one thing that this film did that a lot of...
that I didn't really notice a lot of other Disney
films do... Scar blamed Simba for Mufasa's death.
You didn't see that a lot. I mean, we might have
seen it, but you didn't really see that kind
of thing a lot of the whole thing. You might
see self -exile in a Disney film, but you don't
see self -exile because someone blames you for
killing your own father. And Jeremy Irons as
Scar. While Scar may not be one of the greatest
Disney villains of all time, Jeremy Irons is
easily one of the Disney villain voices of all
time. Yeah, that's probably true. Neil, thoughts
on Lion King? Love this movie. This is probably
the movie I've seen the most of all the movies
on this list, just because there's a girl in
high school who made me watch this almost every
week, and I would be dumb enough to do it. But
anyway, yeah, this is a great movie, and I love
– you guys were talking about Simba carrying
that burden and being blamed for the death of
Mufasa. Yeah, that's a pretty dark thing to do
to a character. I think it really gave a weight
to Simba that a lot of other Disney characters
just don't have because that's a big guilt to
carry on your shoulders. I love some of the visual
gags in the movie. The one that comes to mind
most is the Nazi walk with the hyenas during
the song that Jeremy Irons was singing. And speaking
of that song, you guys were talking about how
much of a god Jim Cummings was. Jeremy Irons
sings the first half of that song, and then at
some point in the middle, it switches to Jim
Cummings. And you would never catch it if you
didn't know. God, who else was in that movie?
Oh, Mr. Bean. What was his name? I'm blanking
on actors' names in this episode. Nathan, who
are you talking about? Oh, Rowan Atkinson. Yeah,
Rowan Atkinson. We have to mention him. God,
he was great in that role. Zazu. Singing, I've
got a lovely bunch of coconuts. Great scene.
We could just spend an hour talking about all
the great scenes in this movie. Yeah, I was kind
of shocked that it wasn't number one. That was
kind of the one I was betting on. And I'm kind
of blanking, like, what the hell could be above
this? I'm out of guesses, so I guess we're going
to find out. We haven't talked about Nathan Lane
and Ernie Sabella as Timon and Pumbaa as much,
or Matthew Broderick as the adult Simba. Ferris
Bueller as adult Simba was genius casting. Jonathan
Taylor Thomas was good as the young version,
too. Yes, no, he was. He was. I'm just glad I
saw him outside of Tim the Toolman Taylor's show.
Did anyone hear the other? voice actor that was
uh recorded as doing the song that got cut as
simba it's not nearly as good anyway um dan are
you equally surprised that this is number four
yeah i thought this was number one for sure just
based upon like the love of like 90s and 2000
disney that's been on the list so far i just
assumed this would be number one so i am again
like everyone else very shocked that it's at
number four that's I, you know, like it's almost
speechless. It was the highest Disney movie I
ranked. It's not my favorite, like I mentioned,
but I think it is the crowning achievement of
Disney. I think it has nearly every element of
Disney, of what it makes a great Disney movie.
You have that emotional parent or death that
has an impact on the character. You have great
side characters. You have amazing music. I mean,
it says something about like the Lion King when
you can get such a, like it. Made into a Broadway
show. And it's just as successful. From a visual
standpoint. It was just the landscapes. And the.
It's just like amazing. There is. I mean like
Mike mentioned. And Neil mentioned. Some of the
emotional. Complexity to the movie. Is. Not to
say unheard of. But something I think is missing
a lot. With Disney as of late. Like they. If
you look at some of the issues that you have
Simba dealing with, they're complex, they're
dark. That moment seeing Mufasa die, that's a
challenging moment for sure, especially when
you see Simba coming up and trying to wake up
his father. And too, like I think Mike mentioned,
it says something about death as well or taking
up your destiny. those different elements as
well and two i just love the final moment when
you have like uh that final climax battle and
just with the fire raging it's just it's to me
it's amazing um i think it should be higher i
top three top two but i mean it's number four
so i guess you can't get all that upset so but
i know that's the same thing i was like i think
it should be higher but there's only a couple
spots higher you can be but it should still be
higher um But yeah, I guess people are scratching
their heads and trying to come up with their
list of three films that are above this. They
call him Mr. B. So we'll have to see. This may
be perhaps the most interesting of our top ten
because nobody ranked it number one. And that's
the only film in our top ten that nobody ranked
number one. And actually, nobody ranked it number
two either. The highest it got ranked was number
three. And it comes in at number three. And that
is a film from 2009 and from Pixar. So this is
one of the ones that is outranking Lion King,
and that would be the film Up. On 19 of the 20
lists, Rotten Tomatoes gives it a 98. Again,
if we were to do that limited ranking, it would
have came in fifth instead of third. So I would
have changed things up a little bit. So Up is
one of the films that we were trying to come
up with. What could outrank Lion King? Well,
we have outranked it with Up. Is that correct
or incorrect, Dan? I don't have an issue with
it, per se. I think I rank Lion King higher.
They're two amazing movies, two movies that are
doing vastly different things, though. I know
that a lot of people make mention, this is not
my original idea by any means, but a lot of people
say that, you know, Up had a more interesting
and complex love story in 10 minutes than the
Twilight films had in six movies. And I think
that's very true. I mean, we talked, I think
Neil was making mention of this earlier when
he talked about WALL -E and being able to tell
a story without words. And it does that within
its first few moments. too we mentioned how Pixar
likes to challenge themselves you can't challenge
yourself that much more than having a protagonist
in an animated film that's like a you know 75
year old man um that's you know I I can imagine
just Disney just thinking there's no way this
could work because you're not going to want to
see a movie about an old guy but they made it
work it it there's so much something about I
guess the you know the that Setting the stage
in the beginning, I think, makes everything that
follows so much better because you have an idea
of the motivations of what's going on. And and
to just the concept of it, it's just so out there.
It's like I never would have think of a house
floating in the air with a bunch of balloons
and how that would work. And there's a lot of
great humor. I love the dog, you know, the dog
collar that you can hear them talk that I found
endlessly funny with squirrels. I mean, that's
to me always going to be. But anyway, yeah, it's
tough to say if it should rank higher than Lion
King. I personally didn't, but I'm not going
to get upset about it. I think it's certainly
deserving of top five. So it's really, you know,
you're good no matter what you get with this,
I guess. Mike, let's go to you next. You're the
only one out of the 20 that did not rank up.
Because I think at the time when I made the list,
I hadn't seen it yet. That's the only reason
why. I have seen it since, and I do enjoy it,
but I enjoy other Pixar movies more. It is an
amazing story. It is a good story. It's an interesting
take on the whole... As Dan said, it's an interesting
take on the love story, but it's also an interesting
take of love story and best... Weren't the two
guys, the hero and the villain, weren't they
best friends at one point, or weren't they friends
in... previous years or something or other no
he it's one of those he looked up like the the
villain in it was someone that he looked up to
as a child i believe that's right yeah it's some
sort of similar friend kind of thing and we've
seen that before uh you know i'm not saying that
against the movie um i i will agree with dan
i did like the dog but that other thing Actually,
that other thing, which is actually named Kevin
for some stupid reason. I didn't particularly
care for that character. That doesn't surprise
me. But no, I mean, I think it's an emotionally
charged movie, and I think it was a really good
movie. I personally, on our list, I would flip
-flop three and four. I don't think this is better
than Lion King, but it's interesting to see where
it fell. Steve, is it worthy of being in our
top five and in this case our top three? I don't
know if I'd put it in the top five because I
think there's other ones that are within the
last few films that could have been moved higher
up in place of it. But I can definitely see it
being in the top 15 anyway. I mean, it's an overall
enjoyable film, and I do have to agree with the
comment earlier about it tells more of a story
than Twilight. That's not hard to do, though.
But it's a nice little adventure and story that
kind of one of those end -of -life fulfillment
type things. and of course the young kid and
everything else. It's not one of my favorite
films, but I definitely see a place for it in
the top 15. Neil, agree or disagree? I put it
at number five, so I think it does deserve to
be in the top five. It's hard to say whether
this is better or not as good as Lion King, because
it's starting to all blur together now. How could
I possibly rank these now? I do think that this
is a great film, and it does deserve to be in
the top five. When Blanchard said something about
that other thing, I was like, please don't be
talking about Russell, the little Boy Scout kid
who was also along on the journey. Oh, no, no,
no, no, no, no. I was talking about the animals.
Yeah, I know. But, yeah, that was a cute thing
that I wasn't even expecting in the movie was
the kid just tagging along on the adventure.
I like that character. He was very atypical,
A, because he's Asian, and B, because he's fat.
He's like this little fat kid who you don't see
that in a lot of animated films. So that was
kind of cool. Great film. That's all I've got
to say. Another unanimous opinion amongst us.
And there's only two spots left. What could we
possibly have left? Or what out there are people
still trying to see squeezed into the countdown
that now they are losing hopes of? Let's see
what's next. Well, with number two and with number
one, we are going to pass a couple milestones
here because the last three films, the last four
films have been in the 1500 point range. This
should give people an idea as far as the voting
went. It's not even close now. The last four
were in the 1500s. The next two are in the 1700s.
So the next two blew the competition out of the
water. And also the next two films both appeared
on all submitted lists. So nobody left either
of these next two films off of their list. So
let's start with number two, and that would be
2010's film from Pixar, Toy Story 3. 1713 points
20 list was ranked 1 by 1 person Rotten Tomatoes
score of 99 and if you were taking the limited
rank it would have dropped down to number 4 on
our list but it comes in at number 2 Toy Story
3 Neil? Oh my god this movie yeah much better
than Toy Story 2 this is Words do not describe
this movie. The first image that always comes
into my mind of this is like almost at the end
where they're like they're in the incinerator
and they're all they think they're all going
to die. And I'm kind of giving away the end of
the movie. Well, not exactly, but they think
they're all going to die and, and they all hold
hands together. And I'm like, Oh my God, it's
kind of dark. It's always burned into your head
is because that's what they use. That's what
the trailer companies used as the promotional
stuff. That's true. Yeah. But it's, it's the
fact that they just went there and it's a very
powerful emotional scene. It's God, that seems
great. God, this is. I've tried to remember.
I've only seen this movie a couple times, but
I'm trying to remember more of it, but I can't.
But I do know that it was so good. Yeah, I've
just got nothing. Steve, coming in at number
two is Toy Story 3. Quite a few spots higher
than Toy Story 2. What are your thoughts? I don't
have a problem with it, although this is... telling
of what number one will be um just saying um
but no i mean i i really love this film i i i
think for a a sequel and coming this late in
the game i think that it knocked it out of the
park um but there's there's definitely a lot
of great moments in this this film uh making
it a perfect send -off for it if they never made
another one again. It's like every conversation
we had throughout the 100 countdown about sequels,
it was like, Toy Story aside, Toy Story sequels
aside, let's talk about all the other sequels.
Will we see anything else besides those sequels?
Dan, Toy Story 3 coming in at number two. Yeah,
and I think this is probably, I talked about,
I think a Lion King is a crowning achievement
of Disney. I think this is, at this point, probably
the crowning achievement of Pixar. You know,
it started with Toy Story, and I think everything
that's come after this hasn't been as good. Not
saying they can't get back there, but yeah, like
Neil mentioned, that scene in the incinerator,
it is, like, you didn't think a story about toys
could have so... much like weight to it and so
much like sadness and like i think that says
a lot about pixar when you when you actually
sit back and think you know what they could actually
kill all these characters but there's many studios
that you'd actually think that um and i think
that's that they've earned that moment throughout
everything they've done up to that point um i
just love too how pixar can pixar's at its best
it's when it takes Like, with The Incredibles
or other movies, it takes certain concepts or
certain elements and puts it in its movie, and
sometimes you don't even realize it. Like, a
lot of the movie with the daycare center and,
like, how it adds in moments of, like, Cool Hand
Luke and The Great Escape and all these little
elements of the, you know, other movies that
deal with, you know, the same concepts of the
prisons and whatnot. And, too, just little touches
the animation. Like, you see them getting...
And these characters getting like marks on on
them like from markers and stuff like that almost
directly almost like pseudo prison tattoos and
away just and how they're how they change throughout
time to and There's not many movies that can
bring in like So many new characters and still
but all the new characters are just as interesting
just as fleshed out they fit into the world perfectly
and you know the into like this is probably the
best villain of all the Toys R movies by far
You know, so I watched something about him. Just,
you know, he's just an evil character and just
how you kind of you don't know at first. And
you have an idea and how he develops and everything,
too. But, yeah, it's it's an emotionally powerful
movie. And that last beyond the last few moments,
the closing moments of this movie, like you like,
I think we would all say is just. it puts the
perfect bow on the end of this movie it's anyone
that's ever had toys anyone who's ever like it
just speaks so much to childhood and letting
go of your childhood in that last few moments
of the closing moments and it's it it is so i
mean you know it can easily bring a tear to your
eye and what's what it's able to do so very deserving
of top five i think it kind of like steve mentioned
we kind of know where it's going from here so
uh but Interesting nonetheless. And what do you
think of James Bond as Mr. Pricklepants? Hey,
he's got a good voice to him. I gotta give him
that. I think to me that the standout was Michael
Keaton as Ken. He was just hilarious. I am not
a doll! I love this movie. This movie is... As
much as I enjoy the first Toy Story, this movie
for me personally is the best one out of all
three because of how emotionally charged it is.
You know, everything that Dan just said, because
of all of that, this movie is so good. And what
I love about Pixar is when they do movies like
this, whether this is the final installment or
not, they then take those characters and give
us other stuff like Partysaurus Rex or Hawaiian
Vacation or other little shorts without having
to do a whole nother film. And I wish studios
would kind of pay more attention to that. Overall,
Toy Story 3, I absolutely loved it. Michael Keaton
and Jodie Benson as Ken and Barbie, that's just
perfect casting. That is just... The Little Mermaid
and Batman in a relationship in a toy movie.
That's amazing. This will always go down for
me as the animated movie that made grown men
cry. That's all I heard about from people that
were seeing this when it had come out in the
theater. Neil, anything you want to say about
Toy Story before we move on? Yeah, there was
one last thing I wanted to point out. Something
I almost forgot. For anyone who's an anime fan
and is a little... Kind of hurt that there's
none in the top 20. I just want to say that Totoro
is in Toy Story 3. Best cameo of the movie, and
I missed it the first time. I can't believe I
didn't see him. There you go. So there's only
one spot left. Let's get to the revealing. Coming
in number one on our top 100 animated film countdown.
Brother Bear. 1770 points. It was on all 20 lists.
Like I said, if you took its limited rank, it
would drop down to number three, but it comes
in number one for us. Rotten Tomatoes score of
100 from 2009. Naruto the movie. Okay, I'm just
kidding. That was at the other end of our list.
That was the worst ranked movie that got a vote.
Of course, it is the original. film from 1995
and that would be toy story um the first one
uh just go around the panel here not that you
didn't see this coming dan uh toy story coming
in at number one i mean i would say it's interesting
they're coming back to back like this i would
think as if you were comparing toy story toy
story 3 i think toy story 3 is probably a better
movie but Also considering the fact that you
have 15 years of animation that went with it
and that allowed them to go beyond that. And
two, I think a lot of what Toy Story 3 is able
to accomplish, a lot of that emotional weight
that's there would not exist without the original
Toy Story. Oh no, yeah. And I mean, I love Toy
Story. It was, I think I ranked it within my
top five, top three. I feel like I've said that
about 20 movies by now. But I just can't think
on top of my head. I ranked it really high. I
think it was the highest Pixar movie. Again,
similar to Snow White, but I think it's a lot
better. You look at where we are with animation.
CGI has taken over. Unfortunately, classic hand
-drawn animation has gone by the wayside. Or,
unfortunately, depending on who you are. And
a lot of that was due to Pixar. I mean, it was
an innovation of innovations. And it was, again,
a really good movie with a lot of great characters.
So I have no issue with it being number one.
I think if you were going to say any movie is
the best animated movie of all time, you almost
always run the risk of hyperbole and overstating
it. It's tough to give that moniker to anything.
I think there's a few that can. wear that monocle
man wear that reward well toy story is one of
them lion king is another so i personally don't
have any issue with it being number one i think
you can argue there are better movies but considering
its overall quality its impact on the genre and
every all the things like court sides how it
launched pixar into you know what it is today
it i i think it's deserving for sure uh steve
toy story coming in at number one Definitely
cannot argue. I pretty much agree with everything
everybody's already said. It's far and wide the
best Pixar film overall. I mean, just because
that's what started them out and the fact that
this one film spawned every Pixar film since
and spawned the only successful sequels out of...
Pixar, I think that speaks volumes. For sure.
Mike? Toy Story was, as we've kind of already
said, was groundbreaking. Toy Story and Lion...
What I'd like to see is, I'd like to see in the
comments for this episode if people want to argue
Toy Story versus Lion King. And I honestly think
we should probably take the... What did you call
it? The limited rank? Yeah, take the limited
-ranked number one film and the actual number
one film and do a GCR and Wars episode. No, I'm
dead serious. Lion King versus Toy Story. Well,
let me just, for shits and giggles here, taking
our top ten rank as we did it, going from ten
to one. Finding Nemo, WALL -E, Iron Giant, Beauty
and the Beast, Aladdin, Incredibles, Lion King,
up, Toy Story 3, and Toy Story. If we were to
take the limited rank, going in reverse order
from 1 to 10, we would have had Lion King, number
1, Beauty and the Beast, number 2, Toy Story,
number 3, Toy Story 3 would be next, then up,
then actually it would go to Akira at number
6, Spirited Away at 7, Incredibles at 8, Princess
Mononoke at number 9, and then Aladdin at number
10. So that would have been the limited rank
version. One of the best things I love about
this movie, and I didn't realize it when I first
saw it when it came out, but ever since then
I know. You basically have Sergeant Hartman as
the Army Sergeant in this. Arlie Ermey was the
voice of Sarge. I absolutely love that. And the
voice, I mean, Tom Hanks and Tim Allen as Woody
and Buzz, that's awesome. You've got Cliff Clavin
as Dr. Porkchop. You've got Don Rickles as Potato
Head. Was he Potato Head? Yep. Yeah. You've got
Don Rickles as Potato Head, and then getting...
And I know we're not talking about the sequels.
I have to. Okay, Toy Story 2 is not... It's the
middle film. To me, it's an okay film. It's not
a bad film at all. But the fact in Toy Story
2 that they... At the end of this film, it's
a Mrs. Potato Head. A Mrs. Potato Head, everybody.
And in the next film, you're wondering, who are
they going to cast to voice her? They get George
Costanza's mom to voice Mrs. Potato Head. That
was simply amazing casting. As far as the first
film, there's nothing wrong. If anyone can nitpick
this film and find something wrong with it, there's
something wrong with that person. Well, I mean,
you can find something wrong with everything,
probably. No, no, no. I mean, like, truly nitpick
every single piece of the film. Sure, yeah, you're
going to find something wrong, but yeah. Absolutely
loved it. I love the animosity between Buzz and
Woody. I love the fact that they have to come
together and team up. I really like the alien
guys from Pizza Planet. I thought they were cool.
Overall, I cannot say anything against where
we have this film at this point. I mean, it truly
is one of the most groundbreaking films of all
time. I'm getting a little lost just because
we had dual back -to -back Toy Stories. Is there
anybody I haven't let speak on Toy Story, the
original? I have not spoken yet. Go ahead. Well,
everyone's been gushing about this, so I'm going
to go in a different direction. Still going to
gush, but I'm going to gush over the voice actors.
or actually over the characters, basically that
they took all these beloved old toys that we
all grew up with and made them real characters.
I mean, look at Potato Head, Don Rickles. Looking
back, there was a Potato Head cartoon series,
and this blows that away. The Slinky Dog wasn't
even in production when this movie was made,
and they brought it back. Yeah, the army sergeant.
Everyone had those green army men. Everyone had
them. Yeah. God, this is, I mean, it was, oh,
Hot Wheels was in this. They had the Red Baron
car, which was the coolest car. And the only
toy that they didn't get was Barbie. And Mattel
was like, sure as hell knocking on Disney's door
to get her in the next movie. Yeah. Yeah, whoever
the person was that was sitting in the meeting
or the pitch room or whatever, the first person
that had the idea to do what you're saying and
come up with all these classic toys and tournament
characters deserves all the credit in the world.
And whoever was at Mattel who said, we're not
putting Barbie in this movie, that person should
be fired. Fired. Yeah, for sure. Great movie.
I don't want to get in too much of overall reactions
because we will do that in the wrap -up show.
But in each episode, we've at least reacted to
the episode in itself. So looking back at 20
through 1. Breaking it down a little bit, obviously
Disney and Pixar dominated. We didn't quite get
to the ten Pixar films that Dan predicted. We
got to eight of them. And we had one DreamWorks
film and one Warner Brothers film. Otherwise,
the rest were Disney. I saw a bunch of the classic
Disney princesses early on. Then we saw the 90s
Disney come up. later on with Wreck -It Ralph
thrown in between, which I said might be the
surprise of the top 20. Just looking overall
at our 20 through 1, though, get your reactions.
And then, like I said, we'll have all kinds of
time to react to the list overall, to break down
numbers by decade, by years, by companies, by
all kinds of different things. We'll get into
honorable mentions and all the stuff that did
get voted on but did not make the list since
there was 350 films that got voted on. We'll
talk about those that we haven't talked about
yet. So we'll do all that in the wrap up show.
But just looking at the 20 through one, Dan,
what's your reaction? Surprised and not surprised.
Surprised by number one in some ways, because
I think like most I thought it'd be Lion King.
Not surprised there's so many Pixar movies. It's
it's hard to really argue against it, though.
I mean, they're they have been I think they brought
animation up to another level in a lot of ways
and have been such a dominated force and for
such a long time. I mean, obviously Wreck -It
Ralph, like I said, I don't dislike the movie,
but it's probably the biggest surprise that it's
made it up this high. And I did find it interesting
when you mentioned the limited average and what
the top 10 would be if we went off just that.
And I think that's almost a better, I think that
says a lot about the list overall. I think kind
of... what i've noticed so far is this isn't
necessarily it's kind of like family feud in
a way where the answers aren't necessarily the
right answers the answers are the ones people
are most likely to give um just like it's kind
of more popularity than quality which is fine
i think it's what happens when you have such
a huge pool of people that they get from but
um i am happy about a lot of it iron giant making
it a top 10 i think is great uh laden and lion
king being in you know in the top 10 so happy
overall and i I think it's kind of a good way
to end. And after the wrap up and everything,
I will post or we will post dual versions of
the list. We will post that limited list so that
people can react to that in general as well to
see how different it may have been. Because there
is definitely some changes that would have happened
overall. And I will say that you might have been.
The most pleasantly surprised as to how things
changed if we go off of limited average, given
the first film we talked about. Would have came
in the top 20. So that will be an interesting
list to look at in reaction to this as well.
Neil, your thoughts on 20 through 1? Pretty solid,
I think. Yeah, Wreck -It Ralph is probably the
big surprise. I would still put a... Pretty high,
but probably not as high as it ended up being.
I know I didn't rank it anywhere near that high,
but I wasn't, like I said earlier, I wasn't too
upset that it got there. Everything else, pretty
solid. I would probably jumble some of them around
if it were my decision, but I can't complain
about how it ended up. I pretty much, there were
no drop the mic, walk away moments for me this
time around. That's good. It's... It's very interesting,
this top 100, because not all of the DC films
got ranked, but a majority of them did, yet Marvel
never showed up. There's a reason for that. Yeah.
Keep it to 20 through 1, sir. I know, I know.
I'm just saying, it's really, really interesting.
But 20 to 1, I really have no complaints. Like
Neil said, there are probably a few I'd jumble
around. Other than that, I'm fine with it. And
like I said at the beginning, I don't think anyone
can make the argument. Like I said, you can jumble
them around. You can change the ranks. But these
are all the ones that we talked about, 20 through
1, are definitely deserving to be on our list
somewhere. You can't make an argument that any
of them should not be on our list. In fact, I'm
sure you can't really make an argument that any
of them shouldn't be in our top 50 probably.
I mean, I guess you could. It gets a little bit
easier to make that argument. But they all deserve
to be somewhere here. Steve, thoughts on 20 through
1? Some of them I agree with, some of them I
don't. Like the older Disney stuff in there,
I mean, I still see other films that could have
been in there, certain ones replaced. So in that
instance, I can see that. But I think pretty
much everything that's in the top 10, I really
can't argue with the fact that they're in the
top 10. Right. And that's the thing. In order
to put something else in the top 10, you have
to take something out. And that's another way
to look at it. I will say I'm somewhat interested
or surprised possibly that as far as classic
Disney, we didn't see anything past number 14
on our list. And in fact, after Sleeping Beauty
came in at number 14, we didn't see anything
that predated 1991. Beauty and the Beast in 1991
was the earliest film. in our top 13 films. So
definitely dominated by, you know, the last few
decades. So that was a little surprising. I thought
maybe an older film, a classic Disney film would
sneak somewhere in there, but it did not. Anyone
else thoughts on that or anything else before
we, I know we don't have a, I'm actually looking
forward to the wrap up show because we get to
do a whole lot of fun discussion and analyzing
and talking about honorable mentions. So it'll
be fun. Last words going around the table, Mike,
anything before we close up? No. I mean, it's
been a blast overall, and it's been really interesting
seeing the different reactions on the website.
Like you said, we'll get to that next time around.
But no. I mean, 20 to 1, I can't argue with it.
All right. Steve or Neil or Dan, anybody last
thoughts before we close out and get ready for
our wrap -up? I'm just glad there's no big, bad
movie. I think we listed that as really... surprising
or i think out of place so and that's pretty
pretty good movie did not turn up in the top
10 so no no and no and no brother bear either
so that's always that was now that had a chance
so i think it's a rather fair list honestly so
i'm i am looking forward to just getting hearing
people's feedback on the list as a whole i know
a lot of people predicted kind of where they
thought it was going so That'll be fun just looking
at also just the honorable mentions that didn't
make it because there are a few movies that were
on my list that I think are deserving. But so
it'll be kind of fun to talk about those. Yeah,
I definitely have, you know, we talked about
in order to put stuff on, you have to take stuff
off. I definitely have a good number of films
that I'd like to talk about as far as replacing
some of the 90s and 2000 Disney films that we
saw. So, Mike, what do people need to know feedback
wise, et cetera? Yeah. There you have it, folks.
The GCRN Top 100 Animated Films Countdown. Join
us next time when we'll be wrapping up the entire
project. In between then and now, send any and
all emails. or MP3 files if you want to get in
on the show with your own thoughts of the entire
project to feedback at geekcastradio .com. As
always, you can send us a shout -out on Twitter
or Facebook. It's at geekcastradio on Twitter.
Facebook is facebook .com slash geekcastradionetwork.
And, of course, commenting on the website. We
are probably not going to read every single of
the 300 -and -something comments we got. which
thank you so much to everybody. But you have
until Wednesday, December 4th at 11 a .m. Eastern
Standard Time to send in any emails, any audio
feedback, anything. You can send a feedback at
keycastradio .com. For now, I am TF2 on mic with...
TV's Mr. Neal. Steve Megatron Phillips. Movie
Revolt Dan. And Optimus Solo. Thank you for listening
and make sure you unleash the geek in you. We
will catch you next time. You've just listened
to Geekcast Radio. On the Geekcast Radio Network,
there are several ways to get in contact with
us or leave feedback for the show. First, visit
the website geekcastradio .com where you can
comment on all of our different podcasts. Second,
you can rate our show and leave us feedback in
iTunes. Third, follow us on Twitter at Geekcast
Radio. Fourth, become a fan on Facebook. Go to
facebook .com slash geekcastradio. Call the voicemail
line 502 -526 -5821. Please remember to tell
us the show you are leaving the message for and
your name. So until next time, unleash the geek
in you.
No chapter markers for this episode.
Hosts
More from GeekCast Radio
All Episodes →
The Top 100 Animated Series: The 15th Anniversary Ultimate Wrap Up!

The Top 100 Animated Series: 25-01 | Part 5 - The 15th Anniversary Countdown

The Top 100 Animated Series: 50-26 | Part 4 - The 15th Anniversary Countdown

IF you want your voice heard in the wrap up show send emails or mp3s to feedback at geekcastradio.com by December 4th at 11am or call the voicemail line 502-526-5821
I’ll try to send an email if I can get to it. Have some thoughts I’d like to share.
Well now that the list is done I’m gonna go ahead and disclose that I was one of the people who submitted a top 100 list (I had Beauty and the Beast #1 and was the guy who put Spirited Away #2 and Snow White at #4). I’m really grateful for the opportunity to have participated in this list and it was very fun and challenging coming up with my top 100. A lot of the films were somewhat close to how I had them ranked so I can’t complain too much even if some films were higher and some were lower than I would’ve liked. I did feel like there was some confusion between objectivity and subjectivity, it sounded to me like some people were ranking what they legitimately thought to be the 100 greatest animated films of all time and others were just listing faves with no real mind paid to objectivity, I know that had I done an entirely subjective list, films like Mulan and Tangled would have been significantly higher on my list (top 5) than what I ended up ranking them at (in the 25-35 range). Even films I hadn’t seen, I attempted to watch a few clips and did some research on the production and plot of them to formulate a ranking, I felt like I had to evaluate every single acclaimed animated film ever made to get an honest list rather than just leave a potentially deserving film off my top 100 because I’d never gotten a chance to see it. Even with those issues though, the rankings ended up being quite good and entertaining so I can’t really quibble with how others did their lists, it’s just a thought. Honestly, I’m pretty happy with how it came out. The highest film on my list not to make the cut was Cowboy Bebop: Knockin’ On Heaven’s Door which I had ranked #46, so to have my top 45 films all make it on somewhere was really gratifying and vindicating. I might submit an e-mail to the wrap-up show if I can find the time, I’d love to give my opinion on Beauty and the Beast and Spirited Away, or possibly some of my higher ranked films that didn’t make the cut (Cowboy Bebop, Fritz the Cat, Atlantis, Frankenweenie, and Brave Little Toaster were the highest five I had ranked that got snubbed) or possibly to speculate on where I would have ranked Frozen if it hadn’t come out too late (*cough*top25*cough*).
Thanks again and awesome work to all of you guys!
Cool on the contributions! Yeah I haven’t see Frozen but heard great things about it. As for the Atlantis I agree. My input will be in the wrap up tho overall.
Just saw Frozen this week. I agree it should be on the list if done again. At least Top 50.
Ohh,,,Fritz the Cat. Good choice.
Thanks for your input. Appreciate taking the time for sure. If you have more time we’d love to get an email for more input. Also great to hear more opinions.
Toy Story…FTW. Can’t really argue with the choice. Though I think Toy Story 3 is a better movie, Toy Story had a huge change on animation.
I’m so glad I was able to discover this countdown. It was a lot of fun and kind of sad its over, but looking forward to the wrap up episode. Hope you guys do another top 100 list in the future next year!
Wall-E has always been my favorite Pixar movie so I wish it did rank the highest. Glad it did rank as high as it did.
It’s just the absolute best that Pixar has done. I love the “Toy Story” films, but for sheer bravery and innovation in terms of characters and setting, “Wall-E” pips it for me.
Glad I’m not alone 🙂
I think some of you were a little too harsh to some of the Disney classics. Yes the plot of movies like Snow White or Cinderella aren’t that complex, but you also need to think about the time they took. I mean Snow White was trying something that was never done before, so the simple creation of it was a feat in its own.
Anyways no big arguments with the Top 10. Surprised Lion King wasn’t number one, and very glad Iron Giant made it into the top 10. Very deserving.
Looking forward to the wrap up episode. Its been a great amount of fun.
Thanks! Glad ya liked it. Personally on my part I really enjoy Cinderella, but Snow White and boy on a string … no thanks…. they just aren’t that great to me as an adult.
What doesn’t work with Pinocchio as an adult? If anything that story should be better as an adult. Well, maybe more so if you have a child or ever wanted one.
yeah that’s it …. for those people maybe it works. I’m not one of them lol
Very good points. I try to take that into consideration when I put together a list because those things are important. That said, I forgot to add Snow White to my list, as I was just pulling together films, not having a list from which to pull the films. That was unfortunate because, as you said, it is significant. It may not be a film I would personally return to often, I would still rank it higher than some of those films I enjoy more because I feel the quality of the film, historical significance, mass appeal, critical acclaim, etc. deem it a top animated film.
I wish the top 20 was not so dominated by Disney and Pixar. I get why of course. Still Spirited Away among others are worthy of being placed into the top of the top. I like most thought Lion King was going to take it, but Toy Story is not a bad choice. Can’t think of one bad thing to say about Toy Story.
Jungle Book made it to the Top 20! Yay. The Top 10 was a little too Pixar heavy. Monster’s Inc is overrated IMO. Glad to see Shrek make it. How to Train Your Dragon should have made it as well though.
So what all would you take out of the Top 10??
I would include things like Akira, Spirited Away, maybe even South Park, Pinocchio, The Bugs Bunny/Road Runner movie, which surprisingly didn’t make the list at all, and something Don Bluth. Maybe Land Before Time. Don’t know if all those could make it. Just that there is more than Pixar and Disney.
yeah I didn’t even think about the looney “movies” as most of them are edited together shorts. NOT saying that’s bad at all… really love em like that, but they didn’t register in my brain when I made my list
You didn’t answer the question. I wasn’t asking what you would put IN the top ten but what you would TAKE OUT?? Its much harder when you look at it this way. You just mentioned 6 movies you would put into the Top 10 – So you are taking Lion King out? Toy Story? Up? Wall-E? Iron Giant? Aladdin?? Yea, not so easy now is it 😉
Not that hard. I’d take out Up, The Iron Giant, Aladdin, and The Incredibles. I had Toy Story 1 and 3 outside my top ten too but they can stay. I’d pull the above four films to make room for Spirited Away, Snow White, Grave of the Fireflies, and either South Park or Fantasia.
I’d by no means change any of what ended up in the Top 10. Those were all iconic and great films. Iron Giant, Aladdin and Incredibles had great and memorable moments.
You’re all batsh*t insane for suggesting to take out Aladdin from the Top ten!!!! 🙂
I love Aladdin, don’t get me wrong, but I don’t know if I would put it in the Top 10 honestly. I do rank Disney movies like Lion King, Beauty and the Beast, classics like Pinocchio and Dumbo ahead of it. Also Pixar movies like Up, Toy Story 3, Wall-E, and maybe even The Incredibles. Not to mention non Disney Pixar stuff like Iron Giant, Spirited Away, Coraline, Akira, and American Tale, Again Aladdin is awesome, but its not crazy to think it is more Top 15 than Top 10.
It’s crazy to put Pinocchio or Dumbo ahead of it 😉
Oh, I read that too quickly. My bad. Well that is a hard question I grant you that, but I would remove Toy Story or Toy Story 3. I think only one needs to be in the Top 10. I’d also remove Finding Nemo, Aladdin, and push the Incredibles back further. I’d take out Monster’s Inc and Wreck It Ralph from the top 20 as well.
I’d take out Finding Nemo, The Incredibles, and Toy Story and Keep Toy Story 3. Take out Beauty and the Beast as well.
This is somewhat bittersweet. Can’t believe the actual countdown is over. Wreck-It Ralph making it to the top 20 is surprising. Don’t think it deserves to be that high.
Anyways thanks guys for doing this. Its been a great deal of fun. Looking forward to the wrap up episode.
Iron Giant was my #14. Fantastic but I just found the 13 films I put above it better.
I haven’t listened to the top 21-1 episode as of yet. However if I could have taken one film out of the top 100 it would’ve been Legend Of the Guardians. This is just another Dreamworks film where you either get A-D list celebrities to voice characters. You spend more time trying to match the voice and it can drive you insane. What is the point of Hugh Jackman providing a voice when his physical body is not in it. Yet I could say that about a lot of animated films these days. This movie has no substance, the elves are a carbon copy of the Despicable Me minions….sorry but…this film was not worthy. If a fluff and nutter Dreamworks CGI film had to be put in it’s place I’d pick Monsters Vs. Aliens.
Legends of the Guardians may come up in the wrap up show I’m sure.
Will there be a printed list of the top 100 posted anywhere on the site?
YES sometime after Christmas and before new years
Apologies. I hadn’t got to that part of the show before I asked the questions. I only ask as I thought it may be handy for people wanting to leave feedback before Thursday to have a hard copy of the list. Thanks anyway Mike.
LOL I wasn’t yelling attcha when I said YES. I was just being enthusiastic. As far as the feedback from emails or mp3s we said that on the ep, in the hopes that people whom have listened to the countdown as it happens would do so lol
I know man ha ha. It’s just purely for the fact that I do my listening on the move, so I didn’t get a chance to take notes as I was listening. Wouldn’t want to call out a film for not being on the list when it actually was, ya know?
I’ll throw the list onto letterboxd .com later today. That should help avoid that issue.
I will post the cut and clear list tonight for it on the site as a PDF file.
It was another entertaining countdown. I love these things!! The one movie I really feel was out of place was Wreck It Ralph. I admit it was a good movie, but I wouldn’t consider it a top twenty film. I would say top fifty, maybe in the 30’s at best. It was a touching story, but I didn’t feel connected to the characters. And as a person who isn’t a gamer, per se, I didn’t connect with it on the level that some did. Sure, I got some of the obvious references, but as Dan said, that doesn’t make a movie. It isn’t that it’s a bad movie, but I don’t think it’s better than a lot of the other movies on the list, which I feel have stronger characters, tighter or more original stories, etc.
The two movies at the top are very good movies, but I am surprised that they were back-to-back. And I am surprised at where some of the Disney renaissance films landed on the countdown: Aladdin, The Lion King, Beauty and the Beast, and The Little Mermaid. The Lion King was my #1. Aladdin is the Disney film I absolutely love and can watch anytime. It’s just that good. But then, I could say that for all of those films.
I am very glad The Iron Giant ranked well. I would have loved to have seen it even higher, but I think it is in a good spot. It truly is one of those movies that surprises you in so many ways and has a great theme.
The Incredibles. The first time I saw it I enjoyed it, but it just gets better upon repeat viewings. It’s such an amazing film. Same for Up, Wall-E, Finding Nemo (another film that I just love watching anytime). Pixar has such a strong catalogue of films and I was not surprised to see so many ranking well.
At this point I look forward to the wrap up show.
I must say there is not one movie in the Top 20 that doesn’t deserve to be there. I was a little worried based on the list so far. Those worries were for not. If there was one movie I would take it it would have to be Wreck-It Ralph and maybe Cinderella. You got number 1 right in my book so that’s most important.
Wreck-It Ralph does stand out like a sore thumb. A sore thumb from playing too much video games perhaps!
Man has this been fun ride. The amount of emotions I have gone through. I’ve laughed, got angry, haven’t really cried, maybe I will when its not around any more. All I can say is I hope yo do this again sometime soon.
not sure HOW soon we’ll do animated films again, but there are plans for other Top 100s
I didn’t mean animated movies, just another Top 100 list.
I second the notion of another countdown list. This was a lot of fun.
How bout the Top 100 Top 100 lists j/k. I too would love to see something similar again sometime soonish.
are there even 100 Top 100s? oh wait maybe there are thousands lol
Even just to make it easy on yourselves, a top 20 or something. I know a LOT of work went into compiling all that info.
All I have to say is….make sure you listen to the wrap-up show! 🙂
Wouldn’t miss it!
I’m sure we’ll have something in the works. 🙂
Lion King was not number 1? SHOCKED. SHOCKED I Say. Not a bad shock. Just a general shock. Toy Story is not a bad choice though.
Yes, I was thinking that was number 1 as well. Toy Story makes sense though.
For some reason I love it when Mike and Dan disagree. Those have been the best moments of the podcast episode so far. Wreck-It Ralph, Transformers, and World’s Finest. You should do full episodes on those. I’d pay to see it!
LOL there were gonna be some deep battles during the TFTM segment when it placed, but I decided to control myself.
Yea, for some reason Dan has found himself in more arguments/debates than I have lately….its odd but interesting at the same time 🙂 Good break for me I guess haha
for now…..LOL
For some reason its been a lately lol. Glad its been entertaining.
Just listened to the episode again, and looked over the entire list below. I will save more deeper thoughts for a email to not clog up the comment section, but I will say this. *hands clapping* Great job guys. I have issues sure, but I really dug this a lot, and I listened to it while working out so any rage you enticed was put to good use.
Excellent! Good to know we can entertain and motivate at the same time 🙂
Not ONE Star Wars movie on this. No love for Clone Wars? Just Kidding. That movie is awful. Now the cartoon series on the other hand. That’s amazing.
Been a fun time. Looking forward to the wrap up episode.
I had put Tartokofsky’s “Clone Wars” series on my list, but wasn’t sure if it was eligible as it’s more of a compilation of shorts than an actual movie.
Aquaman huh? Sure why not. If we can do a Guardians of Galaxy movie why not Aquaman too. Who to play him. Well that is hard. Maybe Ryan Gosling as suggested below.
Wait..my bad. Wrong episode. Sorry…little tipsey tonight.
Finally finished this epic episode. Not many surprises. The movies that should be there were there, the order was a little off. Pixar taking 1, 2, and 3 does seem too much. Looking forward to the wrap up episode.
I love Pixar as much as anyone. WIth that said the Top 20 was too Pixar heavy. Monsters Inc, Finding Nemo, and Toy Story 3 are good movies. But not Top 20 worthy IHMO>