GeekCast Radio
GCR – Episode 23 – Top 100 Animated Series 60-41

Part of a Collection
About this Episode
Geekcastradio .com presents The Geekcast Radio
Top 100 Animated Series of All Time Megatron
Phillips, Mike TFG1 Blanchard, Kevin Optimus
Solo Thompson. Alright, welcome back to the countdown
everyone. You've heard hopefully 100 through
61 to this point, and hopefully everybody has
listened to episode 20, the introduction. If
you haven't listened to the introduction, please
stop what you're doing and listen to the intro
now, because that'll save you from making ignorant
comments later on. And today we're going to go
from 60 to 41. And before we get going, I've
got a couple pieces of business I just want to
take care of. First of all, we have another special
guest with us representing This Week in Geek.
We have Double D David Dennis. Hello, sir. Hey,
how's it going? It is going very well, and we're
happy to have a member of the Twig family here
with us, even though Mike sometimes double dips
between the Geek Cast Radio and This Week in
Geek. And just a couple pieces of business. Besides
that, if you haven't noticed, our list has been
getting a little bit of attention. Over at geekcastradio
.com, we have been getting dozens of comments
on the individual episode posts. There's also
been a forum thread started over at TuneZone.
That has had over 30 replies to it so far. Yeah,
it's got three pages of replies right now. So
if you want to get involved in any of those discussions,
please do that. I will just, again, repeat, please
listen to 20 before you make any comments because
a couple people apparently didn't listen to that
because we explained a little bit of the bias
in episode 20. We explained a little bit about
some anime things. I'm once again seeing people
talking about nostalgia making our entries or
influencing our picks. And once again, I'm just
going to say that if a show was good at the time
when it aired, that means something, even if
it doesn't hold up. And I'll leave it at that.
Like we said in the last episode, the more we
get down the countdown, the less bias you're
going to see. And I am confident in saying every
show that we talk about today. basically deserves
to be in the top 100. I'm confident that all
of them do, in my opinion. I think most of the
bias is over now. So there may be one or two
that you guys might have an issue with, but we'll
see. Anybody have any comments before we get
into number 60? Mike, I know you got a comment.
You always got a comment. No, I'm fine. Steve?
No, I think I'm good. I think I just want to
find out what's new on him. Well, that's because,
you know, Kevin has to be a control freak, and
he's the only one that knows the list. And everybody
knows that anytime Mike calls anybody a control
freak, yeah, pot, kettle, meet each other. Anyway,
let's get right to the countdown then. 60. All
right, so starting off our episodes today, number
60, The Tick from 1994. Nice. Now, I myself am
not super familiar with this show, but I know
at least one of us is because, Double D, you
had this at number 27. Why does Tick deserve
to be in the top 100? I grew up with this show,
and this is just kind of a cult classic. Even
if you ask Mike, I don't know, I don't think
he spent as much time on his list. Well, I know
he didn't spend as much time on his list, but
let's not get into that. But even Mike absolutely
loves this show. And this is one of the better
superhero spoof shows out there, and it definitely
had that weird kind of offbeat 90s humor. I guess
I can... if that makes any sense. No, it doesn't.
It was a sense of humor that was very distinct
to the 90s. I don't know if you could really
get away with the tick nowadays, as we saw with
the very short -lived live -action show. But,
yeah, this show is kind of a classic to me, and
I'm glad it's on the list. I don't think it really...
I think it's in a good spot, I'd say that. I
was just going to ask you that, because IGN had
this as number six. Yeah, it does not deserve
to be that high on the list. I think 60 makes
more sense than 6. See, they just forgot the
zero, that's all. Yeah. It did get some critical
acclaim, a couple of Annie nominations, an Annie
win, a couple of Daytime Emmy nominations. Five
of us voted for it. A couple people had it in
their top 20. I'm fine with it being on the list
because it was around for a while, you know,
three seasons in the later part of the mid -90s.
A lot of people love this. It just was something
that I kind of missed out on. I was in middle
school at this point, and I just wasn't watching
as many cartoons, so I kind of missed out on
it. Mike, what are your opinions on the tick
making our countdown? Spoon! Spoon! Oh, man,
I wish we had a clip of Townsend Coleman saying
that. It's funny, Townsend Coleman, who voiced
the tick, He went from Michelangelo in Teenager
Ninja Turtles to the tick. True. And I never
really got into this show. I respect it for what
it is. I don't dislike it. It's okay, but it
has a certain taste that you have to have, I
find. Oh, I should mention, too, I almost forgot,
this also was in a tie with number 61, which
was the last entry of last episode, which was
Phineas and Ferb, but Tick won in a tiebreaker.
Steve, any thoughts on the Tick being in the
top 100? I would definitely say that this was
one of those shows that deserves to be on the
top 100. Granted, it wasn't on my list. Probably
won because I forgot about it. which usually
happened to a couple of the shows that I found
out in this list so far. But I did watch it,
although I don't remember almost anything about
it besides Townsend Coleman as the tick at this
point in time. But I'd have to say there definitely
was a pretty entertaining show, kind of off -the
-wall, out -of -the -mold type, superhero type
cartoon. I think we're actually starting off
all four in agreement that this show deserves
to be on the list, but it does not deserve to
be number six like IGN had it. Oh, no way in
hell. I think it fits right where it's at. I
think it's almost a perfect placement. That's
a good start to our episode today. Let's see
where we go next. 59. and defender of the Crystal
Castle. This is spirit, my beloved steed. Fabulous
secrets were revealed to me the day I held aloft
my sword and said, For the honor of Grayskull!
So following up the tick at 59... We have an
80s classic in She -Ra, obviously the sister
to He -Man. And I know some people are going
to have, this may be the one show on our episode
today where people have a problem with this,
but I'm going to reiterate what I said earlier
on in the countdown when we talked about Jem.
Jem and She -Ra defined basically 80s cartoons
for females. In my opinion, those were the two
biggest cartoons for the female audience in an
entire decade, so I think it does deserve a spot.
It might be a little high in my opinion, even
though I ranked this at 59, which is where it
falls in. So I guess I got this one on the dot.
Mike, you had this one in your top 11. Well,
I had it in the top 20. You had it in number
11. Same thing, whatever. And as we've said before,
the whole point of the project is multiple people.
So my personal list is obviously going to be
very biased towards 80s stuff, but the actual
list that we're creating here, I mean, 59 is
fine. I wish it was a little bit higher, maybe
like top 40. I just wanted to know if you had
anything to admit since you had Jem and Shira
in your top 11. Yeah, what's going on there,
Mike? You know, it's just one of those things
that it's nostalgia, and it's just I remember
watching them as a kid, and that's really all
it is for me as far as my personal list. I need
to clarify that because I don't want anybody
coming at me saying, oh, well, it's too high
or it's not high enough. You know, my personal
list, I think all of our lists are very biased,
but I did work and try to get as many. you know,
like what I felt deserved all time. And that's,
as I said, you know, multiple lists and Kevin's
whole point system and all that is what put it
here. And I, you know, I think it's, you know,
it, it was one of those things where, um, well,
what put it here was you and pixel Dan putting
it in your top 20. Well, true. But, but my point
is, is that, um, you know, like you said, Kevin,
There was no action cartoon for girls. There
was either Barbie or Jem or something like that
in the 80s, and this is what they created for
it. Regardless if it stands up now, it was something
that girls back then... Did you just invent a
Barbie cartoon that didn't exist in the 80s?
There were direct -to -video Barbie movies. Yeah.
There were no Barbie cartoons. Yeah. Well, no.
I meant Barbie as in, like, the doll. You know
what I mean? As far as, like, stuff in the 80s
in general, not specific to cartoons. But, I
mean, having She -Ra at... And 59, I'm fine with
it. I think it's too high, even though I ranked
it at 59. I think this one, I'm going to reiterate,
this one, Cops, Bravestar, they all deserve to
be in the 90s, I think. This was not ranked by
IGN, Steve. Did IGN get it right? Should this
not have been ranked? On the one hand, I can
see where they would think that, but... On the
other, it's enough of a following behind it,
and it's still primarily attached to He -Man.
Well, and I don't think some people understand
the cult following that this and Jem still have.
We are all into... some of us are into like the
superheroes and we know that there's a cult following
and there's like web pages and there's forums
and boards and all that about that. And same
with Transformers, you know, same with Thundercats,
same with Turtles. I don't think people realize
that there are those out there for She -Ra and
Jem as well. Yeah, and I would definitely say
that this deserves to be on the list. I agree
with you, too, that it shouldn't be this high
on there. But it's still one of those shows that
needs to be on there, just like Gem and all the
other ones. And especially because it's one that
it was something young girls could gravitate
towards as well. It did have 93 episodes. Maybe
93 is where it should have came in. I don't know.
I would say this deserves to be somewhere probably
in the 80s or 90s on the list. I understand the
cultural significance of She -Ra for young girls.
I never really watched it personally, but I can
see how it would get on the list, but I don't
think it really deserves to be this high. That's
just me. No, I completely agree. I think I kind
of voted it a little bit lower just because I
knew a lot of people wouldn't vote for it. So
I put it kind of right at that 60 mark. But I
think we're all kind of in agreement that it
maybe should be closer to the 80, 90 mark. Mike,
any last thoughts on your love for She -Ra since
you had it so high? No. Okay. 58. So we started
in the mid -90s, then we went to the mid -80s,
and now we are back in the mid -90s for another
one that kind of has a cult following at number
58, and you should obviously know it from that
theme song bit, Sailor Moon. It was on for five
seasons, 200 episodes. Four out of the five people
that voted for it voted it in their top 20. It
falls in at number 58. I'm going to start with
the only one of us that actually had it on their
list, which is Double D. You had it at 83, so
is this another one like Shiro where it deserves
to be on the list, but it may be a little bit
too high, or did the four people that had it
in their top 20 have it right? I think it's a
little bit too high. My list is kind of biased
towards the 90s in the same way that Mike's is
biased towards the 80s. I grew up with Sailor
Moon, and I was just obsessed with the show when
I was eight or nine. Until you got to the second
or third season, and then it just fell apart.
And even as a kid, you know when you're a kid
you have less taste in things, but I still didn't
like it past that point. I love the theme song,
though. Yeah, this show has a wicked theme song.
As soon as you put Sailor Moon in the little
Skype chat here, immediately the Sailor Moon
theme song started running through my head. I've
never even seen the show, and I still put that
theme song in my top list. Whenever I make a
top list of 90s theme songs or whatever, Sailor
Moon's always in there, even though I've never
really hardly seen the show. Nice. It is a very
memorable show for people that grew up with it.
But I think it should be maybe a little bit lower,
like maybe in the 60s, 70s, something like that.
It's one of those that I think if I watched it,
I actually would like it. I just never have had
the chance or never taken the time to actually
get involved in it. IGN, again, this is the second
one in a row that IGN has not ranked. Mike, how
do you feel about IGN not ranking it? You didn't
rank it. We did. What do you think? I think it
does deserve its spot, and I didn't rank it because
I remember watching a couple episodes here and
there, but it wasn't something that I was watching
all the time back then. This is another one where,
you know, whereas Jem and Shiro were, you know,
for girls in the 80s, this was pretty much the
90s girls cartoon, I think. The weird thing I
find, though, is more guys seem to like Sailor
Moon than girls. Yeah. It must have been that
naked changing sequence. It's guys that were
of the right age. Yeah. So, Kevin, this show
would have been perfect for you. No, I was already
like 15 or 16 by this point. I was liking real
women at this point. And we didn't have the internet
to post all those, let's say, non -authorized
Sailor Moon videos yet. Steve, what's your opinion
on Sailor Moon making our countdown? I would
say that it's definitely something that should
be on there because, I mean, granted, it lasted
a long time. There's a lot of memorable things
to it. I, granted, have only caught it a couple
times, but I still think it warrants a spot on
the list. I don't really know where to place
it, but I wouldn't say I would put it any higher
than where it's at. And I think it's just another
example that every – I'm to the point. Like I
said before, every show we get to now I think
deserves a spot in the 100. We might disagree
on where it goes, but I don't think many of these
people can say don't deserve to be at least in
the top 100. Except for number 95 a few episodes
ago. I don't even know what that was. I don't
even know what he's talking about either. Captain
Planet. Oh, well, I said this episode. I said
every show we get to in this episode. I know.
Yeah, let's not. Why are we talking about Captain
Planet? There's nothing to do with Sailor Moon.
Though it would be cool if they teamed up. That'd
be interesting. It's a different story, yeah.
57. All right, staying in the mid -90s for another
one at 57, Freakazoid. It was 53rd on IGN's list.
It is 57th on ours. It was 58th on JT's. Steve,
you had it in your top 20, as did Phil, Mike,
Laidman. Ryan had it at 22, so a lot of people
had this higher. Does it deserve to be higher,
Steve? I think so, just because this was such
a hilarious show to watch, and it pretty much
related to nerddom in general. You had this geek
that basically sits there on his computer and
then hits this span of keys and turns into a
superhero. I mean, who wouldn't want to relate
to that? True. If only it worked like that. Yes.
It doesn't? Dang it. I wish. I was hoping. Yeah,
I think even though I had a bias towards the
90s, as I said earlier, Freakazoid was one of
those shows that I had on my list in one of the
earlier incarnations of it, and then it got kicked
off by other shows when I started to think of
other things. So I do like this show, and I understand
the importance of it. I don't know. I'm glad
it's on the list, but again, I didn't end up
putting it on my list for that reason. I thought
there were better shows that I could have ranked.
I forgot to tell everybody again about the amount
of time you put into creating your list and how
many versions of your list that I received over
that. Well, I didn't actually put that much time
into the initial version of the list, and that's
why I kept doing revisions, because I kept realizing
that I had forgotten stuff in my rush to kind
of put it together the first time. I was a big
fan, because I knew at least at some point you
were putting some thought into it and wanting
to redo things. Mike, I haven't given you a chance
yet. Your thoughts on Freakazoid? It was one
of those shows that it came alongside Animaniacs
and Tiny Toons and all that stuff. If you couldn't
get into it, you just couldn't get into it. But
if you got into it, you were, you know, termed,
quote -unquote, a super fan of it. I like the
theme. It's one of those shows that it is a really
good show for its time. I do think it deserves
a spot on the list. I don't think it deserves
any, like, I think it fits right where it is.
I don't think it needs to be any lower. I kind
of agree with you. I know Steve wants it a little
bit higher on the list. I think it's fine where
it is. I wouldn't want it too much higher myself.
But that's just because I don't think its audience
was as big as some of these other shows. But
I do agree that it does deserve to be somewhere
around where it's at right now. So I'm fine with
it. I would still say that it's roughly in the
same range even as IGN. So I would say that this
one pretty much is an even knockout on both lists
anyway. All right. So, so far, the most represented
franchise. In the countdown, at 81, if you think
back, at number 81, we had the 1960s Spider -Man.
At number 75, we had Spider -Man and his amazing
friends. And now at number 56, we have the 2008
version, Spectacular Spider -Man. Well, thank
God. Please, nobody from Toon Zone come after
us. It's on the countdown. It's coming in at
number 56. iGen had it at 30. We're going to
do a little bit of talking about this one because,
again, I want to bring up the whole franchise
thing. I'm actually the only one that voted for
this out of the four of us, and I'm the one that's
not the superhero fan, so let's not go there
too much. Four people had it in their top 30.
How do you like this one showing up? I'm going
to start with Mike. How do you like this one
showing up at 56 in comparison to the other Spider
-Mans that are out there and that have already
made the list? I've only caught maybe four episodes
of this series. I... And it was one of those
things when it was on, I couldn't catch it when
it was on. I've since gone back and watched YouTube
videos of it. It's a very well -written series.
The voice acting in it is just amazing. I'm glad
it came in at the countdown. I'm sure a lot of
people will say, oh, why isn't it higher? Why
isn't it lower? And when you first mentioned
Spider -Man franchise, I was like, oh, no. Oh,
no, please, no. That other show better not be
ranking. here because that'll piss me off but
no spectacular spider -man is just a well thought
out i mean it's a very story -driven cartoon
and it was it was very well done i thought and
56 i think is from what we've created so far
from 100 to now right here in the middle is where
it should rank. Josh Keaton was definitely good
as Spider -Man, I thought. I based this one more
off of when I went to do my superhero voting.
I'll at least give this disclaimer. Since I don't
know a lot about all the superhero shows, I did
a lot of research as far as what the fandoms
out there like, as far as which... Which Batmans
are the best? Which Supermans are the best? Which
Hulk or X -Men are the best? Which Spider -Man
are the best? And a lot of people had this one
towards the top of their Spider -Man list. Steve,
in comparison to the two Spider -Man shows that
have already shown up or any of the other Spider
-Man shows out there, should it have been 60s
Spider -Man and His Amazing Friend and now Spectacular
Spider -Man? Is that the right order so far?
I would definitely say so. I mean, granted, I
haven't... Everything I've heard about this show
has been good. I personally have not seen it.
But having seen elements of the other two, I
would definitely say that this should be on the
list. I don't agree with that it should be in
the top 20 or 30, but I'm glad to see it at least
hit the list pretty much where it hit. Should
we see any more Spider -Man, or is this the end
of it? We better see more Spider -Man. I'm thinking
that at least we're going to see the 1990s Spider
-Man show hit pretty close. Yeah, I'm pretty
sure quite a few people put that on their list,
so I'm thinking the 90s Spider -Man's probably
going to be on here. But I'm okay with this one
where it is. Do you think that this one's better
than Spider -Man and His Amazing Friends or the
60s one? From the little that I've seen of it,
I'd say so, yeah. I think they put a lot more
thought into this one. The 60s and 70s ones were
good for their time, or I guess Amazing Friends
was early 80s, but I mean, they were good for
their time. So I can see how they made the list,
but I think this list is developing a bit of
a Spider -Man bias. I don't know. This is the
third Spider -Man show, and that's definitely
more than any other franchise has. I don't know
if any other franchise has a chance to catch
it or not. I guess we'll have to wait and see.
Maybe Batman. I don't know. Batman has made its
emergence in the list, so who knows what will
show up later as far as that's concerned. But
I can honestly say I haven't voted for any of
the Spider -Men so far. I just hope that Spider
-Man Unlimited does not come in anywhere near
here now, because it's going to be a travesty
if it does. Well, so far we have three Spider
-Men and one Batman, so Batman would have to
catch up a little bit. Yeah. Wouldn't be that
hard to do. Yeah. Besides Spider -Man Unlimited,
is there any others that you really are hoping
don't make the list, or are there any others
that even have a shot? Really, at this point
for me now, it's just Spider -Man, the animated
series from 1994. As far as the Spider -Man cartoons
go, Spidey 94 was, you know, people will say,
oh, the animation doesn't hold up. It's not about
holding up. It's about what you remember watching
it. Spider -Man, the animated series, had really,
really great storytelling. It had great voice
acting, and hopefully it'll show up. We'll have
to see. fifth pre -1970s show to make the list
at 55 the pink panther show i'm going to start
with this one i had this ranked at 53 and it
came in at 55 actually eight of the 20 people
had it on their list this basically ran in one
form or another for a decade And I honestly,
even though I only put it at 53, I think Pink
Panther should actually be in the top 50. I think
this is a little too low for it. I think it should
be a little bit higher. Just because, I mean,
I know it wasn't your typical cartoon as far
as, like, voicing and stuff like that. It's basically
without voice, just with music and that type
of thing. But this is an iconic show from that
era. It's one of the most iconic shows from that
era. forget some of those classic shows. I might
be alone on this opinion, but I think it deserves
higher than 55. No, I'd agree with you. I had
it as 49 on my list, so I think it deserves to
be in the top 50. Like you said, this show...
It mostly relied on music and comical situations
more than dialogue, but it was so well put together,
and the music was just wonderful. I'm not entirely
sure. I know Henry Mancini did the music for
the Pink Panther films. I'm not sure who did
the music for the show. It was also his theme
that was used in the cartoon series. I know he
used the theme. I'm not sure if he did the actual
music, but still, it's a memorable series for
what it was and very influential for its time.
Well, and a show that could capture a kid's attention
at that time that had no talking. Without dialogue,
yeah. To be able to do that type of comedy without
that, I think it adds to how good it was. It
was nominated for one Daytime Emmy, which was
a big deal back then because cartoons weren't
nominated for that stuff a lot. Mike, you had
it at 63. Does this belong in the top 50? Oh,
yeah. Oh, yeah, it does. The Pink Panther cartoons
specifically were awesome, were great because,
you know, normally it's him. Like, I remember
one specific episode, he was trying to get some
sleep and there was something going on outside
his house or whatever. Something ends up bothering
the Pink Panther. And, yeah, this so deserves
it. The other thing I want to mention is. This
also had cartoons running with it. This is another
one of those shows that had cartoons running
with it, which were The Ant and the Aardvark,
which did have voice acting to them, and The
Inspector. I love those two cartoons. I think
we did give it a little bit more respect, obviously,
than IGN. IGN had it at 67, so at least we got
it higher than that at 55, but I still think,
like I said before, this is a top 50 show. Oh,
yeah. So it should have been a little bit higher.
Maybe Steve disagrees because, Steve, you're
the only one of us that did not vote for this.
Is this fine where it is? Is it top 50? Should
it be lower? Where should it be? I would probably
say that I like it where it's at just because
I'm more so I liked it back in the day. I mean,
granted, it wasn't on my list, but it wasn't
one of those most influential shows, in my opinion,
of what entertained me. I mean, I liked it. There
was nothing wrong with it. I liked that it lasted
as long as it did. But it's... I don't know if
I'd have it under 50. but I would say that it
should be at least 50. Well, 55 is not too far
off, I guess, from the midway point. I just think
it would have been nice to get at least that
little nod into the top 50. I don't know. We
haven't seen a lot of classic shows so far. Like
I said, this is only the fifth show that's come
in before 1970. We had Johnny Quest. We had Huckleberry
Hound. Hong Kong. Hong Kong, if we were 70s.
We had... like one or two other ones that were
pre -70s. So, so far we're not seeing a lot of
those classic shows fall in, and we'll have to
see. Hopefully we can see some of those get some
respect a little bit later on. 54. From days
of long ago, from uncharted regions of the universe,
comes a legend. The legend of Voltron, defender
of the universe, a mighty robot. I have not mentioned
this before as far as the points a lot, but we
have just reached the point where it would actually
take four people to rank something number one
on their list in order to get it into the list,
meaning a show would have to get 400. Over 400
points to make the list, and this is the first
of those shows. Coming in at number 54, I know
Mike's happy about this one, the 1980s classic
Voltron. Had 124 episodes. IGN ranks this one
at 76. We rank it at 54. All six people that
ranked this actually ranked it higher than 54.
So the only reason it's not higher is because
more people didn't rank it, but all six people
had it in their top 50. Mike, how do you feel
about Voltron coming in at 54? This show should
have been higher. This show should have at least
feel about Doug. So there you go. Well, all right.
Well, you know, the thing about it is, is any
of the 80 shows that come in that I grew up with.
I will say should have been higher, but that's
just my personal bias. But Voltron should have
at least made like 49 or 48, I think, or something
along those lines. It should have been at least
just barely making in the top 50. Voltron had
a great opening story, the telling of the five
space explorers and finding the lions and finding
the castle of lions and all that stuff. One of
the things I did not know as a kid, and I found
out later, was that Peter Cullen had done voices
on Voltron, and he specifically does the narration
in the opening theme song as well. And when I
was a kid, I was like, wait, what's Optimus Prime
doing on this show? It's basically the same voice
like he does with a lot of them. But I will say
this much. We got it better than IGN. It's better
than 76. Yeah. I mean, Voltron was one of those
shows. It's one of those classic 80s shows. And
I know that people, you know, for me personally,
if you go back and you listen to ToonCast Episode
4, I specifically say that to me this is not
anime. Well, I'm just going to bring that up.
This is the one. This is if there is. An anime
show for non -anime fans, this is it. I would
say Sailor Moon and maybe Pokemon fall into that
group as well. Yeah, I mean, there's a few shows
that even though they're anime, even people that
don't like anime like them, and that's the situation
for me. Like this one, and there was a couple
other 80 shows that I'm not going to get into
a lot because they're not on our countdown, but
there's always those few that cross those boundaries
even to non -anime fans, and this is for sure
one of them. And one of the reasons why I say,
to me, Voltron is not anime is just because of
when it was on. You're going to get railed for
this, by the way. No, I'm not. People are going
to be calling for your head because you're calling
this not anime. I know. Well, all right. Well,
I will say, I know it came from Go Lion. And
yes, I know Go Lion was, it came from a multiple
of different animes from Japan. But the U .S.
Americanized version of it. It doesn't feel like
it's animated to me, and it told a specific story.
And, yeah, they had to change a few things, like
Sven being injured instead of just outright dying.
One of the things I do want to bring up is Voltron
was the first show to have stereo. First cartoon
in the 80s to have stereo sound. And it was just
amazing. Yeah, that was a big deal back in the
day. I remember that. Things would have a little
thing. At first it was in color, and then there
would be a thing at the bottom that would say
in stereo, and now it's starting moving towards
being in 3D. Double D, does this deserve a spot
on the list? You did not rank it. I think the
only reason I didn't rank this is because I sort
of forgot about it because I never really grew
up with Voltron, though I understand its cultural
significance and I understand why people like
it so much. So I am glad that it made it on the
list, and I think it's right about where it deserves
to be. Yeah, actually, we didn't talk about where
it was. I mean, I did say that six of us voted
it in the top 50, and Mike said it should be
a little bit higher. I'm not necessarily upset
with this being at 54. To me, when I think about
Voltron, I don't necessarily think top 50, so
I'm kind of okay with it. Steve? Well, to start
out with, I would agree with Mike that I don't
see it as an anime, but I do see that it is still
an anime. Right. But granted, I don't have this
on my list either, but it wasn't one of those
shows that I just... I can see the following
behind it. I can see why everybody loved it.
I don't know why IGN ranked it so damn low. They're
just fucking retarded. But I would definitely
say that it's top 50 worthy. Right. Maybe even
top 40 worthy, but I'm not completely dissatisfied
with where it landed on the list. Yeah. I do
like it, but it wasn't one of those shows that
I could sit through often. It seems like we're
starting a trend here because, you know, Pink
Panther, IGN did not have high enough. Voltron,
they did not have high enough. And it's going
to continue. At least we beat IGN. And we're
going to continue to beat IGN. We have a couple
trends continuing. First of all, the trend of
older shows not getting the amount of respect
that I think they should. The second trend is
IGN doing horrible because they ranked this one
at 68, and at least we're beating it at number
53 with Popeye the Sailor. I don't understand.
There's seven people that voted for this. We
all voted it in the top 50 except for one. Mike,
how the hell did you vote this 99? Fuck you.
It all goes back to Bluto the Rapist. Oh, my
God. What? Seriously? Okay. Now, I need to clarify.
If you go back and you listen to Tooncast episode
73, I think it wasn't at 73, Kev? I don't know.
I'm not Rain Man. Shit. Definitely came out of
my brain. Shut up, Steve. Just explain yourself.
When we covered Popeye on ToonCast, when I actually
went back and watched the cartoon and I looked
at the show, the first thing I saw was, okay,
Bluto is a stalker and a potential rapist. That's
all he is. He wants to get Olive Oil and then
fuck her brains out. That's all it is. Why does
that make this 99th best show instead of... Yeah,
but most bad guys in cartoon shows are like that,
though. It's kind of a common theme. To illustrate
this further, I had it at 31. Steve, you had
it at 34. Glade had it at 36. PixelDan, 27. DoubleD,
you had it at 22. JT at least had it at number
50. To me, this and Pink Panther are no -brain
top 50 shows. Yeah, I was just going to say that
I think this deserves to be way higher on the
list. This is probably even... top 30 material
uh i mean i'm glad it made the list obviously
but this show is a classic and yeah it's almost
like it's come past the point of just making
the list and now it's about like where these
are falling at because all these should make
the list yeah exactly but popeye was on air,
whether it was new shows, reruns, or the old
theatrical shorts or whatever. I mean, it was
on air for almost freaking 50 years. Yeah, there
are very few shows that they can just keep redoing
and redoing and rehashing, and there's the live
-action movie and all that. Actually, I think
this was one of the first cartoon shows to get
a live -action movie way back in 1980 with Robin
Williams. Just the cultural impact that it had.
I'm just a little bit surprised that it showed
up now instead of later. So the point is that
IGN ranked it 68, we ranked it higher, and all
of us except for Mike ranked it higher. So Mike,
IGN is the only one to get it better than you.
You are the Judas Iscariot among us, my friend.
Except for the few people, obviously, that didn't
put it on their list at all. Steve, your thoughts
on Popeye? It should have been a hell of a lot
higher than this. This was the shit back in the
day, man. Even if you didn't like spinach or
whatever, this was something that you see this
guy eat a freaking vegetable and he gets these
monstrous muscles and just beats the hell out
of whoever is his opposition. This was the first
pro -social cartoon that was like, fuck Captain
Planet. This was telling us to eat our vegetables
back in the 60s. It's like, eat your vegetables.
It'll make you big and strong. You need to beat
up big guys like Bluto that are trying to rape
your girlfriend. I will say that they're both
crazy for liking olive oil. Yeah, it's kind of,
I don't know, stick figures, like almost something
you'd see on Nightmare Before Christmas. For
Tim Burton got his ideas. Obviously. But, I mean,
it's still a show that deserves to be much, much
higher on the list than where it's at. We should
not be talking about this this episode. Yeah,
this should be next episode for sure. And IGN,
what the fuck is wrong with you? And Mike, really,
what the fuck is wrong with you? Clearly he doesn't
like rape. And it's not only that. He's not the
one causing it, though. Shut up, Steve. Unless
he wants to. Maybe that's why it's at number
99. He wants Bluto. No, no, no, no, no. It's
the fact that Popeye is stopping him. It's almost
like the Dark Knight. It's the Joker. He wouldn't
know what to do with her when he got her. Exactly.
Mike, just admit you're wrong. The other thing
about Popeye is the way that they advertise eating
your vegetables, they advertise it like he's
doing fucking steroids. Well, they probably wanted
it to be that, but they couldn't, so they had
to make it vegetables. Mike, just admit you're
wrong so we can move on. 52. I'm sorry, but I'm
going to sound like a broken record here because,
once again, IGN got this way wrong, and I think
we got it a little bit wrong. I think it should
be higher. 52 Smurfs. Now, let me start. It was
on for a decade. It was on for the entire 80s.
421 episodes. Five Daytime Emmy nominations,
two Daytime Emmy wins. This is the pinnacle as
far as if there was a cartoon for that generation,
that decade, a cartoon for that age, like that
preschool, kindergarten age group, Smurfs was
it. Live action, you had Sesame Street. Cartoon,
you had Smurfs. This is what you watched at a
young age if you were a kid in the 80s. This
belongs top 50. I know 52 is close. It belongs
top 50. Mike, what do you think? I agree with
you. And I don't care who says it doesn't hold
up or who says this is a perfect example of the
people that say you're voting on nostalgia, you're
voting on stuff you grew up with, or you're voting
with stuff that is either unwatchable or doesn't
hold up today. I don't care if it was good for
10 years, it deserves a spot. It was good for
the kids at that time. So I don't care if it
holds up today or not. It wasn't trying to hold
up in 2010. It was trying to hold up in 1980,
1981, 1982, and it successfully did that. And
now we're getting a live -action movie out of
it. Exactly, which is kind of freaking scary.
Yeah, which is probably going to be horrible,
but that's a different discussion. But I think
we might have two sides of the spectrum here
because people either rank this high or rank
this low. I will say nine people voted for it
out of the 20 that submitted lists. Now, me and
Mike have this in the top 35. Steve, you and
Double D have this in 87 and 94th, so did IGN
get it right when they put it at 97, or did we
get it closer to having it right here at number
52? I would say, I don't know, maybe like a little
bit lower than it is. I mean, I never grew up
with the Smurfs. I think that's why. I ranked
it so low, I just didn't have that connection
with it. But I still put it on my list because
I recognized how important it is to people of
that generation. The people that grew up in the
80s absolutely adore the Smurfs. So I understand
that, but that's why it didn't get any higher
on my list with all the rest of my personal favorites.
How about you, Steve? I would have to say that,
for one, I didn't realize there were so many
episodes and it went on so long. Because to me
it just seemed like they were telling the same
damn story over and over every episode. Well,
they basically were. So that's probably why I
ranked it so low, being 94th on my list. I would
probably warrant that, yeah, well, obviously
it deserves a spot on the top 100. You just have
to be stupid not to have it on there. But it's
not... I don't know, just for the fact that it
keeps telling the same exact story every episode.
It's just, I don't know, it gets repetitive.
It's almost like Captain Planet, except for Captain
Planet was just lame by comparison. I'd rather
watch little blue people running around compared
to that. I think two things for me, and I know
I kind of said a lot already, but two things.
Number one, if you've had... This had 421 episodes.
Let's not even go that far. If you've had over
300 episodes, you automatically should be a lock
for a high spot. I mean, 300 episodes, much less
400. And the other thing, the amount of shows
that tried to copy it are endless. As far as
diminutive, little, whether it was people, aliens,
Snorks? Yes, I mean, Snorks, the Littles, I mean,
the Monchichis, I mean, I could list about 20
of them if you guys wanted me to, and I don't
want to bore everybody. No, yeah, you're going
to bore us. But, I mean, this show, everybody
tried to copy it, everybody wanted its success,
and to me, 400 episodes warrants top 50. Oh,
yeah. I think it should be a little bit higher,
at least top 50, maybe even top 40, just for
the cultural significance it has. And as far
as it holding up today and the movie and all
that, well, you know, whatever. As Kevin has
said before, it's not about holding up. It's
about ranking the cartoons as they were. It's
unfair. Go ahead. The fact that they're making
a movie shows that the audiences of today, the
little, I guess, four to ten -year -olds of today,
can still enjoy the Smurfs. And since they're
making a movie, they're obviously going to market
the hell out of the original show. So that shows
that the marketing geniuses behind this believe
that the children of today can still enjoy this
show as much as the children of the 80s. So that's
really saying something. And obviously they're
trying to cash in on all the adults that were
kids of the 80s that are now going to take their
kids to it. But I just, again, I think it's unfair
to judge people's work from 20, 30, 40 years
ago by today's standards. And you've got to judge
it based on what they did at that time. And to
be on, how many cartoons have lasted nine seasons?
If we were to make a list of cartoons based on
number of seasons or number of episodes, I'm
guessing this would be top 10 or 20 on both lists.
As far as total number of episodes. But at the
same time, that doesn't really dictate the quality
of the show. No, but I'm saying part of quality
is how long are you around for your audience
at the time when you're being produced. The staying
power of it. And to not get canceled at all over
10 years. And I guarantee you, if we had ratings
information involved in this, as far as Nielsen
ratings or that type of stuff, it was wiping
out the competition for almost all nine of those
years. And to me, that counts on something regardless
of overall quality as we view it now. I don't
know. I might be one of the minority in feeling
that way because everybody on all the message
boards, all they talk about is, does it hold
up today or can I watch it as an adult? The show
is not intended for adults. Yeah, I don't think
it matters if you can watch the Smurfs as an
adult. It wasn't made for adults. That's not
the point. Yeah, exactly. So, yeah, I'd say I
agree maybe that it should be a little bit higher.
No, I'm not saying it should be that much higher.
I just think it warrants top 50, which we only
have one more show left in this half, and then
all of them are going to be top 50. And then
we can stop complaining about how they're not
in the top 50. Yes, so let's see what the last
one is that doesn't make the top 50. 51. Another
piece of evidence as to why IGN sucks. They did
not rank this show, and everybody knows that
this deserves a ranking. The 2003 version of
the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, which under
different titles lasted for seven seasons, 166
episodes, IGN did not rank this. Six people did.
Five of those people had it in their top 35.
It's the last one that doesn't make the top 50,
but it comes in at 51. Steve, what are your thoughts
of the newer, the latest until this year version
of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles? I would definitely
have to say that this was a great show. I liked
what they did with it this time around. They
didn't go for as much of a campy thing like what
they did with the 80s version. I mean, the 80s
version was great, don't get me wrong. I loved
that show, and there's no way that anything could
top it for what it was. This incarnation of the
Ninja Turtles was quite awesome graphically,
vocally, and... And story -wise, I mean, yeah,
it had its off -the -wall moments, but so did
the 80s one. And this show definitely is top
100 worthy. I think it should be a little bit
higher on the list, but I'm at least glad that
it made the list. I'm glad that it made it at
least this high. I think a lot of people forget
about it. And I'm going to go out on a limb here
because a lot of shows, the original is necessary
in order for the other ones to be popular. I
don't know. Say what you want about certain shows.
I'm not going to go Transformers or G .I. Joe
on anybody. But if the original Thundercats is
not popular, we're not getting a new Thundercats
this year. That's not something that they just
would have came up with, and it wouldn't have
been popular. Let's say they did do this Thundercats
this year. It would not be popular without that
one in the 80s. This turtle show would have been
popular even, in my opinion, if the 80s turtles
never existed. Yeah, I think this is one of those
shows that actually lives up to the original
incarnation. It's one of the ones that I think
I forgot to put on my list. I know I put the
original Turtles. I think I just wasn't even
thinking of this version, but I have seen both.
They're different, and I know people love the
80s one for sort of the nostalgic qualities,
but this one almost has better storytelling in
some ways. Oh, yeah. Yeah, this show, much like
Spectacular Spider -Man, was... one of those
things that was very story -driven. The voice
acting was great. It got a little wonky when
they did Fast Forward, because there were so
many time travel stories. They were basically
constantly jumping in DeLoreans and going to
different time periods and crap like that. It
set a whole other generation onto the Turtles.
Oh, yeah. And the voice acting is actually...
As far as comparing voices, it's hard to do in
the Turtles franchise because so many of them
are really good. Like Michael Cinder -Nicholas
and Wayne Grayson and Sam Riegel and those guys.
I mean, they did great in this show. And this
show, I like the fact that they didn't have to
go for the same type of feel as the first one.
The first one, like we've said, is campy and
comedy more. This one's more action, a little,
not necessarily darker tones, but darker compared
to the 80s one. I think what they did with this,
and I'm not trying to cut you off, Kevin. I think
what they did with this is with Turtles 2003,
they took the Eastman and Laird comics, and they
took the 1987 cartoon, and they meshed them together.
Because there are comedy bits in this series.
Yeah, they sort of did like a marriage of like
a best of. Right. Because the comics, if you've
ever read the comics, they're very dark. Yeah,
they're extremely, extremely dark. Yeah, compared
to the show, which was aimed more at kids. And
then you get this, which is kind of the happy
medium. Right, exactly. And I think the big thing
is when you're going to remake a show that pretty
much everybody loves, like the Teenage Mutant
Ninja Turtles. You have to do a good job or everyone's
just going to hate it. And the fact that people
like this enough that it ranked... What is this,
51 now? 51, yes. The fact that it ranked 51 on
this list shows that they did a great job of
redoing something, staying true to the original,
but still doing a great job of updating it for
a new audience. And just for, I know there was
a lot of people out there that probably thought
this was not going to make our list. So hopefully
they're still listening and still tuning in because
I think this gives our list some credibility
since IGN somehow did not put this on their list.
And for all those people that didn't think we
were going, to. Sorry, you're wrong. We recognize
the greatness of the Turtles. Yes. So let's see
what makes our top 50. 50. I am Adam, Prince
of Eternia, defender of the secrets of Castle
Grayskull. This is Cringer, my fearless friend.
Fabulous... I find it very interesting that this
one is back -to -back with the 2003 remake or
reboot of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles show.
Our first entry in the top 50, and I'm actually
going to say for the first time in this episode
that this is a perfect placement for this, the
2002 version. of Masters of the Universe. Wait
a minute, they remade Masters of the Universe?
Oh my goodness, if you have Masters of the Universe.
You didn't know that? I didn't even know this
existed. You need to go get it. I'm going to
sit out right now and just let you guys talk
about this. No, you seriously need to go get
it. You can get the complete series in one set.
It's like just one box set and it's only like
$20 or $30. It is some of the best writing and
one of the best reboots of a classic franchise
I think I've ever seen. Once again, IGN did not
rank this. I had it at 26. Mike, you had it at
22. Chris from Chicken Pop Hot had it at number
2. Ryan had it at number 18. Two Annie nominations,
a Daytime Emmy win. The only bad thing about
this series is that it got cut before they finished.
Yeah. Kevin and I can really talk about this
because we pretty much watched, well, at least
I watched the entire series over a three -day
period. Kevin watched it over like a ten -day
period. You know, I've said this before, and
if people haven't heard me say it, you'll hear
me say it now. The original He -Man and the Masters
of the Universe, the 1980s version, was single
-story. It was single episodes, no continuity
whatsoever, and they were like mini -movies.
This one, the He -Man and the Masters of the
Universe 2002 cartoon, this actually gave you
continuity of... It started out at the very beginning.
And the character development was epic. Yeah,
the character development was so great. It started
out at the very beginning with Randor being one
of the king's head guards or something or other.
And they give you this whole backstory of how
Skeletor became Skeletor. And every time they
brought a new character in, the design was perfect.
The look was perfect. It's one of those things
like... David said in the last one, this is a
franchise that you have to be very careful when
you redo it or when you reboot it, as is Transformers,
G .I. Joe, Turtles, et cetera, lots of them.
And for them to do this, and I think to a person,
every He -Man fan was just about happy with this
one. Oh, yeah. And to make that possible, I mean,
the character designs are good. The storytelling
is good. They actually develop their characters.
I can't say enough good stuff about this. I'm
not saying it should be any higher than 50. I'm
just very, very happy that it came in at number
50 and that we ranked it since IGN didn't. Exactly.
The last thing I'll say before Steve goes is
when I first saw this, when I first watched it
from episode one. I thought they were going to
have the same theme song because it starts out,
it starts out, you know, I am Adam. Yeah. And
then all of a sudden you have all this action
going on and you get no voiceover. They basically
interrupt him. Right, exactly, because this is
a Skeletor that ain't going to wait around for
people to say stuff. Well, and like I said, it
ran for 39 episodes, and it cut off right when
it was about ready to hit its climax and to become
even way more epic. They're bringing Hordak in,
they're doing the Snake Manor in there, and it
was about to go apeshit crazy, and for some reason
the show got the axe, and I really wish they
would have been able to finish it because it
looked like it was going to be phenomenal. Now,
correct me if I'm wrong, was this on Cartoon
Network? I'm actually not sure. I want to say
that it was. Okay. Which would explain why it
got killed so quickly. Yes, it was. And Cartoon
Network has this thing where they have to axe
a show right when it's getting good. And it's
not probably just Cartoon Network, but I think
it's primarily Cartoon Network is like, yeah,
we're kind of done with this concept. Next. And
they have their assembly line moving forward.
As for this show, granted, I don't have it on
my list either. I think I overlooked it. But
from what I have seen of this, this show is freaking
awesome. The writing, the voices, the new versions
of the characters are just freaking badass as
all hell. Yeah. I want to give a shout out. We'd
be remiss if we didn't say the guy that was behind
it all in this series. Mike Young did a phenomenal
job with this. I know you haven't seen it, Double
D, but any thoughts? It sounds really good. That's
my thoughts. It sounds great, I guess. I think
it's a great start to the top 50. 49. I believe
we've outdone IGN once again. So we went from
the 2003 Turtles to the 2002 He -Man to the 2008...
Clone Wars, The Clone Wars. This is the complete
CG, 3D, whatever you want to call it, Clone Wars
that started in 2008. It's still going on. IGN
ranked at 89. I think we did much better because
I actually do think this deserves a spot in the
top 50. We might have different opinions on this
one because Mike and I are the only ones that
had it in our top 50. Mike, I'll let you talk
first about this one in comparison to the other
one, too. This is another one that... I'm the
type of person that if I don't catch on to something
when it first starts, I want to wait until it's
either done or until, you know. I've seen bits
and pieces of this, but from what I've heard
and from what I have seen, just amazing, amazing
storytelling. As Kevin said, it's still running.
I believe they just wrapped up their season three
finale just happened. Just the way that they're
expanding the Star Wars universe with this cartoon
and they're paying homage to all these different
things. So many characters. Yes, so many. Even
Jar Jar had an episode for Pete's sake. You know,
it's just amazing, amazing storytelling. They
brought Qui -Gon Jinn. They brought Liam Neeson
back. for a few episodes as a quote -unquote
ghost spirit thing. It was very, very, very cool.
What sells me on this one over the 2003 version
is 100 % visual. Oh, yeah. I would say the storytelling
a little bit as well. There's a few really corny
moments in the 2003 version, and you don't get
as many of those in this one, I find. It's like
almost without even seeing the show, though,
you can just tell that this one's going to be
better somehow. Yeah, it's also... aimed at a
little bit of an older audience, I think, than
the 2003 version, because this is actually a
surprisingly dark show. They're not afraid to
kill clone troopers in each episode. But, yeah,
it's a very well -done show. It's one of those
more recent shows that I think definitely does
deserve to be on the list. I don't know about
top 50, but definitely top 60 material, in my
opinion. Birdman had a number 13. I just want
to bounce off of what Double D just said, that
maybe not top 50. Steve, does this not quite
deserve top 50 in your book? I would probably
say, I mean, granted, I haven't seen diddly squat
of the show, but everything I have. heard of
it and seen as far as the visuals and the voicing,
I'd have to say it's good. I probably would have
to agree with you guys. I would say that this
would definitely be a top 60s. See, I think as
long as it fell somewhere in this episode, I'm
fine with wherever it would have fallen. Yeah.
So I'm happy with it. I think it was better,
is better than the 2003 version, so I'm happy
it ranked ahead of it. And I think IGN at 89,
that's a little too low. Again, I'm going to
make the comparison like I did with the Turtles
cartoon. Basically, you have Clone Wars. That
was the 2003 version. Now you have this version,
The Clone Wars, where Clone Wars was kind of
a campy type of thing. It did have some story,
but those were technically shorts. I mean, they
weren't an overall cartoon series. They were
a series of shorts. And with this, you have entire
season arcs, entire stories. Every time I see
an advertisement on Cartoon Network for this,
it makes me want to watch it, but in the back
of my mind, I'm like, why am I going to jump
in now and not know what's going on? And the
only bad thing about this series is in order
to buy the seasons, you have to be rich. Seriously.
The seasons are ungodly expensive. But it's because
they put a ridiculous amount of bonus features
on them as well. Another thing, too, to note
is that this series, although it's sort of a
remake of the 2003 series, it doesn't ignore
that series either. A good example is the character
of Asajj Ventress was invented for the original
2003 series. She never appeared in anything before
that, and she's still in this series. So it's
not like they're ignoring that continuity. They're
just doing a more expanded, sort of a fuller
version of it, which is cool. Right, yeah. 48.
Yogi Bear is smarter than the average bear. Yogi
Bear is always in the ranger's hair. At a picnic
table, you will find him there. Stuffing down
more goodies than the average bear. I've got
to say, we're completely owning the IGN list
so far in this episode between the ones that
they didn't rank and the ones that they didn't
rank high enough. And this is one of the biggest
travesties of the IGN list, the fact that the
Yogi Bear show did not show up on their list.
I don't even think we need to mention how stupid
the IGN list was anymore. It's a given at this
point. I don't know. Maybe their theory is it
was part of the Huckleberry Hound show, but that's
bullshit because it spawned off its own show.
I actually don't think we have this high enough.
It's 48 on our list. This, to me, is top 20.
This is the show that made Hanna -Barbera what
it is. It spawned. If it wasn't successful, we'd
never get any of the Hanna -Barbera classic shows.
I would say that the Flintstones was probably
Hanna -Barbera's most memorable show. But Yogi
Bear is a fantastic show, and I'm glad it appeared
on the list. I'd say it's right about where it
belongs, personally. I think the difference was
Flintstones was supposed to be the primetime
show more for an older audience, whereas the
Yogi Bear show was like the cartoon for kids
type thing in the daytime. And actually, as far
as when it happened, Flintstones comes a little
bit later, I believe, if I'm not mistaken. And
the Yogi Bear, if I'm remembering back from our
ToonCast time, and I'm not going to say any episode
because I'm not trying to pimp it out or anything,
but they went originally at their very first
pitch as far as this went. When Huckleberry Hound
came out in 1959, this is what actually sold
Huckleberry Hound, was that Yogi Bear was a part
of it. And so even though the Yogi Bear show
didn't start until 1961, it was actually around
a little bit before the Flintstones, if I'm getting
my facts right. But anyways, I just think it
should be top 20. I mean, I think without its
success, we don't get a lot of what we got from
Hanna -Barbera. Mike, what do you think? No,
Yogi should so be a little bit higher. It was
just so, so awesome to have, you know. It's just
a fun, fun show. Well, it's a fun show. Actually,
if you look at individual characters and how
many times a character has shown up in another
show, in another movie, or something like that,
obviously you get your Batmans and your Spidermans
and stuff like that. But Yogi Bear is one of
the most iconic characters ever. He has shown
up in at least 20 different television shows,
movies, or whatever, which is up there with,
I don't know, Bugs Bunny and those types of characters.
I mean, Yogi Bear is iconic. Yeah, I would say
he's probably one of Hanna -Barbera's top five
most popular creations. Definitely stupid of
IGN to not include this on their list. Even though
it only ran for two seasons, it didn't last a
very long time, but it still... Everyone remembers
it. There are shows that could have ran for five
or six years that people have forgotten, or that...
just aren't that great but this show ran for
a short time and it was amazing so and and it
spawned off it was kind of like one of those
even though the original show only lasted that
long it's one of those like scooby -doo where
it spawned off all these different versions of
itself and you had like yogi's gang you had like
yogi's uh treasure Yeah, he showed up in the
Laugh Olympics and all these different shows.
I mean, there was probably like 15 different
shows that Yogi starred in over three or four
decades. You had Yogi's Kids, which was, you
know, all the way in the 80s they were still
making Yogi's cartoons. And since we mentioned
it with Smurfs, we should mention the live -action
Yogi that just, did it already come out? Yes,
it's out. Yeah, I haven't seen it, but I haven't
heard anything good. At least we ranked it, and
at least we gave it top 50. Steve, you did not
vote for this. Do you think it warrants top 50,
or at least are you happy that it's on the list
somewhere? Yeah, I would say I'd rate it top
50. I don't know what the fuck I put on my list.
Some of them, I'm like, why didn't I have these?
And then some of them, I'm like, why did I even
bother putting these? This show, I did like watching
this when I was growing up, and this is one of
the few that I can still watch now that's from
that time era. So I definitely think it does
hold up pretty well. I do see that it is too
high up there on the list, or too low, depending
on how you're looking at it. You think it should
be higher? Yes, I think it should be much higher
than where it's at, and I think it should be
higher than what IGN gave it. Well, IGN didn't
rank it at all. That's right. Yes, and IGN is
nothing but a bunch of fucking asshats for not
even having Yogi Bear on their list. How could
you not have such an iconic show on the list?
Do we even have to continue mentioning IGN at
this point? Yes, we do. Idiot Gaming Network.
We've made our point. Idiot Gaming Network. The
bottom line is Yogi Bear deserves to be on the
top 100, and I think it deserves to be higher
than 48, but at least it's in the top 50. 47.
Another franchise heard of for the first time
now. We've had a lot of comic book series with
three different Spider -Man entries and a Batman
entry. And at number 47, we receive our first
Superman entry. Superman the Animated Series
from 1996. Also one of the first times so far
in this episode where IGN has actually ranked
something higher than us. Let's start with Steve.
Superman the Animated Series coming in at 47.
You agree, you disagree, and will this be the
only Superman series that makes the countdown?
I disagree. I think it should be higher because
this is the definitive best Superman cartoon
series. Granted, there aren't very many of them
compared to, like, Batman or, say, Spider -Man.
I would actually disagree with that personally
because I had the original Max Fleischer Superman
series. I think I had that as, like, number nine
on my list. Although I do love this series, but
I would say that's the definitive one personally,
though I doubt it's going to make the list, but
we'll have to see. No, see, I love this series
because of not only the graphics or the animation
style or the writing, but I love the consistency
with the rest. This is what kind of bridged the
gap between... Batman the Animated Series and
Justice League and got everything rolling through
there. Plus, you have a great voice cast. This
starts the many crossovers that you'll see through
the DCAU. I used to watch this show when I'd
watch Batman because everything was pretty much
back -to -back back then. I just loved it. So
we got one person that's saying that this is
the definitive, one person saying that the early
classic Superman is the definitive. Mike, break
the tie. The Max Fleischer show is a product
of its time. While it is still good, it so is,
no. It is good. It was very awesome for the time,
but those adventures were just so there. Even
back then, I think, you know, For me, it didn't
really capture me. It was a different time, though.
Now cartoons are more linear and you can bring
back characters and stuff like that. Back then
it was almost expected. to have like a different
plot in each episode. And it was more about Superman
kind of, uh, there'd be like a volcano going
off or something and he would have to figure
out a way to stop it. I mean, it was still thrilling
in its own way. It was just kind of different,
a different form of storytelling, but no, I definitely
agree that this deserves to be on the list. I'm
very happy that it is where it is. And I'd even
say it could be a little bit higher. Oh yeah.
It's so needs to be higher. you know, like Steve
said, this is what, I mean, Batman the Animated
Series is technically mini -movies. They're mini
-individual movie -type episodes. and it really
is on its own. Superman the Animated Series,
specifically the episode Ghost in the Machine,
is where all of the continuity starts, as far
as that goes. And I know specifically that the
producers, Bruce Timm, James Tucker, all of them,
Dwayne McDuffie, may he rest in peace, all those
guys, they didn't set out to make the continuity,
but by the time they got to Justice League and
Batman Beyond, they were like, oh. We can tie
this into this. We can tie this into this. So
really, this is where it starts. And voice acting,
oh, my God. Tim Daly as Superman was awesome.
Dana Delaney as Lois Lane. Perfect casting for
Lois Lane. Dana Delaney's voice for Lois Lane,
to me, is the definitive Lois Lane out of animation,
live action, anything. I would have to agree
with you on that, actually. Whenever I'm reading
a comic book and Lois Lane's character is in
it, that's sort of the voice that's going through
my head. So this show did have fantastic voice
acting, great animation, and a lot of really
good characters as well. I remember... I think
my favorite episodes were the ones that had Metallo
in them, a very well -developed character for
a superhero villain. Yeah. So is this one of
the rare instances, this episode, where IGN actually
got us one time here since they had it at 36
and we had it at 47? Yeah, probably. I mean,
we're not so far off. I mean, I still think this
is at least top 30 material, maybe 28, 27. And
the other thing that really, really hit home
with the continuity with this series, not just
Ghost in the Machine as far as tying everything
back, this was the first crossover. World's Finest,
the three -parter, where you had Batman and Superman
meeting for the first time. You had Lex Luthor
and the Joker teaming up, and then Batman and
Superman teamed up. Anyone that says anything
against World's Finest, a .k .a. the Batman -Superman
movie, you are fucking dead to me. Because that
three -parter was just amazingly written, amazingly
voice -acted, and it told a fluid story, and
it's one of the greatest things about this series.
Why would anyone say anything against that? Oh,
there's crazy people out there. I like IGN. Is
this legitimately top 30, Mike, or is that your
superhero bias playing effect? No, it's legitimately
top 30. There are a few episodes in Superman
the Animated Series that aren't so, so great,
but for the most part, legitimately, I wish it
was at least top 30. Even if it came in at like...
I said 27, 28 earlier, but maybe 30 or 31. I
think it needs to be a little bit higher. Overall,
very, very well done. It's just amazing. Go ahead.
The only criticism I maybe have for the show
is I don't think it was quite as memorable as
Batman the Animated Series in terms of tone and
storytelling and stuff. But I think for me personally,
that's just because I've always liked Batman
more than I like Superman. But it's probably
the best way that they could have ever brought
Superman to the small screen for that era, I
guess. Steve, I just want to go to you for a
second, and then I actually want to stay with
this one for a little while, but Steve, did IGN
get this one better than us at 36 compared to
47? I would... I don't know. I wouldn't give
it a 36, but I would still have it closer to
40 than where it's at. So, like, in between,
basically? Yeah, kind of a happy medium between
the two, because I don't think that it deserves
where it landed, and I don't think it... deserves
where IGN put it. I kind of agree with your whole
statement, Dave, that you just gave between Batman
and Superman, that Batman, for me, is more...
my favorite than Superman, but this was still
a great cartoon. And that's why I want to stay
with this one for a second longer, because I
mentioned that this is the first example of,
you know, this was another franchise that we
hadn't heard of. Obviously, we've talked about
Batman, and we've talked about Spider -Man. I've
got two questions for all you guys. The first
one I want to start with is... Do we expect to
see any other superhero franchises that we have
not seen somewhere in the rest of this top 50?
I mean, we've seen Spider -Man, and we've seen
Batman, and now Superman. Are there any others
we should see? Oh, yeah. X -Men is probably the
big one that comes to my mind. The 90s X -Men
series. I mean, there was also X -Men Evolution,
which was okay, but... What about stuff like...
Yeah, that definitely should be on there. What
about stuff like Fantastic Four or just other
superheroes that are nothing like that? Iron
Man? They were good in their time, but... Go
ahead, Dave. Yeah, I remember the Iron Man series
being okay. I think he actually had an episode
in the Spider -Man show before. Yeah, that's
where it started. But I don't think any of those
are really good enough to be in the top 50. I
think if anything like Fantastic Four or Iron
Man had appeared, it would be in the lower 50
probably. So a possibility of maybe seeing or
hoping to see some X -Men or something like that.
And other than that, maybe... Hopefully, if the
90s X -Men series doesn't appear somewhere on
this list, then I'll be a little bit pissed off,
personally. So will I. It's a classic. Is Superman
the worst out of the franchises we've talked
about so far? Is Spider -Man and Batman just
superior franchises? No. I mean, well, specifically
to Superman the Animated Series, it's, as I already
said, you know, it basically started the DC animated
universe continuity. It... is its own thing,
where I said that, you know, Batman, the animated
series, is technically like many movies. Superman
was more serialized. It was more... But isn't
Batman and Spider -Man both better than Superman?
No. I'd say that... I mean, you know, people
like them for... It's a personal preference.
Yeah, I'd say it depends what you're looking
for, really. Spider -Man was a little bit cheesier,
a little bit more on the sci -fi side of things.
Batman was a lot darker, and then Superman's
kind of in between the two, almost. Gotcha. I
just never have liked Superman anything. I don't
know why. But I think it'll be interesting. Like
I said, we'll see if we see any more Batman or
Spider -Man, and now that you guys bring up X
-Men, we'll see if we see that. Thank you. So
previously, I don't know if it was the last episode
or the first episode, we mentioned some stuff
about Nickelodeon shows and if we would see another
one. And making its spot in the top 50 here at
number 46 is a Nickelodeon show, and it is the
one that we thought we might see, and that is
Rugrats. Fucking hell. Shut up, Mike. Before
Mike does whatever he does with shows that he
doesn't like, I want to at least look at the
facts here. From 1991 to 2004, it was on. It
had nine different seasons, 173 episodes. It
spawned multiple movies. Rugrats All Grown Up,
another show. Eight people voted for it. It's
getting nominations and awards out the wazoo
as far as Annie's and Emmy's. In my opinion,
before we let Mike talk, this definitely deserves
a spot in the top 100. It definitely deserves
a spot. In my mind, right around 50, whether
it's on the other side of 50 or this side of
50, I think this is a quality show that a lot
of people watched over a decade, and I think
it warrants a spot. Mike, go ahead. I was kind
of hoping to talk before Mike. Go ahead. The
only thing I'm going to say really quick is you
need to switch. Number 70 with this. You need
to put Doug here and put Rugrats at the fucking
far end of the countdown. Okay, I'll agree with
that, because I definitely think Doug was the
way more intelligently written Nickelodeon show.
But I also grew up with Rugrats as well, so I
do have kind of a soft spot in my heart for this
show. And it was a good show. I mean, there's
a reason why it lasted so long, and then it had
all these movies made out of it and everything.
It was just a fun show, I don't know. To me,
Rugrats has a bigger following, though, than
Doug. Whether Doug was a better show or not,
Rugrats was the one that was more popular, I
guess. I think it's because Rugrats had more
of a universal appeal. I think Doug had a very
specific audience. I think it was aimed more
towards males, kind of in a little bit of an
older age range. Rugrats was more of a show that
guys and girls could watch, and it reached...
Sort of an all -ages, well, not all -ages, but,
you know, it reached kind of a wider crowd, which
I think is why it showed up higher on this list.
I think it could have gone a little bit lower,
but I think I feel the same way as you, Kevin,
that it should be somewhere around the 50 mark.
And looking at the people that voted for it,
Dodd had it at 38, PixelDan 49, Ryan at 52, and
both of us at 58. So we all kind of had it around
that middle part. You know, one person had it
at 72, and a couple people had it in their top
20. I gen hit at 92nd, and I think that's too
low. I think it's definitely better than that.
Yeah. I don't understand what your hate is exactly
for Rugrats, Mike. One of the reasons was at
the time I was living with some friends who had
kids, and that's all the kids would watch because
technically this is a kids' show. This is like
an age. It doesn't mean it's bad. Four to 14.
type of cartoon. This is not something at the
time... I just... I don't know. Whatever. It's
just one of those things where it just didn't
appeal to me whatsoever. And it was one of those
things where if I had to choose, I would rather
watch Bobby's World than watch this. I'd actually
agree with you on that. Oh, I'd rather watch
Bobby's World, too, but I don't know. You can't
discount it just because it's a kid's show. You
rank Smurfs pretty high. Yeah, but Smurfs was
a dick. No, specifically when I say kids show
coming to Rugrats, Smurfs were not little babies.
Yeah, but Rugrats was basically the Smurfs for
the 90s. It was, really. Steve, weigh in. I would
have to say that although it was not on my list,
I would say that Rugrats is definitely one of
those influential shows for some people. You
either got it or you didn't. And I personally
don't care for the show, but my wife grew up
on it. And there's only like a year and a half
difference between the two of us. And she loved
the show growing up. So, I mean, I can see it
was either a hit or miss. You either liked it
or you didn't. And if you liked it, it's one
of those great shows that you just kind of followed
all the way through. Whereas if you just didn't
give a crap, that's why it isn't on your list.
Right. But I would say that it does deserve to
be here. Yeah. Like I said, I just fall back
on that, too. Anything that shows up for nine
seasons and continuously gets renewed, that quality,
at least in a manner of doing what it was supposed
to do as far as being popular for its demographic
or its ratings, had to be there. I think what
I liked about Rugrats, too, was it was a surprisingly
innocent show for during the 90s when you had
stuff that was going more for edgy, like Ren
and Stimpy or Rocko's Modern Life. Then you had
Rugrats that was a lot less edgy, a lot more
kind of simplified and innocent for younger kids.
So it kind of went against the grain a little
bit, which was nice. I will say, though, that
it started off better than it ended. Yeah. You
can definitely see a quality difference if you
watch the original episodes from, like, 91, 92,
and then watch some of the newer stuff. It's
just not really as good. But, I mean, you're
going to run out of ideas after a while once
you have that many seasons. True. So we did see
another Nickelodeon show on the list. I don't
know if we'll see another one or not, but at
least we've seen... Two or at least one more
since we talked about Doug. 45. So, uh... Coming
in at 45, another classic. Like I said, we haven't
had a lot of them, but we've been getting a little
bit more of them lately, and that is Jetsons.
Funny that it came in 46 on IGN and comes in
at 45 for us. I'm actually okay with this. I
could see it being a little bit higher, but I'm
okay with it at least being in the top 50. It
was around in the 60s. It came back and made
a revival in the 80s. To me, this is always the
second -rate. I mean, it's basically Flintstones
in space, so I'm okay with it being about right
where it is. Mike, you had it at 51, so is it
about right for you too? I kind of wish it was
top 40, like either right at 40 or 39. And, yeah,
I kind of ranked it a little bit higher or a
little bit lower on my own list, but that was
because of other reasons. As far as it being
the futuristic version of the Flintstones, I
kind of will agree with that. However, one of
the best things about the Jetsons for me specifically
was... The crossover. When the Jetsons met the
Flintstones in that crossover movie they did
back in the 80s. That was just so, so awesome.
I thought you were going to say the Jetsons movie,
like the actual movie. Oh, no. No. I did just
make a page for the Jetsons meet the Flintstones.
I loved that movie when I was a kid. I don't
know. I haven't seen it in a while, but when
I was younger, I adored the Jetsons movie. That
was like the one thing that I actually really
liked about the Jetsons. I liked the Jetsons
because I've always been a sci -fi fan, but if
you were to give me the choice of watching Jetsons,
since they're watching Flintstones, I would have
watched Flintstones. Oh, yeah. Flintstones had
way more intelligent writing. Jetsons almost
felt like they were going to fire three of the
writers from the Flintstones, and instead of
firing them, they threw them on a different show
that was basically a Flintstones ripoff. It's
not a bad show. I'm not saying it's bad. I think
it's good where it is on our list. But, yeah,
I agree with you that it's definitely... Just
the futuristic version of the Flintstones. And
it's almost like they made this show specifically
so they could do that Flintstones crossover.
Yeah, I don't know. It's like they had that in
mind when they created it. I mean, if you look
at it, and before Steve goes, if you look at
it, I mean, yes, Fred and Wilma only had Pebbles,
and then Barney and Betty had Bam Bam, whereas
George and Judy have Elroy and Judy. It's kind
of almost the same thing. George and Judy have
Elroy and Judy? Whatever. You know what I mean.
George and Jane of Elroy and Judy. You know,
you have this thing of the shows are basically
mirror images of each other. It's kind of like
people always want to copy the Scooby -Doo method.
And it was just so good. But what really cemented
Jetsons for me was... When the Jetsons met the
Flintstones, because I just love that movie.
I remember when I was a kid, I watched that movie
more than enough times for the VHS tape to break.
Wow. I think I watched that movie like once.
Yeah, I watched it once. Steve, IGN 46, us 45,
you 43, so is this perfect? I would say so. To
me, I like this show, and although it wasn't
as strong as the Flintstones, it's still one
of those ones that you just can't deny it being
that high on the list. Yeah, I think it's a perfect
placement, actually. I mean, I could see it being
a little bit higher. As long as it made the top
50, I'm happy. So I think this is the first time
we've had 10 people. Half of our voters put this
on their list. IGN had it at 31. We put it at
44. It is the Muppet Babies. Ran for almost all
the 80s, 84 to 95 seasons, 107 episodes, three
Daytime Emmy nominations, five Daytime Emmy wins.
I think almost all of us voted for this one,
actually. All four of us voted for this one.
Let's just start with Steve. Muppet Baby's at
44. How do you feel? I feel fine with it. I mean,
it wasn't a bad show. It wasn't one that I particularly
watched all that often. I mean, it did last a
long time. But I think it's by no means should
have been rated any higher than where it's at.
I think this one and Smurf should have been flipped.
I think the reason... I'm just glad this outranked
Rugrats, to be honest with you. But I think the
reason why this showed up so high on the list
is because if you don't have any connection to
the Muppet Babies, then you're not going to care
about it. But I think anyone who watched the
Muppet Babies as a kid just loved it. I remember
watching this every day when I got home from
kindergarten. They had this show on, and I just
adored it. It was one of my favorite shows. I
think why I liked it when I was a kid was because
it didn't really talk down to its audience. It
sort of just talked at them, if that makes any
sense. No, I agree. It's what a good kid show
should be, I think. Well, Scotty and I had it
actually in the top 20. And the reason I did
that was because, for me, this was one of my
favorite shows when I was a kid. It's something
my sister and I loved. We loved, obviously, The
Muppet Show and all the Jim Henson stuff. And
this cartoon version, I loved the live -action
stuff that they put in there. This is one of
the first characters that I can remember, and
a lot of people have copied this, though, with
the nanny, one of the first characters that you
couldn't actually see all of. You never got to
see her face. It had a lot of... great characters.
So I had it higher. I'm okay with it where it
is. The only reason I said Smurfs maybe should
be higher is because Smurfs had a little bit
longer run, had 300 more episodes. So to me,
they should be near each other. I don't know.
I think in some ways, though, I think the Muppets
was almost the more... better read show yeah
then it was better written and better made i
think than the smurfs in a lot of ways i think
this the smurfs it was just more popular and
had more of a staying power well and the other
thing the muppets did really good is they had
the kids stuff and they had like the kid friendly
stuff but then they would go on these adventures
or go on these crazy things and it almost felt
like you were it reached Multiple audiences as
far as age groups. Yeah, and the Rugrats almost
did the same thing. Like I said, I'm kind of
glad this outranked it because it came first
and almost did the exact same thing. So you almost
wonder if Rugrats was just sort of copying this
formula. Pretty much. True. Well, then the other
thing the Muppet Babies did is they did comedy,
they did sci -fi, they did fantasy, they did
adventure, they did all these different types
of genres. They tackled it all. Mike, you haven't
said much. What do you think about this one?
I love this show. This is one of those shows,
along with The Muppet Show, that just... And
I know The Muppet Show is obviously the live
-action stuff, but just... It was so great to
be able to look through, you know, Cartoon Kermit
and Piggy and Rolf and Fozzie and all them and
Gonzo. And they just kind of took the Muppets
to a whole new level with this. Because there's
so much more you can do in animation with characters
like these. And it was just really, really great.
The only real thing I liked about the live -action
parts of this... was kind of like the door double
-take where Gonzo would open a door and he would
immediately shut it and then open it again to
see if it was real. But I specifically liked
the cartoon more than the live -action stuff
that was in it. Well, and you also have a phenomenal
voice cast in this. Frank Welker doing a lot
of stuff, Dave Coulier, Rusty Taylor, Peter Cullen
at times, Howie Mandel, Greg Berg. I mean, it
was a great voice cast. There's not much bad
you can say about this show. Don't forget Barbara
Billingsley. Yeah, as Nanny. But, I mean, there's
just not a lot of bad stuff that anyone could
come up with about this show, I don't think.
I mean, ten of us voted for it. Like I said,
I think everyone who ever was exposed to this
as a child, it had a major impact on them. It
won a ton of awards. Even back when it was actually
running, people respected how good it was written
and what was being done there. The nicer thing
about it is it wasn't the same old thing like
how Smurfs was. This was something totally different
pretty much every episode. So we kind of had
the 90s version of the show with Rugrats and
then the 80s version of the show with Muppet
Babies. What were kids watching in the 2000s?
43. Oh! Who lives in a pineapple under the sea?
SpongeBob SquarePants! Absorbent and yellow and
porous is he. SpongeBob SquarePants! Hypnotical
nonsense be something you wish. SpongeBob! So
from Muffet Babies to Rugrats to number 43, SpongeBob
SquarePants. Another one that's lasted a long
time, started in 99, and it's still going, folks.
Four of us had this in our top 20. IGN had it
in their top 20 at number 15. I'm not going to
list all the awards because it will take too
long. This definitely deserves to be in the top
50. I think it could have been a little bit higher.
And I'm not necessarily someone who grew up with
it. I'm not someone who watches it a lot. I just
respect how long it's been around and how many
people love this show. Let's go to Double D.
You had this one down at 93, so is this too high?
I'd say, yeah. I'd say this probably... I think
93 is a bit low. I think I just kind of threw
it in there as an afterthought, really. I think
this kind of deserves maybe to be somewhere in
the 60s or 70s. I do... Like, I respect SpongeBob
a lot. I just never really got into it, and I
think it's a little bit overrated. I think the
reason a lot of people like this, I hate to say
it, but it's because it's funnier when you're
high. I mean, kids like it because it's stupid
humor, but all the people our age that watch
this show and really like it are probably on
something at the time. Nice. But it at least
deserves a top 100. Yeah, definitely, definitely
deserves to be in the top 100. I just don't think
it deserves to be this high, but I definitely
understand the appeal of SpongeBob, and it does
have some hilarious moments. There have been
a few times where I've watched SpongeBob and
just laughed my ass off at stuff that just made
no sense, but I think that's why people find
it so funny. Yeah. Mike, how did this not make
your list? It was something that I hadn't really,
I knew of the popularity and stuff like that,
and I had seen episodes here and there, but it
was something that wasn't really on the top of
my mind of best of all time. Yes, I understand
that the popularity and the longevity of it is
great, and I will agree with what you guys have
said, that there are some bit parts, really,
really funny parts. Kevin, we've said this before.
We spent six hours on our lists. So it's like...
And Steve, I don't think you did vote for it.
I think that's supposed to be someone else's
name. That's supposed to be someone else's name.
So do you think this should not be on the list?
I think it should be on the list, but I don't
think it should be this high. I think it should
be above 50. Yeah, I don't know. I see it in
the top 50, but I... You mean below 50, Steve.
That's what I mean. I can see it either way.
Like I said, I'm not a huge fan, so I'm not going
to try to rally votes for it to be in the top
50 or anything like that. But I can see it in
the 40s. I can see it in the 60s. I think 43
is fine for it. It is an amazing show as far
as voice acting. Tom Kenny as SpongeBob. You've
got fucking Clancy Brown as Mr. Krabs. You've
got Clancy Brown, who was Lex Luthor in Superman
the Animated Series. He was the Kurgan in Highlander.
He was the head guard in Shawshank Redemption.
And this, it's like you wouldn't expect him to
do a voice like Mr. Krabs, but at the same time
you would. Honestly, and I know Kevin's going
to kill me for this, but the only reason why
I've started taking more notice of SpongeBob
now, and like I said, I just forgot about it
being on my list, about not being on my list,
but the only reason why I've taken more notice
of it now is because it comes on every Sunday
at 11 .30 right before Power Rangers Samurai
on Nickelodeon. You are so lame. Shut up. Thank
you. Thank you. Shut up. 42. All right, I know
Mike's about to have a fangasm here, but before
he does, I just got to say this is too high for
this show. It does not deserve to be in the top
50. I don't care what Mike says. Number 42 is
Masked Crusaders Working Overtime. Anyway. Yes,
no, thank you so much. I wasn't ready for you
yet, actually. I don't care. 42 is perfect. Okay,
I don't think it should be where IGN put it at
99. I don't think it should be there. I think
it should be in the 90s or 80s somewhere, probably
in the 80s. I voted for 56 just because I knew
a lot of people would leave it off their list.
It should not be top 50. It's a great show for
80s people, and it's cool. and it had a unique
idea and a different take on stuff, but it should
not be top 50, Mike. I know Phil, you, and Christopher
had it in the top 50, but let's be honest. So
did JT. Or that's my man. That's a little too
high. You know, it did only run for two seasons,
and I will fully admit that some of it is extremely
cheesy, especially with Matt Tracker's kid, Scott,
and that little fucking stupid -ass robot, T
-Bob. But one of the reasons why, you know...
that I absolutely loved it is because it's a
different take on... Honestly, it's a combination
of G .I. Joe and Transformers, and it's a different
take on it. And one of the other reasons why
I absolutely love this show is the theme song
and just the way that they did the transformation
of the cars and the people and all that stuff.
It's just great. And I think 42 is okay for it.
It's not top 40. It's not top 30. It's not closer
to the top. But for me, it's kind of like right
in the middle as far as where IGN ranked it and
where we ranked it. The toys were excellent.
The theme song is one of the greatest theme songs
ever. created for a cartoon. I don't know. To
me, I lumped this one in with Bravestar, Silverhawks,
Cops. They should all be, like, 70s, 80s, maybe,
somewhere in there. I don't know. What do you
think, Double D? I never really watched Mask
like I've heard of it. But it wasn't on when
I was watching cartoon shows as a kid. I guess
they just didn't air any reruns, and obviously
I wasn't alive when it was airing. So I just
kind of missed the boat on this one. So I don't
know if it's that good or not. Well, it's not
been on DVD, so you've had no way to watch it.
It's never been released yet. Oh, okay. Yeah,
I wasn't sure. Yeah, I don't really have much
of an opinion on this one. I think that's the
only reason why I sort of missed it on my list
was because I just haven't been exposed to it.
Yeah, I'm fine with it being top 100, but not
top 50. Steve, any thoughts on Mask? I would
have to say I don't really care for the show.
Yeah. It just wasn't one of those ones that I
grew up with or have any recollection of. I don't
know if it should be ranked this high. It's one
of the weird 80s action, just random niche shows
that somehow made it into the top 50. Yeah, and
see, I know it has a following, it has episodes,
it has all that crap, but it's still, I don't
think it's top 50 worthy. I think it should be
in the 60s somewhere. Yeah, and I have to agree
with you only because the fact that they weren't
showing any reruns of this when I was a kid and
that it hasn't really had that much of a lasting
cultural impact. I mean, the people who love
it really seem to love it, but I don't think
it really deserves to be this high. Yeah, I mean,
I'm not trying to rain on the people's parades
that rank this high. I mean, I know Mike and
JT and Phil and Chris were probably happy that
this is this high because none of them wanted
to see it down by 99. But you can't compare it
to those other 80s shows that have had different
incarnations, different stuff released, movies
or DVD sets or this or that. I mean, this does
not quite have the same following that some of
those did. No. 41. To me, this is another one
that you either like it or you don't. The people
that like it like it a lot. I recognize that
it's been on for 13 seasons and 255 episodes.
We're talking about King of the Hill at 41. To
me, I'm not a fan. Does it deserve top 100? Yes.
I'm fine with it where it's at because I don't
want it any higher. Mike? This needs to be much
lower. This needs to be really, really low 70s.
It is a good show, but I don't know. Every time
I catch an episode of this in syndication, because
I know Cartoon Network runs it a lot now on the
overnights. No. It's won a crap load of awards.
It's been on for 13 seasons. It's got some merit.
I just don't think it should be any higher than
it is. I'm fine with it at 41, though. I don't
think it needs to be in the 70s. Steve, do you
have any opinions on King of the Hill? Personally,
I don't think it should be where it's at. I agree
with Mike that it should be in the 70s. Okay.
But this is my reasoning for it. Not only is
the animation a little annoying to me, but the
show is pretty much one of those shows that you
can fall asleep watching because it's so boring.
I would much rather sit there and... Granted,
Simpsons has lost its tune a long time ago, so
I wouldn't sit there and say that it's better
than Simpsons either, but I would rather watch
Family Guy or Futurama over this. This show,
by no means, should be any higher than any of
those. Yeah, but we haven't seen Family Guy or
Futurama show up yet. Well, let's talk about
that before you give your thoughts on King of
the Hill. Since this is one of the first kind
of primetime, more modern cartoons, which other,
I mean, IGN's list was loaded with them. I know
a lot of them are Adult Swim or whatever, but
what other primetime cartoon shows should be
on this list or should we expect to see? If King
of the Hill is at 41, what else should we see?
Futurama, most definitely. Futurama has a great
list. Yeah, I love Futurama. Obviously, Simpsons
and Family Guy we should see. I'm not a huge
fan of Family Guy, but it deserves to be on the
list. Not higher than this, though. Yes, it does.
I'd actually agree with Mike. I'd rank King of
the Hill a little bit higher than Family Guy.
I think King of the Hill was one of the things
I forgot to put on my list. I have like five
or six shows that I just... forgot about to be
honest with you um i don't know i drank family
guy way higher than king of the hill i have to
agree with kevin on this one Well, the thing
is, King of the Hill had more memorable characters,
I think. I disagree. More developed plot lines.
Family Guy, you could have an episode. It probably
had more developed plot lines, but not characters.
Definitely. Family Guy, you could have an episode
that has a five -minute plot of Peter crossing
the road, and the whole time he's crossing the
road, he has flashbacks about thinking about
other times while he's crossing the road, and
that could be a Family Guy episode. I could write
my own Family Guy episode in 20 minutes if I
wanted to. It's just random pop culture. references
but i guess my point is though the you said character
wise characters there's the the characters in
family guy are way more saying family guy they're
a little bit too two -dimensional to be honest
with you and brian come on They're memorable,
but they're not... The characters in King of
the Hill, say what you will about the comedy
or the writing or anything, but the characters
are fleshed out way better in this show. Has
Mike even seen... Mike, have you even seen an
episode of Family Guy? Yeah, I've seen several.
Steve, chime in. I definitely agree with the
fact that characters are more fleshed out in
King of the Hill. I'll give you that. They have
more personality. They have more development.
I agree that they're more fleshed out. I think
they're more memorable in Family Guy, though.
They're more memorable in Family Guy only because
they have these batshit retarded conversations
that you know how it's going to go when they
start it. Yeah. Besides Family Guy, King of the
Hill, and Simpsons, and Futurama, any other primetime
adult cartoons that we should see on this list?
In fact, I don't even know if I can think of
any other ones. No, not really. I can see some
people saying South Park, but that lost its tune
way before Simpsons. I think South Park deserves
to be on the list. Yeah, I agree. Some stuff
that kind of didn't last as long and has been
a little bit forgotten. Obviously, we saw you
guys talked about The Critic the last episode.
Talk about excellent writing. South Park definitely
had some excellent writing. Whether you're a
South Park fan or not, you can't watch some of
those things and not be like, wow, that was clever.
I think also Robot Chicken probably deserves
to be on the list as well. That's not cartoon,
though, is it? Technically, it is. Yeah. I'd
consider stop motion as a form of animation.
Animation, you still have voiceover. You're still
putting a voice to something. So it's still technically
animation because they animate the action figures.
Another one that I love as well that probably
won't be on the list is the Dilbert cartoon.
True. I just think it's interesting that this
is kind of one of the first ones of these that
we've seen, and I'm interested to see what other
ones we have and what our reactions will be as
far as if and when they fall into the countdown.
But I think that kind of wraps it up for this
episode. We've gone from 60 down to 41, so we've
crossed the halfway point. We've given you the
10 on each side of the 50 mark, and we're down
to our top 40. Interested to see what happens
from here. So make sure you tune in to our next
episode to see numbers 40 through 21. And we
would like to thank Double D for giving us the
Twig representation here on this episode. Exactly.
Thanks for being with us. No problem. Thank you
very much. You've just heard 60 through 41 of
the top 100 animated series of all time. Stay
tuned until next time when we reveal 40 through
No chapter markers for this episode.
Hosts
More from GeekCast Radio
All Episodes →
The Top 100 Animated Series: The 15th Anniversary Ultimate Wrap Up!

The Top 100 Animated Series: 25-01 | Part 5 - The 15th Anniversary Countdown

The Top 100 Animated Series: 50-26 | Part 4 - The 15th Anniversary Countdown

The best anime for people who aren’t anime fans are probably the two objectively best anime: the TV series Cowboy Bebop and the collective film works of Hayao Miyazaki (notably the Oscar-winning Spirited Away). They’re slightly more obscure than Voltron or Sailor Moon, but that says more about their marketing than their quality. My dad has little interest in anime, but says Spirited Away is one of his top ten favorite films of all time. Please, if you consider yourselves interested in animation or even film in general, check these out! I’d be very interested to find out what you think of them.
Interesting comments on MASK… Over here in the UK it is still in re-runs and is out on DVD. I guess the “fandom” for the show is bigger over here than in the States. Hence why I ranked it high.
Plus it’s an awesome series!
yesss Phil it’s an awesome series I love it for it’s pure 80’s nostalgia type stuff. Plus there have been rumors that we here in the States will finally get it on DVD.
Overall I really can’t complain much about these selections. In fact, the list so far is shaping up pretty nicely. But, I have a few comments.
Rugrats – This show was amazing. This is why I wish I had submitted a list. There are the cartoons I grew up on in the late 70’s and throughout the 80’s. Then I have the cartoons I watched that my youngest brother grew up on in the late 80’s and early 90’s. So my knowledge of cartoons and favor towards many of them is broader than some. Take Rugrats. Some of you don’t like the show because you weren’t the demographic. But my brother was in love with this show, as well as other Nicktoons, like Doug. Our generation had Smurfs, but his generation had Rugrats and other Nicktoons. As a viewer older than the target demographic, I can say I was thoroughly entertained. It was interesting seeing how the babies saw the world and had adventures. It’s similar to the other shows, like Muppet Babies, which had the same basic premise. For the same reason Smurfs is on the list, Rugrats should be on the list. And I like the ranking it got.
Spongebob – Wow! I would have ranked this MUCH higher. In fact, I would rank this at least top 20 if not top 10. It is a huge cultural phenomenon with toys, a movie, tons of episodes and awards. This show is brilliant. Kids of the past decade, and their parents, ALL know Spongebob. The first three season in particular are pure gold. But even beyond those seasons it still has moments of brilliance. The comment that you have to be high to enjoy it? This is one of the few cartoons that is just zany good fun. They don’t make many cartoons like this anymore.
M.A.S.K. – I watched it, but it has been so long since I’ve seen it that I can only rank it on nostalgia alone. But the theme song freakin’ rocks! One of the best of the 80’s themes.
King of the Hill – It’s one of those shows I always said that I enjoyed it when I watched it, but I never made a point to do so. It really would fit in better in the 70’s or 80’s in the rankings.
Voltron – I love the music in this show. I have the Beast King Golion Volume 1 and without the wonderful score, the show is missing a critical component. Speaking of shows popular for their time, Voltron was HUGE. HUGE. For that alone it deserves a higher ranking. This one is disappointing being ranked outside of the top 50.
MOTU (Cartoon Network version) – A very good update of the classic. Glad it made the list.
Yogi Bear – Awesome. I remember this fondly from my youth. Yogi stealing picnic baskets and eating sandwiches. A Hanna Barbera classic. Not a bad spot, but could rank higher. IGN not ranking it was a travesty.
@rubi-kun: Spirited Away is highly praised, but I couldn’t get into it. Princess Mononoke and Ninja Scroll are two of my favorite animes. For 80’s action cartoon fans, I feel these, and Akira, of course, are probably more your speed.
“yesss Phil it’s an awesome series I love it for it’s pure 80′s nostalgia type stuff. Plus there have been rumors that we here in the States will finally get it on DVD.”
Indeed we are, and my buddy Eamon O’Donohugh is doing the artwork for the DVD! 🙂
I’m glad that both the 2d and 3d clone wars made the list. It was awesome to hear that. I do disagree with which one is better than the other. This is coming from someone who watched and enjoyed both, as they aired. So rating the 3DCW higher, without actually seeing it, I might have an issue with. In general, it’s really apples and oranges, the 2d micro-series was meant to be short and sweet, and the 3D series are a half hour long over multiple seasons.
–
I know you all are not fans of the vector art style of Genndy Tartakovsky, but I absolutely love it. The character designs and art direction of the 2D micro-series are awesome. They used quite a bit of CG in it too, and it fit well. I think people give more credit to narrative story telling, than cinematic. Tartakovsky uses silence, mood, camera angle, things that are visual before using voice narrative. Samurai Jack is a perfect example of that technique.
–
Fast forward to now, with the 3d clone wars… It is a great show, I love it, but there are some stinkers in there. Story gets really slow in a few places. Other technical stuff too that I can spot being an animator, but I won’t get into that. The advantage is that this series expands on so much. New scenery, new characters, a host of cool stuff. All of the art direction is amazing. If you look at the designs, with the sharp angles and hard edges, it takes directly from the 2D micro-series. So I would argue that we wouldn’t have 3d clone wars, without 2d clone wars.
–
Many people are put off by the art style. I understand that. Some see it as more of a gimmick. So I’m actually glad that they continued clone wars in 3d. Just makes sense.
This got a high rating, and well deserved.
I’m fine with where MASK ended up. I loved it a whole lot because it mixed G.I. Joe, Transformers AND Knight Rider!! Well, Season 3 K.I.T.T. anyway. LoL
Other than that, I can’t believe I forgot to place “Spectacular Spider-man” on my list. *hangs head in shame*
Voltron at 54?! I call s’henanigans’, if only because I think it should have been in the top 40 (at the least). The music, the action and the stories made this cartoon (just like “Robotech”) one of the shows that prompted me to take a deeper look at what I was watching. Maybe that’s just me, but that’s how I feel.
I soo agree Voltron should at least have been Top 50 like 46-47
BOOM! Outvoted!
Yogi Bear should be ten to fifteen spots higher. He should be way ahead of any other Hanna-Barbara series of any era, except for maybe Tom & Jerry.
Rugrats should not be higher than Recess. In fact, Rugrats should not be on a list of this kind at all.
The Clone Wars… dead at Grievous’ feet.
I agree with ya neil on Rugrats ugh lol
The Clone Wars RULES that other antiquated animation!!!!
the tick needs to be higher great show
she-ra nothing to say
sailor moon needs to be a little bit lower
freakazoid needs to be higher
spectacular spiderman ok placement
pink pather good placement
voltron ok placement
popeye the sailor man needs to be way higher
smurfs needs to be lower in my opinion
tnmt 2003 vesion very good placement
he-man and the masters of the universe 2002 this one should have been way higher than the 80’s one
star wars the clone wars 2008 again watch the movies way better than the two tv shows
yogi bear ok placement
superman the animated series good placement
rugrats awesome placement
jetsons ok placement
muppet babies ok placement
spongbob square’gay’pants i would only except this if it was #99 only because the frist three seasons. 4 and over don’t watch it get’s very gay
M.A.S.K good theme but i never watched this show
king of the hill needs to be 20 places lower then i would be fine it’s not that funny