Remote Control
Top 100 TV Shows Countdown: 100-76

About this Episode
Hey, this is Steve blue and you are listening
to the geek cast radio network You are listening
to the cast radio network Radio Network's Top
100 Television Show Countdown. Unleash the geek
in you. It's time to get things started because
we at the GCRN are ready to kick off the Top
100 Television Show's Countdown. This will be
unlike any of the previous Top 100 Countdowns.
and it will be cross promoted on three of our
podcasts, Geekcast Radio, The Telecast, and Remote
Control. TF2 and Mike here, and before I hand
the reins over to TV Role, Dan, I just want to
say that Geekcast Radio will be making a huge
comeback for the end of 2015 and the rest of
2016. We've got a number of things lined up to
finally get us to 100 podcast episodes and more.
So joining the countdown, we have Steve Megachon.
Hello. Hello. Optimus Solo, hello. I'm here.
Yes, we know. And T .V. Royal Dan, hello. Hey,
how's it going? Wow. Somehow I think Michael
Wilson should be here too, but anyway. Let's
get to the countdown these hands top 100 TV shows
taking away Dan since you essentially are the
which is my mind It's weird that you're the mastermind
behind the top 100 television shows countdown
because you've told me on multiple Occasions
that you just aren't the TV guy at all Well,
that's kind of recently changed as it gets harder
and harder to go to the movie theater. So it
gets easier to watch TV. So it's kind of I along
with many people are kind of making that transition
as TV is getting better and better. And, you
know, movies are just as good. But, you know,
I can watch great quality television, comfort
my own home, just as good as a movie. And, you
know, not have to go out to the theater and pay,
you know, $20. So it's a it's a it's a comfort.
And, you know, they do say we are in the golden
age of TV, which is one of the reasons we are
kind of doing this. This is the third top one
hundred count. And we're doing this time on TV.
We've done top animated TV series. We've done
top animated movies. We're moving out of the
animated world, looking at live action television.
But animated films are included as long as they
are in those those prime time slots. But. This
is one of the most massive countdowns that we've
had so far. To give you an idea of how big it
is exactly, we've had 29 different lists have
been submitted. Over about 20 different podcasts
are taking part in this. And some of the podcasts
that you're familiar with, some of that helped
us out last time, like Pop At Old Podcast, Wits
Movie Reviews, Kevin Dillon, who was a movie
reviewer as well. A lot of classic partners that
we've had, some new ones that some people you've
heard on. podcast here, like the True Bromance
podcast, the Simplistic Reviews podcast, In Session
Film podcast, a host, and we're actually going
to have a page up, hopefully soon, of all the
different people that are partaking in this.
So it's a massive project. It is KeithCastRadio's
Top 100, but in all honesty, we are one piece
of this gigantic puzzle to try to represent TV
as best that we can. So to give you an idea of
just what we're talking about here with 29 lists
the way it works is based everyone that contributes
provides a list. They rank that list. It's pretty
simple. The higher its rank, the more points
it receives. I combine all those lists and we
make our top 100. Within all the combinations
with all those lists, it was kind of crazy just
seeing the variety of TV shows that got nominations.
So much so that we actually had over 600 shows
got at least one vote from someone. So if you
like a TV show, chances are, even if it's not
in the top 100, someone voided on it someplace.
So I'm going to say this knowing what happened
with the last top 100. This might be... This
might be one of the most unique that we've done
so far. You're going to see a lot of differences.
You're going to see a lot of surprises early
on and often, honestly. So I guess I'll throw
it over to you guys. This is the third time you
guys have done a top 100. I've only been part
of two of them. And Kevin, I know this is unique
for you because you're usually on the other end
of this as the list master going down and knowing
the list going in. This is the first time you're
going in not knowing. How does it feel to be
on the other side? I think it's actually kind
of exciting to not know what the results are
going to be because it's going to be the first
time that I'm actually able to react and not
kind of know what's going to happen ahead of
time because before I knew what the what the
lists were going to be so I kind of knew if this
person was going to react or if that person was
going to react so I was kind of already braced
for that but I like the idea of not knowing it
and especially for a list like this when TV series
you're dealing with So many shows that have existed
and so many different routes that people could
have gone so it's not gonna be like I Have a
feeling it's gonna be very much different than
it like take for example when we did our top
100 animated movies Once you get down to the
nitty -gritty you might not have known the order
But you kind of knew which movies were left that
were gonna show up like in the top 10 top 5 type
of thing So it so it became somewhat easy to
figure out what was still left I don't think
that's going to be nearly the case with this.
I have a feeling we could get down to the number
two show and I still could have a question on
what number one was going to be. Possibly. Hopefully
not because hopefully it's shows that I voted
on, but I just have a feeling it's going to be
a lot more unpredictable and hopefully... I don't
know. It's going to be hard to say. I mean, we've
had different biases that have shown up in both
of the other top 100s. It's hard to say if that's
going to show up here, but I'm excited to be
on this side of the fence for once. Yeah, and
that's true. So one thing I was thinking of with
television is, you know, with movies, if you
look at the best movies of all time, it's pretty
shocking or the most notable movies of all time.
It's pretty shocking to say someone says, I've
never seen Star Wars or Godfather. People are
a little bit more taken back by it. It's more
common to see those. But if you look at the best
TV shows it's a there's not much consensus one
list can really vary from the next and I think
it's more common for people not to see a great
tv show because there's much more of a time commitment
some tv shows are harder to find than others
so with that it's it's harder to kind of nail
down exactly what is technically the best tv
show so we'll kind of see how that lays out here
Steve Kevin mentioned biases and we've seen some
of those biases in the past anything you think
might impact the list overall any type of shows
you feel might populate the list more, any genres
you feel might get higher knowing we are a geek
-centric podcast considering what we've seen
with past Top 100s? Well, I mean, I think in
kind of just slightly touching on what you said
before about the palette of selection here, the
animated films and animated TV series are a lot
less filled as television happens to be. So there's
a lot more selection to choose from here. And
like you said, there's things that there's some
whether they survived or got canceled there.
They all existed. So I think we're going to see
a lot of shows like those hidden gem shows that
you that some of us may have ever heard of. And
we're going to hear about some shows, obviously,
like you're going to see Game of Thrones and
those type of shows like your HBO type shows
or AMC shows. You're going to see a lot of those
probably show up. I'm guessing probably going
to see a lot of the superhero shows show up.
To some capacity, not really sure how. They're
going to be spaced out only because, as you said,
like, personal biases and tastes are going to
come into to play into this, but having so many
other contributors to this, I think that it's
going to make it. It's going to be scary for
everybody to figure out what ended where just
because it's just such a big playing field. This
time around compared to the other two. There's
just there's just so much more that that can
happen Definitely definitely and Mike Do you
have anything that you are hoping to see within
this top 100 anything that you're worried about
seeing as we start this countdown? Only because
of the real -life ramifications and because most
people are not like me that can't separate Real
life from television. I'm kind of worried to
see where the Cosby show is gonna land Because
as much as we all love the show, most people
that I know nowadays are like, oh, I'm not denying
that the guy's a monster, but it's just one of
those things where I can still watch that show.
Where certain things could end up coming to play
because of personal action of the person involved
in the show. can damage the show possibly. I
do want to say something else really quick as
far as some housekeeping things with this Top
100. This Top 100, we're doing it a little bit
differently. Previous two, we've had seven and
six episodes. This Top 100, we're only having
five total podcasts, which is interesting because
this first part is going to be the intro and
numbers 100 through 76. So we're going 25 at
a time instead of... 20 at a time like we used
to so that's again that that's gonna make it
kind of interesting to see where The end of each
podcast is gonna land us, you know, because I
think it's gonna end up being a lot more interesting
of a cliffhanger being in 25s to As we go along
because we're gonna be like damn they didn't
make this 25 block Yeah, absolutely all righty
I did wanna bring up one thing, so we did talk
about how TV is a huge scope, because we're talking
about from... TV from its infancy to today. So
we did try to narrow that scope a little bit.
So if you're curious about like, you know, what
about sports programs, news shows, we did try
to eliminate those also shows like game shows,
reality TV, just because they're harder to compare
to general TV. Maybe we'll do like a top 100
game shows at one point, I don't know. But when
you're when you're talking about such a large
amount of a medium that has so much to choose
from, we did try to at least steer people a little
bit. But even with that steering, We've still
got a variety of different picks and I think
it was really great getting such a huge amount
of feedback and getting a lot of Lists because
it did allow for certain tastes to come out.
So we'll see how that goes. I know with the the
top animated T movies podcast it was early Early
on it was dominated by really recent stuff 20
2000 to 2010. Do we think we're gonna see that
again here? I can I can definitely see that happening.
That's what my biggest question is going into
this whole thing now, obviously we have a different
group of contributors in a different pool that
we're choosing from so maybe that changes things
a lot but my question is more so about not necessarily
maybe the 90s and the in the 2000s as More as
it is the modern, you know, like we talked about
a little bit in some of those past countdowns.
Is it more the modern stuff, the stuff that's
still fresh on your minds or the stuff that's
been in, you know, on repeat for the last five
or 10 years, even if it's not brand new shows?
And I wonder if maybe some of those older shows
have been forgotten or will be lost in the shuffle
or or that type of thing. So my only fear is,
will people be more creating their list based
on what's what comes first to their mind and
what's more modern and what's more in the now?
So I don't know. how that will shake out. Yeah,
and luckily we do actually have another special
guest just joining us and with another member
of the Center of Geeks podcast, Amanda, I do
have to thank you for joining us here. And this
is your top 100 debut. So I don't know if you
listened to the top, the previous top 100 podcasts
or not, but I'm curious to hear what your thoughts
are going into. Yeah, popping the top 100 cherry
tonight. So that should be fun. I think that
this was such a super daunting task for me. I
definitely had to enlist the veteran, Kevin,
over here to get my list made last minute here.
I did see Kevin's list. I think I've seen less
complicated like NASA and stuff like that, just
all the points. So it was intense. So I'm sure
he had a steer. I gave her the simplified version
of that and let her kind of go on her own. He
was coaching me through the whole thing. She
didn't want to eliminate shows. I'm like, you
have to get rid of 27 more shows. I'll just combine.
She's like, can I do that with all these different
shows? I'm like, no. So essentially, you were
her Adam Levine. I don't know what that means.
From the voice? From the voice. Duh, dummy. He
still has his hair, though. Otherwise, we would
not be in a relationship anymore. I'm part Adam,
part Blake, I guess. I don't know. Yeah. Wait
a second. You made the image of me being Blake.
What the hell's wrong with you? Come on now.
It's a long time ago. Yeah, it was, wasn't it?
I have no idea what's going on right now, but
who thought the first TV show we talked about
today in the top 100 countdown would be The Voice?
Well, there you go. It's not eligible, folks.
No. I'm going to channel my inner Gwen Stefani
and get this going. All right. Well, without
any further ado, let's get the countdown started.
One hundred. All right. Well, starting the countdown
at number 100, we talked about like the top 100.
animated movies started off in a lot of the 2000s,
2010s. Well, we're actually starting in the good
old 1989 with Show I think that I think Kevin
and Mike and I know it holds a special place
in your all heart and I know Amanda as well because
You were the top rinker with this as number 100
is none other than saved by the bell. This is
a travesty Kind of surprised honestly, it was
on nine lists received a total of 394 points.
So just give you an idea of what that means is
in order to get in the top 100 you needed to
score 394 points and consider one list someone
is ranked at one it would receive 100 so that
lets you know that in order for a show to get
on this it had to get had to be had a lot of
a claim for this one it ranked 9th so it was
on a good number of lists it just was not ranked
very high the highest rink here like I mentioned
was Amanda as she ranked it all the way up at
number 14 so Amanda let's start with you here
are you a little a little sad to see it go already
no I mean, I'm a big fan. I think that it holds
a lot of nostalgia for a lot of people, even
today. And I think that it, I don't know if it
really deserves much more acclaim than they got.
It tried to do its spin -off thing and I don't
think that was successful. So we'll hold the
higher spots for those that can hold out a little
bit better. The college years was awesome, no
matter what anyone says. It lasted a long time.
Sadly new class was the longest part of that
series I know I believe you've you did say by
the bell for the telecast so Considering that
how do you feel about it making the top 100?
Should it make the top 100 should it be higher
or what are your thoughts? I think if I'm ranking
my personal favorite shows, it probably has a
shot of making them top 100 especially if I'm
not narrowing that focus by going for a specific
type of show, primetime or different genres or
that type of thing, I actually didn't rank Safe
by the Bell on my list. I felt like I shouldn't
rank Any of the ones that to me it's I was looking
more I guess as primetime TV shows and I kind
of eliminated a lot of the more afternoon or
Saturday type shows So it was just a personal
thing to help me get down to my 100 that I eliminated
all of those types of shows and I figured that
was also a good way to get some of my bias out
of it because I would have voted for a lot of
these as far as personal favorites, but it did
not make my countdown. That's where I was. I
had a block there. I was like, so I can't just
put all my favorite shows on here. This actually
has to be some shows that are good that I don't
think are good. Who doesn't know the Saved by
the Bell theme song? Who doesn't, you know, understand
the references? It's one of the few shows I want
to own on DVD or Blu -ray or whatever so I can
watch whatever I want. I just couldn't rank it
in the top 100, personally. I want a Zach Morris
cell phone, okay? Don't we all, don't we all?
Steve, so we're at number 100 with Saved by the
Bell. You say you own Saved by the Bell, and
I know in past lists we saw a lot of our childhood
favorites tend to dominate the list. What does
that say to you, do you think, knowing that we're
already seeing a show like Saved by the Bell
within the top 100 at the very 100 spot? I mean,
I'm glad it hit the list, at least, but I kind
of understand where it's at, because as far as
writing, while it was strong for what it was,
and it was kind of a groundbreaker at the time,
compared to other shows that have come since
that, I don't think that it's as acclaimed anymore
as it was. I think it gets more acclaimed in
nostalgia glasses than anything else. Yeah, I
think that makes any sense sometimes you see
that with with those shows though I gotta say
it was it's one of the I think there are some
interesting aspects of it I know like what it
was a Jimmy Fallon who did that that skits of
bringing back the The classic Saturday Night
Live and there's still a lot of love out there
So it could be on nostalgia who knows it's been
a very long time since I saw it Mike I know the
first words out of your mouth was travesty. It
did not take very long for that to happen So
is it travesty for it because it's too high too
low or because it is it came in at 100 I would
expect something to come in at 100 at like Gotham
or you know something horrible to come in at
number 100. I hope nothing horrible makes the
list. Well you never know. Beggars can't be choosers.
Was Saved by the Belt it was a generational thing
it was one of those things one of those shows
that we grew up on it was one of those shows
that I remember watching it after Saturday Morning
Cartoons. When Saved by the Bell started until
when it ended, I remember getting up 6, 7, 8
a .m. every Saturday watching cartoons till 11
30 or noon and then after that Saved by the Bell
was on whether it was reruns or whatever. Did
you ever play outside or is your Saturdays all
TV? Yeah, it's all TV. He doesn't believe in
the outside, come on now. No, the outside world
really, really, really sucks. He burns us, he
burns us precious. Shut up. I thought you were
going to say the outside world rejects you. He's
like the kid on that movie with... For a second
there, I really thought you were going to make
a Bubble Boy reference. I was going to have to
punch you. No, I wasn't going to say Bubble Boy.
It's the one with David Spade and Rob Schneider
and the brother of David Spade in the movies
sits inside a closed room and eats sunscreen.
Black Sheep? No, that's... Anyway, whatever.
This is TV, not movies. Saved by the Bell. I
love the show. I don't think I've seen any episodes
since. We did the telecast episode for the review
of the series. It's just not something, like
I said a second ago, a little while ago, I personally
can watch the college years more than I can watch
the rest of Saved by the Bell. But, you know,
hey, it's that 100, it's kicking things off and
who knows. Alrighty, well, let's get over to
number 99 and let's just say we're about to hit
a milestone already. 99. Yes, that's right. We're
already hitting a milestone. The reason being
we're already seeing someone's number one come
off the board and we're only two shows in and
I gotta say of all the shows that we talked about
today this might be one of my biggest surprises
because it's a show I forgot existed before I
started doing this countdown and that at number
99 we have the adventures of briscoe county jr
someone had it ranked all the way up at number
one it was on only on six lists but that number
one rank really did push it up it only beat save
by the bell by four points so it was quite a
squeeze there what I know it's second for a second
there. I thought you were saying quite a screech
there I'm like, wait a second was quite a speech
there How does a series that was on for one season
make somebody's number one? That's a good question.
It is. Well, yeah, I know it's it's again TV
has a huge variety. So kev I personally am not
well versed in the ventures of briscoe county
jr Any any response of seeing it come on the
list at number 99? I can honestly tell you I've
never seen an episode of it. It was on in 1993,
which I was like 12 and it was only on for like
a year. You were 12 and 93? Shush. So I mean,
it was only on for a year. I mean, I like westerns,
but I don't remember this being something that
anybody was talking about. I mean, it's pretty
unacclaimed. That's how you want to say it. So
this must be a personal favorite of somebody's.
Steve any any reaction to briscoe county jr.
I'm kind of surprised that it's actually beating
saved by the bell Yeah, I mean again the power
i'm surprised that it's i'm surprised that it's
beating 700 other shows That's my point is one
season and it's it's this Wow, I do know actually
doing some research it does have quite the cult
following It was one of those shows that many
felt was canceled far too soon It had that death
slot of being on a Friday at 8 38 o 'clock where
it was well received at the time But certainly
the ratings did not did not show and also had
considering it didn't have that The geek icon
Bruce Campbell who actually said this was his
favorite thing he ever did So it does have his
stamp of approval. So there so there are some
positives of the show Mike, I'm not sure if you,
I know it wasn't on your list, but any thoughts
of seeing Griscode County, Jr.? I used to love
this show. How did I know that? Here's the thing
with this show though, the show was weird for
me because they didn't play in between Waddock,
Texas Ranger and Nash Bridges 90 chance. 93 was
before and Nash Bridges was 96. Oh, my bad. but
i remember this was this was weird for me because
it was like adventures of briscoe county jr then
the x -files so that was back when it was on
was this on the same time as like the young indiana
jones or something like that i remember because
i don't remember that show but i think so risk
adventures of briscoe county jr was a really
weird show because they had like one or two or
that they had a series of the episodes that they
told this story about the whole John Bly character
and everything else and then all of a sudden
they ended that immediately and then went into
some serialized thing it was like the show changed
mid -tempo and after that arc kind of stopped
I kind of lost interest in it I mean don't get
me wrong I love Bruce Campbell in this show this
is the first show first time I was ever introduced
to him as an actor oh what the heck I'll call
you. Five kings. Five aces. It's okay, boys.
Put your guns away. You cheated me fair. We are
gonna get something out of this, though, because
I think this show being on here will spawn...
five years from now, us doing like the top 100
one season shows that didn't make it through
one season. The top 100 one hit wonders. Well,
there actually is a TV guide list of the top
100 or the top 60 shows that were canceled too
soon. But I mean, I didn't want to get your opinion
on this if you have one. I don't know if you
even know the shows existed. But any thoughts
on Briscoe County Junior? I have never even heard
of the show and I think I'm OK with that. Good
to know. Good to know. I mean, you could catch
up on it real quickly. It's probably only 13
episodes or something. I don't know if that's
something I want to commit to. It might last
shorter than this episode. Who knows? We'll see.
All right. All right. So. That's it for number
99 and what that does tell you though is Though
being number one on the list does get you someplace
that you can see that does not get you very far
You need you need to be on a lot of lists You
need to get a lot of people loving your show
in order to make this top 100 Let's get on to
the next of the countdown 98 All right. Well,
so we had a huge surprise already. We're gonna
take a quite a trip though because very different
in genre a little bit more more current actually
the most current show we're getting to so far
and we're going to go into the first show we
see on a cable network show as we get into our
number 98 with it's always sunny in philadelphia
the fx comedy it was on nine lists the highest
it was ranked was 28 so unlike briscoe county
junior it did not get ranked very high one thing
coming into this we talked about being on different
networks, being on cable that would have any
impact on this show, knowing that you're going
to the big thing with these is being able to
have exposure and having people seen it. So I
know I was the only one on the panel currently
that did rate the It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia.
And I got to say, I am definitely really happy
you made the list. I wasn't sure where it would
rank. It's deserving. I think it's actually at
a pretty good spot. I think I had it ranked higher
in my list, but I understand it being ranked
here. It's the type of comedy Let's just say
it, there's nothing it won't do, for sure. What
are you doing? It is two in the morning. I was
sleeping, Dennis. Let's cool it up now, baby.
So let's do some yachts. No, I don't drink. You
know that. I think it makes people look ugly.
I... Maybe I should go to my room. That is not
your room anymore. It is my craft studio. So
kindly stay out of there. Don't forget, dude.
It's all good, dude. She turned it into a craft
studio where she makes terrible sweatshirts out
of cats or puts cats in sweatshirts. And then
I'm like, dude, what the hell did you do? Dennis,
do not talk to me that way. I am your wife. Please
show me some respect in front of your friends.
That was honestly almost canceled after the first
season, but luckily with Danny DeVito coming
on, which is a weird thing to see in the second
season, it really took off, and it's a show that's
not really afraid to offend people in any way,
and I think it really set the stage for what
was to come with FX comedies. Amanda or Kevin,
any thoughts on It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia?
Uh, I've seen... I would say a handful of episodes,
but I laughed the whole time and it does go there.
I mean, didn't somebody poop the bed? It wasn't
that a thing. That's the one of the more tame
things that happened. Within the second season,
you see people on welfare in smoking crack. Just
for fun. So that's again, there's there's, you
know, it's if you see shows like Saddle Park,
other though it's around the same vein. But again,
it's I would say it's more than shock comedy
because it's what it does with it. I think especially
the characters are kind of very, very interesting.
Think it's all it's a dumb comedy, but there's
also so many plot twists that you're like what?
It's one of those shows that kind of creates
its own language in a way with the different
things it does and then you have something like
one of its characters just purposely gaining
weight because he just gives you notices that
Most characters and TV shows look better as a
series goes on so he just wants to reverse that
but it has nothing to do with the show He just
does it for the effect of it, but uh Kevin Mike
anything to say on it's always funny It's one
of those shows, there's a handful of comedies
that were out in that time period in the mid
2000s up to where we're at today that I have
nothing against, but for some reason I just haven't
sat down to catch up on. And I like Danny DeVito,
so I think I would like it. I've probably seen
maybe an episode or a couple parts of episodes.
I just hadn't seen enough of it to fully put
it on my list, which But that doesn't always
eliminate shows from being put on my list, but
that in combination with some other things kept
it off of my list. But it's something that I
need to catch up with. I think me and D should
be best buds. I think we hang out with all the
time. It is available in a lot of places. You
can stream it on Hulu. It's available on Netflix.
And I think Amazon Prime as well. So if it's
a show, it's one actually I started, I caught
up a little bit when we were doing this list.
I wanted to watch more of it. So it's a, it's
better as it goes on. And a show that's been
on for at least 10 seasons deserves some credit.
Yeah, considering it was with an FX when it was
in its infancy, I think. That rule depends on
the show, because there's some shows that lasted
10 seasons that could have only lasted five in
actual good quality content. Looking at you,
Smallville, as far as it's always sunny, all
I can think of is, oh my god, that's the friggin'
penguin. What is he doing there? Don't worry,
I warned Amanda about your references. That was
a little bit more common than I was expected.
He is far from the penguin in this. He even looks
shorter than he is when he's the penguin in this.
At least he doesn't have the fins. You don't
know that. Steve, I did have a question for you.
Knowing this is our first show from not a major
network, do you think it has any indication of
what's to come on the list? I'm really sure.
Like, I have this feeling that we're gonna see
a lot more shows with Vane pop up because I have
this feeling that everybody else likes these
kind of shows. I am not one of these people,
but it's not necessarily, it's more so because
I don't get cable. So, and I don't have all,
I don't subscribe to all these things, so what
I watch is on the basic cable channel, so. Lot
of my rankings are from that or from what I have
had cable in the past. I Think that a lot of
these type shows the landfx HBO You know em see
like I said before I think a lot of these are
gonna show up to some capacity Yeah, and like
I said, that's a good point. So because some
with TV unlike movies Accessibility can impact
you know the way a show falls on this list contrary
to popular belief We are not professional movie
critics or TV critics. I know it's hard to believe
I know but because of that Time accesses will
possibly have an impact on what people go for
so keep that in mind Alright, and let's just
say we're kind of getting back to old times as
we get into our next in the countdown 97 Yes,
well, it did not take long for us to enter familiar
ground as with it's only at number 97 and we're
already in and we're already back to the world
of animation with The Flintstones at number 97.
Most notably, as we mentioned, primetime animated
shows are eligible and sometimes people forget
that The Flintstones was not actually a Saturday
morning cartoon show, but it was designed for
adults and designed for primetime. Steve, Mike,
we ended with you last time, so let's start with
you here. We're starting with an animated show
already. You're surprised that we're already
getting back to the world of animation? A little
bit, because I just never remembered the Flintstones
in prime time. I remembered it in Saturday morning
reruns. Do you think it's deserving of a top
100 TV countdown? Oh, it is. I mean, it's essentially
an animated version of The Honeymooners. But,
you know, it's just one of those things where
I felt when we were creating the rules for the
countdown that... the animated show should have
been axed because we've already done that you
know I mean I get its importance I get all that
but this is supposed to be about live action
not animation I disagree with that. I'll strongly
disagree with that. And let's just say, you know,
we'll see why as we as we continue to count down.
Well, Amanda hasn't done any of that. So we're
going to just veto that and say, yes, that fluence
condom should be on there because I said so.
And I can't argue with that. So, Amanda, are
you knowing that you think it belongs? Do you
think it should be higher? Is it in a good spot?
What are your thoughts? I think it's a good spot.
I don't think it's a high enough caliber in the
animation field as like a Simpsons or something
along that lines. I think maybe it could have
been a little higher, but yeah. Sure That's that's
that sounds it sounds right about right Kevin
I know you ranked Flintstones really high when
it came to the animated series countdown But
comparing it to TV is a different piece because
you're you know, you're comparing it to other
comedies rather than other other animated TV
series So it's kind of on the other end of the
list here. Is that Show you that animation maybe
is not respected as much as live -action. What
is that? Do you think that says about the Flintstones?
Well, what number are we on? We're on 90 97 I
rank this 96, so I'm pretty happy with it. But
the main reason why I think it deserves to be
on here is I think people forget three different
things. Number one, they forget that it was a
primetime show. And number two, I think they
forget the impact that it had on animation and
on the ability of a prime of an animated show
to be in primetime and not just be there but
to compete with the top rated shows. This was
a show that was nominated for an Emmy. This was
a show that was in the top 20 rated primetime
TV shows one of its years and it was in the top
32 of its years. So it's not something that was
just some fly in the pan or flash in the pan
type animated show that Made headlines, but nobody
really watched it. I mean, this was a successful
Milestone impact -making animated show and yes
It does have a lot of ties to other live -action
shows like Mike mentioned, but I don't think
that can be discounted I don't I'm not saying
there's a million animated shows that belong
in this but there's definitely a handful and
it's one of them I mean, did you see the movie
that they made? Let's not talk about that. That
might actually hurt. Never mind. The sequel to
that movie was even worse, but John Goodman was
easily the best live -action Fred Flintstone
in 1994. Oh, ever. There's stiff competition
for that. Moving on. Steve, any thoughts on the
Flintstones before we move on to the next one?
Well, it was kind of like when we were... Developing
the idea of this of animation entering into this
I I was like initially against it Because like
Mike had said we had done it. However It's hard
to discount the relevance of this show or the
shows that it's spawned from it Because if we
wouldn't have had the Flintstones, we wouldn't
have had you know, your family guy the Simpsons
I mean because essentially these these like comedy
family kind of things that are going on spawned
from that and So without having that strong foundation
of something to kind of play off of I don't think
that we would have the What we have today and
in the animation world that's in the other primetime
spectrum Definitely definitely and like Kevin
mentioned this was a show that was legit when
it came out so much though It was the first as
Kevin mentioned the first animated show ever
to be nominated for a primetime Emmy not the
daytime any Emmy not like some random Award that
doesn't matter was nominated for best outstanding
comedy series. So it unlocks the loss to another
classic show that the Jack Benny show So again,
it's a highly respected show So I know I too
growing up just assumed it was Saturday morning
cartoon show But when you go back and look at
it, it kind of makes sense that it wasn't so
alrighty Let's move on to the next in the countdown
and let's just say one person in the panel Might
not be too happy with what we have in store 96.
All right things might start getting real as
we saw a number one off the board and we are
about to see a number two come off the board
as at number 96, we have Supernatural. God damn
it! Yes, as you can see, a lot of lovers of Supernatural
on the panel. It was on seven lists. It was highest
ranked as number two, like I mentioned, by none
other than Steve Megatron Phillips. So it's fitting
that we start with you, Steve. Seeing your number
to go off the board. I know how that feels cuz
last last time we did this mine My number two
was off the board at a hundred So at least you
beat my number two from last time but the little
little upset seeing it fall this low already.
Ah Surprisingly, yes. Oh, that's such a pain
because the last two top 100s mine at least made
it to the top five Yeah, this is This is real
rough on me because I've been watching the show,
my wife and I have been watching it since just
before the second season aired. We picked it
up at like a video store and started watching
the blitz through the whole first season and
since have watched it religiously. And for a
show that has gone on this long, I'm surprised
to see it this end of the spectrum. Like I was
expecting maybe like the, you know, the top 50,
but not like the bottom feeder edition of the
top 100. So yeah, this is kind of painful to
watch this fall this early. I've been there.
I've been there. We're going to start our own
little counseling sessions as we talk about our
top shows going down way too early. And Amanda,
I think I heard you also not too happy seeing
this fall already. So a little a little shock
that Supernatural is already coming down the
board. Jensen Ackles is my future ex -husband.
He just doesn't know it yet. This was originally
your number two. This should have been. If we
were doing a personal list, this would have been
my number one show, hands down. It came in at
my number five just because I felt like I had
to put some more high caliber, better accepted
shows on my list higher. But this has to be my
favorite show ever. I've seen the season several
times. All the reruns, as soon as it's on TV,
the new episode, I want to see it. I follow them
all on Twitter, on Facebook, anything and everything.
I've got t -shirts in the closet right now. She's
not lying. And I just cannot. Understand why
it's so low. I don't get it probably because
it's a bunch of dudes that can't appreciate some
sexy men killing ghosts Hey, we hey, we love
the Ghostbusters. I don't know what you're saying
Dan Ackroyd's not sexy come on Maybe not that
Dan Ackroyd now, but then It just keeps getting
bigger, but yeah, I think this is a travesty
so That that's probably the the biggest hit I'm
gonna take this whole show So it's okay up to
this point. We've seen a Western we've seen Comedy
we've seen a kids show we've seen a cartoon and
and now a fantasy TV show Is it seem kind of
odd seeing such a mixture of genres and we've
only a few episodes few shows in so far I don't
know if I would say odd I may be surprised at
those genres being the ones, and there's a few
that we haven't seen represented yet that I would
definitely expect to see very soon. I had this
one ranked number 93, so I'm still happy. I'm
doing good so far. Was there like a fantasy draft
kings or something that we entered this? I don't
know, but nobody entered any fan duel stuff.
I'm just liking my chances so far being the most
accurate list. Do we have a pummel list for people
that rank things? inaccurately yeah i have it
on my list there was only what nine or seven
for this one there's nine nine people rank this
hey i'm one of nine i'm one of nine yeah okay
so you're you're not bad i gave us points yeah
considering that's that's 20 people that you
have them on that pummel list so i gotta you
gotta consider that i'm safe so far no eye poking
for me i'll find them down all righty well we're
gonna return to familiar ground with our next
on the list so 95 Yeah, that's right. Well, we
talked about one FX comedy, and we're going to
go talk about another one. And I'm not sure how
much we're going to have with the panel today,
but I got to say I'm happy to see this on the
list because it is one of my current favorite
shows. We have Louie. Again, another FX show.
It was on nine lists. It was as highest ranked
as 11. An average rank of 41. So no one ranked
it super high except for maybe one person. I
got to say, I am a huge fan of the Louie show.
It's odd. It is a show without structure, in
a way. There's no predictability from episode
to episode, season to season. Different characters,
different actors play different characters. You
never really know what you're gonna get. It is
like Forrest Gump and a box of chocolates in
that way. Very, very happy. All you have to do
is go on YouTube and tell everybody that I did
not steal your material. I never said that you
stole my jokes. You never said it, but you let
other people say it. What let? I can't tell people
what to say. You're full of sh... Dane, look.
You know what? I'm excited that you're in this
room right now, because I've waited four years
to tell you this. Do you know that you're 2006?
2006? Yes, 2006. You don't really say 2006. It's
2006. 2006 is like saying the year 2000 and,
by the way, the number six. 2006 was the greatest
year of my entire life. I had a double platinum
comedy album, first one ever to exist. I had
a massive HBO special. I was on the cover of
Time. Well, you were on the corner, that little
corner thing that wasn't... Not like when the
president is on the cover. 2006. That should
have been like my triumph. And I enjoyed it,
Louie, for maybe two months. Two months before
it started to suck, because everything I read
about me was about how I stole jokes from you,
which I didn't. I kind of think you did. Dude,
why would I steal three jokes from you when I
have hours of material? Why? Why would I do that?
Risk my reputation? Because they were funny jokes,
but it's also just you know really funny coming
from the mind of Louis CK and what's kind of
cool about it for those that don't know is that
Louis did not want to do a TV show and F actually
wanted him to do one so they kind of just said
hey Do whatever you want and that's what he did
and did did it to routing success because it
is on our list It is coming with a pedigree.
It has won multiple golden. It's been nominated
for multiple Golden Globe Awards It's won multiple
Emmys for best writing best directing Lead actor
for louis ck. So it is well regarded one of the
most decorated shows of today I know amanda.
You said you watched it's always sunny. Do you
ever catch louis? Um, i've seen little snippets
and I think that his Because he does he have
like a sarcastic dry kind of like ass. Holy humor
Is that's only actually a good good word good
word to use. I would say he's definitely uh Unfiltered
in a way. I would say and it's like the R rated
version of Seinfeld if you want to put it that
way Yes, I Agree that it's decorated and I think
that gives it some credence I mean it hasn't
been it's only been on for what five seasons
and it already has, you know multiple Awards
to go with it. So it's obviously well done. I
don't get That channel and I've never seen it
so I can't speak for it But I don't think too
many people would have a problem with it showing
up on the countdown Definitely not and I will
say again I no longer have cable but it is I
did try to look at shows that Are currently streaming
some people didn't want to check this out. This
is one that is currently streaming on on Netflix
So if you wanted to check it out I will say it's
first season a little rough around the edges
but it really kind of hit its strides season
2 season 3 and Don't go in expecting the same
type of roles you would you would see for a normal
sitcom because it kind of just does its own thing
it's sometimes it'll just be a random like side
story sometimes it's like a combination of short
stories within a TV show it's it's really cool
on that end like it's just like him trying to
really rewrite the rules of TV so all right well
let's move on to our next show and let's just
say well we're gonna be talking about an icon
and we might see some uh some strong reaction
to where this show falls uh -oh 94 all right
yes i'm talking about an icon so much so we we
had one number one on our list fall and we had
one number two Guess what? We're having another
number one fall and it's our first sketch comedy
TV show of the day And that is none other than
the Carol Burnett show one of the most decorated
shows of its time and We've been kind of in our
current period of time so we're taking some trip
back and I know this is a show that's unique
in the sense that it's a show that I think was
before much of our childhood so I was actually
surprised to see it ranked so well. It was on
seven list and as I mentioned is ranked as high
as number one. An average rank of 40 so for the
most people did not rank it above top 25 top
30 so it's kind of why it's falling here. Mike
any thoughts on seeing the Carol Burnett show
at number 96? It deserves to make the list, but
at the same time, I do not remember any sketches
from this thing. Didn't she have, like, a sweet
wig and she dressed up like an old lady? She
did a lot of things. Kevin, any thoughts on The
Carabinette Show? Yeah, I mean, I guess I should
be happy that it's on the countdown. I would
make the argument that it should be higher. I
think this is what I was talking about in the
introduction where I said I was afraid that maybe
some of the older shows would fall. fall to the
wayside or get lost in the shuffle. So I am glad
it made the countdown. I think it deserves a
little bit more credit. It was on 11 seasons.
Out of those 11 seasons, it was nominated for
awards, 10 of them. It was in the top 30 of the
TV ratings for eight of those 11 seasons and
this was something that really shaped the landscape
of sketch comedy in a way I mean there was a
lot of sketch comedy shows back in that time
period in the early TV days all the way up through
the 60s and 70s heading into like stuff like
Saturday Night Live and etc, but I just think
some of the stuff that she Did was amazing. And
if anybody is a like a night owl, I'm sure you've
seen like the Carol Burnett clips in like some
type of 2am infomercial because they used to
play all the time. But yeah, that's kind of funny
how I remember it too much that such I would
see are the commercials and tell me to buy VHS
tapes all the time. So Yeah, I'm just happy it's
on the list. I guess it was interesting to it
actually had a revival series in the 90s I think
I when I when I caught it cuz my my parents were
a big fan of the show and it came out and it
has a Huge impact. I think that the kind of the
bad thing about a variety show or a sketch could
show like this one It doesn't you don't see it
in reruns a lot So for many of us when it being
before our time It's not something that's gonna
get syndicated not something you're seeing like
a Nick at night or something like that So it's
like it doesn't necessarily have that staying
power. So it may be why you know those That did
experience it really loved it. Like I mentioned
already up to number one number one on one person's
list So those people that were probably you had
the opportunity to see it did enjoy it a great
deal as Kevin mentioned it was huge success of
its time, but I ranked it number 19. So obviously
I'm in support of it. Yeah, sure Steve any thoughts
on the carabine show Well, I did forget that
show I do remember watching clips of it. I guess
I just never associated name with Stuff I've
watched of it and it was normally late night
stuff and in when you're up playing video games
late at night and everything and you had the
TV on for background sound I you know, I've caught
stuff like that and the crazy old lady skit where
you know She's wearing the grandma's wig and
everything. So I mean like I'm familiar with
a lot of the stuff in it. I It's nice to see
an older show With such a following actually
show up in the list Regardless, it was come before
or after it. Yeah, definitely, definitely. So
that's one thing. We're at number 94 right now,
and we're seeing a yin -yang of years. We've
not really stated one period of time for longer.
And, well, next one's going to be kind of interesting.
I think it's going to lead to some fun discussion.
So let's get to it. 93. I'm going to start this
by asking you all a question. Can you actually
tell me? Can you tell me how? Can you tell me
how to get? to Sesame Street because that is
our number 93 show Sesame Street. I was shocked
to see this on the list. It was on eight lists
as high as ranked. It did not get ranked super,
super high. The highest it was ranked was twenty
eight. So no nowhere in the top 10 top 15. But
Mike, let's start with you. You I know you had
some thoughts on the show, like saved by the
bell and where it landed. What do you what did
you think about Sesame Street coming in here?
This is just crazy. It goes to show what we said
in the intro about where shows are gonna fall.
It's just gonna affect us all very differently.
Yeah, Sesame Street was very groundbreaking.
It was probably the first show most of us in
the 80s saw as kids. It was one of those morning
shows where that's where we got our morning lessons
before we actually went off to school. Yeah,
I mean, it's definitely had a huge impact on
our childhood. Kev, I know what you said was
saved by the bell. You kind of didn't include
it because you were mostly focused on more prime
time action shows and prime time shows. So I
know Sesame Street did not make your list, but
how do you feel about it ranking here in the
top 100? I mean, if you hear the term top 100
television shows of all time, it makes sense
to include something like Sesame Street, just
like it. Flintstones, just like Saved by the
Bell for the impact and for kind of the type
of genre they were and being kind of the best
of those genres. And nobody can obviously argue
with its longevity. Again, I left it off my list
because I guess in my focus, I was in order to
try to come down to 100. I was mainly thinking
about primetime television shows. But as far
as, like I said, hearing the phrase top shows
of all time, Sesame Street should be in the conversation.
It certainly makes sense. I mean, it does have
some primetime acclaim. It's actually won six
primetime Emmys for its different primetime specials.
So it has some pedigree there. It's actually
kind of insane because there's actually some
surveys done in the latest S2006 that says 95
% of all American children have watched System
Street at one time or another. So it certainly
has impact. It has won over 159 Emmy awards.
And also, if you took some type of statistic
as to which show has been seen by more people,
in more countries in the world, I would guess
that Sesame Street would be number one on that
list. It sure would rank there. Steve, let's
move over to you. What are your thoughts on seeing
Sesame Street at number 93? It definitely deserves
to be on the list. I mean, it's been around since
the, what, the 60s? And then it's had multiple
iterations across, you know, worldwide. And then
the fact that it's got probably one of the longest
running series ever. And the fact that everybody's,
like you guys have said, everybody's watched
it at some point in their life. Amanda, any thoughts
on Sesame Street? Yeah, I watched Sesame Street
just as much as anybody growing up. I watched
it in preschool. I know all the characters. I
think that it was not... as dynamic as some of
the shows. I think it stayed what it was for
a very long period of time until it kind of made
itself a little bit more modern. Bringing in
Elmo, I thought that was really, really fun.
I like him as a character, not just the Oscar
the Grouch. Burton Ernie and all those guys I
don't think he was a part of the original cast
was he he just brought in a little bit later
No, he was part of the original cast. I remember
him Elmo was not when he first debuted to is
more like a caveman He wasn't like the Elmo we
know and love they kind of switched him around
and to what he is now Yeah, he's more of the
focus of the show now, which is the the I think
the key thing there right Yeah, it's shifted
gears a little bit, but I think that they made
a little bit more PC a little bit more now and
I think they've been able to grow with. Yeah,
and most shows can't reinvent themselves as successfully
as Sesame Street has to become relevant and can
stay relevant. And you got a little some of its
pop culture references it's done, like some references
like Game of Thrones and Mad Men. They're pretty
incredible what it can do. And one thing I would
advise seeing is there's actually a documentary
that came out this year, I Am Big Bird, which
talks about Lewis Carroll and his work as Big
Bird. I think that kind of shows you just how
much impact Sesame Street can have. looking at
one specific character so I too didn't rank my
list and just some behind the scenes I did provide
everyone a master list and this was actually
even included in the master list because I just
didn't even think of it but so it was actually
written in by people so that's how much people
love it they loved it so much it was a write
-in campaign to get it on this list so maybe
if I included it would have been higher I'm not
sure but uh it's cool ground roots people have
spoken I know, I know. It's insane. There was
an online campaign. It was crazy. It's Kickstarter,
I think. All right. Any other thoughts on Sesame
Street before we move on? All righty. Well, this
next one's going to be fun, so I'd just say I
could see some people not looking what we're
going to be having for our number 92 slot. 92.
I talked about Prisco County Junior was maybe
the most surprising show because I never really
heard of it. this show is most surprising because
i didn't think anyone liked it and that is none
other than agents of shield is showing up at
number 92 it was on seven list highest ranked
as number nine a show that i tried to watch it
and could not get through it steve we ended with
you last time let's start with you here thoughts
about agents of shield coming in at number 92
i hit my top 20 but that's it's at the high end
of it but um i would say that The show has actually
kind of gotten to its own now, as sad as it's
taken it three seasons to get there. I have kept
up with it. The first season, like the beginning
of it, it was kind of, you know, playing with
the mystery of Colson. Then you get it to the
end and it's really weak when it's not surrounded
by a movie. However, season two did pick it up
a lot better than season one did. And then after
Age of Ultron, it seems like this series can
actually hold on its own now. It is sad it's
taken it three seasons to do that on its own,
but it has gotten a lot better than what it once
was Mike did you watch agents of shield at all?
I made it through five episodes of season one
I've never gone back to it and I probably won't
until it gets cancelled Do you think it deserves
top 100? No, honestly Just sheer out of season
one out of what I've seen no Amanda, let's go
to you next. Do you think agents of shield is
kind of getting some love because of the Marvel
movies? Do you think without those it would make
this list? Yeah, I think it's totally dragon
on the coattails of the films. Um, I love the
Marvel universe I love all the movies, but this
show I could not get behind I think I only made
it through a few minutes of an episode and I
just was completely disinterested but the more
I hear people you know, getting hooked on this
show, it makes me want to watch it, but I feel
like I'm so far behind now, I'm not sure if I
want to binge and really try to get on board
with this. Kevin, any thoughts on Agents of S
.H .I .E .L .D.? Well, we've never been accused
of having a superhero bias, have we? Once or
twice, once or twice. OK. I mean, this is a product
of being a superhero show, a Geekcast radio network,
as the name of our website. It's also a modern
show, so I guess it's fresh on people's minds.
But for someone to rank this number nine of all
time, that's got to be... I don't know. He's
British, so... That person has not seen a lot
of TV. But I, man, I can't watch this. I'm still
trying to catch up with like more legit superhero
TV shows. So I'm still trying to catch up with
Arrow and Flash and... waiting for more Daredevil
and stuff like that, so I have no time for Agents
of Shield. Do you think it's a sign of more superhero
shows to come? If this is on there and those
other, I would be shocked if we don't see at
least a half dozen more. Alrighty. Any other
thoughts on Agents of Shield before we move on?
I'm interested to see where... Agent Carter comes
into play here, then doesn't she have her own
show? She does, she does. Is she your number
one? Is there any, Dan I gotta ask you a question
before we go any further. Are there any shows
that made the countdown that haven't actually
aired any episodes yet? Well, funny that you
say that No, just not Okay, good. I don't think
that whatever that shit that it was it legends
of tomorrow for Supergirls not on the list or
wonder girl or whatever it is as much as I wanted
to list like heroes reborn and there was Well,
I mean like I still had to see it first and it's
still not done So, I mean it realistically couldn't
be included in legends tomorrow and Supergirl
again same issue And with all the other Netflix
series coming out I will say you know like I
like Steve mentioned I have seen people saw people
say that it does get better as it goes on I personally
I Friday watch it a few times. I cannot get past
the fifth episode in the first I will say the
first 13 episodes are horrid I almost the show
myself at that point and then I made it past
that point And then they started kind of dangling
that carrot you got an actual episode with Sam
Jackson in it for an entire episode helping Coulson,
which helped and then which was on the co -potting
of Captain America 2. And then then you get into
the second season and in the second season, the
beginning of it fell short until you got wrapped
around the close to the eventually and then it
kind of picked up and it stayed that way. So.
In Agent Carter's eight episodes, that was more
interesting to me than the five episodes I've
seen of S .H .I .E .L .D. I did like Agent Carter.
I didn't. I'd be curious if... Sorry to interrupt.
I think it kind of lends itself, though, because
the shorter season, they can tell a tighter -knit
story instead of filling it with filler garbage.
I just think she's more interesting than Colson
at this point. What I'm saying is, because there's
22 episodes of Agents of S .H .I .E .L .D. compared
to the eight episodes of Agent Carter... There's
not as much junk in the in the show. Yeah. Alrighty.
Well, let's move on to the next in our countdown
91 so we were in the world of action Superhero
we were in Sesame Street Well, let's move back
to the world of comedy It's been a while since
we went there with another sitcom a more recent
sitcom that just recently ended and that is At
number 91 we have how I met your mother. It was
on seven lists The highest was ranked at was
actually in the top 10 wasn't was number eight
Was on nine less 433 points only beat agents
of shield by one point Like I said, i'm going
to bring that out a few times. This list is super
super close Uh, let's start with amanda here
any thoughts on how I met your mother not legitimately
but to show Stay away from my mom dan This is
another one where I haven't caught an entire
episode and I think it's one of those that I
didn't see from the beginning and it's a lot
of inside jokes is what I've felt from it and
I think that I need to watch it from the beginning
to get more out of it. I just really couldn't
get on board with it. I mean, MPH, cool, but.
Hey, it did bring his revive his career. So points
for it there. Steve, any thoughts on how I met
your mother? No, I was trying to make a joke
and it came out bad. But no, I mean, I watched
the show, like, on Nessing. I kind of felt that
with the inside joke thing, but at the same time,
I felt that the episodes were kind of almost
standalone -ish, that you didn't necessarily
have to know the jokes that were going on because
they were kind of... create new ones every episode.
And so it kind of lended to itself and you really
didn't have to understand what was going on because
it kind of explained it. I mean, I don't have
a problem with showing up on the show. It did
last quite a few seasons. So I think it does
deserve to be there because it was a funny comedy,
but. Kevin, up to this point we've had three
modern sitcoms show up. We've had Louis, we've
had It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, and now
How I Met Your Mother. Do you think we've got
those shows in the correct order? It's hard to
say because I haven't necessarily been a religious
watcher of any of them to really compare them,
but I think when it comes to which show was talked
about the most or which show kind of was more,
not necessarily critically acclaimed, but...
More watched, more talked about, et cetera. I
would think How I Met Your Mother probably is
the highest ranking one out of that. That doesn't
always necessarily mean it's the best show. But
again, a show that was on for nine, 10 seasons
or something like that. So it had some staying
power, which a lot of times is not the case,
especially in the world of sitcoms. You see that
sometimes more with the crime or the action shows
that are able to last that long, but... sitcoms,
it seems like a harder game to sustain for 10
plus seasons. So it has some critical acclaim
behind it. It obviously was talked about a lot
of that in Big Bang Theory quite a bit. So I
ranked it, even though I haven't seen a ton of
episodes because I felt like at least it deserved
a spot somewhere in the countdown. Yeah, I was
along the same lines and it does have some acclaim
like you mentioned it wasn't nominated for 28
Emmy Awards So it's you know, it has been highly
regarded and it was highly rated and I think
when you kind of look at today's Landscape is
kind of strange. You try to say what is the show
of the 2000s because there is huge variety there
usually the one of the shows I think that you
would the most common show you think you would
hear people talk about one was how I met your
mother So I personally wasn't a show I regularly
watch but I could recognize, you know how good
it was and would catch it on syndication here
and there. So it was funny and NPH knew Patrick
Harris. Let's say I do think he was quite funny.
So and I see what Amanda's saying with the inside
joke thing. I do think that you do see that you
where it's a lot of references to itself and
it might be harder to get into it unless you're
in on the ground for Amanda. Quick question.
Any chance we see another NPH show is doesn't
he just have the new Best ever or I guess Okay,
yeah, I definitely Considered the dukes for my
list. So we'll see. All right. Well, he better
be I mean, I think he is one of the biggest I
want to say like a pop culture icon in the TV
world Mean if you have like a child prodigy,
you're gonna call him Doogie Howser no matter
what he he's into his doctor or You know nuclear
physicist or whatever he is. He's gonna be a
little Doogie Howser in my book Alrighty. Well,
I'm gonna put a little bit of a warning before
we get into our next pick. You keep scaring me
with these warnings, Dan I know I'll just say
if you're listening on headphones might want
to turn the volume down a little bit cuz you're
You're about to hear some screaming Alright,
yes, with our next pick, we saw one of our panels
number 2 go down, now we're seeing one of our
panels number 3 go down, because everyone's thinking
about who it could be, who could it be. Well,
at number 90, we have one of the most iconic
cars of all time. And that is Knight Rider as
number 90. It was on seven list, highest ranked
as number three by none other than TFG1 Mike.
Mike, let's start with you here. Obviously coming
in a lot lower than you had it. What are your
thoughts on seeing Knight Rider show up at number
90? I could see the 2008 reboot coming this low,
but come on. If the 2008 show was on our countdown,
I might leave. Well, at this point, yeah, I would
too. But I'm just saying that, I mean, come on,
this You take Knight Rider, Airwolf, and A -Team.
Those were the three, three of the biggest. Might
have one good show. Oh, shut up, MacGyver. You
know, those were the three shows, three action
shows I remember watching as a kid. And Knight
Rider, I did a whole podcast on Knight Rider
alone and reviewed every single episode from
all three incarnations of that franchise. But
I think Evil Kit from Killer Kit would say it
best, I ain't your pal. Well, that's good to
know. I have no idea what that means. But Steve,
any thoughts on Knight Rider showing up at number
90? I don't necessarily have a problem with it.
I mean, I have it in my later half of... I actually
have it at 76. But no problem showing up where
it does. I do see that it's iconic. It does scream
80s cheese. I don't know. It's a fun show with
a talking car that's... That's, you know, helping
solve crime and everything. So, um, dude, you
got to at least give. It's Feeny. I know. Come
on. Come on. I don't much care for his drivers.
This is Feeny before Feeny was Feeny. Come on
now. I don't care. He's Feeny. See, they like
references. That's how they work. That's the
way to go. Amanda, I know. He likes his references.
I just have to capitalize on them. Amanda, any
thoughts? Any? Thoughts on that writer whatsoever.
Oh that I'm way too young And I do remember what
the theme sounded like and what the car looked
like Can I tell you what any of the episodes
were? No, I think that it's it's definitely iconic
So I'm a little shocked that it's so low but
definitely not Top five material in my book.
Yeah, I'm too young. It's probably something
that David Hasselhoff hears way too much nowadays
I'll say this When the show was airing, I was
- Mike, you already had your turn. Shut up. When
it was actually airing from 82 to 86, I was a
bit too young, but I'd caught it in reruns. And
in 1986, when I was six years old, I actually
went to the Boston Budweiser Expo and I got to
stand in front of Kit. I get to sit in Kit and
I actually got my picture taken with Michael
Knight. That was just - So you were at a beer
expo when you were six. His real name's not Michael
Knight, by the way. Shut up. You don't wanna
hear it. The character, you idiots. I know. Well,
I was born in 87 so I should get a pass from
this awful show Yeah, most of you youngsters
get a pass so Kev I'll go to you next. Do you
think Knight Rider is top 100 worthy or is it
one of those situations? I know we've seen it
in the past with when it comes to 80 properties
that maybe quote -unquote You know nostalgia
or novelty glasses that people are wearing when
reviewing this show. I Mean, I like don't get
me wrong. I like Knight Rider our family watched
it off and on. It wasn't something we watched
like religiously or all the time or anything
like that, but it's a decent show. I have a problem
putting any show in the top 100 that stars David
Hasselhoff, but maybe that's just a bias on my
end. Wait, then why was Baywatch Nights number
two on your list? Shhh, Dan. Not supposed to
reveal stuff that's not actually going to show
up in the top 100. Wait, you put Nights as the...
Oh my god, I was going to say you put the original
show fine, but Nights... Alright, I'm gonna be
cursed with that forever now. But no, that did
not make my list either. I considered it in my
initial, you know, selection of shows, but as
soon as I went through the second draft, it was
cut out because there was just too many other
good shows that I had to make room for. So nothing
against Knight Rider. I think if it's in the
90s, that's fine, but it should definitely not
be any higher than that. All right, so we're
we're already out of the 90s going into the 80s.
So let's see what we have next 89 the surprises
continue with our number 89 I think for those
people might want to go to their IMDB get ready
to type in this show's name because I think there's
a slight a good amount of people that don't know
this show ever existed because it's another show
that was only on for a short time and that is
Sports nights coming in at number 89. No, not
Sports Center. No No, not some sort of sports
show, but actually Sports Night. It ran for two
seasons on ABC. The show was on 10 lists. It
was on a great deal of lists, as high as ranked
as number three. I gotta say, I know Briscoe
County Junior is a show I talked about being
a surprise, but this to me was a huge surprise
because it's a show I really enjoyed, but did
not know there was that much love out for Sports
Night. I know a lot of people may not even know
it existed, but... Created by Aaron Sorkin was
his first show before he went to West Wing so
kind of where he cut his teeth Kev, let's start
with you here was sports night a show you have
watched at all and or maybe caught I know it
wasn't syndication on like Comedy Central and
a few other shows for a short bit. I Think when
you just mentioned it was probably the first
time I heard it since whatever commercial I might
have seen in 1998 or 1999 for it. I at least
have heard of Briscoe County. Who is in this?
Jason Molina and there's a legit actors I can't
think of their names, but some actors that are
in good wife now I will say it does have maybe
not like star studded cast But if you watched
any Aaron Serkin show, you're gonna see some
other similar actors Yeah, I just I probably
knew this existed in 1998, but my current self
did not Doesn't this have Felicity Huffman in
it? Yes, it does. Yeah, I remember that. I don't
remember the show Actively I had seen I Would
always catch it at its tail end when they were
going to close the broadcast because wasn't this
essentially The 90s sports like version of what
the newsroom was for HBO. Yeah, it's basically
what it was It was you know, yeah Sports Center
was maybe at its height maybe not the heights
but it was certainly breaking out and it was
kind of the behind the scenes of a News program
and like behind the scenes very much newsrooms
a good comparison. It was like that before sports
Yeah, I saw that. Can I say it? It's chickens.
Well, I think it's also pigeons. Do pigeons roost?
I think they do. I think they perch. They roost.
Look, it's fine with me. Hey, you know what?
I think someone was flirting with me today. I'm
sorry? Someone might have been flirting with
me today. Sally? How did you know? Sally's always
flirting with you. Well, she's not. Yes, she
is. It's okay. I've been flirting back. You're
kind of feeble, aren't you? Well, have I? I really
don't know. I don't want to look foolish. Not
much chance of that. Do I flirt badly? You flirt
fine. Seriously. You flirt fine. Dana. Flirt
with me now. Flirt with you now? Yes. I will.
Start. How you doing? That's good, Casey. How
many years of college? I've got more. I'm just
saying hi. Lay it on me. What's your name? Casey,
I'm saying flirt with me. I'm not playing somebody
else. You're not helping. Start again. Flirt
with me. I'm starting now. What's your name?
My name's Dana. You unbelievable moron. You've
known me for 15 years. Flirt with me. Tell me
why you like me better than Sally. I do like
you better than Sally. Tell me why. I don't understand.
I don't think you're ever going to have sex again.
I gotta go. You're smoky. I'm sorry? The difference
between you and Sally, you're smoky. I'm smoky?
You're smoky. You're a lot of other things too,
but you're smoky. I don't know what that means,
but I like the sound of it. Tell me what it means.
That's hard to translate. Try. You'll make a
joke. We're flirting. It's okay. Are we really
flirting, or are you just pretending to be you
flirting with me actually being me? You think
I'm smoky? Classy, impressive, sexy. Was sexy
going too far? It was fine. You're smoky. Thank
you. Natalie, wait up. I'm sorry. I got to talk
to Natalie. That's fine. We're on the air in
very soon and Natalie's there. Okay. So, I'll
see you later. Yeah, just a little bit in fact.
Because we're going on the air. And you're okay
with birds roosting? I'm okay with birds doing
anything you tell them to do. I'm really surprised
it is this high, honestly. I'm surprised we've
seen multiple shows now, well, multiple meaning
two, that were on for such a short amount of
time and did not really have much as far as notoriety
at the time or since for maybe forgotten type
of shows and it's interesting to see that ten
people put this on their list. It did get some
acclaim when it was out. It was nominated for
best performance in it in for a Golden Globe
It did rank in TV guide actually talked about
it getting canceled too soon It it ranks number
10 in the 2000 list made by TV guide for shows
canceled too soon So there is I think it's a
show that I got more love when it became one
of the shows that Comedy Central showed when
it expanded and it was on all the time. That's
when I started watching it. The first season
is almost unwatchable, though, because it has
a laugh track, but it's not like a three -sam,
it's three -camera sitcom, so it feels very artificial,
but it's still a really good show. And if you're
a fan of Aaron Sorkin's writing, I think you
really see it here. And it's actually a question.
I know with... Animated movies we saw it dominated
by Disney Pixar those types of names and you
see that a lot too with actors or directors You
get dominant lists at times someone like Aaron
Sorkin or other TV creators have do you think
there's any chance there are other Names like
that that tend to dominate a list like this knowing
that sometimes you know Just being attached or
having a certain name attached and get it get
people to rank it higher. Maybe then they should
I don't know if it would necessarily get it to
be ranked higher, but I think names being attached
at times have led to more of the series getting
greenlit or more of the series being... on for
multiple seasons that type of stuff i mean there's
been definitely some names along the way that
i remember like back in the what was the early
2000s if david e kelly's name was attached to
something it seemed like it got a lot of praise
so i mean i think names can have more of effect
of the shows either seeing the light of day or
getting some critical acclaim at the time that
they were out i don't know how much it would
affect somebody ranking it though Think it might
have helped people go back and always like, you
know You do it like a direct perspective when
you go back and you watch all their movies Sometimes
you might see that with a TV show knowing it
has you know This is where you know Aaron Torkin
did things before this he had you know few good
men and and things like that But this was kind
of the show that he did before West Wing So it
I think if he didn't do that It could have actually
maybe even be a little higher on the list and
I don't know I couldn't find this if it was available
streaming any place I don't know how well it
holds up. But any other thoughts? on Sports Night
before we move on to the next on the list. Alrighty,
well, this is going to be a drastic change as
we go into what's next, so let's see how it goes.
One thing that's interesting about number 88
is the fact that it actually tied with sports
tonight, but it beat it out based upon number
a list in average rank. And I think it's probably
I talked about sports tonight to show not many
people heard of. I don't think you can find many
people who have not heard of this show or at
least watched it here and there, even if it was
just their kid. And coming in at number 88, it
is the Andy Griffiths show. We're going we're
going back to classic comedy classic sitcom.
Let's start with Steve Let's start with you here
any thoughts on seeing the Andy Griffith show
showing up at number 88 I know that it's it's
a very iconic show. I seen bits and pieces of
it It's definitely not from our time But it's
like the starting point for a lot of people that
you'll end up following so on I'm not real well
versed in it but I do know that it does deserve
a place on on here because of Just the sheer
syndication numbers. This show should have been
in the top 50 at least. I agree with Mike on
this. I mean, this is the Andy friggin Griffith
show, people. This is Barney Fife for crap's
sake. What's wrong with you people? What are
we doing, Andy? I mean, how can you not love
Don Knotts as Barney Fife? I mean, essentially...
Andy and Barney were the Batman and Robin of
this show. They really were. They were the Adam
West and Burt Ward to this show because it was
so awesome. Then you have Ron Howard as little
Opie Taylor. This is one of those shows that,
like The Cosby Show, like Family Matters, like
some of the other comedies and family show type
shows, this is a show that taught you lessons.
Opie's got growing up. He's he's learning the
same and even even Barney even Andy had to teach
Barney a few lessons or two But I mean having
it this low is again We're gonna be using this
word a lot in this countdown folks. This is a
travesty having it at 88 Kevin. Do you agree
with that sentiment? I don't know if I'd go so
far to say travesty because I think it's more
of a sign of like I said, maybe some older stuff
Not resonating as much with today's audiences
or today's you know, when people are comparing
it to the number of shows that have become available
since then, my argument would be this. I would
argue that it should be on the other side of
the 50 mark. I had it ranked at number 37. This
is my main argument for the Andy Griffiths show,
though. And it's not just, you know, classic
syndrome or nostalgia or anything like that.
A lot of shows, it takes a few seasons before
they get, you know, before they gain steam and
really start clicking. Or if they're instant
successes, they often kind of peter out as you
get towards their final two three seasons or
something like that this was a show that was
successful from episode one until the last episode
it was on for eight seasons and in eight of those
eight seasons it was top 10 rated show in the
country, including one year where it was the
number one rated show overall for the whole year.
So to be in the top 10 rated show every single
season of its existence to me says something.
And I just think it probably deserves to be a
tiny bit higher, but I'm happy that it is on
the show on the list. I'll say this. It's the
only show as a kid that I learned to whistle
the theme song. Well, there you go. Amanda, I
know the show was before your time. Luckily,
it was before all of our times. Any thoughts
on any Griffith? I actually did catch quite a
bit of this in the rerun form, obviously. And
I think you guys have touched on all the main
parts. I think it was really iconic. And it was
definitely one of those lesson driven TV shows
that I think it was reminiscent of, you know,
like The Waltons and things like that. And it
had a feel good. feeling even if you didn't um
i guess it gave me the feels i mean it wasn't
always a happy ending i would say either i think
there were some hard lessons taught and uh i
think that uh little ron howard was super cute
little opi and i think that like you said everybody
knows that whistle theme song so i mean i think
it should have been definitely in the top 50
Yeah, I can I agree I think it should be higher
I am a little surprised I think it too it comes
back to What we mentioned it's just experience
watching the show. Maybe people forgot about
it didn't see it I do have a difficulty watching
some old shows. I can usually watch old sitcoms
Okay, and the Annie Griffith shows I think one
of them when I think classic TV There are a few
shows that come to my mind and Annie Griffith
certainly one of them It's just it has that you
know homestyle feeling to it. It feels good.
You know Aunt B. Who doesn't love Aunt B, right?
Yeah, so all right. Well with number 87 we're
going into a territory that's A few have gone
before maybe I don't know. I think I got that
quote wrong. We'll see as we get into next on
the countdown. 87. Alrighty, at number 87 we
have Star Trek Deep Space Nine. There's five
of them. I mean, I know. I know. You got to give
that space just for people to guess which one
it could be. Yes, Star Trek Deep Space Nine had
438 points. It was only on six lists. So it was
not on many lists, but it was ranked really high
as the highest number 10 on one list. And I guess
we should probably start with the guy who has
a Star Trek podcast. Steve, thoughts on Star
Trek Deep Space Nine. Is this Star Trek deserving
a top 100? Yes, actually. This is one of those
Star Trek shows that actually took me a long
time to appreciate, because growing up I had
no appreciation for the show whatsoever. It wasn't
until I started the Star Trek podcast and Dodd
challenged me to return to it as an adult, and
it covers a lot of different themes in it that
aren't necessarily covered on any of the other
tracks. You get kind of the random, hokey stuff
in the original track, but in this one you get...
less of the diplomatic and more of the the war
territory and and how these people have to survive
during war time and it's it's almost constantly
going on during this entire thing because it's
constantly struggles and and border battles and
then it's just a all -out war by the end of it
but the way they handle these characters the
evolution that they they kind of play throughout
the series i almost feel is more than what we
get in some of the other Trek series as far as
character development I mean, it happens in some
of the other ones, but I think that it happens
a little bit more here because there's a lot
of changing of everything. I know you're another
Star Trek fan. Does this rank high for you in
the many Star Trek series? It was towards the
end of my first kind of wave, I guess, of interest
in Star Trek. I was die -hard Star Trek fan before
it and definitely watched the first probably
two to three seasons the first half of the show
and then for some reason or another I kind of
lost interest or got distracted by other things
I don't know I was in high school at that time
so whatever reason I stopped watching it but
I think it was a good show I think there was
some interesting characters involved I would
I haven't seen enough of a couple of the other
series to tell you where I would rank it but
my personal top 100 there was only so many Spots
I could put Star Trek in so it did not get ranked
on my list But it's interesting to see it make
it I makes me wonder how many Star Trek shows
will make the entire list Amanda let me throw
that question to you any thoughts on how many
Star Trek shows we're gonna see on this list
I'm not really sure This one being, I think,
maybe one of the least known for me, I think
it's reasonable to see it come in at this rank.
Maybe there is going to be a couple more higher
up, I think, without a doubt. But if it's not
Kirk or Picard, I'm not really sure what's going
on with it. Mike, any thoughts on Star Trek Deep
Space Nine? I remember catching episodes of this
show here and there when it was airing. I remember
Captain Cisco and all that stuff and I don't
know, it's just one of those shows that I saw
when it was on but I never really paid attention
to it because I was still more into the reruns
of Next Generation. But it's actually a show
that I'm actually going to be watching all seven
seasons of here soon because I have to... write
a review for the Allland Records limited edition
scores. So I'm actually going to be going back
and revisiting this show for the first time in
a long time. That's going to take a while. Seven
seasons on Netflix, yep. Yeah, I did that on
Netflix when I got it. I will say that one of
the significance of this show too is it's the
first sequel from The Next Generation and it
takes place in the same universe and same timeline
as The Next Generation. This show grows its legs
out of best of both worlds on TNG, so. It does
have some award acclaim. It did win four Primetime
Emmys, both for hairstyle and makeup. But still,
you know, those are important. You got to look
good. You got to look good. Got to make your
Klingons and Romulans look legit. I know. I know.
All right. All right. Any other thoughts on Star
Trek before we go on to our next on the countdown?
I hope we only I'm not. I'm a huge Star Trek
fan, but I would be I don't know. Are we going
to see two more? Because if we see more than
two more, I'm going to be shocked. Well, we'll
have to see. We'll have to see. All right. Let's
go on to our next on our list. 86. All right.
Well, for our next on a list, I'm actually going
to. Start with a request and that request is
just to give the facts because in number 86 We
have the TV cop drama dragnet It was on nine
lists received four hundred and forty three points
as highest ranked as number 12 on one person's
list Mike we ended with you last time. Let's
start with you here thoughts on dragnet coming
in at number 86 The most memorable thing about
this show was Joe Friday's narration and how
they set the show up. I just absolutely love
that. I just thought that was so cool where it's
I think that's where cops kind of got their I
don't mean the TV show I mean the animated show
kind of got their narration from was Dragnet.
Honestly, Dragnet, it's something I haven't seen
in a long time. You know you have certain aspects
of TV shows that you remember more than others
and the opening narration and and how he narrated
the story Throughout each episode is the one
thing I remember most about dragnet Amanda questions
for you. This is a first cop drama first cop
show We're seeing cop shows are usually pretty
well well known within TV that kind of go hand
-in -hand Surprised it took this long to get
to one a little bit. I think there's so much
crime cop dramas, especially out there, especially
over the years that I'm a tad surprised, but
I think with what we've seen thus far, a couple
of those that are a little out of the blue maybe
could have been replaced by some of these cop
dramas. Yeah, I could see that. Kevin, any thoughts
on Dragonet? Yeah, I mean, Dragnet's classic.
It's hard to hate on Dragnet too much. It was
also something that was definitely popular when
it was on. It aired for eight seasons and for
those seasons, it was top 10 rated show. So,
I mean, it was something that was successful
at the time. Definitely people were watching
it, talking about it, et cetera. In my head,
for some reason now, it's Confused, Dragnet,
and Get Smart. I know they're not the same show.
Really? You missed it by that much? For some
reason in my head, they're like combined as the
same show. I like Dragnet. I think it's good
to have some more classic stuff show up, so I
have no problem with it. Steve, any thoughts
on Dragnet? Most of what I know from it is the
parody of it, which was the film, which was supposed
to actually take place after decades after the
original. Yeah, I mean, Dragnet is certainly
iconic. What's kind of interesting doing research
is you hear, you know, just the facts, man, is
one of those famous misquotes is not... Actually
what what Joe Friday says it says all we want
are the facts ma 'am. Not just the facts So it's
like Luke. I am your father It's you know, one
of those things that kind of gets misinterpreted
in and miss said all the time And it does it
was a huge show for its time and like Kevin mentioned
it did win five primetime Emmys for which is
this is award I wish they would bring back best
mystery and intrigue series. I mean, come on
now if you're winning best intrigue series, that's
that's impressive We need to bring that award
back. I need to be a movie Oscar for that, too
Yeah, and yeah and speaking of movie suite there
were three film versions of the dragon that there
were some revival series as well Like they came
back to show that that would not die. It was
a formula They tried repeating it, but it really
was best done best the first time I've actually
could see an argument for it going higher Its
impact within the the cop genre per se and I
think it's better than most of those shows around
the same time So but I'm glad like we said we're
seeing some old shows being represented already.
So Alright, any other thoughts on Dragnet before
we move on? Yeah, thankfully the quote, it might
have been, you know, changed or misquoted or
whatever else, but there's at least one classic
show that you can never misquote. Excuse me,
sir, just one more thing. And let's go to one
more thing as we go into the next in the countdown.
At number 85, we are going back to the world
of comedy and another comedy classic in the show.
I'm actually I'm happy it's on the list a little
sad. It's not higher, but I'll live with it at
number 85 We have the Bob Newhart show with four
hundred and forty nine points on eight lists
was actually on fewer lists than Dragnet but
it was ranked higher because it had an average
rank of forty four point nine where Dragnet had
it fifty one meaning that people who did rank
it tend to rank it higher the Bob Newhart show
Kevin, we're talking about classic comedies and
where they're ranking. You think this is another
sign of a show that should be higher or are you
happy where it's falling? I think it's good.
I don't know if maybe some of it, I mean there
was other shows that he was in. And I don't know
if maybe there was a new heart. That's the thing.
That's the problem. There's a new heart show.
There's a Bob Newhart show. Sometimes it's we
got votes for all of them. I'm not I can't say
if any of them else ranked on the list, but that
is that is a common confusion because when you
put your name in the title for every show you're
in. Right. So my question is, did that hurt this
show overall? Did maybe some people only vote
for one of them or, you know, if they had been
a combined entry, I guess, would they have gotten
more votes? So I don't know. I could see it being
a little bit higher. just because of the presence
Newhart had in television, especially, you know,
throughout the 70s and 80s, so I could see that
argument. I personally am fine with where it's
at, but I'm like you, I could see it being a
little bit higher just for his presence. Steve,
any thoughts on the Bob Newhart show? No, not
really. I mean, I've heard of it, but most of
my exposure to the guy has been in film or in
the Big Bang Theory, so... I remember the Newhart
show. I don't remember the like the Newhart show
was was the one that I always watched Yeah, that
is I could see what you're saying Mike with the
Bob Newhart show in the Newhart show I It's really
splitting hairs for me I think I've always enjoyed
the Bob Newhart show a little bit more but either
have Bob Newhart who I think is like the nicest
dude ever created and I really personally love
his style of comedy very subtle it I don't know
he would say things and say hilarious things
without ever like Making it obvious. How was
the rest of your day? Oh, it was great. I gave
my first IQ test today. Well, how'd they come
out? I don't know. I haven't graded them yet.
How did the one come out you gave last night,
you know, to me? Oh, fine. How fine? Well, you're
so interested. I thought you didn't believe in
IQ tests. Well, Emily, if I can give up three
hours of my life to take an IQ test, you can
give up three seconds of your life to answer
it for me. What was the score? I don't think
people should know their IQs. Well, you know
your IQ. Well, that's different. I have to know
mine. Well, I have to know mine. What was it?
129. 129. That's good, isn't it? Oh, that's very
good, Bob. That's almost gifted. Almost gifted.
What's yours? Oh, it's not important. I know
it's not important, but what is it? I'm embarrassed.
Honey, don't be embarrassed. I had four more
years of college than you had. Bobby, it's 151.
His comedy still works today when you don't see
that with many classic comedies I think it is
you can watch the show unlike a lot of sitcoms
and still laugh at most of the jokes the same
way They're meant to be left at at the time.
So I think it's a good spot 85 I think you know,
you possibly higher I don't know but again like
like Kevin mentioned it could be in with Mike
as well combination of having similar shows get
an impact, you know, we're short land so I don't
think we're going to have that problem done with
Next on the list because I'm pretty sure everyone
on the panel has at least watched it once. At
number 84, we are having one of the biggest shows
of the 1990s as we are going to no other than
Tool... time itself, Home Improvement coming
in at number 84 with 450 votes. It was on nine
lists as highest ranked as number two. Amanda,
I'm hoping this is one show that was not before
your time. Any thoughts on Home Improvement?
Oh no, yes. I wish that I could make the Tim
The Toolman growl noise right now or whatever
it is. Something like that, yeah. I watched a
lot of this when I was younger. I think that
I had a huge crush on JTT back in the day, Jonathan
Taylor Thomas. I liked seeing the kids grow up.
I loved the relationship the mom and the dad
had. I even loved that he had this completely
separate life. aspect. I think he had his TV
show, but then he also came home and kind of
shed that popularity and that fame and was just
a real dad, you know, with a hobby car in the
garage and, you know, his wife trying to get
through school and kids to manage. And I thought
it was a really fun show. And Wilson, was that
the neighbor's name? I think he was probably
my favorite character. Mike, any thoughts on
Home Improvement? Home Improvement was amazing
at the time. You know, as Amanda was saying,
you have so many different aspects of the show.
You have him on his TV show. You have him with
his family. And then the third aspect is you
have his friendship with Al Borland, played by
Richard, Richard Karn. And that's just one of
the craziest TV friendships I think I've ever
seen between the two of them. It's such a love
-hate. It's so awesome, and I'm going to reference
the current show Tim is on. It's so awesome when
they had the characters from Home Improvement
come back to be on Last Man Standing, the episode
where Patricia came back and they made all the
jokes about Home Improvement. That was just awesome.
But Home Improvement itself, as Amanda said,
watching the kids grow up, watching Tim eventually
evolve into this really cool TV dad of the 90s.
a damn good show. Yeah. And Kev, I know when
you talked about Andy Griffith's show, you talked
about a show that started off strong and ended
strong. And we see that too with Hope Improvement.
It started ratings wise. It debuted in the top
10 and stayed in the top 10 for all eight of
its seasons. So similar to that show, do you
feel that Home Improvement should be higher on
this list? I'm going to be the one person that
probably gets some hate on this one. I think
that is the one argument for it is how popular
was when it was out, how high it was rated from
the very get -go, and what kind of pivotal role
it played in the ABC lineup at that time. I think
it was ABC. Was that the TGIF? It wasn't a TGIF,
but it was on ABC. Right. Well, you know, it
was around a time where they were making a push
with a bunch of shows that were somewhat similar.
So I think it was popular, I think it had an
impact and things like that. For me personally
though, and maybe it's a factor that I was a
little older at that time, but I just feel with
Home Improvement and I could name a couple other
sitcoms in the 90s, to me they just didn't do
anything. that I hadn't seen before. There was
nothing groundbreaking in those shows compared
to some of the same sitcoms I had seen in previous
years or previous decades. So for me, I actually
left it off of my list completely. It just didn't
have enough going for it to bump some of these
other shows off my list. I think it's warranted
because of the ratings, because of how popular
it was, and because of how much love there is
for it. I'm glad that it's not any higher, though.
I'm surprised it's not higher. i'm surprised
it's not higher but i'm glad it's not higher
but i can definitely see why people would make
an argument that it should be somewhere in the
top 100 but i know i'm going to be in the minority
there i ranked ranked it in the top 40 but like
i i find it more entertaining than a lot of the
other shows that have come since like everybody
loves raymond or that that kind of show like
i i will give you that there is nothing unique
about it It is nice. The dynamics that's good
in it. The actors are good in it. The writing
is good. So I can see why it's in the top 100.
I'm just glad that it made the list, at least.
For me, this show is more important to me than
a lot of the other ones that are in the same
vein that have come out around it or after it.
So that's why I ranked it where I did. Right.
And I think that's valid. I think for certain
people, certain shows are going to hit more of
a soft spot or they're going to resonate more
depending on That type of thing. So I think that's
super natural. I think that's a legit argument.
You cannot compare supernatural to home improvement.
Oh, I can do whatever I want. It's a different
vein, but I do agree spiritual should be a lot
higher. So I don't think you can argue against
someone when they say, you know, if you're looking
at like, let's say all the sitcoms of that vein,
whichever one strikes more of a chord with you,
that's the one that you should rank. So I don't
have a problem with that. I was just for me personally,
it's not the one that resonated as much for me.
Yeah, and I could see that. I think it's hard
for me when you mention groundbreaking or not
doing something other shows done before. It's
hard for me to say because when I saw it, it
was like one of the first shows of that nature
I got into. So it is, you know, a show I grew
up really liking and I still, there are not many
shows of that time period I can watch and still
laugh at. Home Improvement is one of them. Like
I watched something like Full House, for example.
I loved that show as a kid. Watching it now,
I cringe a lot. Yep. Yep. A show on Whoop improvement,
I think it's still funny. I think Tim Allen,
he did incorporate a lot of his standup into
that show, which is the common thing to do. You
see that with a lot of standups. It was a thing
at the time. Same thing in college we did. So
it did follow that formula, but I don't know.
I think there was something just, I think maybe
who it was speaking to, the fact that it was
a show within a show and not that that hadn't
been done before, but I think it all kind of
just comes around to just maybe the chemistry
of the cast and I don't know. I think a lot had
to do with him and himself and the the the naivety
of the character that he played Yeah, it like
it had that slapstick comedy. I think that you
know, he would expect for a family show So and
yeah, I mean actually this is about right where
I had it on my list So I think it's a good spot
for it and I like you guys I'm a little surprised
it's not higher But again, it's a continuing
the one common that we're seeing with that list
and that surprises So let's see what's next on
the list as we get into the next show on our
countdown Eighty -three Well, so far we saw shows
on Network TV, we saw shows on cable TV. Well,
we're seeing our first show with number 83, our
first show that is actually on a streaming service
as we are breaking ground here with Orange is
the New Black at number 83. It was on eight lists.
We received 454 points, four more points than
Home Improvement, as high as ranked as number
nine. So it was on one person's top 10 list.
that I know it's getting a lot of claim it's
surprising enough it's actually but when people
not realize the most watched show on Netflix
so it is breaking ground in that end so it's
a kind of cool seeing where one show on a streaming
service showing up already Amanda let's start
with you here any thoughts on orange is the new
black showing up at number 83 I actually only
ranked this in my top 100 because I know how
popular it is I've only seen maybe five minutes
of an episode and it was some weird lesbian prison
sex and I was like yeah I'm not really sure about
the show yet so I think that I need to warm up
to it a little bit more because um who's that
chick from that 70s show Donna it was her and
some other chick and they were like hardcore
getting it on in jail and I was like yeah I think
this is pretty much all the show is but I know
that it's so popular that there's got be something
behind it. Kevin, any thoughts on Orange is the
New Black? I'm still trying to... picture Amanda's
face when she watched those five minutes and
didn't know what she was getting into. I was
a little confused, and then when I realized what
was happening, I was like, well, I think I kind
of knew this is what was going to happen. I can
see the draw to the... That's dumb to say right
after she said that. I can see the draw. I watch
it for the article. Right? They have good wings.
You watch it for the article. At this point,
that's all you can do. No, I understand that
notwithstanding. I can understand how people
got into it for other reasons. I think it was
something that was unique. It was something that
was kind of maybe for a lot of other people that
were seeing a lot of those types of shows as
far as what I'm talking about with like gritty
crime prison type stuff. They were seeing a lot
of that that was basically dominated by male
casts. And so I can see where maybe this one
comes along and offer something different that
people gravitate to. I've only seen a part of
a few episodes when other people were watching
it and I did kind of get sucked into whatever
the story was, but because I didn't continue
watching, I can't really tell you much about
characters or plot lines or anything like that.
But I think it definitely does have the ability
to kind of capture you once you've been watching
an episode or two and kind of keep you for the
long haul. I think it goes for that being the
all -female cast. I think that they do play super
heavy on the girl on girl thing because they
think that's what people really want to see.
And I think that that should be a small part
of it. I think that if I watch more of this,
I'll be interested to see what the story does
to see if they don't just go for that sex sells
kind of viewpoint. So we'll see. oranges in the
black for me was a show that I didn't have much
interest in but my my wife started watching it
and I kind of Yeah, I like caught it secondhand.
I wasn't really paying attention, but I did get
sucked into it and I would say that yeah There
is you know, that sex aspect of it But that's
really a small piece of it and it really hits
that dramedy not to bring up that word because
it's an awful word But it really hits that that
sweet spot really well because there are some
comic moments But it gets some into some dark
moments too. And it was interesting that it's
one of the few shows that was been and nominated
for both best comedy and best drama. And it has
been nominated for 12 Emmy awards. It's won a
few for performances, Golden Globes as well.
So it does come in with award acclaim. And it's
saying a lot. It really kind of, you know, House
of Cards really, I think, got the attention showing,
like, because it had big names attached. But
I think Orange is the New Black to me was maybe
arguably the better show. Being an all -female
cast is I think an additional benefit to it because
it does get into a lot and gets into all the
characters. There are a lot of characters that
are specific, a lot of episodes are specifically
directed to specific characters and you kind
of get their background and you end up with such
a rich show because you get so many well -developed
relationships and you're really understanding
where the people come from and it's a variety
of different types of people and types of people
you don't necessarily see on TV. They're not
the glamorous types. It's and it's not overly
gritty like something like Oz It's not like the
woman version of Oz, but it's able to really
catch that balance So I think it's deserving
of 83. I can maybe even argue that it should
be higher I do think that maybe that the fact
that it's on netflix could impact people because
if you don't have that netflix You can't watch
it so it could have Being on netflix they can
they can do a little bit more as far as what
they could put on these other prime time shows,
I think that That's they push the envelope because
they can and that's what people want I think
this too is going to be one of an Examples of
shows that you know, maybe we talk about when
we get to the wrap -up But this is a prime candidate
for something that if you do this list five years
from now Ten years from now could definitely
jump in the rankings Yeah, and and like you and
I think being on netflix too. Not only can you
just do whatever you want. You also don't need
to Go to small things like time format. You could
be like 47 minutes or something like that. Like
you can you can make your show last as long as
it should. So there's been a lot of that. But
Steve, I don't think you was ranked on the list
or you saw the show, but I did have a question
for you. Do you think you will see any more shows
like this? Orange is black. Any of those those
shows that are on the streaming services, which
is relatively new only in the last few years.
Any chance we'll see more show up in the top
100? I can only say so because I think a lot
of the stronger shows that we're getting now
at this point are coming out on these streaming
services only in that they don't have, and I'm
not saying that there aren't strong shows on
the other networks, but I think that because
the other ones are controlled by networks, they're
hindered in that fashion. Much like you guys
said, they can make them however long they need
to be or kind of get around those obstacles because
of being at a streaming service compared or being
on cable where just anybody can get on it. Because
I mean, Netflix can be different by profiles
based on age. So you can lock kids out of that.
So it can be as graphic as it needs to be compared
to being on cable where any kid can just flip
the channel and watch it. So that's why they
can't really do any of the stuff that they're
getting away with away with here. But that being
said, like my wife watches the show like I have
caught it here or there just being in the same
room. It's not a show I get into personally,
but it's I can see why the acclaims there. I
think the other thing with the Netflix shows
is Yes, we're gonna wait on the production of
the show But once it releases they release a
whole season at one point. It's not just no I
know but I'm starting to change though, right
but I'm saying like, you know, you take something
like The Flash or Arrow or any other show that's
on broadcast network television and you still
have to wait a week for the next episode whereas
with orange is the new black and any other show
house of cards that's on netflix they put the
whole season out at once so you can just sit
there and binge watch if you're interested in
whatever show that they put out i do that with
hemlock grove but as soon as i put that out i'm
like yeah watch this and then i'm like i have
no idea what's going on now i have to wait for
this to happen Again like yeah, but I'm glad
that they do that because I hate when books and
on the cliffhanger I hate when movies that are
gonna have a sequel and a cliffhanger. I just
I want to know I want to know now Occasionally
occasionally some people's watch maybe certain
scenes, you know Already well, let's get out
of this conversation as quickly as possible as
we get it into the next in the countdown 82 Well
for this next show on this list, maybe we should
just Adlib because it would be fitting for as
number number 82 coming in with seven on seven
lists with 454 points is whose line is it? Anyway,
it was highest ranked as number nine. So it did
reach the top ten for for one person It was on
the fewest list we've seen so far only seven
But for the people that did rank it did rank
it relatively high. Let's start with Mike here
Was this a shot show that was defined? when we
came up with the rules because there's two versions
of this there's the u .s. version in the u .k.
version and both got votes so both the whose
line is in any way it was separated so both the
u .s. version and the u .k. version did get votes
so and uh they were separated so this was which
one is this this is the u .s. version okay a
good one whoa no offense to uk listeners Yeah,
you can't think that like talk about books and
stuff. I'm very well versed in both universes
I will say there technically there's been three
areas of the show the two American which are
technically a continuation of each other and
then there's the the British version and Without
getting into the British version the American
version. Yes, it started with true Carrie, but
it was very PC and very there were only so many
limited things that they could do because of
it being on an ABC channel So there were a lot
of things that they couldn't actually talk about
or actually say or actually do Whereas now that
it's on the CW and it's it's got the new host
and it's got the new format And not as strict
to the guidelines they can go anywhere. They
want to they just bleep out whatever it shouldn't
on air so But it's just going I mean on 12 seasons
total if you combine with the the 2000 well the
98 to 2004 and then when they revived it in 2000
I want to say 11 yeah with the true carry version
it They may have been restricted, but they still
got away with a lot of jokes Not really if you
go back to watch the because I have a lot of
the DVDs with a lot of the outtakes And there's
a lot of stuff that did past as there were certain
things that got passed, but it depended I would
almost argue that the the the newer version is
better than that But it's also at the same time
because it's got all the special guests instead
of actually having more for the skits So it's
kind of a double -edged sword. I I love the show
but it's it's I Almost want to argue that the
UK one's better My only problem with the current
incarnation of the US one is the guests because
they have the way they structure it is a guest
will come out and they'll do a skit then they'll
act like oh hey you're leaving see you bye and
it's like if you're gonna have a guest in the
entire show to work with most of the skits have
them on the whole show don't just have them show
up for 10 seconds Alrighty, I can't say to that
because I've not watched the updated version.
But I mean, thoughts on whose line is it anyway
showing up on here at number 82. Do you think
it gets hurt by the fact there are so many versions
of it? I don't think it draws away because you
either like the show I think or you don't. And
I mean, two words stick out. Wayne Brady, that's
pretty much all I get out of that. So I mean,
I enjoyed it. It wasn't my favorite show. I've
seen quite a bit of it, but nothing that really
stuck out that I remembered. I had fun with it,
but I think I got bored with it after a while.
So I don't think I even got into the newer versions
or even the UK. I think it's a good spot where
it's at. Kevin, any thoughts? I mean, I loved
Wayne Brady and I'm going to forget the other
two guys. Brian Stiles and Colin Mochrie. Yeah,
I loved all of those guys, but I have never been
a fan of Drew Carey. So that kind of was a turnoff
for me, but I remember enjoying the show and,
you know, I did like it. I like certain segments
better than other segments, but generally did
laugh. And I do like that improv style. I think
if we're talking sketch shows, I would put Carol
Burnett and a higher ranking than whose line
is it anyway. But again, it was on for a long
time. There's been multiple versions. A lot of
people like it. So I don't have a problem with
it being on the countdown. Yeah, I don't disagree.
I think I would definitely put carol banana head
of whose line maybe do it a little bit of a flip
-flop I do like his line. It was a lot of fun.
I didn't really watch the new version I did watch
a little the uk version when it was like syndicated
on comedy central But I think my heart was with
the abc version What's kind of interesting is
that someone did try to combine the versions
and see who? Had the most points who ranks at
number one any ideas of who ranks at number one
for the most points And who line isn't anyway?
Wow Cost you I'm gonna say Colin McCree. It doesn't
matter because of points that matter. No Number
number one was actually Wayne Brady as he had
total points of over 50 billion 72 million points
number two was Ryan Stiles he only had 11 11
billion so and then call mockery with a measly
3 billion. So yeah That is that is that's doing
a fantasy ranking for whose line that there's
your top three That was actually my least favorite
part of the show was the and I know it's just
sketch comedy and whatnot But maybe I'm just
too cutthroat. I wanted the points to be more
systematic They actually did count in the British
one. Yeah, okay American one if they didn't matter
The the British when they actually counted the
points and like Clive Anderson was the host of
that one and he would actually break it down
and tell who was actually winner of it and They'd
have to basically sit out but That's the winner
get to sit out. Yeah, they're like you're gonna
sit out everybody else has to be my improv monkeys
out there and but no, I think that the One of
the funny things about the whole thing is the
whole staple of the show pretty much is Colin
Mochrie and Ryan Stiles Being that Ryan was on
it for the almost its entirety since the the
initial UK version and then Colin joined in shortly
thereafter and they've been on it ever since
I remember when I first saw the ABC version of
whose line I'm just like wait a second. What's
judge Reinhold doing on skits? I swear Ryan Stiles
and judge Reinhold almost look exactly alike
No, he wasn't All right, well let's Let's put
a ribbon on the whose line is it anyway talk
and move on to the next on the lesson Let's just
say we're gonna get maybe a little bit more modern
I've said hint was a little too on the nose as
in number 81 We're going back and we're staying
in the world of comedy with one of today's most
recognized comedies modern family at number 81
it was on ten lists, so it's actually on one
of the higher amount of lists so far, 460 points.
Highest ranked though, it did not get ranked
very high by many people, it was 32, so it did
not rank higher than that, which I found a little
surprising. Maybe Kev, let's start with you here.
Any thoughts on Modern Family coming in at number
81? I had it ranked at 77. So again a little
close again a little close. I mean, it's it's
it's further apart, but you know, your streaks
still live. But no, I think this is this is legitimately
deserving for a lot of reasons. It's very popular,
obviously does well with the ratings, but it
does super well when it comes to awards. So,
I mean, I think it's one actually for best comedy
five times out of the seven seasons. So that's
a bit obnoxious to the rest of the competitors
that have been nominated. That's like back in
the day when... I can't remember what show literally
like won every year. And it was like, all right,
guys, Frazier or Seinfeld or something like that.
So I mean, Modern Family definitely does well
with whoever's in charge of the Emmys. But I
think it's deserving. That's why I put it on
77. It kind of falls in that same range for me
as How I Met Your Mother and Big Bang Theory
and a few other ones that are these modern comedies
that have kind of shifted away from just the
standard sitcom and gotten a little bit more
diverse with their styles and stuff like that,
so I think it's deserving. Amanda, like Kevin
mentioned, Modern Family is a show that gets
a lot of accolades, gets a lot of awards. Do
you think it actually hurts it as people get,
like Kevin mentioned, get annoyed just by how
much love it gets? I think that the way it gets
hurt is it's setting its own bar, it's setting
its own standard, and can it... live up to its
own expectations and for the next season. I think
it is a really great show. I'm not really sure
about awards and things because I'm not that
cool. Or that nerdy. Or that nerdy. Either way,
same difference. People could get annoyed just
like I get annoyed with Taylor Swift fucking
winning everything and I hate her in her face
and her teeth and She just have awful teeth Just
her whole face I just want to rearrange it with
my face I didn't think we'd get Taylor Swift
mentions on the record today We got a little
Taylor Swift some T Swift as I like to say when
I'm on the radio cuz I don't like saying her
whole fucking names I hate her that same thing
where people, there's so much love surrounding
them and I think there might be a faction that
just doesn't get it and they might be those ones
that are annoyed with it. See, I think I've heard
you talk about Modern Family a few times. I believe
you're not a fan, so are you, do you think it
does not deserve to be in the top 100? I get
why people like it. Like, I mean, I... Something
about the show just doesn't sit right with me
when I'm trying to watch it, so I can't really
fathom putting myself to more of it. If that
makes any sense, like, it's just not my style
of comedy, so I don't really like it. If it doesn't
have a laugh track, I find it immensely unentertaining
to me. I wouldn't say boring because I laughed
for that last time, but I just, I don't find
it entertaining. that regard, but I don't necessarily
watch a show because it has the laugh track and
that doesn't cause me to laugh or anything. I
just, I'd usually choose to watch the shows that
have it because I don't like the dead air during
the show because it sounds very off -putting.
With a show like Water Family, what you see with
a mockumentary style, there is almost, it's a
pseudo laugh track where it's not necessarily...
The laugh track, but it's the reaction of people
around the conversations that are happening where
you almost it's the looking at the camera It's
like the breaking the the fourth wall where it's
almost taking the replace of your if your common
laughter But if that's not something that you
know, you don't like that style I can understand
that and that could be why I don't like it because
I've never thought about the fact that it's a
mockumentary which is You know, it's basically
documentary style shooting and I don't like documentaries.
So that's probably what else I could. Blasphemy
blasphemy. Kevin, you mentioned like ranking
it within How I Met Your Mother and those type
of Big Bang Theory. And to me, this show is,
in all honesty, a step above those shows. Writing
wise, it's so much more clever to me than a show
like How I Met Your Mother. And unlike How I
Met Your Mother, I think it's a show you can
you could watch any bits and pieces of it like
come in season six. or whatever. Episode 18 and
understand everything that's going on. I think
it gets kind of a bad rap for being a safe show
per se It's it's a you know, it's a family show
So it doesn't maybe it's not as risky as something
like we talked about with it's always sunny in
Philadelphia It doesn't go that route But I think
it's it's a safe show that is able to be really
clever and there's some jokes that are Really
smart and really it's really keen on the great
setup. It knows how to really set up jokes Well
almost as well as I'm not to put it in this came
for something like Seinfeld or something like
that, that it sets the stage and then when the
punchline hits it really works. It does, I think,
rely on some of the same jokes too much with
some of the characters, but Phil Dunphy to me
is a fun character. I do really enjoy it. And
it does, again, maybe rely on some of the tropes
of that side of the mockumentary a little too
much, but I don't know. I enjoy Modern Family.
Could it be higher? Maybe, but you know, it's
not like it's going to go anyplace, so I think
it's a good spot for it where it's at. All righty,
let's move on to next in the countdown Coming
in this to me I get another surprise coming in
at number 80 not necessarily It's bad, but when
you think you cast radio you think nerd you think
geek type of shows This is not necessarily a
show you think would be have universal love but
apparently it does because it's coming in and
number 80 and that is The Golden Girls, coming
in with 461 points and beat Modern Family by
a point. Eight lists, as high as ranked as number
nine. So it didn't meet the top 10. So that's
kind of where it beat out Modern Family, getting
ranked a little higher. Mike, starting with you
here, do you think The Golden Girls is getting
ranked so high simply based upon looks of its
cast? No. Do you have Glanche's poster in your
room still? No, but seriously though any thoughts
on the golden girl? This show it's it's essentially
a show about friendship It's a show that broke
ground really for women in television because
there were issues in that show that Had never
been on TV before and a pause You'd know We've
already established that I'm the young one here,
so don't try to hate i'm still viable this is
going down a road i did not expect all right
do you think uh mike that golden girls is is
number 80 good spot for it should it be higher
what are your thoughts it could be a bit higher
but 80 is fine for what we're doing here amanda
i know this is maybe a show before your time
as well but any thoughts on golden girls i love
golden girls i've seen so many reruns obviously
not when they first aired but there's been a
ton of lessons to be learned From these ladies,
I think that that opening song, I don't care
what you're doing, when you hear this song, you
get that feel good feeling and you want to go
sit in your kitchen and have some pie and talk
about Saint Olaf or wherever you're from. So
I think that I'm a little shocked that this is
this low. I think it's one of those big iconic
shows that everybody at least will know and maybe
not love, but I think that there's a lot to take
away from the show, and I think it should definitely
be higher. Steve, are you a fan of Golden Girls?
Do you think you're surprised to see it here
on this list? I'm not surprised to see it. I
mean, I understand somebody may have voted for
it. It's surprising being a predominantly geeky
list, to have it actually show up. in general,
but I don't disregard why it's here. I personally
did not vote for it, but that's neither here
nor there. It's kind of funny. Kevin, thoughts
on Golden Girls? I'm still trying to figure out
what's happening. When you said that, I was actually
somewhat in shock. I couldn't hear it because
I gasped. He swooned. No, I don't get it. I had
this at number 15. it was on seven seasons it
was nominated for best comedy seven times all
seven years for golden globe six of the years
for an amy it was in the top 10 rated shows six
out of its seven seasons it has a lot of people
as funny as it is i think way more people enjoy
the show than you would realize in all circles
geek circles, different age groups, different
whatever. I think for some reason this resonates
a lot and a lot of people have caught this on
rerun. just the cast involved and the whole dynamic.
This is a comedy that was, it was unique. It
was different than a lot of the other types of
sitcoms out there. I mean, how many other sitcoms
were about a group of five aging women or there's
not even one about five aging men. Like it's,
I don't know. It's, this one deserves to be higher.
I don't understand. You could probably blame
me because I didn't rank it. Maybe that was more
of a brain fart on my part, but it's just, it's
a show that I, you know, it's one I didn't really
watch a great deal. But thinking about it, looking
at it, it does make a lot of sense considering
at the end of the day, no matter the age of the
characters, gender of the characters, when you
have a funny show, it can resonate with a lot
of people. And I think that's bottom line what
Golden Girls was, you know, obviously had more
than just laughs. It had, as Amanda mentioned,
dealt with a lot of, and Mike mentioned, dealt
with a lot of Strong issues, but at the end of
the day I think just having really funny dynamic
characters that are all diverse and have their
own personality and talking about the cast as
far as how You know, I mean all of the almost
all these people did more than Golden Girls before
or after like there's some very experienced actresses
involved in the Golden Girls And I'm sorry, I
didn't mean to cut you off. I'm still trying
to come to terms. Yeah, I know. It's a little
shocking, a little shocking. We'll get through
it, though. We'll get through it together. Yeah,
yeah. So yeah, Golden Girls growing down at number
80 and coming up next, we're about to break new
ground in multiple ways. So let's see what's
in store next. Yes, we're breaking ground for
a few reasons first off usually this is when
the show ends and we're in our next episode But
as we're going to number 76 today, we keep on
going But we also break new ground because we're
getting our first show on a premium Network as
we're getting at number 79 Homeland. Yes, we
received 462 points on seven lists, highest ranked
at number 12 by two separate people. Kevin, are
you shocked that this is the first time we're
getting to a show that is not on one of those
cable networks or general ABC embassy networks?
I'm either shocked or... I'm shocked if it turns
out one direction and I'm not shocked if it turns
out another one because it surprises me that
it has taken this long to get there. So I would
be shocked if that means that there's not going
to be as many of these or maybe it just means
that the ones that are on there are going to
be ranked much higher. This definitely has a
whole lot of critical acclaim and has been very
much put. You know, if people were ranking, especially
if we were doing like modern shows, like ranked
the best shows from the year 2000 on, this would
probably be, you know, very high on that list.
So I am a little bit surprised that it's taken
this long, but maybe that means that a lot of
them are ranked pretty high. And it's kind of
interesting when you look at how close the last
few shows are. Modern Family was number 81 with
460 points. Homeland at 79. 462 points. So we've
only gone up, we've gone up three spots and each
spot has only been one more point. That means
all it took was one person ranking at 100 to
boost it over those other ones. Exactly, exactly.
Well, luckily for this, no one ranked that extremely
high. I've heard a lot of people compare current
shows to what Homeland used to do. Or what it
did originally like I know a lot of people that
do podcasts for like reviews of the blacklist
or Some shows like that and they compare it to
homeland a lot. I just don't get the appeal I
do honestly the first season to me I have seen
I haven't seen the most recent season, but I've
seen every other season before that Speaking
of someone who has watched the show the first
season ranks to me is one of the best seasons
I've ever seen it You know, Claire Danes, it's
her character can kind of get on your nerves
a little bit, her character being like bipolar
at times, and it's just she can maybe play it
a little too on the nose, but at the end of the
day, it was, you know, it is that thriller show.
It had an interesting plot, really great mystery.
What do you got there? Nothing. Do you want me
to take a look? When you brought the computers
back up, you rebooted the monitoring system.
I'm still station chief. I get notified whenever
someone opens a safe. Well, I know this isn't
for you. Or this. Where is he? I don't know.
Okay, where are you supposed to deliver this
then? Nowhere. Max, what are you trying to do?
You took advantage of her. You mean Farrah? She
was a financial analyst. I know. She did spreadsheets.
And you brought her here to this f***ing place.
And I told you how sorry I am. What more do you
want me to say? Don't say anything. Okay, what
do you want me to do then? Bring her back. I
wish I could, but I can't. Then get Hakani. I
can't do that either. Since when? You never say
that. You were in charge here, and you survived,
and now you're saying there's nothing to do for
her, but you're just not willing. I am willing,
but I cannot lose anyone else. It kind of lost
its way in season three when it tried to maybe
keep characters around longer than it should,
but The last season really kind of brought it
back in the head when it kind of jumped around
a little bit in time. But when this show was
really on, it's again, suspenseful. It's very
timely dealing with a lot of the stuff of today,
obviously being homeland, being dealing with
terrorists. I've never seen Blacklist. I think
I don't know how it really compares from what
I did see at Blacklist. It's a little bit more.
It's not super, super realistic. It's not like
it's. Documentary like style is super gritty,
but I would think it's more not nearly as out
there as as blacklist I think it's more you know
put you in the ground trying to get some sort
of reality compared to That a blacklist. I do
think it deserves to be on here I could see maybe
an argument for being higher, but knowing what's
on the list. I think it's an etiquette spot I'm
not arguing for being lower, but okay Have you
watched it? No, but The point that I was saying
earlier about people that watch the Blacklist
that relate the Blacklist to Homeland is more
so how the FBI works in both shows. That's where
the comparisons are coming from. OK, but it's
dealing with the CIA. They do different things.
But hey, I have not really watched Blacklist
a great deal. But I do enjoy what I did see.
But I really enjoy Homeland. So I think it does
deserve being on here. So I'd be curious to hear
what other people have to say. I just think it's
really surprising it took this long to get to
a premium network. So we'll see what that has
in store as we continue this list. So we took
a small break from the world of comedy, but we're
going back again at number 78 with 464 points
It was on nine lists. I show I guess there's
more love for it than I realized and that is
scrubs Yeah, Zach grass himself coming in at
number 78 Caviar will start with you here Shocked
to see scrubs. I guess maybe for me up so high
I don't know if I'm unloading that This makes
me wish that we were having another briscoe county
take a spot here. I actively hate this show I
I am turned off by just about I've tried I've
been around a lot of people that watch this show
and I I think I had a roommate that really liked
this show at one point and I tried and I was
just Honestly, I actively turned off by it. I
didn't find it funny. I found most of the...
I couldn't appreciate it for anything. I couldn't
appreciate it for the actors, for the jokes,
for anything about it. I hate the show. Sorry.
I've been here five years, big guy. I know that.
Kim, it's a game we play. What's your name? It's
Dirk. What's that guy's name? I don't know. He's
a patient. Looks like a Dave. Are you a Dave?
Maybe he's a Dave. We don't know. Hey. Torture
him about this. We'll do. Peace out. How come
I never noticed her before? Oh, because she wears
a wedding ring. Yeah, you don't notice women
who wear wedding rings. Kim was here on your
first day. That's enough. She was at Ben's funeral.
Dude, she's been around. So you're saying because
she wears a wedding ring, she's invisible to
me? Yes. Please, T. I'm not that shallow. Oh,
really? Will all women who are married in the
area please remove your wedding rings? Thank
you. Dr. Feinberg? Anastasia? Don't hold back.
I was hoping it did not make the list. What's
that? How the hell did it get nine years? Well,
that's the thing. It ended up, this is one of
those shows that, you know, it was on NBC. Lee's
NBC gave us ABC for a few years, perhaps maybe
staying on for too long. Steve, is Scrubs a show
you saw? Any thoughts on Scrubs? I've tried watching
it. It has that like campy and like really stupid
comedy in it. So I just, I couldn't do it. Anyone
have any positive things? It depends on the episode,
honestly. It depends on how the episodes are
set up. I've seen a few episodes. I eventually
want to go back and rediscover the show. There's
two actors in this show that I absolutely love.
It's the chief of the overall hospital and, oh
god, I forget what his name is, the other guy
that's the second -in -command. And I'm not looking
at... any lists or anything as far as who it
is, but I really enjoy those actors. But yeah,
this show, this is, I think this is stranger
showing up on our countdown than Golden Girls.
Yeah, I guess. I mean, I don't I don't hate the
show per se. I'm not a big fan of Zach Grass
and pretty much anything he does. Do you want
to rank this as the 10th best show of all time?
It did happen. It did happen. I'm sorry. So up
to number 10. Yeah, it was on my list as high
as ranked as number 10. So yeah, there you go.
But consider again, we're talking about how close
this list is. I mentioned Modern Family had 460
points. Scrubs has 464. So as we go up this list,
when it comes to the point totals, we're not
going up that far. So it's really nitty gritty
here. Let's see if that continues as we get into
the next in our countdown. 77. Well, it's been
quite a long time since we talked about a cop
show back in number 86 with dragnet and we're
gonna talk about another one at number 77 we
have NY PD blue with 466 points again only two
more points than scrubs We're not getting huge
difference in points here on nine lists as high
as ranked as number 15 Kev, I know you hated
Scrubs. Any better feelings towards NYPD Blue?
NYPD Blue deserves a spot over Scrubs. Every
single time you make this list, at any point
in the future, the past, whatever. Man, I'm still
getting over the Scrubs thing. But yeah, I mean,
NYPD Blue was pretty well -acclaimed, nominated
for a lot of awards. It was very much high -rated.
Two seasons in the top 10, five seasons in the
top 20. Over half of its seasons were nominated
as far as best drama. So, I mean, I'm not someone
that watched, excuse me, that was like a die
-hard watcher of NYPD Blue. So, I'm not its biggest
fan, but I still recognized how popular it was
and how well -received it was. So, I have no
problem with it showing up somewhere on the list.
Mike, I know you watched a little bit of NYPD
Blue. Thoughts on it coming in here at 77? Let's
get a little bit of background leading up to
our top 100 here Dan had been putting and I think
you're still gonna be putting up matchups But
on our Facebook page and Twitter and all that
he would put up matchups of show versus show
and which was the better one and Before we recorded
this episode the the one you put up was the shield
FX is the shield versus NYPD blue and one of
my comments on the post was Yeah NYPD blue the
show that was like every week. Okay, how can
we show Dennis France's ass? Cuz that's really
I'm sure that was their goal. I'm sure it was
too I mean, let's face it that show was all Andy
Sifowitz Dennis France's character it was pretty
much all his character and dealing around the
stories that you know, dealt with him. I haven't
thought about NYPD Blue in at least 15 years.
I know it was a damn good show at its time, at
its peak, but I haven't actually seen an episode
in such a long time. I do remember, though, when
one of the, I forget which season it is, you
know, Zach Morris joined the cast. I'm like,
oh, maybe that'll bring the ratings up for it.
Getting all that saved by the bell, well, yes,
I'm sure. Yeah. Well, we started with Saved by
the Bell. It's fitting that we're getting near
the end here with a Saved by the Bell connection.
Amanda, any thoughts on NYPD Blue? Uh, I haven't
seen any of this either, so I'm out. I caught,
sadly enough, I actually, in there with Mike,
I actually started watching NYPD Blue simply
because I'm like, oh, that's Zach Moore. So I
remember when he was cool. So I started watching
NYPD Blue. And, you know, it's weird seeing him
in a different light and went back and watched
the show. I like NYPD Blue. Some people maybe
argue that it should be higher than Kevin mentioned
with all the accolades, you know, has. Won multiple
Emmys. It was highly ranked. It was highly one
of those shows that was both high ratings and
Well received by critics to me. I like it It
still fits in within the cop procedurals. I think
it's better than most shows. I think it may be
better. It's more middle of the road. Not middle
of the road, but I think there are cop shows
that are way, way above NYPD Blue. It gets a
lot of claim for its grittiness. I think the
issue that hurts NYPD Blue is the shows that
have come after that are... It was gritty for
early 90s, and it kind of represented the type
of show that was out there with the Commish and
NYPD Blue and Homicide Life on the street. Which
at the time probably seemed a lot more gritty
than it does now Yeah, and Amy it did push the
boundaries. I mean it was a network TV show so
Considering that but I think that is kind of
what happens with when that's like a key point
to your show when you have shows that can do
it better Than you so I think it deserves a good
spotter. I think it deserves top 177 is I think
a decent spot for it Steve any thoughts before
we move on to the last of today as we get into
number 76 and a cop t -drill fan So that's not
something I would have watched. All right. Well,
we have one more show to go before we end today's
episode We've had a lot of variety. We kind of
got in a lot of directions and I don't know this
is gonna be We talked about surprises. I think
that's gonna continue with our next entry 76
All right. Well, we've had two sketch comedy
shows already with Carol Burnett and whose line
is it anyway? Maybe this show maybe not as well
known but it certainly has a cult cult following
a strong following as you'll see here coming
in at number 76. It is those crazy Canadians,
the kids in the hall with 476 points. So this
is the first time we took a jump in point totals.
NYPD Blue only had had 466 points, which was
only six more than number 81. So we're taking
a 10 point jump here. Only on eight lists though,
I think, so it's on fewer lists, but it got its
highest ranked as number 16. In fact, the majority
of people who voted for this voted for it within
their top 25. Big reason why it's on the list
here. You know, it is, I think, a show that,
again, a show that wasn't, I came to because
of its syndication in Comedy Central, a show
that has a very unique comedy setting. Kevin,
I know with Scrubs you talked about how you hated
that comedy. Any thoughts on The Kids in the
Hall? I'm going to be somewhat ignorant on this
one. I haven't seen enough to speak too much
of it. I know that there is a cult following
to it, and I know it definitely has a certain
fandom for it in the same way that a few other
sketch comedy shows might have as well. I think
it's one that kind of flies under the radar and
could get lost in the shuffle, but obviously
those people that voted on it voted on it high
enough to make the list. The first time I watched
it, I think it was The Bird Lady or something
like that, and I'm like, what in the world is
this show? The show business is full of actors,
singers, dancers, and models. And then there's
me. Actor, singer, dancer, model, Canadian. I
can make the word Canadian sound sexy. Most people
think that I'm from the States. And even worse,
they think that I'm from New York. Because I'm
so sexy. But New York isn't sexy. It's sleazy.
Americans know as much about Canada as... straight
people do about gays. This was a group that was
existed prior, but Lauren Michaels brought them
to TV and helped make them stars per se. And
necessarily it did receive some I mean, love
for outstanding variety show did receive a couple
nominations, though maybe its best award perhaps
the best award we've talked about today is the
fact that its hosts, the members of its cast
did get the worldwide acclaim of getting a star
on Canada's Walk of Fame. So let's be honest,
I can't really get a higher accolade than that,
being on the Canadian Walk of Fame there with
Wayne Gretzky and, I don't know. Sling to get
under somebody. Pamela Anderson probably, just
right next to them. But yeah, the kids in the
hall, it's... As I mentioned, it's only on eight
lists, so I think what happens with these types
of sketch shows is that there is a certain type
of taste comedy -wise, and it gets difficult
if you're not within that, but I think, too,
it got a huge second life on things like YouTube
and those shows where people can watch its clips
and things. Steve or Amanda, any thoughts on
Kids in the Hall? Play hockey, and that's as
close to anything Canadian as I get. Question
here is we had three sketch comedies. We had
Kevin. I throw this question to you because you
I think you We had kids in the hall. We had who
whose line is it anyway, and we had the Carol
Burnett show How did we get that order? Do you
think we got the order right should be switched
at all? Um, we got it in reverse So who's that
stays where it is and the girl Burnett gets where
this is that? Yep, that's what I would go with.
I would put Carol Burnett as the best and then
out of these three and then who's lying. But
I'm saying that completely ignorant on Kids in
the Hall because I just haven't seen enough of
it to judge it fairly. Do you think it is a sign
of things to come knowing that we're seeing some
of these shows that really have strong cult followings
doing pretty well? I think maybe with the group
that we have we're going to have some more shows
that have maybe smaller... under the radar cult
followings that maybe got enough points to make
the list. Maybe we have a group that really likes
sketch comedy and maybe we're going to see a
whole bunch of other sketch comedy shows added
to the list. It's weird though because sketch
comedy was way more of a prevalent and popular
thing in the early TV days and my thought is
going to be that we're going to probably see
a lot more modern sketch comedy shows which it's
going to be an interesting conversation if you
were to take the genre of it's you know on its
own once we're done with this list to see how
it stacks up because every other show was a sketch
comedy show back in the early early tv days so
i have a feeling we're not going to see as many
of those but we might see a handful you know
two three more modern ones all right well let's
take a quick break and when we come back let's
just get some final thoughts before we end today's
episode Hey guys, this is JD from the In Session
Film Podcast. Every week on our show, you can
join my co -host Brendan and I as we review the
latest films that's out in theaters. It also
inspires us to discuss a top three list of some
sort, and we have a lot of other fun movie discussions
as well. It's always a blast. And we also have
a show on Fridays called our Extra Film Podcast.
This is a show that gives us the space to talk
about the latest Indies and art films and other
classics that we normally just don't get to talk
about on our main show. You can find our podcast
on iTunes, Stitcher Radio, SoundCloud, TuneIn
Radio, Player FM and more. In fact, you can just
see everything about us, including our social
medias at InSessionFilm .com. So join us every
week. We'd absolutely love to have you. I'm Colin
Baker. My name's Fraser Hinds. Hi, I'm Daphne
Ashbrook. This is Andrew Cartman. Hi. This is
Colin Spohr. Hello, I'm Simon Fischerbecker.
This is Ian McNeese. Hi, this is Travis Richie.
You listen to this bark. Oh, for two minutes.
Listen to Mark Who 42's universe. If you're into
Doctor Who, listen to Mark Who 42's universe.
We always have the latest Doctor Who news, reviews,
and interviews. So we have 25 shows down so far.
Unlike last list, we did not see any domination
in genre, any domination in years. We saw a huge
variety of everything, really. Kevin, starting
with you here. Surprise on what we saw so far.
Anything that stands out to you? man like you
said there's definitely some diversity going
on here i am surprised that we had a couple shows
that were on for such a short amount of time
make the list in uh you know one or two seasons
type of shows i am basically scared and cowering
in a corner because so far only eight of my 100
have made the list so i either have a lot that
are gonna still hopefully dominate the rest of
the countdown or I am going to have a whole lot
of my list that's not represented. So I'm going
to cry a few tears probably by the time this
whole thing is over. Steve, any shows to you
so far that really stand out that really shocked
you? I guess like the Briscoe County Junior and
the Scrubs and the shows like that that we all
had our public outcry about. I really don't know
of any other ones besides that and I think it's
kind of funny I've only got nine so far that
have been on my top 100 that have shown up I've
been keeping track because I'm like I have a
feeling which ones are gonna end up being closer
to the front but I'm probably way off the way
this list is going Amanda this is your first
time doing a top 100 list Was it everything you
expected? And more. Except that my favorite show
on the planet was so freaking low, and I don't
get it, and I'm pouting still. It blew my mind.
You guys crushed my dreams and my hopes. So I'm
not really sure what the rest of this list is
going to... Yeah, it just burst my little super
-action bubble. It's on the list, though. Half
my shows aren't going to be on the list. It just
sucks, though, because it's at the bottom end
of the spectrum and... It was number two for
me. Yeah, Dan the other thing too just not to
butt in but Maybe it's gonna have to deal with
the fact that we have so many more people that
contributed less than our last two top 100s Almost
by probably like 30 % more lists But we have
seen a whole bunch of shows that have been ranked
in People's top five already fall and that was
something that was never the case really too
much in our past countdowns I wanna know who
these motherfuckers are because I'm a little
upset. Yeah, I mean speaking we know not only
that we saw already so far three number ones
fall We saw a couple number threes fall couple
number twos fall a number four here in their
fall So yeah, I mean being ranked highly on one
person's list. It doesn't guarantee you I mean
it may it might help you get into the list for
sure But you needed like I mentioned it's one
thing we're gonna continue to see in order to
be on this list We're having so many people contribute
you need you know, either a couple of things
that happened being on a lot of lists or being
rankly really high on a select few. The fewest
list a show was on going into this was six lists.
So, which is honestly, which is low, but considering
the amount of people in the variety, and like
I mentioned, over 630 shows got votes on it so
far. Mike, you didn't get a chance to chime in
here. Yeah. So any thoughts on the countdown?
So as we... got into the first top 25. I think
still the biggest shock for this first episode
of the countdown is that Saved by the Bell was
100. You've got to be kidding me. I'm surprised
it made the list, but I think it's good. Well,
I think it's good. I just think it should be
higher. Yeah, I mean I could see that I'm not
saying I'm not saying higher is in top I mean,
I know everybody loves say by the bell most people
do apparently not by our standards, but I'm saying
like at least in the 80s maybe or the 70s not
just right at 100 because I was expect like Essentially
for me if I was doing this list, I'd probably
switch Say by the bell with agents of shit and
put agents of shit at 100 Well, you could do
that any other if there was one show that we
could take off and maybe Remove from this section
and bring in to next week's show any show. Do
you think that is most deserving Kevin? I mean
the the highest two that I had ranked were Golden
Girls and Carol Burnett show So I would probably
put Golden Girls in the next episode rather than
this one if that's what you're asking Yeah, I
think that's what I'm asking. So Uh, so 25 shows
down 75 shows more to go Any thoughts before
we bring this episode to a close? Um, we only
have 75 shows left and I need to fit 92 of them
in there It's not gonna happen well funny funny
story about that Alright, well that's gonna do
it for this first part of the top 100 television
show countdown here on geek cast radio telecast
and remote control Next time and we'll find out
what was it 75 to 50 or 51 51 51 Yeah, yeah,
yeah You can find us at the cast radio on Twitter
go to Facebook Facebook comm slash geek cast
radio network Kevin what is your Twitter? My
Twitter is Optimus Solo. Amanda? Hardcandy Mandy,
eyes no wise. Dan? Still at mover revolt, I tried
to get a change for this episode, but I didn't
want to do that, so. Yeah, I changed it at the
beginning of this one. Steve? SCP -21? And I'm
of course at TFG1Mike, head on over to GeekCastRadio
.com, comment on this episode and let us know
what you thought of the first 25 rankings. Unleash
the geek in you and we will catch you next time.
Please remember to tell us the show you are leaving
the message for at your name. So until next time,
unleash the geek in you.
No chapter markers for this episode.
Hosts




Just started listening and I have to defend Briscoe County Jr. That show was awesome and just cause it was only one season doesn’t effect is quality. I only own three TV shows on DVD, and Firefly and Brisco County Jr. are two of them (Sci-Fi Westerns for the win). It’s sillier than Firefly, but has a really good mixture of plot and humor and the lead actors are just great.
I liked Briscoe…. it was just weird that in the middle of the Season the whole dynamic of the show changed. I forget after which ep that happens.
I’m there with you. I don’t own the show but how aweomse was it to have Bruce Campbell on TV. Especially at that time. I’d love to see him play this character again. After seeing him in the Ash vs Evil dead show he could still do it.
So happy you guys are doing another one of these. Once I heard you were doing another one I got super stoked about getting a chance to see how it turn out. Have to say a few big surprises. The good: Kids of the Hall making the list (love that show), Always Sunny Making the list (although it should be much higher). The Bad: All the hate for Scrubs. Sorry but I love that show, Sports Night being on the list. Really? Where did that come from. Overall though happy with what you have so far. I love you get shows like Saved By the Bell, Andy Griffith and Louie all in one show.
See I remember enjoying Scrubs but haven’t seen it in years. It is a show I’m going to be re watching soon. Thanks for the feedback, glad you are enjoying the show!
Sorry but I hate Scrubs almost more than any other television show I have ever watched. Just being honest!
Some random thoughts on the list.
“Kids in the Hall”- It’s okay, but if I was gonna put a Canadian sketch series,I would’ve probably put either “SCTV Network” or “Bizarre” ahead of it, if more people knew about them,they would’ve been ahead of them. Especially “Bizarre”, which I thought about too late to consider for my list, but yeah, “KITH” is okay, but there’s better sketch comedy on there.
“Scrubs”- Way too low. It was way ahead of it’s time, challenge many of the notions of comedy, it’s doesn’t the credit it should. It’s this generations “M*A*S*H”, and I don’t get the panning of it by some of you. It’s way too low, should’ve been Top 50, easily.
“Whose Line Is It Anyway?”-I had the British version on there, I would’ve brought up, how it really was, essential sketch comedy at it’s barest, literally, improvising, which had not been done more, and that’s why, at least some version belongs on the list. Really, revealing the first drafts of the writing process essentially, and that’s the thing that’s really unique about the series. Really stripping down something that, most people proudly didn’t think could be stripped down.
“Orange is the New Black”-Too soon, but okay.
“Home Improvement”-Didn’t make my list, but probably would’ve made send top 100. Um, I actually don’t think it holds up as well now, than it does back then, especially the later seasons. I think when you go back to those post-“Roseanne” shows that were about the more midwest, realist, stand-up influenced shows, “Grace Under Fire” is the one that really holds up better now, but still, I’m glad it’s on there.
“Knight Rider”-How the hell did this make it? Even if you’re going by nostalgia, I can think of five better cars from the eighties I would’ve put on there before “Knight Rider”. “Magnum”‘s car, “The Rockford Files”, eh, “Miami Vice” holds up better. I don’t get this at all.
“How I Met Your Mother”-If this show was on, in the ’70s, when “All in the Family” and “The Mary Tyler Moore Show” and “Soap”, and “Good Times” and all those other shows that were really re-imagining what a sitcom could be, then this show would be more respected. I mean, it’s hard to do a nine-season run on a sitcom, with a running storyline that you literally start from the first episode, very bold, very daring, even though, too many can easily mistake this as a “Friends” ripoff, it’s really, shocking how well they did this. A different era and it would’ve gotten more respect.
“Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.”- Okay, this is bullshit. Shouldn’t be on the list, shouldn’t have considered. Not a good show, at all,-, it’s yeah, this is when it’s clear that some people have TV knowledge and some don’t when crap like this makes it.
“Sesame Street”-It’s the only kids series that made my list, I’m curious to see if something like “Mister Rogers’s Neighborhood” or something like that makes it though; it’s tough to compare, but there is definitely more than enough reasons why “Sesame Street” needs to be on the list.
“Supernatural”-I don’t get why people like this show. WTH? It’s a dumber version of “The X-Files”, wth? This and “Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.” people like certain things and therefore they’ll vote for, superhero, supernatural stuff, without regarding quality even within the genre. Yeah, I’m baffled it made the list, much less people defending it.
“The Adventures of Briscoe County, Jr.”-I don’t remember this show, but when I did my poll on my blog years ago, after polling 100 people, with just Top Ten lists, it did get one vote, so there is a base for it, I’m a bit shocked it showed up here. I do three one-season shows on my list, and yeah, I understand not putting too much stock in length of time, some thing don’t catch on, but this wasn’t one of them. And somebody has to explain to me the appeal of Bruce Campbell, I don’t get it.
“The Flintstones”-I guess you can argue it’s importance, but I’m a little surprised it showed up here. Let’s not even just compare it to animation, when you think of some of it’s competitors in the genres of a family sitcom where the family’s strange for some reason, up against “The Munsters” or “The Addams Family” or “Bewitched”, in that era, I don’t know, it’s kitsch appeal gets more faint the longer it’s passed in my mind.
“Saved By the Bell”- Oh c’mon, I know it’s nostalgic but this show is terrible. Just because we remember it fondly, I don’t know if it should be on here.
“Homeland”-I’m actually a little surprised this one showed up. It’s good, but I don’t rank it as a great series. Even in it’s first season, it’s basically a show with one trajectory and had nowhere to go but down, maybe it’s gotten a rebound lately, but-eh. It’s the same people who did “24” I believe, but that show was always intended to be a season long, only, and then they figured out how to extend it, and “Homeland” is kind of an example why you shouldn’t do that in my mind.
“Dragnet”-I’m glad the original version made the list, I was afraid the late ’60s one would’ve made it; not that that version, undeserving, but it’s oddly more dated, especially how anti-drug it was, it comes off more comedic. The gritty ’50s version, based on the radio series, definitely holds up better.
“The Carol Burnett Show”-Way, way, way too low. And it still holds the record for the longest recorded laugh in TV history with the “Gone With the Wind” parody sketch. That alone should’ve put it on the list.
Overall, eh, I’m nervous about the rest, but it’s not as bad as I worried it would be, so far anyway. Looking forward to the rest of the list.
Supernatural is a pretty decent show really, better than most. It’s not The Sopranos or anything, but it isn’t trying to be. It’s funny, the leads are pretty likeable, there are some really good horror moments.
It does run a bit long, they really are reaching for ideas by season 7 or so, and it’s fan community is really, really fucking crazy, but if you’re looking for an above average popcorn show, you could do a lot worse.
Yeah, “Decent”, that’s the word. That’s what annoys me with putting it on here. It’s decent, it’s not in the great echelon of series. No it isn’t a bad show-, (Well, it’s not bad for a CW show, I will need to qualify this) but it’s not great. I wonder about the fans of it, I know some myself, I suspect that A. they haven’t seen some of the better shows before and after it, but especially with horror fans, I have a theory that horror fans will anything horror whether it’s good or bad and react the same way. Hell, there’s a whole film subgenre based on this, grand guignal, horror as comedy. But, as to “Supernatural” the leads, eh, I don’t know they don’t seem interesting to me, I think they’re too pretty boy-ish honestly, Tina Fey has that theory about how “Friends” is the exception and no other TV show has been successful with all it’s main characters being young good-looking people, (I’d argue the British version of “Coupling” is the other exception, but…) it sorta applies here, to me and other than that though, all it ever feels like is a cheesy retread of better shows, and not done with like a nod to those others like, “Monk” for instance. I really don’t see the appeal.
I would argue that Party of Five was pretty dang successful with a cast of good looking people as well. Regardless of any opinions good or bad on Supernatural I would say it definitely has a huge following and maybe that alone warrants it getting a spot on the list.
Eh, some of the worst shows of all-time have a “following”, that’s- eh, I can’t go that far. Especially today, you know, people forget this now, but we’re in such a horrible time for television because there’s so much of it and, it’s all specialized towards an audience of some kind. A specific, it’s not going out into the ether and see who comes to it, which is new; that was never the case. Before there was three channels and that was it, you watched everything. A show like, “New Girl”, which is basically the center of FOX’s comedy lineup, gets ratings that were a 1/3 of shows that got cancelled ten years ago. Meanwhile, if you check the top most-watched TV broadcasts of all-time list, like the top 50 or top 100 or something, and most of it, what you expect, last episodes of “M*A*S*H”, “Cheers”, “Seinfeld”, “Magnum, P.I.”, (Yes, the highest rated drama series finale of all-time, is still “Magnum, P.I.”, by a mile btw over every other drama series finale you can think of.) and about twenty Super Bowls, and “Roots” and the “Who Shot JR”, Dallas, etc. etc., and somewhere on that list, like 49th still, or something like that, is an episode of “The Beverly Hillbillies”. Not a special episode, not a memorable episode, not a good episode, a random episode of “The Beverly Hillbillies”, that there is literally no explanation for why it’s has those ratings. Half the damn country watched it that night (And it was about half the country at the time) you watched things ’cause the novelty of a screen in your living room playing stuff, was still fresh. Popularity can make it noted but, I’d hardly call it a warranting reason for a list like this. (And in case you’re wondering, in it’s time, however big you think “Supernatural” is among it’s fans, “The Beverly Hillbillies” was about 25 times bigger, and worldwide too. Seems unbelievable today, but there a huge fanbase for it, that’s Beatle-like almost.) Anyway, I disagree fandom alone that not warrant a spot of a list like this. It shouldn’t anyway.
As to “Party of Five”, eh, it was moderately successful, although you’re the first person I’ve heard even mention it in fifteen years. It’s been that long since I’ve seen it, and from what I remember it, most of the cast was supposedly kids, (or were supposed to be) and it was primetime soap a la “…90210”, and, yeah, soap operas might be an exception to this rule, although most of the soap operas I can name have at least aged character that’s not exactly the epitome of youth. It’s been too long since I revisited “Party of Five” for me to remember, but I’ll bet there’s a regular that you might be forgetting that doesn’t fit the mold.
Interesting you have some done really well thought out responses and love reading them. Unfortunately I think I’ve disagreed with you on every point you’ve made so far. Again I didn’t say fandom or popularity is the end all be all of if a show should make the list. I said it’s one of a dozen components that should be considered. also you say you have no time for personal favorites…I hate to break it to you but Scrubs is clearly one of yours and I’m sorry it’s not funny it’s not genius and it’s not too 100 worthy!
I assume you are joking lol, but even as someone who didn’t enjoy Scrubs I could see its argument for Top 100. I honestly didn’t realize how critically praised it was until I started doing research. Still not a fan of it, but I do respect it.
Joking with which part?
Yeah, I’m not in the majority when it comes to believing this is the greatest era of television. That’s not to say that there aren’t great shows, I agree, but I think it’s closer to for every one “Breaking Bad”, there’s about ten “2 Broke Girl$”. Let me give a stat, 1973, Saturday Night Lineup for CBS. 8:00pm, “M*A*S*H”, 8:30pm, “All in the Family”, 9:00: “The Mary Tyler Moore Show”, 9:30pm, “The Bob Newhart Show”, 10:00pm, “The Carol Burnett Show”. You will never get a lineup that good again. Now, here’s the other question I point to, when I see a lineup like that, “Who was the audience that those shows were aiming for?” And the answer to all of them is nobody. Actually that’s wrong, the answer is “Everybody”, and that’s the thing that really makes television unbearable to me nowadays, and why, maybe we have a lot of good shows on TV, but is it a good era of television, and I say no. Because everything is micromanaged to the point, where even great shows like a “Scrubs”, are going to be attracted to only a very particular group of people. The demographics era if you will, and too much of television does this. Not just in content, but even in audience, even to the point where networks are just based around getting that audience of whoever. CW particularly I find obnoxious (although they are getting slightly better) ’cause they usually seems to aim specifically for dumb 13-year-olds and usually takes what could have been a decent idea and then dumbs them down to the point where you’re no longer bringing an audience up to you, you’re going down to them. (That’s actually probably the #1 real reason I would strike “Saved By the Bell”, ’cause lets face it, you didn’t exactly feel like you were getting something substantial out of watching it. It’s sugary cereal, nothing nutritious but you feel filled up) I mean, I get it for a cable network to be doing that, ESPN should just be trying to get sports fans, but a basic network, I don’t even have to pay for? And yeah, every HBO and AMC, and Showtime, there’s ten or twelve TLC’s out there, and it’s not even that it’s reality vs. scripted, even a show “Game of Thrones”, a show I like, but it’s definitely more akin to a specific demographic than other demographics. That’s why I find it frustrating, there’s a lot more good stuff out there, but 20 or 30x more bad stuff too, and even sorting through the good stuff can just be an overload nightmare, and even then, it’s catering to an audience too much usually. There’s a great “A Bit of Fry & Laurie” sketch from the ’80s that I always like, it was in a restaurant, and they were serving a guy who wants to break up BBC, and make UK television more like American cable, and give everybody more of an opportunity to get on television, free to all. Understandable, makes sense, but they soon take his fork away and they bring him back a bag of plastic sporks. This is what you want, a lot of lesser quality programs on many channels, and not one perfectly good working fork. That’s kinda how I see a lot of television these days. Perfectly fine a lot of it, more of it but I also tend to see that I’m swimming through sporks looking for a fork. And as television and movies, I do think there’s a switch in freedom and quality that does indicate that people are moving away from film and to television, although I would argue that that’s as much movies faltering as it is television getting better. There’s more freedom in television, some television now than ever before, but, eh, that’s actually been that way for awhile. Technically there’s nothing on HBO that couldn’t be on network if they put it on at ten o’clock or later, they just aren’t doing it.
As to favorites, eh, I’m weird, well, if I do have favorites, I won’t admit them. That said, I don’t think of “Scrubs” as a favorite, but I’ve gone on this rant before elsewhere, but I’m not a “favorites” guy, I look at the quality before I ever look at preferences, and it’s cost me a few times, personally but I, I always believe that the distinction that people should make before anything else is between what is “good” and what you “like”, and like, is a bias, so I immediately discard it. The only time like ever comes into play when I’m analyzing is when I honestly have gone through every other piece of analysis, and even then, it’s just a tiebreaker. To me, I want to know why something’s good, tell me you like it, and i tune out, that’s a preference, and you’ll like something regardless of quality, so it means very little to me and I don’t consider, so I when someone bashing something, whether they like it or not, that’s almost indefensible behavior, ’cause quality isn’t really something debatable. I know we pretend it is, but it is determinable and measurable. I mean you can claim “Plan 9 from Outer Space” is better than “Citizen Kane”, it ain’t gonna be true. 95% of analyzing something, pretty much isn’t opinionated or debatable, now when you get to arguing whether “Citizen Kane” is better than “Casablanca” or “The Godfather” or something like, then that 5% of analysis gets a little more interesting, but I don’t consider personal favorites. Sorry, just not how I analyze work. Apparently that’s weird, but I was taught that, I figured everybody else was, until, you know, the outside world heard about it, but… (Shrugs) I’d still argue it better than taking your favorites as preferential over what might be good.
You can act like your taste has nothing to do with your analysis all you want, heck you can even actually believe that that’s true. Unfortunately it’s not man. I’m sorry but you can try all you want to say quality is not debatable or personal taste can be removed from your analysis but bottom line is……it’s not and it can’t. Quality is subjective and personal taste always plays a part whether you admit it or not our whether you are doing it subconsciously or not. also numerous times in this discourse on this page you have made comments to allude to the fact that somehow you have a superior skill set, upbringing or intelligence level….those aren’t good habits to get into in these types of debates and commentary just fyi
Um, no I don’t buy that. There’s a lot of stuff that’s great that I can’t stand at all a lot of it I actually did put on my list. But, yeah, I strongly disagree with this. If quality was really that subjective than at some point in the last 500 years or so, something would’ve replaced the Mona Lisa at the Louvre. A part, that’s subjective, yeah, but the more I think about it, it matters less and less. I can’t say someone’s untalented even if I can’t stand what they do, when clearly they are. Quality, for the most part, isn’t subjective. That’s like saying that somebody who’s a professional juggler, can’t juggle. No, I can see he can juggle and he’s worked at it for years, you know. How well they use those skills to the best of their ability and towards the piece as a whole, how well does the juggler use his skills, that’s a bit more debatable, but, yeah I get upset when I see people, really embrace the things they prefer or like, over the stuff that’s clearly better and good. To me, that’s a complete reversal on how to analyze quality and that’s just limiting. This is another reason why I say this isn’t a good time for television, especially with so many outlets and shows that, you’re no longer to go and sit and see what’s presented, people just look for the things they are already predisposed to liking. It’s limiting when you do that, but it’s encouraged now to seek out the shows that you’re already supposedly pre-disposed to liking. I find that frustrating and limiting. We don’t all have the same accesses to everything, we’re seeking out what we’re prone to seek out on our own. The fact is, you never know what you’ll actually “like” until you discover it, much less what’s good. I truly do tend to ignore my personal taste. How successful, I am, I think overall I’m pretty good at it. Doesn’t mean I haven’t occasionally rewatched a “California Dreams” when no one’s looking, but still, I’m not looking at it as something I like to watch anymore, so that’s an improvement.
As to alluding to being more intelligent, I’m not trying to. I just come off like that sometimes, I’m told. Yeah I wish I had something better to respond there, but (Shrugs) it comes with the MENSA card, what can I tell ya? No, I’m kidding about that, but I am trying not to do that and to listen intently to everyone else’s perspective, but I often don’t agree, and I try to explain why. That’s about it.
Except your Mona Lisa argument doesn’t work because its as much about the history of the piece and who made it , as it is as the quality of the product of why its there. As speaking with a brother in law who goes to Yale for an Art doctorate I can tell you artists often have very bad things to say about many famous artists and their work that appear in museums. (it doesn’t get annoying at all)
Being a professional doesn’t in turn make you great or good at what you do. Rob Ryan has been a professional defensive coordinator for decades now, I’m pretty comfortable in saying his pretty awful at his job. No matter what your status, history, or occupation you still need to execute.
Maybe its due to text as that can cause cloud someone’s true intentions, but You’ll do yourself a huge favor in life if you realize that everyone doesn’t have to think, absorb, debate, or determine the exact way you think they should.You talk about limiting, and that mindset will only go to limit your own perspective. I didn’t read, watch, or listen to reviews to reinforce my stance or disregard others. I tend to enjoy learning how others process films, and the reason they like or dislike something. Their opinions won’t change mine usually, but I also won’t disregard it either. I love your thoughts, your reviews are great, and well thought out, but they aren’t gospel. Nor are mine by any stretch of the imagination. No one’s opinions are, when someone acts like they are that’s when they lose me.
I look at a documentary like Leviathan. I personal love it, and feel its a great doc for reasons I won’t go into, but I also realize people are going to hate it for good reason. I don’t see how anyone can walk out of that movie and say this is in fact the true score of what this movie is. Because what unbreakable facts are you biasing that off of.
What are the non debatable elements you use to determine the exact quality of a show. is it providing the audience with what they want? Is it creating a show that anyone can enjoy any episode? Is it ignoring the audience and creating a show that will only appeal to a specialize few? Is it creating a show before its time? Creating a show of its time? Is there an exact pacing scale someone should follow? Can’t be too quick, or too long? What’s the right or wrong way to use your dialog? How much humor should it have?
.
There are perceived great movies that Roger Ebert doesn’t like,and perceived bad ones that he does. Same for every critic, and everyone person. I’d hate to live in a world where Rotten Tomatoes has two scores 100% or 0% because we now have objective blue print to review media. Just sounds really boring to me. But that’s a subjective opinion I grant you .:)
This!!
I think I did pan “Leviathan”, but eh,- look I get what you guys mean in the general consensus, but on a personal perspective, eh,…. If you’re not going to go out and defend every perspective one has on something, I-eh, it doesn’t hold up. Look, I know people disagree about The Mona Lisa, I’m one of them, but A. the point still holds, historical context is apart of how you analyze a work too, and to some extent opinions are subjective, some more than others, but, I don’t understand, at all, treating them that way. If you’re not gonna go out on a limb, and really analyze everything about something if you can, then, what are you doing, just passively observing? Eh, you know, I understand that some aren’t gonna accept, see or appreciate something the ways I will, but I don’t like of idea of not promoting my perspective, and anybody else doing the same thing for that matter. I genuinely don’t think it’s good that people allow they’re subjective opinions to be the main basis for how they analyze art, of any kind, and I definitely think that it’s worth exploring and promoting my process. It doesn’t preclude disagreement by the way, just a higher level of it. It’s not assumption, either, you do have to prove one is talented. I’ve panned every Shane Carruth, ’cause I’m convinced he’s not capable of creating, an actual human character for instance (or tell a story that doesn’t involve all the characters unknowingly controlled by things outside themselves). If he can change my mind on that I’ll be ecstatic, but I’m not assuming anything, prove one’s talented and then I’ll look at how that talent is used. As to analyzing art mathematically, well,… yeah, it’s not necessarily mathematical, but I do disagree with that scene in “Dead Poets Society” where Robin Williams makes everybody tear up the part of the book about analyzing authors that way. Not that one has to prefer Shakespeare over Frost or whoever, you should still, understand where people come from with how they come to that conclusion. If anything, I find it makes it even easier to criticize and pan stuff that is otherwise generally accepted. I don’t know how you guys started misinterpreting what I’ve been writing as anything more than spirited debates and analysis, just because i analyze it differently, and because it’s my perspective, I think you need to present it as, one’s own gospel almost…-, okay, not gospel, that’s a terrible word to use there, but as assured as possible. I’m presenting an argument, and I’m looking for the defense to present a better or more convincing one. That’s all, I’m looking at the evidence and trying to read it, and you can read it differently than me, then, show me how to read it better. Even still, it’s-, you know to go back to “Leviathan”, eh, understand why some might disagree, I get, but just accepting. It’s your truth that you see it one way. This above all, to thy own self be true, it should be presented as truth, from you, it’s how you see it. That’s why I always present my perspective that way.
As to analyzing from an archaic perspective, eh, you know, that’s the thing, it’s not archaic a perspective, it’s just not the perspective of television. I mean, it’s not new, I doubt that people who loved John Wayne movies cared about “The Brady Bunch”, but it’s overly prevalent, and especially with all the availability of other outlets, it’s causing television to not be television. That’s what I’m more skeptical of, with all these shows and ways of viewing them, it’s not-so much that it’s analyze differently than before, but it’s analyzed in a way that’s, simply not television. It’s easier to avoid bad shows, it’s also easier to miss good ones, and frankly neither of those are actually good. There’s plenty of bad television that’s ingrained in our culture and mind that’s secondhand verbiage now, hell, I just mentioned one of them. And that’s a part of television, is seeing everything available, that’s just not happening anymore. We didn’t watch a lot of those shows because we liked them, we watched them ’cause they were what’s on, and a big part of it too. That’s the real reason I don’t like the micromanaging of series towards demographics, especially today, it shouldn’t be just that easy to avoid. Television at it’s core is supposed to be all-encompassing, and that’s not what it’s becoming, now it’s, literally everybody watching their own thing on their own computers. I mean, yes there’s more freedom (Although Jack Benny had just as much freedom as Louis C.K. has now in his time and there’s a few other exceptions.) but the focusing in on demographics, that’s what’s narrowing about it, even more than the availability of other viewing options (Although I’m only begrudging accepting those just apart of the world at large now too). I get it from a business perspective to lean towards some more than others, but especially on network television, it shouldn’t be this obvious about it. And I’d argue that because some channels offer freedom for artists, doesn’t mean that’s greater either; in some ways it’s much more difficult to be going after everybody possible and getting that while creating great television. As great as it is that we are getting great shows now, we got great shows in the past too and terrible ones then and now as well, but now it’s not more limiting than ever to an audience. Despite the great shows, I find that, that makes television and in many ways, us, a lot more worst off than we used to be. That’s why when television industry as a whole nowadays, I don’t see us progressing as others do. I’m not saying I wouldn’t be avoid watching “Keeping Up with the Kardashians”, but it should honestly, be harder to avoid it than it is.
You really come off as someone who thinks his own shit doesn’t stink. I went to your site, checked out your reviews and they are fine, they aren’t as good as you think they are. All I see you say is give evidence and your reviews are nearly all opinion on how things should be made the way you want. That and jesus christ dude paragraphs are your friend and not every review needs to be war and piece. A little less rambling would go a long way. Honestly man you come off as a person that needs to get over himself. You are not on a higher plain then everyone else. You just get way too high on your own supply.
That’s not necessary. I’m all for debate and disagreement. Personal attacks like this are taking things in a direction that is not needed. If you want to disagree with someone fine,but it’s not that difficult to be civil about it.
I guess I’m not understanding what you are saying. Correct me if I’m wrong but what I gather from your thoughts is there is a definitive answer to whether a product is good or bad. And those that don’t agree with that answer are only doing so because they let personal biases get in the way.
I’m not saying opinions don’t require evidence, just that two people can watch a movie or TV show, and provide equal evidence of what it is good or bad.
Look at your Shane Carruth example. You are starting with a subjective opinion that a movie is required to have a human character at its center. I’m sure you can provide evidence of why that’s important, as I good indicating why that has no impact on what the movie is actually accomplishing. If you need that in your films I get that, but what I
get from what your saying is that in order to argue the quality of Primer I would have to argue it has a human character at its center, because that’s the determining factor of why it’s good or bad.
The reason we are misinterpreting what you are trying to say is because you speak as your opinion as fact, or like you have some uncanny ability we all don’t and that’s why you think the way you do. You have talent for sure, but you’re not alone in that.
You may not realize but you come at viewpoints as if someone needs to perceive or evaluate something the same way you do, like the quality of TV today. You say provide evidence but I’ve yet to see you give evidence of why TV is better back then than today beyond TV doesn’t fit into the format you prefer, or networks don’t work the way you think they should. If they don’t fine, if that’s the way you want things I get it. But it’s
not the way things have to be. You keep speaking about quality of something, yet I have to see how a show’s demographics impacts its quality. You aren’t following through with your own requirement.
For me the bottom line is with TV today the talent is better at all fronts. The heights of TV today are greater than before, and we are able to create TV that is equal to that of film on every level. That wasn’t the case before. TV felt like TV because it wasn’t as well
produced, didn’t have the same level of acting talent, and was beholden to ratings. Yes there is garbage, and yes it could easy for great TV to get lost in the shuffle, as has always been the case. Personally I prefer living in a world where I don’t have to watch TV based on a specific day and specific time. It would be impossible for me to watch anything if that was the case. My questions is how much greatness is there. And how high does that greatness go. Awful stuff will be forgotten and go away like it always does. It’s not like the 70’s was void of bad movies, but its look at with such regard because of the amount of great movies and just how great those movies where. That’s what I see with today. A time where its impossible just to keep up with how much great stuff there is. Not an issue when everything at a specific day and time it was on.
You may think differently, or have different expectations of what TV should do. I respect that and would never state you have to have the same expectations that I do.
However, It’s as if you unwilling to realize that the way you prefer things are not fact, or completely objective. You act as if you evidence is fact, you ask for something better but it’s impossible when you unwilling to acknowledge the evidence you are using to determine the quality of something may be evidence that has no impact on someone’s view point. You attack a Shane Carruth movie based on what you expect from a film. Great love seeing how you interpret movies and what you wish to get out of them. If his film doesn’t met those expectations then feel free to explain why. My issue is your expectations are your expectations. don’t need a human character at the center of my film to enjoy it. I enjoy movies that aren’t character driven and can appreciate films trying a different approach.
What I gather from your responses though is that a viewpoint like that is not valid. And it’s only because I’m a casual viewer who doesn’t have the ability you do to perceive film. Maybe that’s not your attention, and I don’t think it is. But based upon the evidence you are providing that appears to be what you are arguing.
Okay, after two days before my computer finally started working again, I’ve long forgotten what I was planning to write in response, (Although I’m probably gonna end up turning the “horrible time for television” reaction/comment into my own blogpost eventually, and I’m definitely not signing off that because it’s more well-produced now, some of it, means TV’s better overall now) but yes, I think there is some misinterpretation of my thoughts going on, and yes, I tend to present my opinions as facts, ’cause that’s how I was taught to present them and argue them. That said, I also don’t think much of a fan perspective, so I do disregard it immediately usually. To me, not only does it play off as bias, which it is, but it often leads to a narrowing of one’s perspective and honestly I see more bad in that perspective than good and find it better to take a look at work outside of that perspective, and usually through a more educated prism. To me, there’s a distinct difference between “like and good” and too often, I see it confused for each other, and often the like completely dominant over the good, and I just disagree with that approach, if for no other, than I just don’t buy that art is as subjective as some say. It kinda feels like saying, “This turning on of the camera and recording of people acting and performing is equal to this other turn on of the camera and recording of people acting,” as, somebody who’s a film school graduate and does still occasionally work in the industry, I know for a fact that’s not true and there’s so much more to it, so when I see people treat it them as though they are and it’s only preference that distinguishes them, I see it as an affront to be completely honest. Maybe that’s why I seem more combative than I’m trying to be, but it doesn’t come off right in my mind.
Okay, I didn’t say I hated Carruth ’cause I’m against a non-human main character, I said, “He’s not capable of it”, there’s a difference. I won’t get too into all my theories on Carruth, but basically the way he uses the symbolic and tonal touches of his films and his outright refusal to create characters that actually are characters and not just people under others’ controls under others’ control or whatever-the-hell, make me believe that he uses though these techniques as a way of hiding the fact that he can’t create a human character or a typical story for that matter. Like I said, maybe his next film will prove me wrong, but two films in nine years and basically it’s like he never passed the first lessons of screenwriting, but someone gave him the advanced Final Cut Pro to use. I mean, Malick never has a traditional narrative either but he could easily do one if he wanted to, but Carruth, I don’t think he does and that’s why I’ve heavily panned both his films…. and my Carruth rant goes on from there, and I’ll save that for another time.
But by being so focused on presenting your point as fact, you don’t seem to be listening or in this case reading the point I’m making.
I don’t’ really care what you think if Shane Carruth. My point regarding your Shane Carruth criticism was that you were basing your argument on something you feel a movie has to have tobe good. My point is who is to say that is a requirement, or a movie can’t be good without that. As there are many critics, who I can only assume have an education like yours, who feel differently than you do. So if we are to use your argument that greatness of quality is without subjectivity than those who disagree with you are flat out wrong.
And that’s my issue. You are so caught up on the idea that you are above bias that you refuse to see how truly bias you are. You’re so caught up on the fact that you come at things from a higher perspective, what you don’t realize is you sound more narrow minded than anyone. Your entire argument on TV is based on your idea of the way TV should act. That is not the case. You don’t make the rules because you went to some school for a film degree. Sure you have tools to review something, but those tools have been sharpened based on your personal taste and preferences. Yes in order to state something is good or bad you need to provide objective evidence, but the final formation of that opinion will still be effected by personal taste.
If you wan’t to continue to think its not fine, but all I need to do is read your thoughts on something to see how you prove my point for me. I enjoy doing so anyways, so its a win win.
This is the biggest problem with your entire argument…you say “Television at it’s core is supposed to be all-encompassing.” …Ummm, says who? See you are working under this artificial construction that there are rules to what TV is and is not supposed to be. Just because you want everyone to be forced to watch the same shows every night and eliminate any show that doesn’t appeal to the ENTIRE family or doesn’t have at least something for each age/race/gender/maturity level/intelligence level/personal taste does not mean that’s how everyone views TV. What is wrong with someone knowing that they really really really enjoy science fiction, and therefore seeks out and watches a variety of science fiction programming? How is that somehow dumbing them down or lessening the quality of said programming that they are watching?
I understand the nostalgia for wanting a day, like days gone by where the entire family gathers around the ONE TV set in the living room after dinner and bonds over a good wholesome program. There’s nothing wrong with you liking that or longing for that…but that doesn’t mean that any other way people value or view television outside of that notion is wrong or evil. You keep saying that people are narrowing their vision because they let the fact that they ‘like’ something shape their opinion of it…yet your vision of television and what purpose it serves is more narrow than anything else presented in this entire discussion.
It absolutely blows my mind how you think you aren’t letting your personal taste, opinions and upbringing etc play into which shows you are saying are ‘good’ and ‘bad’ quality. Remember, we aren’t talking extremes here. No one is saying California Dreams or Beverly Hills 90210 is as high quality as E.R. or All in the Family. But for the hundreds of shows that fall in between those two extremes, there is not right or wrong answers as to how they should be ordered. You could take into account things like actors, directors, writers, longevity, ratings, awards, spin-offs, or a number of other objective pieces of information, but when it comes down to it, the difference between your #76 selection and your #77 selection is most likely almost 100% subjective and based on personal opinions.
You’re grading television today off an archaic principal. People don’t consume their media the same way they did in the 70’s and we have many more networks to choose from. If you were to suddenly limit the amount of networks to what it was in the 70’s you’d have just as good of lineups now as then.
Yes it’s a flooded market so you will get garbage TV, but it’s really easy to avoid. I don’t get how you say it’s hard to fine the great stuff. I tend to just click a button, and boom great TV.
I mean I long gave up on cable and still have access to all the best shows in TV now. I don’t care what networks catered to what demographic, that doesn’t then diminish the fact that there is more great TV than ever before. You say you only argue based on quality yet you ignore the fact there is no debate that the talent involved with TV today is far superior than ever before. That TV never came close to the heights that it does today. You argue that TV is more micromanaged, that’s just not true. Okay CW caters to a certain audience. Great, that’s a tiny piece of the TV landscape. Other networks like FX, AMC, HBO, Showtime, etc… give content creators nearly full control.
You seemed consumed with this idea that television is lesser than before because it’s only directed towards a certain audience, yet then on the same hand argue that when you review a show you only review based upon its quality. How do those points not contradict one another? How can you say on one hand your personal taste doesn’t impact your view point, and then use an element like a show’s viewership as a gauge to judge the overall quality of a show or the medium itself? Does 2001 lose points because if you were to show that to an audience of 100 people only 25 of them on a good day would actually like it? How does being liked by more people make a show better or worse?
TV, Movies, or any form of art isn’t a cut and dry business. Analyzing a TV show is not akin to analyzing the blueprints of building or a mathematical
equation where opinion is null and based solely in fact. No matter how great a critic someone is or how well versed in a topic someone is personal taste plays a factor, especially when you consider something like comedy which is hugely subjective. To act like your opinion towards (the show of the episode I guess) Scrubs is not affected by your personal taste is plainly untrue. Just because you find it humorous does not make it fact, nor does me not finding it funny make that in fact true.
To assume quality of art is not debatable is then to assume there
is a right or wrong opinion towards a given property. There are critics who have well-formed reviews of Pulp Fiction which completely bash the film with legitimate grievances, and then there are those that sing its praises as one of the best of all time. Both which bring up equal valued points. Yes there are extremes like arguing the worst movie of all time against one of the greatest,
To disregard someone else’s opinion that differs than yours as that’s just them allowing their personal bias to get in the way, where I don’t do that cause I only look at facts is odd to say the least. Yes there are extremes or arguing the greatest of all time verse the worst, but at the end of the day to assume your perception of a given property is not effected by your own personal bias is either you not realizing or unwilling to admit it.
Look at some like sports that has quantifiable factors like stats, metrics, etc.. that should give a black and white picture over the quality of player. Yet the greatest coaches and players of all time can’t clearly define how great a player Eli Manning truly is. So how someone can say there are non-debatable factors that determine the quality of an art form to me is a really does nothing more than limit the way you able to experience it.
Dangit! Dan had way more time than I had to form my response and said every single thing I was thinking in a much better way. This is getting weird and unusual but I 100% agree with Dan on every point here
That Scrubs is automatically a personal choice. Though I’m not a fan I think there is merit in ranking it based on critical response.
I don’t see how you can say we are in horrible time for TV. Sorry but TV has never been better. It’s a double edge sword I grant you, as with every Breaking Bad, Mad Men, True Detective you get a Real Housewives or Two Broke Girls. But its also never been easier to find great content, and for creators to get that content directly to the people.
There was a reason why being considered at TV actor was a bad thing, why true cinematic talent didn’t bother with the medium, because you were stuck with a limit amount of networks that had to worry about ratings much more than do today. From production, to acting, to cinematography, writing, the list goes on, the shows today are superior in every way. Shows don’t’ have to be predicable episodic procedurals that only stretch the medium just enough to keep people on board.
It was unheard of in the pre 2000’s era for a Academy Award Winning Actor’s next big project to be a TV show like it was for Matthew McConaughey. When a young director like Rian Johnson would look to a show like Breaking Bad to stretch his creative muscle as equally as film.
TV before could never touch film as a tool for artistic expression. It had too many, restrictions, and cooks in the kitchen to let great people be great. Now we live in a world where content creators can have creative control. Does that lead to more specialized content? Sure, but give me specialized over a broad piece of entertainment any day of the week.
“but we’re in such a horrible time for television” You are literally the first person I have come across with this viewpoint… I’m baffled on this one
I am a fan of Supernatural but honestly Seasons 1-5 were the best. Seasons 6-8 are terrible. Seasons 9+ have been going strongest IMO since Season 5. That being said, I think Season 11 is a bit much. I love the show but I think it’s time to put this puppy to bed after this Season end it.
Thank you for the awesome breakdown.
The one thing I’ll defend is Knight Rider…. it does deserve to be on the list. You say all the other cars were cooler… really? Could Magnum’s car TURBO BOOST….NOPE! It was shiny nd looked good, but it had no A.I. personality like K.I.T.T. Should Knight Rider have been higher…. in my personal opinion yes, but as far as what we are doing here having in the bottom section of the countdown is an ok place for it.
As I said in the ep I plan on revisiting Scrubs and seeing if I still laugh at it. Completely agree on Agents of Shit. LOL
Oh, I don’t know, just because it had a literal “personality”, it’s hard for me to defend “Knight Rider”. That’s kinda like saying, that “Knight Rider” was better and more interesting than “My Mother the Car”, technically true, but still missing the point. (And yes, just because can talk and do things, more than most cars doesn’t mean it’s better than a regular car. That said, I’ll take the gadgetmobile, you take KITT, and we’ll see who survives the demolition derby. 🙂
“Scrubs”, is quite genius, especially when you look at it as a modern version of “M*A*S*H”. On top of the other innovations, the first person narrative, through a voiceover, the cutaways, etc. (A lot of their ideas get credited to “Arrested Development” even though “Scrubs” was on first, that annoys me a bit too) but really the show is, doctors dealing with the everyday like of seeing sick people all day, through humor and their own psychoses. It’s the same as “M*A*S*H”, it’s just not on the level of war, so it’s not aiming there, and yet the show many times, becomes incredibly poignant and emotional despite that. I think it’s very underrated. People ten years from now, and gonna look back and wonder how a network show as inventive as “Scrubs” was, was not a hit show and barely registered and award season and will be dumbfounded by it.
If we are talking K.I.T.T. Season 1 or 2 before he lost his molecular bonded shell…. K.I.T.T. wins the derby. If we are talking after that and when the SPM was added well then it’s a toss up. But the Gadgetmobile really? That think would fall apart! Now if you wanna take the General Lee against K.I.T.T. that I could see being a closer battle.
Thanks for all the great comments!!!
Sorry but can’t disagree with you more about Scrubs, absolutely nothing genius about that show…unless you are talking about genius new ways to deliver toilet humor and jokes that are never funny.
There may have been hospital humor, but I don’t remember toilet humor, none that wasn’t relevant to the plot. No, the show has thousands of funny moments. It’s definitely stream-of-consciousness in it’s approach, which is also unique to that show, but it’s just flat-out funny-as-hell, but it’s also touching, and frankly some of the most powerful moments in television recently are from “Scrubs”. Every time I watch “Grey’s Anatomy”, all I ever think is it’s “Scrubs” but not realistic. (And, like twenty years late, that show always feel like it should’ve been on after “St. Elsewhere” to me, not “Desperate Housewives”.) No seriously, realistic. Cause it’s humor comes from that first instant of your thought process, and not necessarily what’s said, which is, correct, people do usually work their thoughts and words that way, and it just recognizes it, that in the toughest or most dire or depressing of places and circumstances, sometimes the most childish of gallow’s humor is what you come up with to get through it. Everything’s brilliant about that show. Even the last med school season, which yeah, they probably shouldn’t have done, but if somebody other than me had watched it…; it was funny; it would’ve worked.
I’ve seen about 15 episodes of “Scrubs” and it lacks something major…intelligence. Yes, there is an entire montage of toilet jokes in one episode. The characters are as dry as the Sahara desert…we have J.D.’s word for it that Kelso is mean, instead of being shown Kelso being mean. The jokes less subtle than a punch in the face…it’s more like being shot in the crotch with an RPG. And most of all, it is far too juvenile…it’s as if it was made for first-graders who giggle every time they hear the word “sex”. To put it in the same category as M*A*S*H is insane,
AGREE WITH YOU 100%!!!!!! Well put sir!
Oh, I think you’ve simplified the show too much. Kelso is shown as being mean, but he’s not a single-mindedly mean character, it’s also part of his job, and apart of his approach to medicine, and it’s like, I would compare him and Dr. Cox to-eh, the Berenger and Defoe characters in “Platoon” almost. (I know, easy comparison since McGinley was in “Platoon”, but it’s the obvious comparison) As to the jokes, um, again, I disagree. A. most of them are funny, and B. they’re juvenile, because they’re doctors and it’s the counter-reaction to having that kind of job and responsibility, especially for the younger doctors, the titular “Scrubs”, and what I particularly admire about the show, is how those big obvious, over-the-top jokes, that, yeah there’s a bit of “Family Guy” and other kinda not-so-subtle approaches humor to them, but they’re so big you end up seeing the great subtlety in the drama that comes from it on the other side. When things do hit them like a ton of bricks in real life, they don’t shy from it. And yes, the comparisons to “M*A*S*H”, are absolutely legitimate; it is essentially the same premise, doctors dealing with constant putting people together through childish humor and pranks, using comedy to deal with reality. No, it is on the level of a “M*A*S*H” unit in the Korean War, but it’s also not trying for that, it’s trying for the level of somewhat precocious obnoxious youth doctors out of med school, working at a regular second-tier hospital that gets eventually gets torn down by the end of the series. Yeah, they’re not going through a war, so yeah, they’re humor might be a little more juvenile, having not been jaded by something like that. This is why I think it’s also more realistic than most hospital drama series. It’s not aiming as high as “M*A*S*H” smartly, but it more-than-hits it’s mark where it’s aiming and that’s why it’s such a strong show. I think you guys see the show in front of you and whatever it is, being tuned out to it by something that doesn’t hit you on the surface, but the greatness of the series is how there is so much more going on then just the humor in the forefront.
Having the same premise as MASH doesn’t mean they are comparable in caliber of show. And no I’m not an idiot and don’t just see what’s in the forefront. I understand the subtext it is trying to go for. It doesn’t work. When the majority of the show is a glorified cartoon and then you try to switch gears to what you call subtle drama, which I see their drama as subtle as a 80’s after school special, it doesn’t work at all.
Just because they are doctors doesn’t make the ridiculous jokes funny. Sorry but Children’s Hospital is far superior at meshing humor into a hospital setting than Scrubs. The show is too much in love with itself.
Oh “Children’s Hospital” is a satire of hospital shows and other things, it’s funny, but “Scrubs” was going for something more. And, you know, I’ve bashed live-action shows for being too much like cartoons before, “Malcolm in the Middle” for instance, I always thought was a bit overrated for some for that ’cause it often never did give you a breather into something that was a resemblance of reality, but it works for “Scrubs” because of how it uses the perspectives of the characters and the voice over narration. It’s that approach to instantaneous thought, almost in the improv tradition, but a lot of humor is from the ability to capture that. And that’s realistic to me, we do think that way. We may not always say it, or have it shown visually, but emotionally we do and that’s a tough form of comedy, especially in live-action. If it doesn’t make you laugh, fine, but there’s thing that don’t make me laugh that are funny too. I’m not one that things all comedy needs to make you laugh out loud when it’s structured well, whether it’s “Nurse Jackie” or “Happy Endings” but if it’s a glorified cartoon, it’s because it’s how the characters often perceive the incident and many times it isn’t, and I disagree completely on how well they handled that contrast. I hate using the word “Dramedy”, but “Scrubs” knew exactly when and how to hit you over the head with reality, especially during moments when everything else seemed so outlandish, and that’s…, that’s life in real life, and that’s life working in a hospital too. I buy that this is the emotional feelings that these characters are going through and I found those sharp swings believable. They might not be the most likable characters or the ones we’d rather have as doctors, but I don’t like the idea of Marcus Welby clones either. It might not be the right comedy for everybody, but it’s right for this show and it does it with a good reason and it’s built into the series why it’s done that way and they do it well.
Sorry I won’t ever agree with anything positive about Scrubs. The way you describe it its like we watched two different shows. I like shows that meld comedy and drama. Scrubs just had bad comedy mixed with bad drama. In this case two negatives don’t make a positive.
Yea, I’m in the same boat. You can defend this until you are blue in the face. I watched the show on multiple occasions and don’t see it the same way you do. Its bad mixed with bad topped with more bad.
The big thing with this project is that classic debate of favorite vs best. Based on the lists I received it was about split on how people ranked their movies. Some went the more subjective route by giong based simply on what they like. Because of that we are getting like this episode. Some more of personal favorites like Supernatural or Saved BY the Bell, then those that are argue are better quality shows like Louie, Always Sunny, Homeland, and Andy Griffith. I kind of like it that way to be honest. On a selfish side it makes the record more fun because you get true reactions and surprises, and more importantly I like having a list that represents all sorts of fandoms and critical responses.
I agree Carol Burnett is way too high. Honestly I probably ranked it too low on my list. Mostly do to the fact I did watch much of it, and like I mentioned its not a show people were able to experience in syndication. Agents of SHIELD was a big surprise to me. No idea people thought of it fondly at all. Saved By The Bell I’m not surprised it made the list at all. In fact I was more worried it would be higher. GCRN tends to show a lot of love to childhood favorites like that, and we are well known for having a super hero bias. Although most of GCRN’s core crew didn’t vote for Agents of SHIELD. Oddly that one wasn’t just on us.
I could never get into Scrubs. I’ve tried but Zach Braff is like fingernails on a chalk board for me. I don’t buy him as a dramatic actor so every time the show was trying get serious and he was the core it never worked for me. I”m usually open to most tastes in humor but it didn’t work either. I still ranked it on my list because my issues I realize are more of a personal manner.
I like SCTV but I tend to prefer Kids in the Hall, and think its much more than okay. Similar to why I like Upright Citizens Brigade they are sketch shows that stand on their own more and don’t feel just like lesser versions of SNL. As cliche as it sounds the more alternative style helped shape my sense of humor.
Also completely disagree on Homeland. I do rank it as a great series. Much of that is due to its amazing first season which I rank as one of my favorite TV seasons of all time. It did keep that plot going longer than it should in seasons 2 & 3, but regained much of its footing i n season 4.
With Home Improvement I will again disagree. I do feel it holds up, especially compared to shows of similar ilk like Family Matters, Full House of Fresh Prince. Haven’t seen Grace Under Fire since the 90’s so on that front I can’t compare. Maybe its me allowing nostalgia to play too big of a role but watching I still highly enjoy it. Not sayings its an remarkably well written show. The relationships of tthe characters I still find charming. Most of it is because of Patricia Richardson honestly. She plays really well off Tim Allen.
Well said on a lot of fronts here Dan, can’t disagree with much here
If you want alternative sketch comedy, look up “Bizarre” one day, you’ll really get alternative. Last I checked it’s on Youtube, an for now, it’s the uncensored versions. You see, I saw the first season of “Homeland” and immediately realized half-way through, “Okay, this show can’t last more than two years, tops,” and that to me, as good as it was, although, I wouldn’t rank it as a great series, that really it what killed it for me. It was basically that had nowhere to go. It might have found it later, by abandoning much of that original plot, but when a show, is so heavily based on an initial storyline, these two characters, and is-he or isn’t he a terrorist, I was halfway through the season, already seeing the problems of seasons 2 and 3, and whatever ahead of time, and that’s something that’s such a high degree of difficulty, and frankly, you shouldn’t do it with television…-, Jason Alexander talked about this, in-eh, what’s-his-name’s book, um, Warren Littlefield’s book “Top of the Rock” about NBC’s Must See TV era and it’s dominance for 20 years, and Alexander talked about pitching show ideas nowadays, and he’s be pitching and the guy would say, “Well, what’s gonna happen in season three?” and Alexander would look at him weirdly an answer back “Well, I’ll come in here and ask for a raise, ’cause apparently we’ve had two successful seasons.” He’s right. “Homeland” in many respects should’ve just been a miniseries, and then was made into a series anyway. Sometimes that works, “24” is the best example, but they stuck to the one-season gimmick of the show, and that’s all that they really needed to stick to, “Homeland” was already doomed to me, in that first season. Maybe I just know the formulas so well that I catch it before others, but I was already seeing the problems of that series.
Yes, “Home Improvement” is better than those shows… (Well, oddly “The Fresh…” holds up better than it shoud but…) but that’s not the shows you compare it to. You gotta remember, the other side of ABC, there was the TGIF lineup, but the other side was the “Roseanne”, side, and that along with a couple other series, started two things, this influx of stand-up comics, sorta creating shows around their lives and characters, “The Cosby Show”, “Seinfeld”, “Ellen”, in particular, ’cause that’s also an ABC series of the time, but also, this focus on, eh, not lower-class, but definitely a middle-America tone and feel of shows. Technically, “Married… with Children” was first with this, but “Roseanne” took the realistic approach, and that’s where “Home Improvement” comes in. Comparing it to “Roseanne”, to “Grace Under Fire”, to “Ellen”, to-eh, “The Jeff Foxworthy Show”, “The Drew Carey Show”, it’s those shows that “Home Improvement” actually fits into. And it does hold up, especially the early episodes, once the kids grew up and they were doing things on “Tool Time” that were clearly stuff that nobody would ever do for their home or on their own, that’s when it loses it for me a bit. That’s where “Home Improvement” falls a bit to me. It’s still a great show, I was actually a bit surprised I didn’t find a spot for it in the end, but even though it was definitely the most popular of those shows at the time, time has sorta changed my perceptions of it, and a couple of those other shows hold up a bit better to me. If this was a Top 200, I would’ve found a spot for it, but ABC at that time, was a bit schizophrenic, kinda like NBC is now, only without the quality series, and you have to kinda separate, they had the kid sitcoms, they had these mid-America/stand-up sitcoms, and they had “NYPD Blue”, and BTW, this is the Disney network. It’s a little weird, but “Home Improvement” belongs in this other category of series and that’s where, I see it slipping a bit as time passes. Just a bit, I can’t stress that enough, narrowing to a Top 100 is hard; I get it.
And yeah, I’m somebody who has very little use for personal favorites of people, so I’m a bit worried about what some people put on there, but then again, trying to police that, is a-eh, very lonely and often useless quest, so…. except the worst, hope for the best, at least that’s what I’m looking forward to with the rest of this list.
I have not seen or honestly heard of Bizzare but I’ll surely check it out. Again doomed is a strong word for Homeland. Season 2 and 3 weren’t amazing, but I wouldn’t call them doomed or awful. At times even with their issues they were quite good, but didn’t have the same impact as season one. Also disagree with the notion you can’t do that with TV. I hate the idea of putting any type of perimeters that TV has to be one way or another. That mindset is why TV was such a secondary medium for such a long time. Creators and Networks were too unwilling to break from formula or create shows that may isolate audiences. You can never achieve greatness if you are worried about leaving audience members behind. One reason I enjoy Louie so much. He pays little attention to the say you are ‘supposed’ to make TV.
I don’t think you were alone in the worry regarding season 2 and 3 of Homeland. At time time of the first season release that was the biggest question I saw people asking, was how can the sustain this for multiple season. Honestly, that’s not something I at all care about all that much when I’m enjoy the season I’m watching. Especially today when series will end after two seasons because that was the original plan from the beginning. Also completely okay if a show switches directions completely
Regarding Home Improvement. I don’t think it was not aimed at nearly the same audience as Roseane or Married…with Children at all. They may have been representing the same culture and they both revolve around stand-ups, but tonally and the type of comedy are not very similar.
To me I compare to who those shows were directed at. If you did a venn diagram of the audiences of Fresh Prince, Full House, Roseanne, Home Improvement, etc.. I almost guarantee that Prince & Full house would share much more of a same audience with Home Improvement than Roseanne or Married…with Children. I don’t disagree Roseanne is a better show, I just never considered it in the same ilk as Home Improvement.
Regarding personal favorites, everyone’s list is guilty of it one way or another. Some more than others, but no matter how acclaimed or well knowledge someone is personal taste still plays a huge part.
Agree 100% with Dan again oddly enough 🙂
Okay, I might have done something wrong by posting those Youtube Clips, eh, sorry about that, can’t seem to get rid of them. Meant to just the site’s page, not the videos. Sorry about that.
I have no idea what this post is in reference to…?
I believe it was regarding Bizzare . My assumption is he was going to show some clips of the show.
You made some very good points, and many I do agree with. I have nothing against Orange is the New Black. I tried to get into and bailed after 4 or so episodes. Regardless of how good it is, it’s too soon for it to be on a top 100 list when there are EASILY 100 shows more deserving. That’s my point with Homeland and some of the other shows.
Yes, WTF is Knight Rider doing on this countdown?!
“”Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.”- Okay, this is bullshit. Shouldn’t be on the
list, shouldn’t have considered. Not a good show, at all,-, it’s yeah,
this is when it’s clear that some people have TV knowledge and some
don’t when crap like this makes it.”
This is the point I made in another comment. Come on. I’m not that old, but I know of shows that were made decades before my time and understand their relevance even if I never watched them.
hey you leave Knight Rider alone! It was one of the biggest shows in the 80s for action adventure!!
Growing up, I watched it. But I haven’t seen it since, so I can’t speak to its quality. It was a pop-culture hit, but I don’t know that it was a critical success. The theme song, the car, and the premise were a lot of fun though. Still, out of the 80’s shows like this, I would expect to see Miami Vice or Magnum PI above it.
You are missing ONE big one that unfortunately I don’t think we are going to see that trumps them all! 🙁
Well, to be fair, “Orange is the New Black” is quite good, I’m through the first season and I gotta catch up on the rest so far, but yeah, I thought it was a long way off. Also, it’s always too early to tell with Jenji Kohan, people forget she made “Weeds” before this, which was a great show, but that show, eh, it didn’t get bad, but she can get bored quickly it seems, and suddenly the entire show can change itself multiple times over. I’m hoping the fact that she trapped herself into a literal prison, will help but yeah, “Orange…” is a show I’m a bit weary of putting the all-time great banner on it.
I disagree with something being too soon to be on the list just because its recent. We’ll get to this more in the next episode, but to me if your show is great I’m not going to hold off because its only a few years old. Because there are not 100 shows that are easily better than Homeland and Orange is the New Black. I could see tje argument for Homeland but if anything OISTNB should be higher. Its had three seasons, its not like its only half a season in.
I stay by the fact that TV today is far superior than TV pre 2000. The caliber of acting on down is the best its ever been. The best actors of today will appear on TV when that was never the case before unless it was on SNL or some other sketch show.
If this was a film list I’d be upset if it was full of current stuff compared to classic stuff. Being a TV list I think its not only expected, but the right call honestly.
If Agents of SHIELD made it and Daredevil or Flash don’t we riot lol. Am I the only one that never got the appeal of the Andy Griffith Show? I don’t see how it holds up at all. It’s way too simplearly and over simplifies everything.
I’ll be the first with torches and pitchforks to the riot party!!!! With Andy Griffith yes it was simple, but wasn’t that the point at the time? Give everyone Simple life lessons? Having it this early in the countdown is fine with me. Thanks for listening!!
Kids of the Hall is one of my all time favorite sketch comedies. Made me a Dave Folley for life, reason why I watched Newsradio.
How can Mike say Homeland should be lower and he has never saw it? How is that possible? That comment had me stratching my head. So far I’m happy with what’s been on the list. Except for Agents of Shield. That’s not even one of the best 100 shows of today let alone ever. Also Orange is the New Black should be much higher. Top 50 easy.
Compared to shows I have seen versus ones I haven’t. That’s what I meant when I said Homeland should be lower.
That something I don’t understand what you mean either. What makes you think Homeland should be lower?
Yes Mike, you need to elaborate on this one cause we are all baffled here
I made my personal Top 100 to submit for the overall GCRN list out of shows I’ve actually seen. Even if I’ve only seen a few episodes of said show. Then I ranked them as far as where I thought they deserved to be. So for me any show I haven’t seen deserves to be lower than one I have So Homeland never made my list, because I didn’t think I could accurately rank it, yet, Saved By The Bell did make my list. On my list it was at 65. So That was my thought process. That clear things up?
I’ve listened to lists where people announce the criteria they had for making their lists, and I think that may be something to think about in the future. And to emphasize that the countdowns are the GCRN Favorite X so people don’t get so upset about the picks. Just a thought. I, for one, enjoy the discussions, and a lot of people probably do enjoy that aspect more than anything.
the list is specifically not suppose to be the “Favorite” it is about the best, or it should be. Yea we usually do go over the ‘criteria’ we all have for making the lists but with doing 25 episodes per podcast we had to streamline a bit for times sake.
With 29 people apart of the project we can’t really speak for everyone. The project was presented as the Best Shows of All time,and some clearly allowed personal taste to play a bigger factor than others.
Can’t you look at the acclaim and response a show received and conclude it should be on the list or not. My question though is way automatically say it should be lower because you haven’t seen it.
Surely people involved in the rankings would at least know of some of these shows and understand how critically-acclaimed they are from reading about or hearing about them? And age isn’t an excuse. You had to have heard of I Love Lucy, The Honeymooners, The Twilight Zone even if you’ve never seen them. I’ve never seen Homeland either. Yet I know it is one of the top shows out there right now based on critical acclaim. I am fine with it being on the list and its placement because I think even though it has gotten a lot of acclaim, it’s too soon to say whether it will have staying power. Hence, why Agents of Crap should not be on this list. Arrow. Love the show. The first two seasons were gold, IMO. But it missed the cut because there are easily 100 other shows more deserving, IMO.
Awesome that this is happening to say off the bat. Enjoyed the episode and the discussion. Some did have some issue so far with the countdown. Saved By the Bell is an okay kids show or whatever you want to call it. Does not deserve to be in a conversation with great tv shows.I am glad you did include animation. Some of the favorite shows right now are animated tv shows. Archer, Bojack, Rick & Morty, are easily some of the best stuff I watch. I never got The Flintstones. It had some visual gags sure. Not much more. The humor in KIDS IN THE HALL is, for the most part, purely unexplainable, and sometimes it’s actually subtly disturbing–an experimental sort of comedy that best fits in the “either you get it or you don’t” category. When watching KITH with a group, the viewer response will invariably be split: one half will be teary-eyed from laughter while the rest of the gang will be hopelessly confused or frustrated, making condescending statements like “I don’t see how you think this is funny!” . I think its good enough for top 100. 76 is a tad high. Maybe 90’s would be better off. Homeland is spell-binding, packed with enough twists and turns to keep even a seasoned mystery writer wondering. Superb acting and a script that manages to avoid the usual clichés. Kudos to the writers! I found myself debating the civil liberties vs. national security issues that are so artfully posed each week.Claire Danes, Damien Lewis and Mandy Patinkin inhabit their characters.The producers also refrained from populating the cast with impossibly beautiful people who are unlikely candidates for clandestine operatives. The performances are nuanced and exquisitely wrought.They raise serious questions about the sacrifices both personal and physical that are required in the world of espionage, and the political consequences of using “heroes” for cynical ends.
A lot of talk about two things for me have no impact on a show. First being ratings. A show being popular does not make it good. Two and a Half Men is one of the most popular shows but its god awful. Please god don’t make it on the list. The other being Emmy’s or awards. The people who vote on the Emmy’s are well known just to pick the same people every year just because they like them. Long after shows have past their prime they will get nominated because the actor or actress did something good in their past, or just plain habit.
One thing that caught me ear was the honest reaction you all have. I like that you’ll call something out if you don’t think it belongs on the list, which yes is a little weird too since its your list, though as mentioned you had a lot of people contribute.
Any chance you’ll do like a listener or fan vote list? That would be cool to see.
I agree that just because a show has good ratings and/or awards doesn’t make it good. However, it should be part of the discussion. When trying to rate shows its important to bring in objective facts to provide why a show should be higher, lower, or not on the list at all. Emmy’s like all award shows have their issues for sure, but they do mean something.
I agree with most of what you are saying but 100% DISAGREE with your take on critical acclaim/ratings etc. Should it be the only thing looked at or considered…absolutely not. Should it alone be enough to get something on the list, most times no. However, it very much should be a component of how you break down shows. There is something to be said for a show that is actually watched and talked about and part of the water cooler conversation. A show is made to be watched and if its the ‘most watched’ show of its time or a majority of its seasons than that should count for something in a project like this. And regardless how biased you feel emmy’s or golden globes are it still is worth bringing up. I view it as less important than ratings but again these are only 2 of 6 components I considered when shaping my list and attempting to be as objective as possible. I’ll address this more in the next episode’s intro if possible!
I can see you point on the awards, but how does being talked about make a show good or effect the quality of the show? Is Vincent van Gogh not a great artist because no one talked about him at the time? Your show should speak for yourself. Being popular or getting high ratings rarely has anything to do with how good a show is. Baywatch was one of the most watched shows in the 90’s and probably ever. Would you put that on the list? Look at as show like Spaced. Was not talked about much at the time in the US. A lot of people still haven’t seen it in fact. But it is amazing show full of people who are now major stars. Would you not count that because it didn’t win awards or was talked about at the water cooler as you say. Even though if you go back an watch it now you can see how brilliant it is. Also ratings and being talked about aren’t one in the same. I remember everyone talking about Firefly but the ratings were awful. Then you have a show like JAG that had huge ratings, no one talked about it, and everyone has pretty much forgotten it. I can point to show after show that was popular but not good or memorable so that’s why I don’t think that should count for anything when rating shows like this.
I think we are arguing extremes here. I don’t think anyone would say an average show with great ratings is deserving or a great show with bad ratings is not deserving of being on the list. For me the first and biggest thing I looked at was quality of the show. How great did it get. Then I considered things like impact, influence, and at times popularity. It wasn’t a huge factor but if a show had an impact on pop culture because of its popularity that is a positive.
Right that’s my point. I think you are having trouble separating one of many contributing factors and THE only contributing factor. IN my mind Ratings should very much be one of the many components considered. Why? Mainly because is cold hard numbers. You say it should be based on quality…yes but quality after a certain point is the most biased component you can consider. None of us were alive in 1950 (or most of us I assume) so who are we now really to judge those shows accurately? Ratings and Awards can help with that. Even if you rewatch every episode, it may not resonate with our generation because we are watching it after the fact, and in a completely different environment. Ultimately any show put out there is put out there to ‘succeed’ and success by television standards IS ratings. It would be the equivalent of not using statistics when trying to judge a baseball player that no one living ever saw in person. Thats a terrible example but with time I could come up with a dozen better ones. Again is a minor contributing factor but how successful a show was (TV Networkds Standard of success), how much it was watched (any tv shows goal) and how much it was part of the popular culture of the time should 100% be a part of the discussion in the creation of a list such as this!
So let me ask you a question. You have Show A. Show A came out in the 1950’s at the time wasn’t well regarded, didn’t win awards, but now looking back on it it was ahead of its time and an overall great show. You then have Show B. Show B is a show you personally don’t like now watching, but has won awards and had high ratings. Which show would you put over the other?
I would need to know how Show A and Show B rate in the other half dozen criteria/aspects I look at when judging its overall worth.
That makes sense. I still feel it should be a factor. Shows are often popular because who is in them or because they appeal to a large audience. Jay Leno had huge ratings because his jokes were bland and easy. When he left no one really cared. Letterman though was unique and broke new ground. Never got close to him in the ratings. When Letterman left it was a big deal. because those who loved him really loved him.
Agents of Shield? AGENTS OF SHIELD! What is that all about. Agent Carter I could see. Agents of SHIELD is not as bad as people say but no way should be on this list. My prediction for the top 10: 10. Game of Thrones. 9. Daredevil 8. The Sopranos. 7. 24. 6. The Walking Dead. 5. Seinfeld. 4. Mad Men. 3. I Love Lucy 2. Breaking Bad. 1. MASH.
Good predictions. Well have to see how close you are!
Solid choices! I think 3 of those for sure will be Top 10 – But the list has been unpredictable so far! Agree with you on Agents of Shield 100%!
People hate on AOS way too much. Same with Gotham. People watched the first few episodes, didn’t like them, and then went on to assume the shows didn’t get better when they did. Season 2 of Gotham has been great, and for my money is the best Superhero show on TV right now.
I agree S2 of Gotham has been far superior than Season 1!
I agree Gotham has gotten better. Lets not go crazy though. Arrow and Flash are still way better. Arrow has rebounded strong this season and could be the best season yet if all works out right.
Sorry I have stayed with AOS and its not been good at all. Its gotten better but it being better only makes it average.
Gotham S2 has been on par with the best superhero shows on TV, including past seasons of Arrow. I find myself eager to see the next episode. They’ve weaving the storylines very tightly. To say it is possibly the best superhero show on TV right now…you may be right. Sure, I love Arrow…it’s doing better this season so far. Flash…it’s still doing well. But Gotham is killing it.
out of them all though The Flash is the best so far.
Flash is very strong. I finished ep 5, so I am still catching up. King Shark was awesome. It and Gotham are very close for me. Gotham has been a total surprise though. I am glad I stuck with it when I wanted to drop it and my wife insisted we keep watching. It is definitely the most-improved show.
eh its hard for me to get over some of the cheese and the terrible dialogue/writing…we still are watching it for some reason though
Terrible writing??? You are kidding right? The Flash as a character is supposed to be light hearted and upbeat, and fun. Until something dire happens to him or his family. I say this because there’s meant to be a bit of cheese in there, and it’s a good thing that there is. At least it’s not 90s cheese lol
Even as a lover of Walking Dead it does not deserve top 10. Top 50 Maybe. Its a fun show but lets not go crazy. The rest I agree on. Although All in the Family should be there some place.
I’m not saying that’s what should be there. That’s my guess of what will be there.
Okay that makes sense then.
NIce! This made my long trip into work so much better. I cannot get enough of countdowns especially when I don’t have to read anything lol. I hope to see some of my favorite shows make the list. Firefly, Battlestar Galactica, Arrow, The Simpsons, South Park, and Community.
A lot of fun so far. Did not expect all the love for Golden Girls. Never liked anything about that show at all. Not geeky enough for me lol.
Why is Louie so low? The humor is of the best kind – dry and effective, and Louie faces some real problems that are common for all of us at one point – aging and going through tough (but hilarious) changes in life… Seeing THAT from Louie’s point of view is particularly interesting… The show itself is refreshing in the sea of mediocre popular boringness that we see today on TV and has only gotten better. Its way better than Modern Family. More people just need to see it.
My other issue is that Whose Line is it Anyway? is on this list. The UK version was much better and even that its just an above average improv comedy show that just got famous cause it was on TV.
Oh its better than an average improv comedy show. I’ve gone to a bunch and most improv shows are garbage to be honest. Unless you have a well known group that is well regarded and well trained. On a format stand point yes its basic improv. But quality was its very good. It has some of the best improvers in the business.
Isn’t this a nice
surprise. Didn’t realize this was happening and next thing I know look at my
iphone and have a gem waiting for me. I like this format more. Getting right to
it and 25 entries per episode make more sense for me. Plus I’m weird and like
long podcasts. Now the list itself. Hard to say anything about some of the
older shows. Anything pre late 70s is off my radar. I do have to back up Scrubs
though. What’s with the hate? I get not everyone’s comedy style is the same but
Scrubs was a damn fine show. Yes the ABC
seasons were a huge step down but that’s the same with a lot of shows. I’m glad
it made the list and it’s at a good spot.
I wonder with this being a geek top 100 TV list where other Joss Whedon shows will fall if Agents of Shield made the cut. Is Dollhouse top 50? Firefly would have to be Top 10. Buffy too even. Although I always preferred Angel.
angel rocks!!!!
I was confused on so many levels. I am in awe of what is to come.
Had to put this here. Once of my favorite Srubs moments.
I’m enjoying the countdown. The addition of Amanda is welcome to the countdowns, even though I often disagree with her picks. 🙂
I think the list is shaping up nicely so far. I’m disappointed at the placement for Andy Griffith. That is easily one of the most respected TV hits, and a pop culture icon. Oh, and what’s the hate for Scrubs? I understand it is quirky and some people don’t like that style of humor (just like I don’t like The Office), but I was surprised that no one on the panel seemed to like it.
By the way, some picks are just pure head-scratchers. I mean, Supernatural as a #1 TV show? And what is Agents of Shi! doing on this list? Maybe this should have been called a Geek Top 100 TV shows? Some shows aren’t appealing to me, but I still ranked them because they were relevant, ground-breaking, critically-acclaimed, are pop-culture icons, etc.. For instance, I don’t like M.A.S.H., but I expect it to be on this list, and it should be. Agents of Shield doesn’t deserve to be on a list that isn’t more specific (e.g., Top 100 Sci-Fi or Fantasy). Saved by the Bell…I think there are easily 100 shows more deserving. At least some people had the sense to rank Bob Newhart, Carol Burnett, and other classic shows that are still watchable today. In a few years, I doubt anyone will care about what happened on Agents of Shield. Supernatural seems like a decent show. I have seen the first few episodes, but it is not a top ten, top 20, or top 100 show. X-Files and even shows like Buffy or Angel were more relevant, critically-acclaimed, and resonant in pop culture and are more deserving to be on this list.
I noticed that I did not rank The Golden Girls on my list, and that was an error. I’m glad others ranked it. Again, not a show I watched, but I knew of it and believe it deserves a spot here.
Looking forward to the next podcast!
You need to watch Supernatural into it a while before making judgment. Seasons 1-5 and 8-11 are great. Seasons 6-7 are utter garbage. It has lasting power and better than some I’ve seen show up so far. It should be in the Top 50 at least.
To clarify no one had Supernatural at their number one spot. Amanda said it was her favorite show, but didn’t list it as number one however. Someone did list it as number 2.
I don’t disagree that many did allow personal biases to get in the way, and there are shows in the countdown that aren’t in the right spot for sure.
To be fair I didn’t require people to provide a reasoning for their list. It’s hard enough to make one. Maybe if we did it would cause some to look at it differently. My hope was by getting a bigger pool personal taste would be less and less a factor. I think for the most part that happened with some side effects. Like with you and Golden Girls it can be easy to forget a show. So what tends to happen is the shows people are passionate about almost always make the list. While others they didn’t see, had little exposure to, or are unaware of are easily left off. In that case many of the classic shows that aren’t talked about today.
I’ll say things change as the list goes on, and for the most part there are only a handful of shows that made the final list i think are 100% not worthy of the top 100. AOS being one of them.
Still, you understand my point. #2 or #1…anyone voting Supernatural that high obviously is voting based on personal favorites or bias. And that is fine if that is the intent of this list. I also made out a list as one of the contributors, so I know it is difficult to fit everything in or not leave shows out. I do like the discussions regarding the shows and seeing some surprises. It’s all in good fun, honestly.
As for shows today being better…yes, production values and the quality of the writing is better in many respects, but I am surprised to hear you make a blanket statement about TV now being better than TV before 2000. What shows were able to do with their limited budgets by creating memorable characters and stories despite their low budgets makes them even more of an achievement, in my opinion.
To discount modern shows, length of programming and the type is also a bias. So to each their own. There were shows that are going to be biased on the list and there are going to be ones that aren’t. By pooling them together it makes it so the bias more or less leaks out. Had Supernatural NOT been at #2 on a list, it wouldn’t have made the Top 100 which it most certainly should. Not saying it deserves the #2 spot overall but the point is overall they counterbalance bias with more official results once the pool is collected.
Yes smaller budgets have increased but so have the quality of shows. Do we get shows overall that are poor by design, yes but the quality shows more than outweigh the non-quality programs.
When making the list, it gets quite daunting trying to select only 100. Then again when making it your most memorable and favorite shows are going to be remembered for the list first. Followed by the ones you cared less for. I knew of some and forgot them in an honest mistake which may have impacted more of my 50-100 range but predominately my list consists of shows I actively watch or have watched in the past even to some small degree.
Yes I 100% agree placing something like Supernatural that high is based more on personal taste than overall quality.
I’m not saying all TV is better than before, or than I didn’t have classic TV shows in my Top 25, 10, or 5, because I did.
But overall yes I do feel TV is much improved. Its more than just production for me. its the quality of talent on all phases. TV of the past was stuck with episodic story telling that limited its scope and thematic depth. Sure there are exceptions like M*A*S*H ect… but overall you could never get something the caliber of The Sopranos (which I realize was pre 2000), The Wire, Breaking Bad, or True Detective. As we talked about in this episode something like NYPD Blue was looked at as edgy and true to life. Not that its a requirement for a TV show, but if I’m watching a cop drama I’m much more impressed with something like The Wire that does feel almost too close to real life.
Similar with acting and directing talent. Being a TV director is actually beginning to mean something. Looking at True Detective someone like Cary Fukunaga can shape 8 hours of TV to fit very extraordinary cinematic vision to create what was basically an extended film. Some of the best actors are choosing to be on TV rather than getting placed there because their careers in film is over. TV actor used to be a negative, now TV actors are often more respected than most film actors.
To summarize the highs are higher and more often. I’m not saying great TV didn’t exist previously, but as someone who prefers film over TV I always saw it as a lesser medium. To me that’s not the case now. In the 70’s, 80’s and 90’s the gap between the quality of film and TV could fill the grand canyon. Today they are on par with one another.
I understand we also live in a world with every rich or redneck family has a reality TV show, but I find it rather easy to ignore all of that. We have some of the worst TV ever I grant you and some of the best. You, take the good, you take the bad, … I feel like I heard his from some place before.
“Someone had Scrubs at number 10??”
I’M SPARTACUS!
But seriously, for its first eight seasons this was a terrific show with a ton of memorable and diverse characters, even the bit players. Not to mention it found great use for Tara Reid, Michael J Fox, Heather Graham and Brendan Fraser. It walks a fine line between hilarious and tragic in the same half hour slot. I ranked it so high partly out of personal preference and the fact that it remained consistently throughout its first run.
I had no issue with Zach Braff here as this was the first thing I had ever seen him in, so I was in on the ground floor.
Thoroughly enjoyed this episode, and am really looking forward to the rest.
The debate about critical acclaim vs personal preference will always be there, but for me I left off some of the big hitter shows of the last ten-fifteen years purely because I haven’t seen them. I didn’t want to skew the list by adding shows purely because I felt I had to.
Keep up the great work!!
I did not expect Scrubs to get the hate that it did. I did have it on my list, even though its not my favorite show because I do know there is acclaim out there for it. For some reason Zach Braff is nails on a chalk board for me, and I honestly don’t know hwy.
The creating of the list is always a debate. Do you put shows on there you haven’t seen just because they have acclaim? I can see the argument both ways on that. When I made my list the biggest thing I looked at was how great was your show. So things like number of seasons or year of release didn’t come into play that much. In a way I designed it as if I was releasing it as a stand alone article. So maybe a show I’m not well versed in may be higher due to other factors, While something like The Office which is one of my all time favorite shows doesn’t make my top 20 because I realize quality wise, importance wise, impact wise, its not has high as something like All in the Family.
At the end of the day its more of an exercise to get good discussion on a podcast and in the forums or post. Which I feel is happening so I’m happy with it so far.
And you’re certainly getting that. It’s been really fun so far, and Amanda definitely adds a great dynamic to the podcast.
I can honestly say that I had no problem in NOT placing The Cosby Show on my list. Even if Cosby hadn’t turned out to be a monster, I wouldn’t have placed it in the top 100. I found it more preachy than enjoyable.
My goal wasn’t to single out Cosby. There were just at least 100 shows I found more entertaining, and I also managed to avoid ranking such alleged “classics” as The Brady Bunch, Mork & Mindy, Gilligan’s Island, and most if not all of ABC’s TGIF lineup. #DidIDoThat?
Now Cosby’s live albums were gems. The stand-up performances that originated the Fat Albert character were among my favorites.
Yeah i still love best of… with buck buck and the water bottle and all that!
I think you commented on the wrong post. Love the feedback though, even if I strongly disagree with your take on The Cosby Show
I was replying to Mike’s dread over the placement of the Cosby Show, which was literally within the first five minutes of the podcast.
Tangentially, I was the one who put Carol Burnett at #1. I’m really glad I did now, considering where it placed.